Replying to @beeriac @baseballinpix
Apparently you misread the question. "one game, winner take all, both in their prime. Who gets the ball?"
One game, in their prime? It's Koufax and it's not close.
2
9
Replying to @WayneMac1954 @nut_history
Both are all-time greats. But in what way was Martinez more dependable than Koufax? Koufax went out every 4th day; famously threw a 3 hit shutout on 2 days rest in game 7 of the 1965 WS throwing nothing but fastballs. understand choosing Pedro, but was he more dependable?
Replying to @AllAcesCards @SideRetiredPod
Looking at JAWS leaders: why Posey and not Gene Tenace? 3 WS in 3 years, WS MVP. I'm not arguing Tenace belongs in the HOF; I'm more wondering why so many think Posey is a lock for 1st-ballot HOF'er.
2
2
95
Replying to @shakedsetc @Jimfrombaseball
We don't know if he was giving 100% effort or not. That's the point. He was paid money (by his own admission) to NOT play his best; to help his team lose. Do we take him at his word? Maybe not; he was willing to be dishonest for $20,000 (only got $5,000).
1
1
33
Replying to @shakedsetc @Jimfrombaseball
How much better could he have played with 100% effort? We’ll never know if he let up on a fly ball or two at a key time, or swung and missed with runners on. I know he put good numbers on the WS; maybe they would have been much better.
1
1
37
Replying to @Jimfrombaseball
Nope. He was paid $5,000 cash (with the promise of more) to throw the WS, knew his teammates were in on it, and never said a word. He & his teammates were found not guilty because their grand jury confessions mysteriously disappeared. Rightfully banned for life, and no HOF.
1
2
131
Replying to @ShallowCritic @nut_history
"Good seasons"?? He had phenomenal, out of this world seasons. It's a shame he had to retire at age 30 due to injury, going out winning back-to-back CYA when they only gave out one in MLB, not one in each league.
1
19
Replying to @nut_history
What if the medical knowledge that we have today was available when Sandy Koufax had to retire at age 30 due to arm problems in 1966?
What if the 2017 Astros hadn’t cheated in the WS vs. theDodgers?
3
94
Replying to @Jimfrombaseball
This is an amazing photo! Do you know if it's staged or actually taken during a game? How high off the ground is Duke??
1
25
Replying to @Jimfrombaseball
Jim, I love what you post, but several errors on this one. No way the song was written in 1973; Catfish didn’t sign with NY until 12/31/74. And he was not the first pitcher to win 200 games since 1915. Warren Spahn, Lefty Grove, Robin Roberts, Jim Bunning, Bob Gibson, etc.
1
3
59
Replying to @AttorneyHaskell @FreddyLA7
Except that in 1963 the college all-star team beat the World Champion Green Bay Packers 20-17.
18
Replying to @LSpoonerd @NotYourBishop
So you're current law enforcement. Thank you for serving.
1
1
20
Replying to @ScottWarner18
Mid-40's. Go to your local dollar store and buy half a dozen reading glasses. Keep a pair in each car, your desk at work, a couple around the house. That way you've always got a pair close by. And if you're serving in a calling that means you have a desk @ the church, same thing.
29
Replying to @baseballinpix
A great year, but the greatest? No. You make that argument yourself that it's not- Denny McLain, Yaz, and you didn't even mention Don Drysdale's 58 inning consecutive scoreless streak. It was the year of the pitcher.
16
Replying to @GlowSurfing
I was just on 4 different islands in Hawaii last week. Gas is cheaper there than it is in the SF Bay Area.
15
Replying to @MissionVlyMafia
Will Smith the “most hated man in baseball”???? Only by bitter Friars fans.
1
1
2,007
Replying to @Bruce_Jenkins1 @AHerbo1800
Bruce, those four players, with Elgin and Barry in particular, maybe four of the most underrated great players in NBA history.
12
