Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim) profile picture

AWS Community builder | Cloud Architect | DevOps | Open Source enthusiast | Constant learner

Germany
Joined January 2012
Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)Photo by Timur Galeev (@galeev_tim)
Timur Galeev retweeted
One thing I find striking in the discourse between AI 2040 and its detractors is that the two seem to be locked in to totally incompatible worldviews of how fast and how much of a big deal AI progress is: * In AI 2040, every scenario sees superintelligence of some kind emerging by 2040, unless a herculean effort is made to completely stop it * Detractors say things like "AI 2040 is naive about human coordination ability and a threat to freedom", but don't seem to see any naivety in assuming that the ASI transition will just go well by default, don't seem to see ASI itself as a massive power concentrator risk, and don't seem to feel fear of humanity's "hard power" dropping to zero if ASIs can do literally every task better than we can. This stance makes total sense in a "AI is normal technology" world, zero sense in a world where superintelligence is possible by 2030 and almost guaranteed by 2040 I think my beliefs are: - If I was confident that (present-day-style) AI is normal technology, I would be in the detractor camp - If I was confident that superintelligence is coming in 2030 by default, I would be closer to the AI 2040 camp - it's naive, but every other option is naive squared? But my problem is that I feel great uncertainty and have no idea which of the two worlds (or some other third thing) we're living in? Hence why I continue to be open-minded about slowdowns/pauses, but also I feel very uncomfortable with the "open source bad, the good outcome is the one where our guys have controlling global dominance" push coming from some major AI companies and intellectuals - in a "normal" world that's the sort of thing that triggers every political alarm bell at the same time. A big reason why I have been advocating and trying my best to support the d/acc platform (rapid up-skilling in formal verification, cryptography, secure and open hardware, pandemic resistance and other defensive biotech, food and basic resource security, public epistemics, non-power-concentrating versions of physical security) is that these things are clearly worth doing in both worlds. The 2040 plan is already much more open source friendly (even mandating it! yay). It also includes "mutually assured compute destruction" ideas which (if they work) effectively give one of 2-5 actors the ability to trigger a global compute winter - as opposed to giving 1-5 actors the ability to selectively disenfranchise people they consider baddies while exempting themselves. This is also a big improvement. So I can see the earnest attempts to improve along the dimensions detractors criticize on ("does this concentrate power in big AI labs and superpower governments?"), and I appreciate this. I think many people don't appreciate enough the differences between different "kinds" of pause buttons, and how some concentrate power far more than others. Probably we can think harder and improve even more here. But on the "slowdown/pause or not" topic, there isn't a magic "escape the tradeoff" button. The Hansonian in me says: the winning deal is a deal which, from the perspective of both sides' present-day beliefs and knowledge, both sides would accept, though for different reasons. If the crux is AI progress speed, then identify a set of pre-agreed triggers for "okay, serious shit is happening" [super-pandemics? >25% unemployment? something involving slaughterbots?], and pre-agree that we become much more open-minded to the slowdown or pause thing if enough triggers come to pass within some timeframe. 2040 detractors (who clearly implicitly think that we'll see amazing speedup of progress from AI but think that what I call the "serious shit" category is overhyped) will accept expecting that the triggers don't come to pass, and AI worriers will accept expecting that they will. Pre-agreeing on the specific triggers means that once the triggers either hit or don't hit, there is stronger legitimacy around the idea that one side's worldview turned out more correct and we should be more inclined toward their program. If I were @elonmusk (or zuck, or...) I would re-tool twitter much more heavily into being a platform for helping to identify and make these kinds of grand win-win deals, so that we can bypass big-country governments and big-company CEOs and big nonprofit intellectuals and give more people a voice in the discussion. It's possibly one of the best things that social media _could_ do for humanity if it wanted to. But again, maybe this is also naive. Actually, probably it's naive. But currently, I see zero plans for how to deal with an ASI transition that are not naive. Perhaps humanity is stuck with a choice between naive and naive squared (or maybe even naive squared and naive cubed), so I feel inclined to cut some slack to people who are trying.
518
324
104
2,394
544,231
Timur Galeev retweeted
Fable is so insanely good. Deserves the hype.
133
67
25
1,692
657,820
Ready to elevate your #AWS journey? 🤩 The AWS Community Builders program provides access to technical resources, education, & insights from AWS experts. The program accepts a limited number of members each year! Learn more and apply now: go.aws/40oIWJB #AWSCommunity
38
10
61
6,837
Amazon DynamoDB now supports AWS PrivateLink. #aws aws.amazon.com/about-aws/wha…
37
At the last AWS re:Invent, there were a lot of updates related to ML/AI GenAI and everything related to these technologies. In doing so, I wrote a short article on what it looks like. dev.to/aws-builders/beginnin… #aws #ml #ai #genai #awscommunitybuilders
1
44
Timur Galeev retweeted
The Call for Papers for the AWS Community Day DACH is open and we’re looking forward to your submissions! 🗓️ Date: September 17, 2024 📍 Location: Munich, Germany 💬 Language: English (Preferred) sessionize.com/aws-community… #awscommunity #AWSCommunityDay #AWSCommunityDayDACH
7
1
16
1,628
AWA ECS and Fargate now integrate with Amazon EBS🥳 So what does this mean?! Now you can provision EBS storage for your ECS tasks running on Fargate and EC2 without needing to manage storage or compute. wow #aws #ebs #ecs aws.amazon.com/blogs/aws/ama… aws.amazon.com/about-aws/wha…
82
As always, great to see you @vedmichv and talk about various #aws topics. Looking forward to seeing you AWS User Group Braunschweig next year.😃 #awscommunity #awscommunitybuilders
1
4
122
As always, great to see you @vedmichv and talk about various #aws topics. Looking forward to seeing you AWS User Group Braunschweig next year.😃 #awscommunity #awscommunitybuilders
1
40
AWS re:Invent provides great opportunities to explore new services and also network. I try not to miss meeting with @ViktoriaSemaan and talk about various topics regarding AWS. I was glad to see you and talk to you.😊
31
On Sunday I had the opportunity to attend a cool "pre:invent" event: a networking and hike organized for AWS CB, Heroes and UG. The pre-invention hike was a great networking hike at Nevada's famous nature resort Valley of Fire State Park. #awscommunity
1
39
🥳It's great to see @jasondunn in person again and thank you for this wonderful community. #aws #awscommunity #awscommunitybuilders
3
56
I try not to miss an event where I can meet with terraform guru and AWS Hero @antonbabenko and talk about terraform module topics. Thank you for your great work.💪 #aws #awscommunity
1
2
61
🥳It's great to see @jasondunn in person again and thank you for this wonderful community. #aws #awscommunity #awscommunitybuilders
1
2
62
How is it great to meet in person Vice President & Chief Evangelist at Amazon Web Services @jeffbarr 🥳 #aws #awscommunity
1
27
Met some great people from Förderverein AWS Community DACH and all other from Germany🥳 Nice to see you again Markus Ostertag Philipp Garbe Johannes Koch Thorsten Höger Julian Michel Nora Schöner Raphael 👨‍💻 Manke Andreas Rütten Sönke Ruempler #awscommunity
1
29
On Sunday I had the opportunity to attend a cool "pre:invent" event: a networking and hike organized for AWS CB, Heroes and UG. The pre-invention hike was a great networking hike at Nevada's famous nature resort Valley of Fire State Park. #awscommunity
33