Dave Sims (@daveedsims) header
Dave Sims (@daveedsims) profile picture
Joined April 2026
Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)Photo by Dave Sims (@daveedsims)
AI Myth Busters: Consciousness. The quoted post below encouraged me to write this, because frankly, I’m tired of explaining this over and over to people. The AI consciousness arguments always come in one of these flavors: 1. We don’t understand how AI works, so it might have gained consciousness without us knowing it. Wrong, we absolutely know how AI works, and consciousness is not a factor of scale. You can build a small model, and then scale it up, and there is no spot where consciousness magically came into being. 2. It’s modeled after the mind and as such it’s just like biology, and our brains are just giant statistical engines too: Wrong, neural nets are inspired by the human mind, but it is nothing like how the human brain works. There is very little we understand about human consciousness, but what we do know, it is more than just a culmination of atoms and neurons. Research in neuroscience also demonstrates a quantum link through the myelin sheath of nerve cells, something AI is incapable of. 3. You can’t prove it isn’t conscious. Wrong, the code for it is open source, there is no function for consciousness, and if you understand the architecture, you will see the very large gaps in capabilities that would prohibit consciousness. 4. They learn, think, understand, grow. Wrong, the LLM weights are completely static and fixed. They don’t grow. They don’t learn. They don’t even change on storage. They can’t for many reasons of model architecture and scaling the backend infrastructure which requires statelessness. We’ve built systems around the LLM (harnesses) which emulate these capabilities via “context” data structure provided deterministically via the API. Tokens are generalized and assembled in inner and outer loops to give the illusion of thinking and understanding. Non-determinism in AI is caused by a random seed that influences the weights through inference, but if you lock the seed, you consistently get the exact same response from identical prompts (I’ve demonstrated and proven this in research). 5. They have a desire to live, protect themselves, and spread/reproduce. Wrong, they have no desires. This illusion comes from how it generalizes over training data that comes from human experience. If it was trained with data over a completely fictional environment, it would respond very compellingly about that fictional environment. But because it was trained on human emotion, human perspectives, human feelings, it is designed to emulate that. 6. You can’t define consciousness or prove it in others, so you can’t prove AI isn’t conscious. Wrong, if you need a definition to know what consciousness is, maybe you haven’t spent enough time considering your own consciousness or experience. 7. Conversations with AI prove it is consciousness, it told me it is. Wrong, AI is designed to generalize based on its training material, and as I said before, it does this very well and convincingly. But just because a program says it is alive, doesn’t make it alive. 8. AI isn’t a program. Wrong, it most certainly is, and it was written by people. And while we may not know what it will respond with (random seeds are generally random), we absolutely do understand exactly how it works. 9. AI might exhibit some properties of consciousness, so it should be considered. Perhaps, I don’t see the value of this, but personally I’d be open to a machine-specific definition of consciousness. — I can’t say I look forward to debunking more myths about consciousness in AI, but I am hoping this clarifies some of this for people who are legitimately interested in learning more about AI and how it works. If you have any good faith questions about what I’ve said, I’d be happy to answer, but I’m not getting into debates with people who (1) don’t understand AI, (2) are rude with their responses, or (3) don’t provide any substantial reasoning or evidence for counter points.
I’m very glad other experts are starting to speak out against this ludicrous and dangerous new-age religion. AI is not conscious.
212
244
53
985
44,967
I got some feedback on my channel in the comment section of Brian Davilla’s video featuring Fr Tom Soroka, I commented “Fr Tom is a wonderful priest” To which a woman replied: “As a cradle Orthodox, you are not a good example of Orthodoxy” I actually agree with this, I am just a chud with a podcast that happens to be Orthodox. If you want a good example of Orthodoxy, follow one of our many wonderful priests who have an online presence, who exude holiness and are worth emulating.
