Munim (@Munimusing) header
Munim (@Munimusing) profile picture

“In our infinite ignorance we are all equal.” | Elec. Engr. | Power Systems | Legal Theory | OSINT

Joined December 2012
Why PAF's performance was predictable⁉️ Over the weekend, I was engaged in a serious discussion to filter out the rhetorical noise and doubts from what PAF achieved in the air battle. As the gentlemen were from the engineering community within our defence sector, I told them about the mathematical reasoning of sorts that I used for myself to comprehend what had just happened in our lifetimes — and why I was so sure about the outcome. I used an age-old and very quantitative method: binomial probability. Just a simple coin-flip probability –– foundational in military operational research and basic fingertip air combat modelling. I stripped the outcomes of all abstractions (like morale, training, surprise) or qualitative parameters (Link 16 vs Link 17, PL-15 vs PL-15E, etc.) and based it purely on number of assets, attrition rate, combat duration, and observed outcome. Brutally simple. This gives us the raw firepower potential, assuming each aircraft gets one clean BVR kill attempt. Of course, PAF and such air forces have very complex differential equations and Newton-Raphson convergence algorithms to model and predict a real battle. I just used the fingertips, lol. The baseline approach was to rank the world’s top BVR missiles by a largely agreeable open-source probability-of-kill estimate — from AIM-120C/D at 0.20–0.35 to Derby at 0.08–0.10. This gives us a plausible relative outlook of these missiles –– the final spears in all the network, infrastructure, and kill chains. Then, applying it to an estimated force composition of both IAF and PAF, we assigned realistic kill probabilities per aircraft type. On the Indian side, 14 Rafales (Meteor) were the centre of gravity, with Su-30MKIs (R-77/Astra Mk1) and MiG-29s (R-77) acting in escort roles, while Mirage 2000s (MICA) were in the strike role. This campaign package gave us an expected kill score of ~8.7 based on our loose probabilistic raw firepower estimation. On the shooter side, PAF’s 14 J-10Cs (PL-15 EBV), with JF-17 Block IIIs (PL-15E) and Block IIs (likely SD-10A), translated to an expected ~5.76 kills. And lo and behold — PAF performed to the script. From the actual outcome, we saw 6 confirmed kills and one MALE UAV from the IAF package eliminated. But what changes the stakes is this: PAF not only hit its expected score — it did so while receiving 0 of its own expected attrition. Not lower-than-expected losses. Zero. The expected reciprocal loss for PAF was 6–7 aircraft. Instead of the projected 0.66:1 exchange ratio, we got ∞:0. This isn't high performance. This is when the probability curve bends. PAF didn’t just outperform—they broke the model. So how rare is this? Based on asset count alone, Pakistan’s chance of a dominant outcome was 37%, India’s 63%. But raw counts don’t decide battles — timing, integration, decision loops do. To probe further, we assumed 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations theoretically, using the exact same force parameters. The outcome should be that in 88% of outcomes, India should have scored at least two kills. A 6:0 result in favour of PAF should occur in fewer than 3 out of 1,000 outcomes. That’s not a tactical win. That’s a statistical outlier — meaning systemic or technological disruption occurred. So what caused it? India’s effective kill probability was far lower — degraded by jamming, kill chain disruption, cyber denial — and PAF gained first-launch advantage through superior tactical execution. This brings us to OODA. PAF's kill chain integrity held at ~87%. India’s collapsed by over 60%. The enemy never completed its decision loop. They couldn't. Their kill architecture was denied, jammed, confused, broken. As I speculated earlier, the math confirms what was visible from above — a smaller force, acting faster, tighter, and smarter, owned the engagement space. The binomial reasoning shows that PAF achieved exactly what it should have. IAF achieved nothing it was statistically expected to. Monte Carlo estimations show that such a result is extremely rare without some form of systemic breakdown. And OODA analysis shows why that breakdown occurred. But if you want to measure just how severe the damage was — Lanchester’s Law closes the case. With a glaring failure of 6–nil, we can only apply a simplified Lanchester’s Square Law. The actual equations model attrition rates over time between two opposing forces. But with 6 confirmed kills over 1 hour, the PAF's attrition coefficient for India comes out to k_P = 0.469. In clear terms: for every unit of Indian air combat power, PAF delivered 46.9x more attrition. That number isn't symbolic — it’s kinetic. It means each Pakistani aerial asset delivered half a square unit of Indian force kill-power every hour. That’s not air superiority. That’s annihilation mathematics. A level of combat efficiency three times above symmetric expectations. This was system-first warfare — a concept Indians will understand in decades while Pakistanis will have evolved further. It wasn’t just that India was outflown — they were out-looped. First launch. First kill. Then complete denial. PAF mounted its complete shooter package within 3 to 10 mins. Peak lethality was achieved