Hello, @TeamYouTube @YouTube. What is happening on your platform right now is a nightmare.
We understand that YouTube, as a multibillion-dollar company, is focused on making a profit. But please do not forget the creators who spent years filling this platform with content, growing it, and bringing in audiences. Without creators, YouTube would not have become what it is today.
The problem of mass waves of demonetization needs to be addressed urgently. Why are original creators, who make unique content and invest their ideas, time, and effort into it, being left without income? Why is the platform pushing away the very people who help it grow?
There used to be a clear and fair balance between creators and YouTube: we created content, you provided the platform, and the revenue was shared between both sides. But what is happening now is destroying that trust.
Please do not stay on the sidelines. Start listening to creators and pay attention to this problem before it is too late.
After I submitted my appeal, it still received not a single view. This means the appeal I put my time and effort into was not even watched, and it was simply rejected without any real review.
We do not want to spend months paying the price for a bot’s mistake in a problem we had nothing to do with!
Creators affected include:
@AgicusA31290
@ciconimation
@danbayron6
@SLHanimation
@Sangsang_Cmrce
@SonicFunnyhog
@StTyler68303
@rafayta
@doritosreaction
@HammersMar27351
@Dummyworld_Real
@maxedystuff
@MOYAM174204
@GazillLod
@Z1MA777
@YTMickeysPlay
@NpcUniverse
@yuan_chong49275
@PlayShinyLamp
@TricksteriousYT
@ZeljkoRosic3
@ani_real1
@DeyserMe
@lucky14377cff
@stategirlsyou
@CCountryz18217
@CubeDims
@MaksimNatu
@farmer12rice
@garnoldoyt
@MessYourself
@Panzerpicture
@MENTLE_xd
@NYKentertain
@yt_Axolotl_san
@CheGokuZ
@PBACONMAN3
@circogg
@ColePlaysThisYT
@muzin_channel
@stategirlsyou
@FairyLabYT
@kandagar322
@JJstoons
#YouTubeCreators #ReinstateAllChannels #TeamYouTube #YouTube #Monetization #CreatorRights #CreatorSupport
WOW
🚀 TakeGear for Cinema 4D is now available!
A free plugin designed to improve take and shot management workflows inside C4D.
GitHub: github.com/punidamps-cloud/T…
#Cinema4D #C4D #Animation #MotionDesign #3DArt #GameDev
Hello @TeamYouTube Let’s sort this out properly. Even after 60 days, I am still ready to provide all the evidence.
My channel, JJSToon youtube.com/channel/UCBr-aRt… , was demonetized 38 days ago. It has already been 38 days since @YouTubeCreators @YouTube , without any warning, took away my only source of income. I put everything I had into creating my content: each video took me anywhere from several weeks to a full month to make. My content was never created just to chase mass views at any cost.
At the same time, it only takes a look at channels that gain millions of views by using nothing more than sets of hashtags in their titles. Those videos continue to stay monetized.
I insist on a second manual review of my channel by YouTube. Right now, the situation is that some creators openly abuse the system and continue earning money, while I, despite following the rules and creating original content, am left without any ability to work. On top of that, under the platform’s rules, I cannot even create a new channel just to try to recover some income.
Please, @TeamYouTube , look into this situation. I am specifically insisting on a manual review. I am ready to provide every possible piece of evidence: project files, rendered frame sequences, source files, and all the materials I personally created and used. I have kept everything: Cinema 4D files, Blender projects, PSD thumbnail files, written scripts, Premiere Pro sound design projects — and that is only a small part of what I am prepared to provide as proof.
Please retweet this post and leave a like so the YouTube team can see that this is a widespread problem.
xitter.cf/JJstoons/status/203892…
JJstoon retweeted
The guide can be summed up simply:
Stop taking other people's work and repackaging it as your own.
The real problem isn't "inauthentic content." The problem is that a lot of people think it's acceptable to take other people's work, repackage it into compilations or shorts, and then call it a "faceless channel."
And then they complain when they get into trouble.
Faceless channels are supposed to be for creators who don't want their identity linked to their content or for those who create content that should be identity independent, not for people who just want to have a free ride.