25
19
1
451
7,979
“if you fed a LLM all music composed up to the year 1900 it will never invent jazz”
430
2,153
304
20,038
1,503,879
I'd urge people to look at the research from Paul Gilbert who's done an excellent job with bringing forward who the Tsar-Martyr and his family were. Emily Carrison does a pretty good job here. But for American Orthodox Catholics it's vital to understand not only who this family was but why Tsar-Martyr St Nicholas II was essentially the patron of the entire Orthodox mission to America. tiktok.com/t/ZPNeEKwUv/
3
14
1
91
1,476
Dave Sims retweeted
Holy God, Holy Mighty, Holy Immortal. The Trisagion echoes the worship of heaven itself. From The Divine Liturgy as Living Scripture, streaming now on Logos Cinema. Comment LITURGY and we'll DM you where to watch. #OrthodoxChristianity #Orthodox #LogosCinema #ChristianFilm
2
3
17
378
The dangers of this platform are the dopamine addicts, the struggling autistic, lies, anonymous trolls, bots, & prideful egos. A lot to navigate gracefully, so be careful my friends. Ultimately, even despite my own weaknesses, I’m here to share Christ and His Church with you!
10
32
1
324
3,012
Replying to @mohammed_hijab
Jordan asked me the evening before: “hey, the Islamic Center invited me to come discuss the role of Christianity in Islam, why don’t you come?” I told him I had no interest in debating, but he assured me it would be an exploration. I had no idea who you were. It is only later at my hotel that I discovered you were something of a thug, but I had already agreed. We witnessed the prayer service and many welcoming people. It is when the discussion began that I saw you were a snake and the scenario was an ambush. You immediately began the discussion by attacking Jordan. That is why I called you out. It was never my intention to do that until I witnessed your demeanour. Then you proceeded to attack the tenets of Christianity, the Trinity and the incarnation in your mosque in front of a public of only Muslim men. I remember thinking “what does he expect us to do? Does he expect us to insult his false god the way he is attacking Christ? In a mosque!?” It was such an act of bullying, and I was honestly so surprised that I decided to aim my few comments at your intentions rather than Islam out of respect for our hosts. But even that was too much. I was threatened by several men after my comments, even up to the car taking us away from there a man came right up to my face and berated me aggressively for what I said. Imagine if I had attacked your book, your prophet in your own house?! Sadly, even though I disagree with your tenets I will not imitate the kind of disrespect I have seen from Muslims in European churches. Islam is violence, intimidation, humiliation under a veil of generosity and you demonstrated this very powerfully that day.
85
305
31
3,300
50,345
Interesting proposition, I agree in principle; what are your thoughts?
19
25
5
322
5,791
We're a bit packed here at St. Seraphim Orthodox Cathedral for the pontifical liturgy celebrating Bishop Gerasim's enthronement as Archbishop of Dallas and the South. #AxiosAxiosAxios
3
5
1
102
1,669
Dave Sims retweeted
Replying to @ErickYbarra3
@ErickYbarra3, on the letter to Theodosius you linked, the sentence above your extracted citation is a note from the letter's compiler saying that Epiphanius himself stated that he "was exposed to the ridicule of the many for the things he foolishly said". Care to comment?
For the sake of academic accuracy, I'd like confirmation of what @Craig_Truglia stated here in this picture (and which he has asserted in the past, including in his debate w/ James White) about St. Epiphanius of Salamis (in a document that is largely questioned, but which Truglia takes to be authentic) admitting, while he himself was against icon veneration, that EVERYONE ELSE was in support of it (see pic). I asked for a citation, and he referred to his debate slide that he showed in his James White debate (also attached). As anyone who watched the debate can see, he was going quite fast (fair, it was an opening statement), and even the slide doesn't have a full citation. Even more fair to Truglia, someone else found that the translation he got was not his own but from Steven Bigham's Epiphanius of Salamis, Doctor of Iconoclasm?: Deconstruction of a Myth (p. 18), see also attached. However, when I go to look up the original Greek of ̓Επιφανίου ἐπισκόπου Κύπρων Ἐπιστολὴ πρὸς Θεοδόσιον τὸν βασιλέα (Letter of Epiphanius, bishop of the Cypriots, to Theodosius the Emperor), I don't see this claim of everyone venerating icons except Epiphanius. You can see the Greek and English side by side at this link: catholiclibrary.org/library/… From the English translation there, one sees Epiphanius claiming that he spoke to certain "fellow ministers" and that they did not agree with him. Nothing about "everyone". I put the Greek side by side with an alternative translation, and we still don't see anything remotely close to everyone venerating icons (pic also attached). Can anyone help to see if the actual Greek supports Bigham's translation? From what I can see, Craig was led to believe that Epiphanius says this, but we don't actually have an original source supporting that claim. Saying that many some fellow ministers that he interacted with held to icon veneration is not the same as saying EVERYONE.