in the first 15–20 mins. And then complete smacking of whatever Indians threw in for the next 40-45 mins. Insane! That was partly the reason for my speculation before the engagement that this aerial battle would not be one of raw kinematics but of system integrity — and that the moment when a Rafale goes blind, the signal would be heard far louder than its physics. That precise moment is what appears to have unfolded. The disruption forced even the big boss of nonchalant India’s son-in-law-Vance in Washington and the BECA-aligned US command architecture to intervene diplomatically to contain the fallout, despite having Israelis taking the shots while sitting in Indian C2 centres. It was that loud. This is what realists at the Western helm of affairs don’t — and perhaps cannot — really factor in or understand. Pakistan cannot be just “smashed” in a conventional engagement either. The martial asymmetries are mysterious — and in favour of Pakistan ever since. And it’s not just the present — it recalibrates the future. By India’s own platform logic, Bayesian updating pushes PAF’s probability of winning a future BVR battle to over 70%. For IAF? Below 30%. PL-15s, too, have now edged into top-tier BVR missile status — with a real-world kill probability of ~0.36, matching or exceeding the AIM-120D with superior range. But this battle wasn’t won by missiles. It was won by doctrine. By integration. By systems. This is what PAF has built — quietly, patiently, in shadows. While India spent $15B after Op Swift Retort to buy Rafales, advanced air defence including S-400s, BECA and other force-building instruments, PAF built network parity and asymmetry under $5B. They war-gamed against and closely studied Qatari Rafales, simulated Chinese S-400s, had already exercised against US supercarriers, studied P-800 Oniks (BrahMos) equivalents, and rehearsed the highest level of BVR battles in Shaheen exercises with PLAAF EW and space warfare gems on SOJs, J-10Cs, and J-16Ds. They then established a plethora of indigenous technologies — including those that people mistake for Turkish or Chinese, like the YiHA-III, KaGeM V3, CM-400AKG, etc. Many of these platforms are either OEM developments per Pakistani specs and engineering, or jointly developed or produced. PAF trained to blind. To jam. To overrun. To dominate. And when the day came, they didn’t react. They executed. The biggest surprise for Indians was in the cyber domain, in which PAF said it never fully deployed all it has. The highlight of the cyber payload was satellite ISR and comm disruption — with a very likely hacking of Indian GSAT-7A, IAF’s primary comm satellite. Apart from that, in the space domain, PAF had the backing of the Chinese for sure. China arguably has the world’s best or top-most kill chain integration using 13 dedicated military comm satellites — out of a total of 166 in 15 constellations. It will take generations for Indians to replicate that — to develop a system, network, and pack-hunting into their operational DNA. No matter how much they spend on platforms and assets, the outcomes will remain the same. IAF didn’t just meet an air force. It met a network. This was not just a battle won — it was a system war executed with precision. PAF didn’t outperform; they overrode the engagement architecture. IAF didn’t just underdeliver; they never got into the game. We can probabilistically reason what PAF did during Op Bunyan um Mursus, too, with S-400s. And had PAF been allowed to carry out what it asked for, post-Bholari, Indian losses would have been strategic – way past the tactical humiliation it received globally. This is going to be studied. Taught. Cited. Precise. Surgical. Textbook. (I will link the relevant threads below).
38
191
35
564
90,076
Today we release a report about how Israel and pro-Israel groups are attacking Wikipedia, with the goal of influencing AI. It’s out today. Link in next post. This is something I've personally been working on for 18 months, and in the last 2 months I've been working day and night. It's a big report, and a big day for us. The report matters because Wikipedia is where much of the world learns about Israel and Palestine. It also feeds Google Search and AI tools like ChatGPT, so whoever shapes Wikipedia shapes what millions of people are told. The report contains a lot. It details the influence operation by US officials on Wikipedia. It goes through the entire ADL report and fact-checks every claim (they are all false). We document 17 efforts to directly manipulate Wikipedia by Israeli groups. It highlights the pro-Israel sympathies of founder Jimmy Wales, and how he's wading in to influence Wikipedia. It documents the 4 groups that are stalking Wikipedia editors for Israel. We also provide context, explaining how AI works, how Wikipedia feeds into it, background on the ADL, Hasbara, and why Israel needs narrative control.
109
1,671
44
4,518
63,708
آج بلاول کی تقریر کے بعد کچھ لوگوں کو واہ واہ کرتا دیکھ کر اپنی پرانی ٹویٹ یاد آگئی! کیا ہی کانفیڈنس پایا ہے بھٹو اور زرداری خانوادے نے! ایک دفعہ یہ بھول بھی جائیں کہ بھٹو صاحب اپنے سیاسی مخالفین کے ساتھ کیا کیا کرتے تھے، تب بھی کراچی مئیر کے انتخابات کو کون بھلا سکتا ہے؟ خیر اپنا کیا لینا دینا!
آپ نے ٹینشن نہں لینی، کچھ ہی دنوں بعد یہی بلاول بھٹو اور شیریں رحمان ہمیں جمہویت پر اسی پرانے کانفیڈنس کے ساتھ لیکچر دیں گے اور انکی اپنی ہنسی بھی نہیں چھوٹے گی!
