Maybe you have recently become aware of the AI safety debate and the arguments swirling around it.
If you want to understand them, you need to understand a couple things that almost everyone gets wrong:
There are TWO distinct classes of AI dangers, and it's VERY important to think about them separately, and not let one confuse you about the other.
Many many people (including many quite intelligent, clear-thinking people) do not effectively understand the fundamental differences between these two classes of dangers.
The first one has to do with the theory that an AI far superior to human intelligence (Artificial SuperIntelligence, or ASI) will inevitably wipe out the human race.
The second one has to do with the idea that powerful AI will result in very harmful things happening to many human beings, possibly all human beings.
Those two sound VERY similar, don't they?
They are DIFFERENT. Understanding how they are different is crucial if you want to think about or contribute usefully to any conversation about AI safety or AI harm. You might feel like you are Making Very Good Points or Asking Incisive Questions, but if you aren't clear on the differences between the two, you aren't.
So, I'm going to tell you what the difference is so that you can talk more usefully.
The first one concerns itself with a very specific thing, which is ASI (Artificial Superintelligence) that is more intelligent than any human being. When I say that, I am not referring to a thing like how Einstein is smarter than you, we are talking more about something like how a human being is more intelligent than any mouse.
In our regular lives, we meet other people who we can tell are smarter than us, vs some who are less smart. The line is fuzzy, because intelligence has a lot of dimensions. I'm better at a "rotating shapes" kind of intelligence than my wife, and she is better at "words-making" kind of intelligence than I am.
But every human is better in almost every dimension of intelligence than every single mouse.
That's the level we're talking about: an artificial superintelligence - made up of a computer or a network of computers - that is more intelligent than any human. And more intelligent by a long shot, by a wide margin, in an indisputable way like how humans are above mice.
That is the first thing.
The theory says that if you have an AI that is vastly smarter than all humans - in the way that a human is smarter than mice - that superintelligent AI will inevitably, eventually, sooner or later, wipe out every human on the planet.
We will refer to this as "existential risk."
The common follow-up question "well, how exactly is it going to do that?" is NOT the important question, and one of the most important elements of understanding this theory is first getting why that particular question is not important. A couple analogies:
Analogy 1: You are playing chess against a grandmaster. My theory predicts the grandmaster is going to beat you. You can ask "Well, how exactly is he going to do that?" I don't know, because I'm not a grandmaster, I just know that a chess grandmaster is almost always going to beat a normal player like you. And I'd be right. So the question "how is he going to do that" is not important, and doesn't affect the final outcome. He's going to figure out a way because he's way better than you.
Analogy 2: Humans are smarter than all other animals, comprehensively, by a wide margin. We have driven numerous species to extinction, not because we hated them or hunted them. Many of them have died out without most humans even ever thinking about them. All we did was expand our civilization, use up resources, encroach on habitats, and pretty soon the resources needed by those species went away and they died out. We figured out a way to get what we wanted because we're way smarter than them, and often we didn't even notice they died as a result.
A lesser animal asking, "how are the humans going to wipe us out?" is not asking a relevant question. We don't know, but we do know that any time humans and lesser species compete for any kind of resources, the humans will win. The fact that we know who is going to win beforehand - and that it is due to the vastly different levels of intelligence - is the key concept here.
A vastly more intelligent AI is likely to care about things that are incomprehensible to us, the way animals can't understand human goals. It's going to need resources to pursue those goals and it's going to be far more effective at gaining control of them and excluding us from them - in the same way that we are far more effective than other lower species.
A much more intelligent AI will not care about our interests, it will care about its interests, and to whatever small degree we happen to escape total annihilation from losing access to all our resources, any remaining humans will likely be enslaved into a system that serves the AI's own purposes.
That is the first thing. (Remember how I said at the beginning of this post that there was a first thing, and then a second thing?)
The first thing is the most difficult to understand, because you have to extrapolate how a vastly superior intelligence would act, and you can only use analogies like "how do humans treat lesser creatures," and the analogies are messy.
But now let's move on to the second thing.
The second thing is "everything else you've ever heard that AI might do that's harmful."
That's a little inaccurate. It's actually "everything else you've ever heard that humans might use AI to do that's harmful."
This is the critical difference. The first one talks about the inevitable outcome of what happens when two vastly different levels of intelligence collide, e.g. ASI vs humans, or human vs mice.
