The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Project I have long wanted to complete is now live on GDP Dynamics. It features a Goodwin Growth Cycle model with various forecasted techniques. Give it a try.
The Goodwin Business Cycle model is now live at:
gdpdynamics.com/goodwin
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
"Economics limps along with one foot in untested hypotheses and the other in untestable slogans."
-Joan Robinson
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
"The myth that holds that the great corporation is the puppet of the market, the powerless servant of the consumer, is, in fact one of the devices by which its power is perpetuated."
-John Kenneth Galbraith
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
In mainstream microeconomic theory, the law of diminishing marginal returns plays a central role.
When additional units of a variable input (like labor) are added to a fixed input (like capital or land), marginal productivity eventually declines.
As marginal productivity falls, marginal cost (MC) — the cost of producing one more unit of output — rises.
This assumption leads to the familiar U-shaped marginal cost curve, where:
MC first declines (due to increasing returns),
Then reaches a minimum,
And rises thereafter as diminishing returns set in.
Underlying Assumptions
This rising marginal cost framework assumes:
Short-run fixed capital: Some inputs cannot be changed immediately.
Profit maximization: Firms produce where marginal cost equals marginal revenue.
Perfect competition: In many textbook examples, rising MC intersects with a horizontal price line.
Some economists — especially post-Keynesians, institutionalists, and heterodox economists — question this assumption:
Empirical studies (e.g. Hall and Hitch’s "Full Cost Pricing") found many firms do not experience rising marginal cost, and instead use mark-up pricing over average costs.
In industries with increasing returns to scale or network effects, marginal costs can fall.
System dynamics and non-equilibrium approaches often drop the rising MC assumption entirely.
So instead of judging Steve by one shot tweet, you need to go into his work more. Keen challenges the textbook U-shaped marginal cost curve:
The Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns assumes fixed capital and a single variable input (typically labor), which is highly unrealistic in modern multiproduct, capital-intensive firms.
Modern production often involves increasing returns, network effects, and automation, none of which are captured by the standard cost curves.
The marginal cost framework leads to logical inconsistencies when applied in general equilibrium models, particularly when combined with assumptions of perfect competition and profit maximization.
To my PK & MMT followers
I do advise you to correct Dr. Keen's unbelievable view that mainstream teaches that marginal cost always rises.
There are pages & pages of **Econ 101** describing how sometimes marginal cost falls & other times it rises.
It makes you guys look bad & misinforms your followers.
For example, see Mankiw intro textbook here.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Monetarism wasn't a dangerous ideological experiment that got terrifyingly out of control. It was the ideological and programmatic form taken by a very deliberate and successful project to reassert the power of finance and property and to permanently weaken the unions. (4/4)
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Here's the bottom line: "Bankers don’t like budget deficits because they compete with bank loans as a source of growth." thenation.com/article/archiv…
Now you understand why the Wall St. billionaire Treasury Secretary wants to "delever" the public sector and "relever" the private sector. 4/end
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Here is the economics of Twitter blue ticks in one tweet:
Cornell’s degrees are very valuable. People are willing to pay for it. If Cornell decides that it will now on sell all it’s degrees for a price, the market price of Cornell degree will quickly fall to zero.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
I've been getting a few DM's saying "why are you not weighing in on the bank run?" The answer is simple. I don't know what's going on and neither does anyone else. Here's why? We live in a world where opinion is instant and analysis takes time.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
My undergraduate students come to the same conclusion at the end of a 2000 word essay on Globalisation and inflation targeting.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Hi @delta. Your flight attendants greeting us “would you like champagne? Let’s celebrate no more masks” is not what I paid for. It’s not only childish but also creates an uncomfortable, and potentially hostile environment for those of us still masked. COVID is also not seasonal.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Last week, evidence surfaced of the @CDCgov discussing their studies showing "a substantial proportion of Covid survivors will have life altering disabilities" -- and that #LongCovid will have a major impact on the health care system. 2/8 xitter.cf/PPEtoheros/status/1514…
Why is the CDC not talking about their studies showing a substantial proportion of Covid survivors will have life altering disabilities & that it’ll have a major impact on the health care system & social assistance? @LauraMiers @AbraarKaran @WalkerBragman.
stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/1152…
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Base rate fallacy:
Our brains tend to ignore statistical information and focus on specific information related to people and events.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
How many ways can the CDC hurt us?
Serious breaches on airborne transmission, masks, boosters, isolation guidelines.....
And now this.
@JReinerMD is spot on. This is what Americans should be alerted by
xitter.cf/JReinerMD/status/15124…
This is CDC’s community transmission map. This is what individuals should use to gauge individual risk. It’s not so easy to find on the CDC website. Only 24% of the country has low transmission rates. covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tra…
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
This is misleading and will give BA.2 more chance to spread
As of April 7, 2022, more than 99% of the U.S. population lives in a location with a low or medium #COVID19 Community Level.
Find your COVID-19 Community Level: https://xitter.cf/t.co/w3365V9Zr4.
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
In @TheAtlantic, @ProfEmilyOster raged at the CDC for requiring toddlers to mask indoors. In a recent newsletter, Oster reveals she got the requirements wrong. She then spills considerable ink arguing her mistake is the CDC's fault. She is wrong there too. The mistake is hers.🧵
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
How Brisbane Independent School prevented outbreaks of COVID-19, despite Omicron wave
Using a smoke machine, they studied airflow patterns in the school's five classrooms and administration areas.
1/
abc.net.au/news/2022-04-01/b…
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
In the city centre the streets are eerily deserted. Supermarkets and pharmacies, which had remained open on the first day of the war, have closed econ.st/3t9hUnE
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
The economics academy is shocked to discover that Minsky was largely correct.
Forthcoming soon: Greenwood, Hanson @HarvardHBS, Shleifer @Harvard, Sørensen @CBScph find that rapid credit and asset price growth in nonfinancial business or household sectors is associated with a much elevated probability of a future financial crisis doi.org/10.1111/jofi.13105
The Trouble With Economics retweeted
Thinking about biological collections lately I'm reminded of the time that somehow at age 4, I got a personal tour of the @UCBerkeley entomology collection (Essig?) from a kind scientist (anybody know who?!). Asked my parents how on earth THAT happened, and it turns out...🤯





