13
2
84
1,654
All this dressing up is there to hide one thing: the generals have not learnt their lesson, and this piece shows they have no plan to. Take away the new vocabulary and 'administrative accountability' or 'security-centred administration' is a fresh label on an old arrangement. Ayub sold it as the Decade of Development, Zia sold it as Nizam-e-Mustafa, and Musharraf sold it as devolution, good governance and enlightened moderation. Each time the promise was delivery instead of politics. Each time it ended with a weaker state, a bigger debt and a more divided country. 1971 was the bill for the first experiment, and we are still paying for the other two, plus the many interventions from behind the curtain that stalled the political process when they did not tear the political fabric apart outright. Every political choice in today's Pakistan has been propped up, fed and nurtured by the generals, while every alternative route, from student unions to local bodies, has been choked. Now they want to double down on the same failed model. Farrukh sb asks the right question, who holds the administrators accountable, and then walks straight past it. In Pakistan everyone knows the answer is nobody. You cannot audit the auditor when the auditor carries the gun, and if you try, you get the treatment Justice Waqar Seth got after the Musharraf verdict. Corps Commanders' Conference has no agenda of hindsight or retrospection. And if you inspire from Gulf monarchies, Chinese totalitarianism, and Egyptian dictatorships, there is only so much you can think of rationally. In the timelines of nations, the detraction happens almost instantly in this model. رفتم که خار از پا کَشَم محمِل نِهان شُد از نظر یک لحظه غافِل گشتم و صدساله راهم دُور شُد And if we are counting rupees, the Rs76 trillion question cuts both ways. By all means ask where the results are, but ask it of every institution that has had first claim on the national budget for seventy years, not only of the provinces and the politicians. If the human story tells us anything, it is that security states fail, and they fail every time. They can hold territory for a while, but they cannot hold loyalty. The longest runs have always belonged to ideas that people took up as their own, and no administrator has ever been able to issue one by notification. Pakistan doesn't need more vacuum, it needs breathing space. It needs room for diversity, for a real political economy, and for its people and ideas to mature through their own trial and error. That is evolution, and evolution needs an environment, not an administration. Pakistan itself was the revolution; any revolution after it, whether it calls itself reform or 'Pakistan 2027', is a counterrevolution. We have had enough of those. The record tells its own story. When the gun was not standing watch, this nation delivered. It gave itself the 1973 Constitution, the only document every party and province has ever signed up to; also the first and only of its kind in Muslim history. It was civilians who started the nuclear programme and civilians who tested it in 1998. If anything, the pattern is that wherever the generals stepped back, the people stepped up. Elite capture aside, the generals are the least equipped to hold a grown-up conversation on nation-building. They have little feel for political economy, the history of ideas or the sciences that hold a nation together, and even less patience for people who do. The real problem is that the generals still won't accept that the failures of the idea of Pakistan trace back to the arrogance of the gun and the narrowness of the barracks mind. That mind sees a nation as a formation to command, not a people to trust.
New Pakistan By the end of 2027, Pakistan will have the same map but a very different political structure. Pakistan is moving from electoral accountability towards administrative accountability. For decades, political power in Pakistan has flowed from the ballot box. That power is now being reconfigured. Elected representatives will continue to hold office, but the authority to allocate resources and determine national priorities is increasingly shifting towards administrators and federal oversight institutions. The second shift is from electoral politics to performance-based administration. The question is no longer simply who won the election. The question is who delivers, who monitors and who decides what constitutes performance. Pakistan 2027 will move from negotiated politics to security-centred administration. Political bargaining is losing ground. Administrative control is gaining ground. National security and institutional stability will increasingly determine political priorities. The constitution may remain unchanged. The institutions may remain unchanged. But the distribution of power is changing. The emerging structure places civilian political authority increasingly within parameters shaped by powerful security institutions. Administrative accountability, however, must mean more than administrators reporting to other administrators. Who sets the targets? Who audits the results? Who holds the administrators accountable? Without answers, administrative accountability could become administrative control. What will all this mean for an average Pakistani? Hopefully, delivery instead of promises. A police station judged by crimes reported, cases solved and citizens protected, not the number of officers employed. A government school judged by what children learn, not the number of schools inaugurated. A government hospital judged by doctors on duty and medicines available, not the size of its budget. The shift: from spending to outcomes and from promises to performance. In Pakistan 2027, public money must produce public results. Projects must have deadlines. Administrators must be judged by outcomes. That, at least, is the promise. Governments change. Priorities change. Projects are abandoned. Billions are wasted. Pakistan cannot afford this cycle. For an average Pakistani, security is not an abstract concept. It is a journey without fear. A business without extortion. A school without threats. Better coordination between intelligence, policing and civilian administration must produce greater security for ordinary Pakistanis. Pakistan 2027 must move from political privilege to economic opportunity. Administrative restructuring should reduce discretionary privileges. Decisions should come faster. Investment should become easier. Jobs should multiply. Household incomes should rise. That is what reform must deliver. Pakistan’s problem has never been just the availability of resources. It has been what those resources produce. Between 2010 and 2026, Rs76 trillion travelled from Islamabad to Karachi, Lahore, Peshawar and Quetta. That’s Rs20 lakh per Pakistani household. That’s the equivalent of a million schools, a quarter of a million clinics or three hundred thousand kilometres of roads. Where are the results? Over the same time frame, Islamabad’s debt and liabilities went from Rs10 trillion to Rs100 trillion. This cannot continue. Pakistan cannot sustain itself without a new relationship between power and performance. Pakistan’s political map may remain unchanged, but the map of power will not. The ultimate test of Pakistan 2027 will not be who governs Pakistan. It will be whether Pakistanis are governed better.
3
11
1
38
1,748
This Pax Silica Declaration puts the assassination strike on Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang into a clearer, larger context. Israel is shaping control of AI as its best shot at global technological hegemony, just as Netanyahu declared. “Within this framework, Israel will play a central role in building technological and economic resilience, both for itself and in partnership with Pax Silica member states, to reduce external dependencies and diversify supply chains as an integral part of national security.”
