Q: What is your response to someone who comes up to you and says, “Well, I find that your critiques of Israel fuel my fears of antisemitism.”
El-Sayed: I’m sorry for your fear. Obviously, I don’t want to do anything that drives your fear. At the end of the day, there’s a difference between safety or lack of safety and comfort. If what I’m saying is making you uncomfortable, you should be uncomfortable with injustice perpetrated on other people. You should be uncomfortable with that.
Addressing the safety question and the discomfort question are two different things, because if it is your sense of your discomfort and/or fear that has to keep me quiet while I watch 70,000 people get killed, their homes annihilated, their hospitals destroyed… and I can’t critique that, then I think what you’re telling me is that their humanity matters less than yours. And I’m not going to be okay with that.
kim retweeted
Are Schumer and Jeffries popular? No. But are they effective? Also no. But are they at least trying their best? Of course not. But do they at least have our best interest at heart? Not even close.
kim retweeted
The raging debate on the origin of zionism is academic and irrelevant to our lives at this moment. This is not the conversation to have during a genocide.
I don't care if zionism was first a Christian idea. Whether that's true or not is immaterial to me as a Palestinian.
What is relevant and irrefutable is that material Zionism—i.e., the wholesale slaughter and displacement of indigenous Palestinians, the theft of our homes, land, and heritage, and ongoing genocidal apartheid and oppression—is wholly Jewish in its implementation.
Some of you have criticized me for supporting the work of Benjamin Moser. I hear it, and some of it is fair, especially as it echoes what I've said myself.
Yes, a few things he said feel like liberal Zionism, even as he explicitly rejects all zionism. But my impulse was to offer some grace to someone who seems to be embarking on an earnest, moral, anti-zionist journey toward, perhaps, arriving at deeper truths, even if they implicate Judaism itself.
That's not a defense of him, nor is it an endorsement. I don't know him nor have I ever spoken with him. It's just my honest reaction to a Jewish intellectual saying clearly that there is no acceptable form of zionism; that it is an irredeemably murderous, hateful, colonial ideology from the outset.
And there's also something else—something more personal that I have been wrestling with.
Besides the apathy of the Arab masses and complicity of Arab governments, nothing in this genocide has surprised me more than the widespread support Israel continues to enjoy among western Jews.
Maybe I was naive, but there had always been a part of me that believed the Jewish masses outside Israel were mostly decent families who'd simply been brainwashed; and that if they really knew what Israel has been doing to us in the name of Judaism, they'd end that support.
But survey after survey showed Jewish support for Israel increased, even as they witnessed the same horrors the whole world was watching. All the "holocaust museums" that we were made to march through in school have either been silent on this first live-streamed genocide in human history, or they've closed ranks with other mainstream Jewish institutions, all of them running cover and giving support to Israel, while simultaneously coming after individuals and collectives who dare to speak up.
The disappointment, outrage, grief, anger, and pain I feel have been intense, and they made me feel mistrust of Jews outside my circles. I don't apologize for that, nor will I pretend it away—not when I'm watching our people shredded and denigrated day in and day out, while Jews in Israel and around the world sadistically celebrate it or at a minimum, make excuses for the mutilated bodies of our families.
Then comes a statistic that half of the Jewish population in Michigan voted for the first Muslim senator, and a clear Jewish anti-Zionist voice begins to pop up on my feed, effectively countering zionist talking points. So I held onto that, for my own sake—because I'm Muslim and I'm Palestinian and I'm a mother and grandmother, and at my core is a need to believe that most human are fundamentally decent.
Ironically, in doing so, I did the thing I criticize others for doing—centering Jewish voices.
So let me be clear that what matters to me is Palestinian liberation, an end to the zionist project, and full accountability and restitution—nothing short of how Nazis were treated.
The near total merging of Judaism with a brutal colonial project among world Jewry means there can be no getting around an eventual reckoning with western Jewry itself.
But that, too, is not the conversation I want to have now.
I want to talk about the dangers that Jewish supremacy poses to humanity, and to Palestinians in particular; about the inherent, wholly natural right to violently resist settler-colonialism; about Palestinians enduring a fourth winter of genocide in flimsy tents that flood with every rain and blow away in the wind, while Israel continues to murder, bomb, starve and eviscerate a captive indigenous society to take their land; about the Israeli politicians and pundits openly debating on their airwaves on a final solution—how to efficiently, realistically, and effectively finish off the Palestinians left in Gaza.
kim retweeted
These people spend all day, every day telling the rest of us just how bad antisemitism has gotten. How much worse it is getting by the moment. How nowhere is safe. Not New York City. Not Michigan. Not London. Not Amsterdam. Not our universities or our synagogues or the Equinox on 31st Street - the one with that trainer who wears a Palestinian flag pin.
The Jihadists are coming for our children, they prophecy. For our Western values. For our very democracy. Any day now, the terrorists are going to march into our towns and impose Sharia law.
The world is once again, not a safe place for Jews, they warn us. Over and over and over again.
