MikePietsch retweeted
Six Battles a Man Must Win in Private:
1. His Eyes: What he looks at when nobody sees. Job 31:1
2. His Thoughts: What he allows to live in his mind. 2 Corinthians 10:5
3. His Appetites: What he refuses to deny. 1 Corinthians 9:27
4. His Pride: What he will not confess. Proverbs 28:13
5. His Anger: What he keeps rehearsing. Ephesians 4:26
6. His Prayer: Whether he seeks God before he acts. Luke 18:1
The man you are in secret is the man you really are.
MikePietsch retweeted
I don’t think these women understand how the Lindsay Clancy case is impacting the way men see women…
MikePietsch retweeted
The Ellis/D’Souza objection collapses because it assumes, without argument, that divine love must be uniform, non‑elective, and obligatorily maximal toward every human creature. That assumption is never defended; it is simply presupposed. Once presupposed, any doctrine of election becomes “monstrous” by definitional fiat. The argument therefore commits the elementary logical error of smuggling the conclusion into the premise.
Second, the objection equivocates on the term love. It treats love as a distributive attribute—something God must parcel out identically to all—rather than as a covenantal mode of divine self‑giving. In Scripture, divine love is architecturally differentiated: Israel is loved in a way Egypt is not; the church is loved in a way the world is not; the Son is loved in a way no creature ever will be. To insist that elective mercy is a defect is to insist that the biblical pattern itself is defective. The argument therefore fails at the level of textual ontology.
Third, the objection assumes that mercy is something God owes to creatures simply by virtue of their creaturehood. But mercy, by definition, is non‑obligatory. To treat mercy as an entitlement is to destroy the category. The critique thus commits a category error: it treats grace as debt. Once grace becomes debt, the entire Pauline structure collapses.
Fourth, the objection treats divine freedom as morally suspect. If God is free to differentiate, they conclude He is unjust. But that conclusion only follows if one assumes that justice requires equal outcomes rather than righteous action. That is not a biblical definition of justice; it is a modern egalitarian one. The argument therefore imports a foreign moral framework and then condemns Calvinism for not conforming to it.
Finally, the rhetoric of “God makes defective humans” is not an argument but a projection. It presupposes that human fallenness is a divine manufacturing flaw rather than a covenantal rupture. That is not Calvinism; that is not Arminianism; that is not historic Christianity. It is simply a category mistake: confusing ontology with covenant history.
In sum, the critique is not a refutation of Calvinism. It is a refutation of a theological system the critics have invented by assuming their conclusion, redefining biblical categories, and importing alien moral axioms. It is structurally invalid from the first premise.
#CovenantalCategories
#ElectiveMercyIsNotDebt
#CreatorCreatureDistinction
#BiblicalLoveIsDifferentiated
#GraceIsNotEntitlement