The State of Israel, jointly with the member states of the Pax Silica initiative, signed the San Francisco Declaration on the Secure Foundations of Enduring Prosperity – a declaration on the protection of critical technologies. The State of Israel, one of the founding nations of the Pax Silica initiative, signed the San Francisco Declaration on the Secure Foundations of Enduring Prosperity yesterday (Sunday, 15 November 2026), as part of an official visit to the U.S. by all member states of the initiative. The Declaration, signed by the core states of Pax Silica, constitutes an agreement on the protection of critical technologies. This is an important milestone for the founding coalition that will chart the course for future steps, anchoring a vision of Collaborative Sovereignty and economic security based on superintelligence (SI). Within this framework, Israel will play a central role in building technological and economic resilience, both for itself and in partnership with Pax Silica member states, to reduce external dependencies and diversify supply chains as an integral part of national security. At the core of the Declaration is the establishment of joint working groups to secure critical infrastructure and protect critical technologies. The partnership will protect the entire AI value chain: from hardware, software, and knowledge components, to infrastructure of energy, communications, logistics, and data management, with the aim of preventing knowledge leakage and ensuring a stable environment for innovation and mutual growth. At the summit meeting, Israel presented the model of the National Institute for Impact-Driven Artificial Intelligence (NIIA), which enables the strengthening of economic resilience and the acceleration of prosperity through the implementation of advanced AI solutions. Head of the National AI Directorate in the Prime Minister's Office, Erez Askal: "In the AI era, true technological sovereignty is not built in isolation, but rather through Collaborative Sovereignty and deep alliances. The Declaration signing constitutes a major milestone for the Pax Silica founding alliance and will chart the course for our next steps. With this signing, Israel is to play a pivotal role in building technological and economic resilience, both for itself and in partnership with the coalition members. We bring to the table Israel's diverse operational and technological experience in the fields of defense and cyber, as well as the NIIA model for implementing impact-driven solutions, which will enable us to lead the efforts of securing infrastructure for computing and energy, and critical supply chains. Together, we are translating a shared vision into practical steps that will protect all of our strategic assets and ensure Israel's technological leadership."
63
564
37
1,338
41,071
Munim retweeted
Crazy that this was barely even a news story.
A 9-month-old baby has died of hypothermia in his family's tent in #Gaza. "At least 11 children died of cold last winter, and this one has barely begun. Tents & blankets sat at the border, blocked by Israel, while he froze to death. Indefensible." Ahmad Alhendawi @save_children
43
1,685
8
5,801
50,003
"In an early Hamas handbill, it was mentioned that the Israeli Intelligence Service, the Shin Bet, was trying to trap agents with the aid of hashish and other drugs and that it caught young women in its net by having ‘stray dogs’ (Palestinian collaborators) seduce them. The leaflet said that young girls were being encouraged to frequent hairdressers, boutiques (places young educated women used to run as their private businesses), or even shoe stores without a chaperone [...] These tactics became known as the Israeli ‘isqat’ policy. In response, young men were warned off alcohol, pornographic magazines, and loose women who tried to flirt with them in the street. Thus, strict moral conduct, piety and modesty were elevated to important tools for national resistance and weapons of the underground." - Islah Jad, “Islamist Women of Hamas: Between Feminism and Nationalism,” Inter-Asia Cultural Studies 12, no. 2 (2011), p. 187. Note: "Isqat" denotes the methods used by the Israelis to use or seduce the victim and force them to work against their people’s national interests.
9
141
9
488
13,886
Wow. The University of Toronto commissioned a report on anti-Palestinian racism, then rejected it because naming that discrimination makes others uncomfortable. The irony of the Palestine Exception is stunning.
Replying to @thaqafatalhind
The university admin "cannot accept the... report and recommendations as written... aspects be offensive and upsetting to other members of our community, including some Jewish and Israeli colleagues and students." people.utoronto.ca/wp-conten…
69
1,841
33
5,598
83,060
The Colonial Hangover of some public commentators needs a special treatment! The War Crimes of Biden-Harris adminstration can't be whitewashed by Abdul Syed's senate victory.
1
109
10
599
27,809
