John Kelly

We are aware of a website called buyceltic that references Celtic Supporters Ltd and links to our site. To be clear: this website is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or approved by Celtic Supporters Ltd. We have had no involvement in its creation or content. We have contacted the site operator directly and asked for all references to CSL to be removed. CSL takes its responsibilities to members and shareholders seriously. We would not put our name to any resource that we have not reviewed for accuracy and regulatory compliance. #CSL

Two final corrections, then we are done. On payment: Nobody was paid. Not a penny. The Paradox Paper was produced entirely voluntarily by people who care about this football club and believe its shareholders deserve better governance. No fee, no commission, no funding. Months of unpaid work driven by conviction. You have fabricated a claim about payment with no evidence, because none exists. On Szymanski-Kuypers and the audience: The target audience is not 28,000 registered shareholders. It’s the entire Celtic supporter base globally, hundreds of thousands of people who have a stake in how this club is governed whether they hold shares or not. That’s precisely why the paper was published in three formats: a full academic paper for those who want the rigour, an executive summary for those who want the conclusions, and a serialised weekly breakdown so every fan can engage with the analysis at their own pace. The Szymanski-Kuypers framework sits in the full paper. The serialisation explains the conclusions in plain language. That’s not a flaw in the approach, it’s the approach. Your argument is now that referencing established academic research in a governance paper is proof of AI authorship because “no human would be stupid enough.” We would suggest the opposite: no serious paper on football economics would omit the most cited finding in the field. As for anonymity: you have spent this thread calling the work bizarre, AI-generated, and now accusing the authors of taking payment that never existed. You are the reason anonymity was chosen. Every reply you post confirms that decision. We won’t be responding further.

Scan the QR to join.