We're campaigning for a secondary school system with fair admissions & no more 11-plus. Children are more likely to succeed in high quality all-ability schools.

United Kingdom
Joined December 2011
Comprehensive Future retweeted
On September 29th 2026 Andy Burnham gave his first conference speech as Labour prime minister. He called himself "the son of a man who failed his 11-plus." His father, Roy, had died of Alzheimer's disease a few weeks earlier, earlier that month, in fact. "If only, if only he had been able to appreciate that moment," Burnham told the hall. He "could have gone to university himself", but "it wasn't an option". England is supposed to have gotten rid of the sorting of children by exam decades ago. But the country still has 163 grammar schools, state schools that select pupils by test. In Buckinghamshire four out of ten children of secondary-school age go to one. In 1998 their number was frozen by law. On the only occasion on which a community has voted on whether to end selection, in Ripon in 2000, the people chose to retain it, by 1,493 votes to 747. Children take the test in September of their last year of primary school, when most are ten. In Buckinghamshire they are told to take two HB pencils and an eraser in a transparent bag. A practice question asks children to identify a hidden four-letter word in "The film ended happily after all". The answer is "mend". This has nothing to do with the national curriculum, and Kent's primary schools are told not to teach it. So families hire tutors. In London they charge £80-90 an hour (120) and can cost up to £15,000 ($20,000) over the years. Vanessa Kushner, who has been a tutor for 30 years, says she gets calls about kids "aged three to seven" all the time. Katheryn Sharp, who has tutored for over 20 years, calls the preparation "Olympic training". "Any Year 5 who goes away during the summer holidays is out of their mind," she says (children are nine in Year 5). A study of children in England and Northern Ireland by UCL found that around 70% of tutored children got into a grammar school, compared with 14% of those who did not use a tutor. In Kent just 12% of children eligible for free school meals pass the test, compared with 30% of their peers. At the Henrietta Barnett School, in north London, there was a year when 2,944 girls took the test for 100 places. The exam that Roy Burnham failed is now mostly a test of parental wealth. The younger Mr Burnham promised to "rebuild a system of comprehensive education" in his speech. He did not mention grammar schools, and his government has not proposed changing the law that keeps them alive. In 2023 about 17,000 children in Kent took the exam his father did.
2
3
41
1,863
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Educators ? and parents would you agree ?
“The son of a man who failed the 11-plus becoming Prime Minister.” A moving line from Andy Burnham today, and a reminder that no test at 10 or 11 should be allowed to limit a child’s future. Comprehensive education opens opportunity. Selection rations it.theguardian.com/politics/liv…
1
1
64
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Campaign for State Education@CASEupdateSep 25
Don't miss out! Book your tickets for this year's CASE conference: "Why are so many children unhappy at school? And what we can do about it." 📅 Saturday 10th October 🕙 10am to 4pm 📍London Greenwich 🎟️ campaignforstateeducation.or…
1
1
33
Comprehensive Future retweeted
But Nuala Burgess, chair of the campaign group @comp_future, said: “If @Ofstednews is giving a gold star for #inclusion to schools that exclude most local children, they clearly don’t understand the meaning of the word.” #grammarschool #ofsted #SEND #ehcp schoolsweek.co.uk/grammar-sc…
1
1
89
Comprehensive Future retweeted
In my latest @NewStatesman column, I cast my mind back two decades to ask why immigrant children began to dominate grammar schools. Lots of people talk about the experience of failing the 11+...but in some ways it's passing that I still haven't got over! newstatesman.com/politics/ed…
1
15
55
4,452
Replying to @comp_future
It was also rigged. 55% of girl passed but only 50% got in. The acceptance to grammar schools varied accross the country because the provision varied. Ultimately and nationally, there was no equal yardstick for all children in any given year.