موذن مرحبا بروقت بولا تری آواز مکے و مدینے اللہ رب العالمین سید ابوالاعلی مودودی صدر الدین اصلاحی چوہدری غلام محمد رحمھم اللہ اجمعین کے درجات بلند کرے کروٹ کروٹ جنت الفردوس عطا فرمائے اور ہمیں ایسے عالی قدر بلند فکر اور کردار والے افراد مزید عطا فرمائے آمین ثم آمین 🤲 😢 🤲
یہ معمہ ہر بڑے آدمی کے ساتھ رہتا ہے کہ اسکا فکری جانشین کون ہے / تھا۔ سید مودودی کے اصلی علمی و فکری جانشین اور تحریکِ اسلامی کے روح شناس میری ناقص رائے میں مولانا صدر الدین اصلاحی مرحوم تھے۔ تنظیمی جانشین چوہدری غلام محمد تھے۔ خیر، مولانا اصلاحی کی ہر سطر پڑھنے والی ہے۔ آپ اصلی تصوف پر کتنا ہی مطالعہ کر لیں اور پھر صرف «حقیقتِ نفاق» کو کسی اچھے عالم سے سمجھنے کے انداز میں پڑھ لیں (پیر بنائے بغیر!!)، بڑے بڑے خلجان دور ہو جائیں گے۔ یہ بہت ہی بڑی تصنیف ہے۔ مدارج السالکین کو شروع کرنے سے پہلے یہ سمجھ لی جائے تو پھر شاید اور انفرادی سطح پر کمی نہیں رہتی۔ خود مولانا اصلاحی نے یہ تصنیف اپنی جوانی میں فراغت کے بعد براہِ راست مولانا مودودی کے پاس دار الاسلام پٹھانکوٹ میں تربیت اور صحبت کے بعد سب سے پہلا جو سلسلۂ مضامین لکھا تھا وہ یہی تھا۔ اور آخری صدی میں تصوف کی روح اور اسکے عملی تقاضوں کو سمجھنے والا سید مودودی کے علاوہ شائد ہی کوئی اور اس پائے کا ہو۔ انکے مضامین «نظامِ جاہلیت سے تعاون»، «معرکۂ اسلام و جاهلیة» وغیرہ سے بہت ناانصافی کی گئی ہے۔ انکے مقدمے کا اطلاق انگریزی حکومت اور آزادی سے قبل تھا۔ مسلم معاشروں پر اطلاق اور اس سے فساد کا جواز نکالنا مولانا اصلاحی پر بہتان اور تہمت ہیں۔ فکرِ ولی اللہی میں انکی contribution «افاداتِ شاہ ولی اللہ دہلوی» اور «اختلافی مسائل میں اعتدال کی راہ» ہیں جو مولانا مودودی کی ایما پر اور نظرِ ثانی کے بعد اولین ترجمان القرآن میں شائع ہوئے۔ حکیم محمود برکاتی شہیدؒ کے ساتھ ساتھ مولانا اصلاحی وہ link تھا جو سید مودودی کی تحریک کو فکر ولی اللہی سے جوڑتا تھا۔ بلکہ مولانا سے تربیت کے بعد پٹھانکوٹ سے حقیقت نفاق کے بعد دوسری تصنیف مولانا اصلاحی کی یہی تھی۔ کیسے کوہِ ہمالہ جیسے لوگ تھے۔ آج کل کو فکر فراہی کا باجا ہے اس کی حیثیت ہی کیا ان لوگوں کے سامنے۔ پھر مولانا مودودی کو امام ابنِ تیمیہ سے بہت انس تھا۔ غلامِ جیلانی برق کو امام ابن تیمیہ پر تھیسز تیار کرنے پر آمادہ کرنے پھر نظرِ ثانی اور اچھی خاصی ذاتی محنت کے بعد انکی شہرہ آفاق تصنیف «امام ابن تیمیہ» جو اردو میں اپنی نوعیت کی پہلی کتاب تھی، کو شائع کروانے میں اصل کردار سید مودودی کا ہی تھا۔ مگر ان سے پہلے ۱۹۴۵ء یا ۴۶ء میں مولانا صدر الدین اصلاحی نے امام ابن تیمیہ کے مشہور رسالے «العبودية» کا قسط وار ترجمہ کیا تھا جو مولانا مودودی کی ایما اور پسند پر تھا۔ بعد میں یہ ترجمہ «حقیقتِ عبودیت» نے نام سے شائع ہوا۔ اسی طرح ڈاکٹر رضی الاسلام ندوی کی «اقامتِ دین اور نفاذ شریعت» اور مولانا اصلاحی کی «فریضۂ اقامت دین» اور «اساسِ دین کی تعمیر» مولانا مودودی کی فکر کو ہر طرح سے واضح اور دوٹوک کر دیتے ہیں کہ مزید کی گنجائش ہی نہیں رہتی۔ شاید یہی وجہ تھی کہ مولانا مودودیؒ نے «تفہیم القرآن» کی تلخیص کرنے کی کسی کو اجازت خود مرحمت فرمائی تو وہ مولانا اصلاحی تھے اور آپ اگر «تلخیص تفہیم القرآن» کا مطالعہ کریں تو خود اندازہ ہو جائے گا کہ مولانا اصلاحی کس پائے کے method محقق اور عالم تھے۔ خیر، آج مولانا اصلاحی کا آج یومِ وفات ہے۔ کیسا اللہ کا ولی بھی گزر گیا۔ از باغ جهان رخ ببستیم و گذشتیم شاخی ز درختی نشکستیم و گذشتیم
1
2
16
648
یہ معمہ ہر بڑے آدمی کے ساتھ رہتا ہے کہ اسکا فکری جانشین کون ہے / تھا۔ سید مودودی کے اصلی علمی و فکری جانشین اور تحریکِ اسلامی کے روح شناس میری ناقص رائے میں مولانا صدر الدین اصلاحی مرحوم تھے۔ تنظیمی جانشین چوہدری غلام محمد تھے۔ خیر، مولانا اصلاحی کی ہر سطر پڑھنے والی ہے۔ آپ اصلی تصوف پر کتنا ہی مطالعہ کر لیں اور پھر صرف «حقیقتِ نفاق» کو کسی اچھے عالم سے سمجھنے کے انداز میں پڑھ لیں (پیر بنائے بغیر!!)، بڑے بڑے خلجان دور ہو جائیں گے۔ یہ بہت ہی بڑی تصنیف ہے۔ مدارج السالکین کو شروع کرنے سے پہلے یہ سمجھ لی جائے تو پھر شاید اور انفرادی سطح پر کمی نہیں رہتی۔ خود مولانا اصلاحی نے یہ تصنیف اپنی جوانی میں فراغت کے بعد براہِ راست مولانا مودودی کے پاس دار الاسلام پٹھانکوٹ میں تربیت اور صحبت کے بعد سب سے پہلا جو سلسلۂ مضامین لکھا تھا وہ یہی تھا۔ اور آخری صدی میں تصوف کی روح اور اسکے عملی تقاضوں کو سمجھنے والا سید مودودی کے علاوہ شائد ہی کوئی اور اس پائے کا ہو۔ انکے مضامین «نظامِ جاہلیت سے تعاون»، «معرکۂ اسلام و جاهلیة» وغیرہ سے بہت ناانصافی کی گئی ہے۔ انکے مقدمے کا اطلاق انگریزی حکومت اور آزادی سے قبل تھا۔ مسلم معاشروں پر اطلاق اور اس سے فساد کا جواز نکالنا مولانا اصلاحی پر بہتان اور تہمت ہیں۔ فکرِ ولی اللہی میں انکی contribution «افاداتِ شاہ ولی اللہ دہلوی» اور «اختلافی مسائل میں اعتدال کی راہ» ہیں جو مولانا مودودی کی ایما پر اور نظرِ ثانی کے بعد اولین ترجمان القرآن میں شائع ہوئے۔ حکیم محمود برکاتی شہیدؒ کے ساتھ ساتھ مولانا اصلاحی وہ link تھا جو سید مودودی کی تحریک کو فکر ولی اللہی سے جوڑتا تھا۔ بلکہ مولانا سے تربیت کے بعد پٹھانکوٹ سے حقیقت نفاق کے بعد دوسری تصنیف مولانا اصلاحی کی یہی تھی۔ کیسے کوہِ ہمالہ جیسے لوگ تھے۔ آج کل کو فکر فراہی کا باجا ہے اس کی حیثیت ہی کیا ان لوگوں کے سامنے۔ پھر مولانا مودودی کو امام ابنِ تیمیہ سے بہت انس تھا۔ غلامِ جیلانی برق کو امام ابن تیمیہ پر تھیسز تیار کرنے پر آمادہ کرنے پھر نظرِ ثانی اور اچھی خاصی ذاتی محنت کے بعد انکی شہرہ آفاق تصنیف «امام ابن تیمیہ» جو اردو میں اپنی نوعیت کی پہلی کتاب تھی، کو شائع کروانے میں اصل کردار سید مودودی کا ہی تھا۔ مگر ان سے پہلے ۱۹۴۵ء یا ۴۶ء میں مولانا صدر الدین اصلاحی نے امام ابن تیمیہ کے مشہور رسالے «العبودية» کا قسط وار ترجمہ کیا تھا جو مولانا مودودی کی ایما اور پسند پر تھا۔ بعد میں یہ ترجمہ «حقیقتِ عبودیت» نے نام سے شائع ہوا۔ اسی طرح ڈاکٹر رضی الاسلام ندوی کی «اقامتِ دین اور نفاذ شریعت» اور مولانا اصلاحی کی «فریضۂ اقامت دین» اور «اساسِ دین کی تعمیر» مولانا مودودی کی فکر کو ہر طرح سے واضح اور دوٹوک کر دیتے ہیں کہ مزید کی گنجائش ہی نہیں رہتی۔ شاید یہی وجہ تھی کہ مولانا مودودیؒ نے «تفہیم القرآن» کی تلخیص کرنے کی کسی کو اجازت خود مرحمت فرمائی تو وہ مولانا اصلاحی تھے اور آپ اگر «تلخیص تفہیم القرآن» کا مطالعہ کریں تو خود اندازہ ہو جائے گا کہ مولانا اصلاحی کس پائے کے method محقق اور عالم تھے۔ خیر، آج مولانا اصلاحی کا آج یومِ وفات ہے۔ کیسا اللہ کا ولی بھی گزر گیا۔ از باغ جهان رخ ببستیم و گذشتیم شاخی ز درختی نشکستیم و گذشتیم