The second one has to do with what happens when humans possess AI as a powerful tool. This second thing is much easier to understand, because we have many more concrete notions:
Like:
- the military uses AI to make hyper-efficient killer drones and missiles
- your capitalist overlords use AI to replace you and everyone loses their jobs
- authoritarian government uses AI to surveil everybody and control the entire population
- hackers use AI to break into secure networks and hold companies and governments hostage
- students use AI to cheat on homework and show up to college knowing nothing
- AI slop saturates the internet and makes it impossible for artists and writers to make a living
- terrorists use AI to make biological or nuclear weapons
or even things like
- the military hands control to an AI and it misinterprets something and launches nuclear attacks and kills millions
All of those sound pretty familiar, right? Yeah, you've heard them before. We call this second thing "risks from misuse."
These problems are not the first class of problem! This second class of problems exists while AI is a tool that can be controlled by humans, and humans use it to do evil or careless things to each other. The problems may sound exotic or dystopian or novel, but they are fundamentally problems having to do with flawed human nature.
Given a powerful tool, some humans will likely use it to control or otherwise harm others. This is a very familiar problem.
I am not condemning or condoning this. I'm just describing it.
That is a fundamentally different danger from the first thing, which is that when a human is far superior to a mouse, the mouse is likely to come to harm because the human cares about doing human things, and the mouse is not gonna make it once the humans get going.
=====
Hopefully from the above, you have understood the difference between the first thing and the second thing. I will list them again - see if you now understand how they are different:
The first one has to do with the idea that an AI superior to human intelligence (Artificial SuperIntelligence, or ASI) will inevitably wipe out the human race.
The second one has to do with the idea that powerful AI will result in very harmful things happening to many human beings, possibly all human beings.
Can you tell how they are different now?
If not, re-read the stuff from earlier until you understand.
We call the first one "existential risk" and we call the second one "risks from misuse."
Once you understand, here is the CRUX of the problem:
SOLUTIONS TO THE SECOND THING DO NOT HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH SOLUTIONS TO THE FIRST THING.
In fact, it's worse:
Solutions to the second thing (misuse) look roughly like "give powerful AI to as many people as you can, so they can fight the other people using powerful AI."
But the general solution to the first one (existential risk) is basically "don't let anyone have powerful AI, no one can control super-intelligent AI."
Throughout history, harms from technological misuse typically arise because a small group has control of it and can use it to dominate or harm others. Once everyone has it, things tend to stabilize: you can hurt me, I can hurt you, maybe we test each other (ouch 💥), and then we agree not to hurt each other.
But the first one (existential risk) pretty much just arises if anyone (good or bad!) creates a superintelligence. Because they aren't going to be able to control it, the superintelligence will decide it has other priorities, and then we will be at great risk of being wiped out.
And the solutions that generally work to solve problems like the second thing are EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE of the ones likely to solve the first thing.
THIS is why lots of arguments about "AI risk" or "AI safety" go nowhere. Because someone will be thinking about the risk from the first thing, and another person will be thinking about the risk from the second thing. Both are plausible risks but fundamentally they arise from different things - and so the solutions are not just "bad" or "flawed" - they are likely to be very nearly exact opposites.
.a retweeted
The numbers tell the story: momentum for @CarbonDeFixyz on @TacBuild is building 💥
• 180,000+ trades
• $2.3M in volume
• 700+ strategies created
• 42,000+ arbs executed ⚡️
→ Unlike traditional DEXs that wait for someone else to trade against a position, Carbon DeFi's built-in solver system works around the clock — executing order-to-order fulfillment and keeping your strategies active.
Carbon DeFi is more than an exchange.
It's DeFi done right.
A DEX built from the ground up to be the most advanced onchain exchange — directly integrated with Bancor's Arb Fast Lane, the industry's most advanced arbitrage infrastructure.
straight outta evm
Grab your shades and join DeFi Summer on @telegram.
Swap. Lend. Trade. Earn over 200% APYs.
All things DeFi directly from Telegram.
Here's what all you can do while chilling by the pool 👇
2
117
hybrid dApps heating up the DeFi summer on TG 🔥
Missed the action last week on TAC?