JJstoon retweeted
DAY 7 It’s been seven days since @TeamYouTube YouTube stopped responding to me. The issue still hasn’t been resolved, and I haven’t received any replies via email. My channel is also unmonetized. I’ll be posting on X until YouTube resolves the issue with my channel, since they wrongfully removed monetization from my original
Bloomation animation channel youtube.com/@bloomationshort…
Please support me, friends. I see that many creators are currently facing the same difficulties as I am. Let’s stick together during these tough times.
Creators affected include:
@MENTLE_xd
@AgicusA31290
@ciconimation
@danbayron6
@SLHanimation
@Sangsang_Cmrce
@SonicFunnyhog
@StTyler68303
@rafayta
@doritosreaction
@HammersMar27351
@Dummyworld_Real
@maxedystuff
@MOYAM174204
@GazillLod
@Z1MA777
@YTMickeysPlay
@NpcUniverse
@yuan_chong49275
@PlayShinyLamp
@TricksteriousYT
@ZeljkoRosic3
@ani_real1
@DeyserMe
@lucky14377cff
@stategirlsyou
@CCountryz18217
@CubeDims
@MaksimNatu
@farmer12rice
@garnoldoyt
@MessYourself
@Panzerpicture
@MENTLE_xd
@NYKentertain
@yt_Axolotl_san
@CheGokuZ
@PBACONMAN3
@circogg
@ColePlaysThisYT
@stategirlsyou
🤖 Made with AI
My channel, JJSToon youtube.com/channel/UCBr-aRt… , was demonetized 38 days ago. It has already been 38 days since @YouTubeCreators @YouTube , without any warning, took away my only source of income. I put everything I had into creating my content: each video took me anywhere from several weeks to a full month to make. My content was never created just to chase mass views at any cost.
At the same time, it only takes a look at channels that gain millions of views by using nothing more than sets of hashtags in their titles. Those videos continue to stay monetized.
I insist on a second manual review of my channel by YouTube. Right now, the situation is that some creators openly abuse the system and continue earning money, while I, despite following the rules and creating original content, am left without any ability to work. On top of that, under the platform’s rules, I cannot even create a new channel just to try to recover some income.
Please, @TeamYouTube , look into this situation. I am specifically insisting on a manual review. I am ready to provide every possible piece of evidence: project files, rendered frame sequences, source files, and all the materials I personally created and used. I have kept everything: Cinema 4D files, Blender projects, PSD thumbnail files, written scripts, Premiere Pro sound design projects — and that is only a small part of what I am prepared to provide as proof.
Please retweet this post and leave a like so the YouTube team can see that this is a widespread problem.
xitter.cf/JJstoons/status/203892…
Hello, @TeamYouTube @YouTube. What is happening on your platform right now is a nightmare.
We understand that YouTube, as a multibillion-dollar company, is focused on making a profit. But please do not forget the creators who spent years filling this platform with content, growing it, and bringing in audiences. Without creators, YouTube would not have become what it is today.
The problem of mass waves of demonetization needs to be addressed urgently. Why are original creators, who make unique content and invest their ideas, time, and effort into it, being left without income? Why is the platform pushing away the very people who help it grow?
There used to be a clear and fair balance between creators and YouTube: we created content, you provided the platform, and the revenue was shared between both sides. But what is happening now is destroying that trust.
Please do not stay on the sidelines. Start listening to creators and pay attention to this problem before it is too late.
After I submitted my appeal, it still received not a single view. This means the appeal I put my time and effort into was not even watched, and it was simply rejected without any real review.
We do not want to spend months paying the price for a bot’s mistake in a problem we had nothing to do with!