9
25
2
77
4,209
Just let me know which one I should restart
Replying to @MSFT365Status
We’re opening all available pathways to restore service, as our actions taken thus far have not provided the anticipated relief. We found a core process on affected servers is becoming overwhelmed, causing capacity loss. To validate a potential recovery, we're isolating a portion of infrastructure, restarting affected components, and reintroducing traffic to confirm the services remain stable before applying the change more broadly. More info under EX1550543 and MO1550821 in the Microsoft 365 admin center, as well as status.cloud.microsoft if the admin center is not available to you.
418
8,411
290
125,174
2,810,000
My Experience With the Leaders of the Jensen Coup At the start of 2025, numerous Washington, D.C. based NGOs began spreading the false rumor that DeepSeek smuggled 50,000 H100 GPUs. Speaking from firsthand experience, organized think tanks, PR firms, and lobbyists aggressively personally attacked anyone merely asking them to provide evidence. Call them the Export Controls Deep State, or if that’s too right-coded for you, use the Obama-administration term “Foreign Policy Blob”. The same charlatans are attempting a coup on Jensen Huang, the most indispensable CEO to America’s AI success. If we lost Sam, we have Dario. If we lost Dario, we have Demis. Nvidia is singular. The gap between Nvidia and AMD would be wider than the gap between OpenAI and Mistral, Europe’s top AI company whose models don’t rank in the top 40. This is an attempt to derail the most important company for the American AI industry. The entire coup against Jensen Huang can be halted by asking a single question. What evidence is there that Alice Huang is actually a Chinese spy? The answer, unsurprisingly, is absolutely zero. There is not even the pretense of a factual basis for the claim. “We made it the fuck up, and if you have a problem with that, what are you, pro-China?” Taking away this obvious falsehood, the coup against Jensen boils down to a celebrity tabloid headline. Moreover, without the entirely fabricated ‘national security relevance’, these tabloid headlines would be at best a weekend story in the New York Post. Another basic question: if there is evidence of ‘national security relevance’, why not charge Jensen? The basic answer: they lack even the evidence to justify a warrant. During my time in DC, I was advised repeatedly to stay on the good side of the Export Controls Deep State. I was added to many groups for boosting content spreading the 50,000 H100s conspiracy theory. In several groups, I asked whether there was any evidence behind this claim. One group administrator, who was and still is affiliated with Georgetown, explicitly told me to “focus on bolstering the narrative”. I later posted Patel’s pseudo-correction and was subsequently removed from all of these groups. What you need to understand about the Export Controls Deep State is that they have no incentive to be remotely honest, because they are entirely unaccountable. To this day, they provided zero evidence for their claim. Internet historians later traced the origin of this claim to a tweet by Dylan Patel of Semianalysis. Patel later said they lied about his tweet and that his claim counted legally obtained hardware. Affiliates of universities and think tanks promote these baseless claims and are taken seriously by the national press. In reality, their theories about Nvidia are as kooky as the guy who shot up Comet Pizza. The reason they succeed is not only because they are unaccountable, but because they constantly use their unaccountability to attack others. There are broader foreign policy implications to these observations about political power, but I will stick to what I witnessed firsthand. After Trump’s election, his administration began lifting the export control cap. Surprising no one informed about this policy, America widened our lead. Deepseek was closest to catching up to American models in January 2025, literally the moment of peak export controls. Based on communication with members of the administration, the evidence that a) the export controls were net negative and b) the export controls deep state was acting in bad faith, that as soon as the situation was described accurately, the administration began rolling them back. Part