Here’s what went down in case you missed it (ICYMI):
1. @MorphoLabs vaults went live on TAC
curated by @Re7Labs, @nine_summits, @MEVCapital & @EdgeCapitalMgmt
Yields up to ~29% APY
2. $uniBTC pools on @CurveFinance
TAC hit $9.35M TVL, with up to 20.73% APR + $517 daily rewards via @merkl_xyz
3. Rewards are back on @CarbonDeFixyz
Strategies earning until Sept 19th
4. @Brevis_buidl x @UsualMoney dropped secure yield for $USD0 holders
5. 30 days since mainnet launch:
• $206M TVL
• 330K txs
• 3.7K wallets
• TAC’s DeFi stack expanding across @eulerfinance, @MorphoLabs, @CurveFinance, @CarbonDeFixyz.
6. $TAC reward campaign renewed via @merkl_xyz
Stake LPs and keep stacking
From $41M → $206M TVL in just 30 days, TAC is scaling DeFi inside Telegram faster than ever.
DeFi summer isn’t coming. It’s already here
We're keeping a journal so you don't have to
Follow @JournalTac
Like & RT
.a retweeted
In web3, we say “gm.”
On TAC, we say “gTAC.”
What initially started as just a greeting, a way for members of the TAC community to recognise one another, now carries more meaning.
gTAC is officially the name of TAC’s liquid staking protocol. @gTACprotocol
Over the years, liquid staking has proven, again and again, to be one of the most important building blocks in any DeFi ecosystem. If you’ve followed how LSTs grew on Ethereum and Solana, you know how quickly these protocols become core part of the ecosystem (some of them eventually launch tokens too). This is exactly the direction TAC is headed.
As DeFi activity on TAC begins to pick up, re-staking will become one of the most important use cases, which is where gTAC fits in.
What does this mean?
When you stake your $TAC, you’re helping secure the network. Normally, that staked $TAC would just sit locked until the staking period ends.
Re-staking changes that. Instead of your staked position being idle, it’s “re-staked” into gTAC.
So:
You stake $TAC → you receive gTAC.
gTAC is a liquid token you can hold, trade, or use in DeFi. Meanwhile, your $TAC stays staked and keeps securing the network.
Adoption of gTAC means more demand for TAC itself. More demand for TAC strengthens the entire ecosystem.
The alpha here is simple:
Ethereum had stETH, Solana had its LSTs, TAC will have gTAC. So why not be early to it anon?
Follow @gTACprotocol and stay close as this unfolds.
few random leaps aside, a conversation long due; happiness and wealth aren't correlated - unfortunately, that realisation is just the beginning of one's search
I think the main reason you find a lot of very unhappy tech people even at the highest levels
- when you're a typical employee everyone around you is making .5-2x what you are
- when you start breaking out wealth goes on log scale. ppl with 10-1000x your net worth become common
- this is native to network effects, scale associated with AI training, and other winner take all dynamics in tech
- all of VC is structured this way as well -- (1 unicorn returns entire fund rest of investments are zero) which psychologically reinforces all or nothing thinking
- this makes competitive people miserable
- this leads them to do hallucinogens or other psychoactive substances in order to accept their place in the universe
- the conclusions drawn from these psychoactive substances are typically at direct odds with how they got to where they are
- and after getting one shotted they're still ultimately in a hard wired competition with people worth 10-1000x more than them
- due to the structure of technology it becomes more or less impossible to break out of your 'bracket' without engaging in increasingly dark things
- you realize that time is running out -- and become aware of synthetic biology (peptides, genetic alteration of children)
- you end up getting involved in police state investments, gooning investments, or crypto -- and view it as non optional to take the gloves off bc everyone around you is doing the same thing
- you're on a permanent hedonic treadmill and you can't ever get off or go back to where you were before bc after doing all of the things you've done you can't possibly ever relate to normal humans
- you get involved with politics or Catholicism or other Lindy cults to try and get off the treadmill
- of course it won't work and you bring all the weird baggage directly into politics or religion and poison those wells too
the current configuration of economics/ wealth distribution is pretty solidly optimized to drive the wealthiest people in society batshit insane, which - to some extent - explains a lot of things you see around you
3
163
.a retweeted
Replying to @profoundvanity
The next 100M users won’t find dApps, they’ll stumble into them mid conversation
slowly, and then suddenly... are you watching closely anon?
TON blockchain-focused protocol TAC has attracted over $200 million in TVL in just a month after its mainnet launch.
Read more: thedefiant.io/news/blockchai…
1
6
224