Creators affected include:
@AgicusA31290
@ciconimation
@danbayron6
@SLHanimation
@Sangsang_Cmrce
@SonicFunnyhog
@StTyler68303
@rafayta
@doritosreaction
@HammersMar27351
@Dummyworld_Real
@maxedystuff
@MOYAM174204
@GazillLod
@Z1MA777
@YTMickeysPlay
@NpcUniverse
@yuan_chong49275
@PlayShinyLamp
@TricksteriousYT
@ZeljkoRosic3
@ani_real1
@DeyserMe
@lucky14377cff
@stategirlsyou
@CCountryz18217
@CubeDims
@MaksimNatu
@farmer12rice
@garnoldoyt
@MessYourself
@Panzerpicture
@MENTLE_xd
@NYKentertain
@yt_Axolotl_san
@CheGokuZ
@PBACONMAN3
@circogg
@ColePlaysThisYT
@muzin_channel
@stategirlsyou
@FairyLabYT
@kandagar322
@JJstoons
#YouTubeCreators #ReinstateAllChannels #TeamYouTube #YouTube #Monetization #CreatorRights #CreatorSupport
JJstoon retweeted
My appeal has been rejected
Which is a shock considering that on both the incorrect video I uploaded and sent them as a mistake (my bad) which links to the real video, AND the real video both have ZERO VIEWS
Meaning it was not actually reviewed by a real human (1/2) @TeamYouTube
My YouTube Channel has had it's monetization disabled and I can no longer make money of my Videos. I was given no heads up and no reason other than being "Not In Line" with policies. I assume this is a moderation error and I ask @TeamYouTube to fix the problem
JJstoon retweeted
Hey @TeamYouTube Too many creators are facing the exact same situation: opaque decisions, removed monetization, no proper explanations, and support that only makes things worse instead of actually helping.
We do not need endless templates and AI - generated replies that do not listen to creators or review cases properly. This kind of “support” has already pushed too many people to the limit. It does not help - it alienates, devalues, and discriminates against creators who are simply trying to get a fair review.
How many more creators have to go through this before YouTube finally admits there is a serious problem?
We create the content. We bring the audience. We spend years building this platform with our work. In return, we deserve not faceless copy-paste responses, but clear explanations, a genuine manual review, and proper support.
This is happening far too often now to pretend everything is fine.
Creators and viewers, please support this post, repost it, and speak out. We all need transparent rules, real explanations, and human treatment.
@YouTube @TeamYouTube stop ignoring creators. Give us explanations. Give us real support. Give us a fair process.
Creators affected include:
@AgicusA31290
@ciconimation
@danbayron6
@SLHanimation
@Sangsang_Cmrce
@SonicFunnyhog
@StTyler68303
@rafayta
@doritosreaction
@HammersMar27351
@yuan_chong49275
@Dummyworld_Real
@maxedystuff
@MOYAM174204
@GazillLod
@Z1MA777
@YTMickeysPlay
@NpcUniverse
@yuan_chong49275
@PlayShinyLamp
@TricksteriousYT
@ZeljkoRosic3
#YouTubeCreators #ReinstateAllChannels
#TeamYouTube #YouTube #Monetization #CreatorRights #CreatorSupport
JJstoon retweeted
⚠️IMPORTANT READ: If YouTube doesn’t solve its AI problem quickly, we won’t have many human creators left. (+ research insights)
If you’re wondering why it feels like you’re seeing more AI content, and why human creators seem to be disappearing, here are the numbers from a real study by Goldberg and Lam. They analyzed what happened to the stock image market after generative AI was introduced. I’ve added an image showing what the data looked like month by month.
Every single month after AI entered the market, 1 in 4 creators exited because the economics stopped working for them.
Now, it wasn’t bad for everyone.
Total consumption on the platform went up by 39% per month. But sales of human-made content dropped every month.
The platform won.
The buyers won.
The human creators… didn’t.
Think about what that would look like on YouTube.
AI can already generate scripts, voiceovers, thumbnails, talking-head videos, and entire channels at a fraction of the cost and time it takes a human creator to produce a single video. The algorithm doesn’t care whether a video was made by a person who spent three days filming and editing or by a system that generated it in 20 minutes.
This isn’t about being anti-AI. AI helps a lot of creators improve their output.
But it is about protecting the type of content people actually want to watch.
And I’m not just talking about removing AI slop.
I’m talking about making sure human-driven channels are protected and prioritized over AI-driven content.
The stock image market already ran the experiment that YouTube hasn’t fully felt yet. Don't ignore that.
