Politicalization is poor reasoning. Healthcare itself can be seen as political, so that would make our entire profession political as well. Anything scientific will be seen as political by those who refuse to accept it. If you’re going to argue against it, find better reasons
Yet we cont to see studies trying to find a specific ex intervention, technique, or dosage. Do we think that MSK science just hasn't found the right combo of ingredients, as if it's a chemistry experiment that needs to iterate through all possible permutations?
I think musculoskeletal physiotherapy is at a crossroads…
It has a choice to accept the growing evidence showing it currently does very little above placebos and natural history for many conditions and look to change and adapt!
Or continue on as it is and head into fringes of healthcare mixing with other ‘alternative therapies’ and all their woo and quackery!
506
Intellectual openness is about being a filter, not a trash can. Anything thrown in a trash can is accepted by the trashcan. Anything can be thrown in a filter, but not everything will pass through it.
The right attitude of a scientist is to be skeptical—not cynical—of claims and to question everything.
Simultaneously, “If you have your mind sufficiently open, people will throw a lot of trash in it.”
- William Orton
1
518
First moved on to religion, politics, and philosophy, and did horribly in all of them, and now he’s moving on to nutrition even more egregiously? Being an expert in one field does not make you credible in other fields . This seems to be a common evolution for these people
1
411
Kuni Nishimura, PT, DPT retweeted
Replying to @jonathanstea
“Anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that 'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.'”
― Isaac Asimov
Just a reminder that MSK Twitter is not some outlier in human behavior marred by occasional discourtesy. That people think it’s especially diff than any other sphere of discourse means they need exposure to other fields. Rational discourse is the exception, not the rule.
1
218
I know there are a lot of bad takes on Twitter, but wow this is up there. I’m speechless at the stupidity.
156
“That no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish. . .But it is nothing strange, I hope, that men should lie in all ages”
-David Hume
1
2
161
Simple but astute clarification on degree of granularity in diagnostics 👌
Too often the question of diagnosis is split into a binary of “does it or does it not matter”
This often creates a dichotomy & polarity between the 2 groups
Maybe the concept of granularity is a better perspective than the binary one, but how does it apply here?
Here is a 🧵
Just listened to @OnlinePhysios ‘s episode with @ArthriticChick and found it eye-opening. I recommend all physios give it a listen, esp those blindly providing PNE narratives to their patients in pain
Kuni Nishimura, PT, DPT retweeted
Tooth fairy science—coined by Dr. Harriet Hall—refers to doing research on a phenomenon before establishing that the phenomenon exists.
Examples in alternative medicine: human energy fields, chi, meridians, homeopathic water memory, chakras, etc.
skepdic.com/toothfairyscienc…
Controversial thread and it took some context and misunderstanding, but I have successfully questioned my attitude towards reassurance in some ways. There is a distinction btwn physios “doing” reassurance and pts “feeling reassured”
On a critical distinction between evidence based medicine and alternative/holistic/complementary medicine
Beware of the middle ground fallacy.
A friend of mine once remarked that if some people asserted the earth rotated from East-West and others from West-East, there would always be a few well-meaning people to suggest that the truth probably lay between the extremes or did not rotate at all.
- via Paul Meehl
1
2
Passionate, good intentions which are ignorant of their own egregious incompetence are some major offenders in the spread of misinformation.
In less than 24 hours, a thread offering tips to avoid / fight cancer 'naturally' (mainly through diet⛳️) has gotten over 100k likes.
Sadly, the advice given is both wrong and dangerous, and *very* likely to cause harm.
A quick thread on why this is so misguided... 🧵
1
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/article…'
10 Commandments for patient-centered treatment. Mostly targeted towards MDs but can also be relevant for physical therapists
Was interviewed for my first podcast appearance yesterday on The Knowledge Exchange! Listen to the epi here where I discuss with the host, Daniel Arbilla, about critical thinking for new grads and current physio students, and some of the challenges faced
open.spotify.com/episode/3hx…
1
5
Proud to be interviewed on a podcast that has hosted some of the best and brightest MSK rehab clinicians and scientists from around the world!
@JudithDeutsch @RU_CPPTC





