of this is because many of these NGOs are funded by foundations like Open Philanthropy / Coefficient Giving, who explicitly intend to harm American AI companies because they believe American AI will “cause human extinction”. As a result, the BIS under the Biden administration was used as an informal cudgel against AI companies, both to censor in favor of their worldview, as seen in the Gemini scandal, as well as to backdoor regulation to slow down American AI broadly. While they love to accuse everyone else of being traitors, the Export Controls Deep State makes Americans poorer and the American military, to the extent they use AI, weaker. Most of the time, the best you can do is ignore them. They really are unaccountable and the personal retribution isn’t worth the cost. But now, they are leading a coup against the AI industry’s most indispensable man based on lies and tabloid gossip. Everyone should understand that the Export Controls Deep State has never provided any evidence for their claims nor any reason for their word to be trusted.
165
636
148
4,013
537,501
Palestinian journalists are sharing images of what they say is an unexploded US-made bomb used in Israel's attack on Nasser hospital overnight that killed 6 people. Israel says it was targeting a senior Hamas figure based in the Gaza hospital. The pictures appear to show a GBU-39/B bomb manufactured by Boeing.
109
1,530
77
5,131
565,776
What if Jensen Huang decided one day that Washington could keep its hearings and its revenue-sharing deals, and moved Nvidia's, new or otherwise, centre of gravity to Asia? The idea is less absurd than it sounds. The United States has become one of the least hospitable places to run a large, independent business that will not fall into line. It rewards such firms generously while they comply. Once they stop, it turns on them through regulators, prosecutors and congressional committees. This has happened before. In the 1980s the target was Japan. In 1987 members of Congress smashed a Toshiba radio on the Capitol lawn over the Toshiba-Kongsberg submarine-technology affair, and Washington used the 1986 Semiconductor Agreement to break Japan's lead in memory chips. In the 2010s it was France's Alstom. The US Justice Department pursued Alstom under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and jailed one of its executives, and its power business ended up in GE's hands. I’ve seen firsthand the saga post-GE-Alstom merger as GE had been our principal for decades. Insiders in Silicon Valley and on Wall Street still admit, in private, how the Japanese and the Chinese were treated. What has changed is that a company which steps out of line now has somewhere else to go. In earlier decades, many such companies simply faded into obscurity. Seen this way, Nvidia did the most rational thing it could under the terms it was given. It designed compliant chips for China, agreed to give the US government a cut of its China sales, and kept selling within the rules. Nearly every large American hardware company has worked in China on similar terms. Even the shadow companies, whole shell companies, even Ras Al-Khaimah and Dubai’s major shadow economy are exactly what Nvidia has been accused of. All intel agencies and governments know this and keep silent as a choice since these channels are dual use. The question also is, how much access and insight did Jenseng give in return on Chinese supply chains and methods? Even Nvidia was screwed more aggressively than the rest. I mean, GE runs an avionics joint venture with the state-owned AVIC. Honeywell and 3M have deep manufacturing and R&D bases there. Boeing has a 737 completion centre in Zhoushan. So why single out Huang, and turn a customer executive's alleged intelligence links into a story of Chinese espionage at Nvidia's core? That looks less like counter-intelligence and more like the first phase of a political takeover of America's most valuable company. Washington's 2025 equity stake in Intel already shows how that would work. Why is Johny Srouji one of the runners for next CEO? There’s much more to say and the world increasingly knows the tale too well. The problem for Washington is that this is not the 1950s or 1960s. America's economic exceptionalism rested on industrial depth that has since been hollowed out. The bill for decades of debt-financed consumption is now coming due, and much of it is owed to Asia, China included: in Treasury holdings, in supply chains and in the goods themselves. The September 2025 raid on the Hyundai-LG battery plant in Georgia showed how little self-awareness is left. Immigration agents shackled hundreds of South Korean technicians who had come to build a factory Washington itself had courted. A country that treats its own investors this way should not be surprised when the next one takes its business elsewhere, and it will be a domino from thereon. Already all major European manufacturing giants have some subsidiary or JV in China hedging against Americans effectively.