Here’s my ask to one person: @nealmohan
I know you’ve seen some of my work (algorithm, platform changes, etc). I respect what you’re doing for the platform, but this is your moment to stand for human creators. It’s time to put public effort into protecting them.
Not just AI labeling or low-lift solutions, they don't solve the problem in a meaningful way. No, we need a genuine, real, and public effort to preserve what YouTube was built on.
You’re one of the few people in a position to set a precedent for every platform.
Let’s talk.
For those interested in the actual research, check out Samuel G. Goldberg and H. Tai Lam's paper called "Generative AI In Equilibrium: Evidence From A Creative Goods Marketplace"
JJstoon retweeted
Replying to @TeamYouTube
@TeamYouTube YouTube just hit demonetized my animation channel for INAUTHENTIC CONTENT and I think I know why. My entire channel is MANUALLY DONE Blender animations. However I was manually voice replying to almost every comment I saw, and even though my public uploads are at 100
JJstoon retweeted
Replying to @TeamYouTube
@TeamYouTube Please point out our harmful videos (if there are any) or solve our monetization problem. You are destroying the creative foundation of YouTube by leaving AI slop and monetizing it.
original art by @lucisphora
@pandymonster @Panzerpicture
@SLHanimation @ciconimation
@yuan_chong49275
@Sangsang_Cmrce
@GazillLod
@Gajetoon_
@Cryptid_VR_360
@maxedystuff
@MOYAM174204
@heydad159137
@ToonBurger_
@AnonymousMikeYT
@master_pivot
@RSmokeTheBear
@dtoons_news
Hello @TeamYouTube I have a similar case! Please reconsider your new changes and stop pushing creators off the platform. #ReinstateAllChannels
Channel Name: vision VFX
Channel URL: youtube.com/@visionVFX Case ID Number: 4-5401000040646 Number of Days Demonetized: 5 month Reason / Flag Given: misleading family content #ReinstateAllChannels @TeamYouTube
Hey @TeamYouTube I’m waiting for your reply in direct messages! Please tell me what I should do next and what files I need to provide.
Hey @TeamYouTube @YouTube ! my channel JJSToon was unfairly demonetized. I uploaded only 6 trending Shorts, and your AI moderation removed monetization. Please do a manual review — it feels like my appeal wasn’t even looked at… :(
youtube.com/channel/UCBr-aRt…
Hey @TeamYouTube You still haven’t messaged me like you promised. Let’s resolve this situation.
Hey @TeamYouTube @YouTube ! my channel JJSToon was unfairly demonetized. I uploaded only 6 trending Shorts, and your AI moderation removed monetization. Please do a manual review — it feels like my appeal wasn’t even looked at… :(
youtube.com/channel/UCBr-aRt…
Hey @TeamYouTube I’m dealing with the same situation too. Please give creators a more honest and transparent review system that clearly explains why monetization was removed, instead of only pointing us to the policies.
1. Open a new youtube channel
2. Post a video that takes about 100 hours to make, it does great
3. Denied monetization for 'mass-produced content'
4. Post appeal against it
5. Youtube doesn't even watch appeal, rejects monetization
Please RT if you've been hit too
@TeamYouTube
Hi @TeamYouTube! Im sharing the details of my case. My channel JJSToon was also demonetized (February 23). You recently said you would respond, but Im still waiting for an update. Please reply to me Im ready to provide any proof that my work is original and not templated content
URGENT UPDATE: We won. @TeamYouTube just DM'd me confirming they reinstated my channel after seeing our posts.
They explicitly asked for the other creators I've been reposting to TAG THEM DIRECTLY right now so they can look into your cases.
@PizzaSlice_YT @heydad159137 @master_pivot @sweetasyo — TAG @TeamYouTube NOW. They are watching.
Hey @TeamYouTube @YouTube ! my channel JJSToon was unfairly demonetized. I uploaded only 6 trending Shorts, and your AI moderation removed monetization. Please do a manual review — it feels like my appeal wasn’t even looked at… :(
youtube.com/channel/UCBr-aRt…







