Then, they get dressed up in tuxedos and fancy gowns, and they hand each other awards, and lavish praise on one another – for the incredible work they have done to make the world a safe place for Jews.
Hasbarah. Is. A. Grift.
kim retweeted
8 of the 11 Democrats who skipped the vote to impeach war criminal Pete Hegseth were not “caught in traffic.” They were at an AIPAC-affiliated event that was scheduled at the same time as the impeachment vote by the Democrat’s House whip Katherine Clark. Turns out she was whipping votes to protect, not impeach, Hegseth. This was all planned because their AIPAC donors don’t want Hegseth impeached. If Hegseth is held accountable for war crimes it opens up the possibility of more Zionist war criminals being held accountable. They want to preserve the corrupt world we live in now where US/Zionist war criminals murder with impunity.
Big thanks to @JulianAndreone who broke the story about the AIPAC-affiliated meeting being scheduled at the same time as the Hegseth impeachment vote.
This is a massive scandal: 8 of the 11 Democrats that didn’t show up to vote to impeach war criminal Pete Hegseth were at an AIPAC-affiliated event. The Israeli lobby doesn’t want Hegseth impeached because it wants him to keep committing war crimes against Iran. Both parties are traitors and must go.
kim retweeted
Ran into one of those liberal Zionists who poses as pro-Palestine but spends half their time concern trolling about "antisemitism" in the pro-Palestine movement. He tried to get me to engage him in this subject and I told him this:
Address the fact that 99.9% of the time “antisemitism” gets mentioned it’s in reference to criticisms of Israel and Zionism. Address the fact that Israel and Zionism cause many orders of magnitude more damage than the 0.1% instances of actual antisemitism. Address the fact that the overwhelming majority of the 0.1% instances of actual antisemitism are caused by Israel's genocide and warmongering and would go away if Israel stopped butchering children under the banner of the Star of David. Explain how it is possible to have a “serious discussion about antisemitism” while these three things are happening.
You will answer all four questions I asked you in their entirety if this conversation is to proceed. Until you have thoroughly addressed them all, the conversation you are trying to have is nonsensical.
kim retweeted
Anyone who's congratulating Karen Bass for her service to LA isn't serious. Her politics, her actions, her demeanor, her appointments, her words --- they were all trash and embarrassing to behold. True garbage mayor that took way much more from this city than she ever gave.
kim retweeted
If you ride a bike down Rittenhouse Square and don’t purchase something from a business that donates its profits to the Israeli army, @6abc will compare you to a Nazi. If you bomb a school or hospital, they instead call you America’s greatest ally.
kim retweeted
They lied about the boycott- only a few businesses in one area that are owned by three people who give money to the Israeli terrorists are being protested.
They lied about it being on the anniversary of Kristallnacht - which virtually no one under 40 has ever heard of. That happened Nov. 9. The boycott is Nov. 8.
They made the ridiculous comparison of a bicycle ride protest, with a *violent* campaign in which thousands of homes, businesses and synagogues were attacked and even burned down.
They all got the same script, didn't fact check it, and are now defaming the organizers of the boycott in yet another fake-antisemitism bout of hysteria.
America overwhelmingly rejected Israel and the constant stream of false accusations of antisemitismb in the election. They never learn.
kim retweeted
A bike protest in Philadelphia targeting several restaurants has faced widespread condemnation from politicians and organizations in multiple states. When you dig into the details however, it’s pretty clear what’s actually going on here.
kim retweeted
No no, it's not true that antisemitism means criticism of Israel. You're allowed to criticize Israel, you just need to memorize a very long list of rules you must follow, make sure you're only criticizing the current sitting government rather than the Zionist state itself, and be careful not to invoke any of the ten thousand obscure Tropes you've never heard of, or else you will lose your job and possibly go to prison.
So go on ahead, criticize Israel all you like. It's a free country.
kim retweeted
Three in five American Jews believe that Jewish organizations are exploiting fears of antisemitism in order to defend unpopular Israeli policies.
You can’t say it loud enough: these people do not speak for us.
kim retweeted
Is there anything more pathetic than people who act like Jews are not safe in America because, for the first time in history, there is one Muslim Senator? What a bunch of pathetic crybabies. Try living in Gaza for one day.
Democrats must be absolutely ruthless now.
No “healing the nation”. No “moving on”, no “reconciliation”, no “bridging the gaps”. No “if they go low, we go high”. No Obamism.
Subpoena, impeach, prosecute, imprison. Trumpism is criminal & should be treated as such.
- AshMordant
kim retweeted
I've seen this before.
I'm not happy yet.
I want impeachments.
I want investigations.
I want arrests.
I did my part.
Now you do yours.
kim retweeted
if you don't enjoy the schadenfreude of seeing republicans sobbing and screaming and freaking out you have no heart.
if you think the democrats are going to actually do anything you have no brain.
kim retweeted
Hey Democrats, right after you're done celebrating, keep in mind that these 2 should not be leading anything or anyone.
Kick them out and start fresh✌


