1
3
16
1,056
جو عالمِ ایجاد میں ہے صاحبِ ایجاد ہر دَور میں کرتا ہے طواف اس کا زمانہ تقلید سے ناکارہ نہ کر اپنی خودی کو کر اس کی حفاظت کہ یہ گوہر ہے یگانہ اُس قوم کو تجدید کا پیغام مبارک! ہے جس کے تصّور میں فقط بزمِ شبانہ لیکن مجھے ڈر ہے کہ یہ آوازۂ تجدید مشرق میں ہے تقلیدِ فرنگی کا بہانہ —— اقبال کا پاکستان کے متعلق وژن یہ عالمِ ایجاد ہی تھا۔ مگر خودی کا تصور کوئی abstraction نہیں تھی۔ یہ بہت سوچا سمجھا تصور تھا۔ ظاہر ہے کہ اقبال جس دور میں تھے، انکے مخاطبین کے لیے یہ تصور اور اسکا احاطہ کرنا نہایت مشکل تھا۔ اقبال نے فلسفہ اور تاریخ خود یورپ کے چوٹی کے لوگوں سے انہی کی زبان میں پڑھی تھی۔ میں دوستوں کو بتاتا ہوں کہ ہیگل کہتا تھا کہ میرا فلسفہ انگریزی میں ایک نے ہی کچھ ترجمہ کی ٹھیک کوشش کی اور اس نے بھی غلط سمجھا۔ جبکہ اقبال نے جرمن فلسفۂ الہیات کو خود جرمن زبان میں پڑھا تھا۔ اقبال معمار اور practicing وکیل تھے۔ ترجمے پڑھ کر کچہری کے تھڑے باز یا geek نہیں تھے۔ مسلم زعما اور لیڈر انکی بات پر چلتے تھے اور اقبال کو اپنے افکار کے implications کا اندازہ تھا۔ اسی لیے ہندوستان بھر کے علماء جن میں مولانا مودودی سے پیر مہر علی شاہ تک شامل ہیں، ان سے تعلق میں اقبال نے فضول کے مباحث، لایعنی نکتہ گوئی، اور تجریدی آوارگی کی بجائے پریکٹیکل to the point بات کی ہے۔ اقبال کے خطبات بھی انجینئر، ڈاکٹرز وغیرہ کے پڑھنے کی چیز ہے مگر وہ فلسفے کے تراجم پڑھنے والی مخلوقوں کے ہتھے چڑھ کر بے تحاشہ آلودگی میں اضافہ کا باعث ہی ہوئی ہے۔ اسی تناظر میں عالم ایجاد پر زور اور خودی اور تقلید کو چھوڑے بغیر یہ بہت بڑی بات ہے ایک ایسے آدمی کے متعلق سے جس کے سامنے سلطنت برطانیہ اپنے عروج پر تھی اور پوری مسلم اور غیر مسلم دنیا میں تجدید کہیں تھی تو فقط تقلیدِ فرنگی کا بہانہ ہی تھی۔ فرانس، امریکہ، جاپان، لاطینی امریکہ، مشرقِ بعید وغیرہ سب۔ دوسری گول میز کانفرنس اور اپنے اسفار کے بعد اقبال کہتے تھے کہ یورپ کو ابھی پھر لڑنا ہے، خود صد ہزار انجم سے سحر پیدا ہو گی، ہمالہ کے چشمے ابلیں گے، اور گراں خواب چینی اُٹھ کھڑے ہو نگے۔ یہ ہے وہ نظر جو واقعی آپ نے فلسفہ پڑھا ہو تو پیدا ہوتی ہے۔ ورنہ ترجموں کے بعد رٹے ہی مارتا ہے بندا۔ اقبال نے یہی کہا تھا کہ اٹھو اور علوم و فنون میں دسترس پیدا کرو۔ چینیوں اور ترکوں نے یہی کیا ہے۔ ہمارے ہاں کی نظریاتی بحثوں نے کبارا کیا ہے۔ آج اقبال جتنے relevant ہیں وہ شاید اپنے زمانے میں نہیں تھے۔ مسلمانوں کا ماضی، انکا علمی اور تاریخی سرمایہ اب کہیں نہیں جانے لگا ۔۔۔ خودی کو آج تقلید کی زیادہ ضرورت ہے اور مشرق سے اُبھرنے والے سورج میں اب مسلمانوں کا حصہ بھی ہے، جسے اب بقدرِ جثہ کرنا میرا اور آپ کا کام ہے۔
یہ ۹ نومبر انہیں زیادہ مبارک ہو جنہیں نطشے کی تو خیر “ککھ” سمجھ نہیں جس سے اقبال کے سرقے کا افسانہ گھڑے بیٹھے ہیں ۔۔۔ فارسی یا فارسی شعری روایت کا علم ہو تو اقبال کے پلے کچھ نہ رہنے دیں سوائے ارمغان اور بانگ درا کے کچھ حصے کے۔ اقبال نے نظیری کے کلام سے اپنا تعارف کروایا ہے:
2
5
14
433
From the Rafah border crossing, Lewis Hamilton is pulling no punches on Israel's cruel siege regime.
117
2,978
58
12,652
253,611
ISRAEL HAS JUST KILLED THE HEAD OF THE SURGERY DEPARTMENT AND FIVE ATHERS and bombed Nasser Medical Complex.
290
19,996
204
52,787
501,486
NEW MASSACRE inside hospital Six patients have been killed and over 30 others wounded by Israeli airstrike targeted Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis.. Unbelievable damage..
33
1,047
39
1,449
19,086
Never mind, Fable 5.2 did it.
PCB routing is going to be the last engineering job that humans still need to do.
187
981
157
23,218
792,758
As Pakistan prepares to welcome international investors, mining companies and industry experts at the Pakistan Minerals Investment Forum in Islamabad next week, it is important to look beyond the immediate objective of attracting investment..... Read Complete Article : brecorder.com/news/40447902/…
24
39
655