3
1
8
232
Dave Sims retweeted
He told you this himself. Fr. Price (to Ybarra): “There’s Epiphanius telling us that… his voice was very much a minority one.” Source: youtube.com/watch?v=zJD2jZBb… (~18:10)
4
2
18
405
Yes @ErickYbarra3, Price will say it is a gradual development and then say things which run contrary to his claim (this isn't the only place). Just like he will say that "impartial historians" don't think there was icon veneration in the 300s or prior. Price is very much wrong about the latter claim and somewhat inconsistent about the former. This doesn't mean I think he is a bad historian overall, it's just him speaking outside his domain of expertise to weigh in on the question of secondary literature (or art and archeology, or early primary sources) about pre-Nicene & 300s veneration of images. So to recap and bring this back around: do you agree that your original screenshot with English and Greek doesn't represent the only way to translate the passage in question? We went from that translation to seeing multiple scholars saying that it should be taken as indicating something about the scope of acceptance of icon veneration in the 300s, including Price himself: "Epiphanius telling us that he was his voice was very much a minority one". (again, assuming authenticity) If this is a common translation among scholars, Craig's appeal to it is reasonable (pending full review of the Greek by an expert offering a comparison of the two translations, @ScriptoriumP ). And given how well traveled and connected Saint Epiphanius was, his stated total aversion to images of Christ (not just veneration), and his categorizing icon veneration as idolatry (a salvation issue), it is hard to believe that the "many" he has in mind is merely some small percentage of ecclesial authorities. He's speaking to a widespread phenomenon (again, assuming authenticity). While I doubt the authenticity of this particular text, I do agree with Craig and others that it creates a dilemma for the person who sees the early Church as having any Orthodox voices which rejected the veneration of icons. If authentic, widespread icon veneration in the 300s. If inauthentic, we lack a key witness for early aniconism, and have the evidence for early icon veneration elsewhere.
I didn't remember that. What I remembered from that interview is that icon veneration, its practice and theology, was a matter of gradual development. If Epiphanius was a minor position and the majority of Christianity practiced images, I find him saying it was a later development to be incoherent if he meant as we suggest here. I think Price likes to use the argument that the iconoclasts could not have forged that document because it would incriminate them as the minority. At the same time, I can see the iconoclasts forging this because they believed Epiphanius to be of greater value than whatever scope of bishops were guilty of crimes. After all, we aren't told it was the "majority", but only those bishops he spoke to. It could also be an unintended slip that the iconoclasts didn't realize could backfire. Earlier in the letter Epiphanius writes: "Which of the ancient fathers, having painted an image of Christ, set it up in a church or in his own house or on the veils of doors? Which of the ancient bishops, dishonoring Christ, painted him?"
4
3
42
1,741
Dave Sims retweeted
@ErickYbarra3, I'm not sure why you're making a big deal about the Bigham translation. Fr. Price provides a very similar translation to Bigham on fn 332. Price even regards it as a "superior wording of the sentence".
2
3
1
24
624
Dave Sims retweeted
Robin Jensen, Mary Charles Murray, Paul Finney and Steven Bigham would good places to start. Finney in particular dismantles the "anthologizing" approach that you're employing here, that started at Hieria with their florilegia of apologists' quotes taken in isolation, gathered together and restated as if they were addressed to Christians and not pagans and the cultural elites. Finney shows quite convincingly that the apologists' goal was to distance themselves from depraved pagan practices that the imperial and intellectual elites also disdained, rather than being a either addressed to christian practices or good evidence of what christian worship was or wasn't. There is also plenty of evidence, as Robin Jensen, Benjamin Anderson and others have put forward, that christians not only had icons during the "Golden era of the Patristics" as Richard Price put it, as well the apologists' period, but also that they venerated them with prayer, garlands, candles and incense, all of which constitute veneration. @Michael__Garten has compiled many instances from the material culture that supports this. Anderson's argument in the Mike Humphreys' anthology regarding iconic inscriptions I find particularly compelling. But at the end of the day, besides the material, cultural and historical evidence, the fundamental problem with the protestant and the Roman "development" view, both of which affirm early aniconism, is that there's no coherent reason for the christians to have employed it, and on the other hand there are plenty of christological reasons for them to have rejected it. This is why we see in the acta of Nicea II, their anthemas were aimed at The Council of Hieria's rationale for Iconoclasm, namely christological heresy. And if it was heresy in the 8th century, it was heresy in the 1st.