2
2
36
664
Comprehensive Future retweeted
“Grammar schools actually lower standards” Carl challenges one of the central arguments used to defend selective education. He says areas with grammar schools have lower average attainment and GCSE pass rates and argues that even academically stronger pupils don’t necessarily benefit from attending them. Does selection raise standards or damage education across the wider area? 👇 #teaching #schools #education #teacherlife #teachertok #teachersoftiktok
5
2
2
2,131
Comprehensive Future retweeted
"Rather than pay private school fees, they'll pay tuition to get them into a Grammar School" Carl argues that entry to grammar school increasingly depends not simply on ability but on a family’s ability to pay. With around three-quarters of successful pupils reportedly receiving substantial tuition, sometimes costing £1,000–£2,000, is the 11-plus really identifying the brightest children or those whose parents can afford to prepare them? 👇 🎧 Watch the full debate on Teachers Talk Radio. #teaching #schools #education #teacherlife #teachertok #teachersoftiktok
6
2
5
937
Comprehensive Future retweeted
A few weeks ago, I received a full on press release from the parent of a child about to attend one of London’s elite grammar schools. I ended up writing this, on how the grammar school system lost its way
1
1
5
1,278
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Can it be right that Grammar schools are nearly 18 times more likely to be judged by @Ofstednews as “Exceptional” for achievement compared to Secondary Moderns??
1
2
74
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Replying to @comp_future
I agree with all this. For this proposal to work the 11+ has to go. As it should have done under a succession of Labour governments. As I approach 70 I cannot believe the unfair and callous 11+ has survived this long.
1
2
108
Comprehensive Future retweeted
This doesn't bode well. Selective schools getting Exceptionals for achievement is the precise opposite of what the system is supposed to be about. Back in the day, when we had 5A*-C, the top spots were dominated by leafy suburban schools (often faith schools) with stealth-selected intakes and very low levels of free school meals. Progress 8 came along, and started the good work of levelling the field. I'm not convinced it does enough, but it's a great start. If Ofsted continue to disproportionately give selective schools Exceptional for achievement, then they will lose whatever small support they have left, as well as undoing the direction of travel set by Progress 8.
Replying to @Yorkshire_Steve
And achievement grades by same admissions classifications
12
27
108
23,383
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Let’s hope @LucyMPowell gets to grip with the social division Grammar Schools create…
Congrats to @andyburnham on becoming PM and @LucyMPowell on her appointment as Education Secretary. Both have long supported comprehensive education and spoken out against school selection. We look forward to making the case for fairer admissions to the new government.
1
2
111
Comprehensive Future retweeted
"I oppose [academic] selection with everything I've got" Worth reading this interview with then Shadow Education Secretary Andy Burnham in 2010. Free schools, grammar schools and academies are not likely to be in his good books as Prime Minister.... 🔗theguardian.com/education/20…
16
9
7
33
20,768
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Just when you think you have seen everything... Love them or loathe them no-one, absolutely NO-ONE, believes Grammar Schools are inclusive. That's the whole point of them.
17
29
78
5,477
Comprehensive Future retweeted
My interview with Peter Mandler as a podcast - listen on the bus, tube, etc.!
How did the 11-plus become such a powerful idea in English education? Professor Peter Mandler joins us to discuss selection, meritocracy and the history behind today's debates. Now available as a podcast. open.spotify.com/episode/4IT…
1
1
285
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Most ruthless and ambitious parents who want their children to attend grammar school arrange for them to have special tuition at home to prepare for the examination two years before it takes place. This latest move by the grammar schools will not alter the social background of their pupils.
UK grammar schools are moving 11 plus exams from September to July to stop families buying intensive summer tutoring and give all kids a fairer shot at selective places. Does this fix the real access gaps in UK education or just shift the pressure earlier? @NEUparents
11
5
102
37,448
Comprehensive Future retweeted
I asked once if 11+ was testing parents bank balances rather than kids abilities as tutoring costs were nearing £50 per hour
If grammar schools need to redesign the 11-plus to reduce tutoring and middle-class cramming, they’re admitting the system isn’t measuring ‘ability’ in the first place. The tutoring industry won’t disappear because the test is 6 weeks earlier. dailymail.com/news/article-1…
2
1
3
646
Comprehensive Future retweeted
Replying to @comp_future
“Grammar School” areas are abetter named “Secondary Modern” areas* as there are 3x more Sec Mods than Grammars (*actually better called selective areas!).
1
3
10
203