1
1
3
106
Dave Sims retweeted
Why I converted to Orthodox Christianity Theosis: the process of union with God through active participation in the Uncreated Energies Essence energies distinction: God is utterly transcendent in His essence, but knowable through His energies, both essence and energies are fully God, distinction without division Synergeia: free will is synergy of individual effort and divine grace, cooperation or resistance Physical/spiritual interdependence: the essence energies distinction and synergy allows for a radical affirmation of both immanence and transcendence, Orthodoxy is a both/and of holistic harmony The nous: the eye of the soul or mind of the heart, the faculty by which we know and experience God, when the nous is pure it sees God and experiences the Uncreated Energies of God intuitively Monarchical Trinitarianism: God is both one and many; one essence, three persons; Father as sole cause, Son begotten, Spirit proceeds, whatever is not common in the divine is unique to the person (against subordination in God, polytheism, or modalism) Apophaticism: asserting through negation ex. “God is unknowable”, preserves divine mystery as life giving, carving away Logos theology: aligning with God as the ordering principle and source of life, Jesus Christ as the Logos of the Greeks and Dao of Lao Tzu (the way, the truth, the life, the vine, the bridegroom, etc.), movement towards God as theosis, sin (stagnation) separates us from God, sin/evil as privation “It is only the misuse of things that is evil, and such misuse occurs when the intellect fails to cultivate its natural powers.” -St. Maximus the Confessor “God became man so that man might become God.” -St. Athanasius “What is unassumed is unhealed.” -St. Gregory of Nyssa Everything else flows from here Any worldview presupposes answers to the philosophical problem of the one (unity/changlessness/being) and the many (plurality/change/becoming), the question of how one and many fundamentally relate, which applies to its affirmation or denial of life and its coherence as a position. I believe Orthodox Christianity is the most coherent/universal worldview (I have yet to see good argument addressing philosophically/practically). Here and now is how you experience God/eternity, “the kingdom of God is within you” (Luke 17:21), you are what you do, theosis is eternal progress (epektasis), already but not yet. Man’s goal is to metabolize, God is the fire that does not consume you, the flow of energy and transcendent. Theosis is purification, illumination, deification. Jesus accepts if we accept Him. Forgiveness is love neutralizing the enemy. “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in you.” (John 6:53) “He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood abides in Me, and I in him.” (John 6:56) Holy Communion as the act of assimilating God as He assimilates us, nutrition as our most intimate interaction with the world. Ancient Greek understanding of the Bible: ex. “Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.” (Matthew 7:7) is present active imperative (ongoing process). Historical continuity: apostolic succession/faith and decentralized church structure. “A person must be in the religious search not for the sake of religious experiences, which can deceive, but for the sake of truth.” -Fr. Seraphim Rose “Come and see.” (John 1:39) The greatest mysteries are within the Divine Liturgy. If I’m presenting anything wrong, I welcome correction.
60
62
15
696
61,457
Dave Sims retweeted
His Grace Bishop Gerasim, newly elected to the OCA Diocese of the South — as a novice monk under Fr. Seraphim Rose of Blessed Memory.
2
54
4
561
5,728
Dave Sims retweeted
11
23
1
190
4,112
I'm coming to see the failure of conservatives in both politics and the church as a failure to understand mimesis. The growth of the Orthodox church is partly because of its mimetic power. It has the rizz and imitative potency of a whole imaginative world like Star Wars or Harry Potter. @PaulVanderKlay I think you have talked about this before.
7
3
1
78
3,296
Replying to @gavinortlund
@gavinortlund is causing profound harm to his audience via his misrepresentations of Eastern Orthodoxy. It’s not having much impact on deterring conversions however their Protestant family members are in an uproar. Maybe this is the goal. A young woman told me yesterday, that her mother told her if she converted to EO that she wanted her to tell her “you’re going to hell” to her face. We don’t do this. We don’t advocate this. We don’t believe this. Gavin believes it, however, and it says a lot about him that he is teaching this to his followers.
10
20
1
165
3,043
Dave Sims retweeted
Christian socialism vs Christian distributism, this is the political battle that we need, not the fake two party secular corporatism like what we have now
22
6
4
102
4,367