Replying to @JordanWithaG @notronmexicuh
On top of the uncounted 25k natural deaths and the estimated 20-25k militant deaths you may be left with 25k violent civilian deaths plus 10k since October 7th.
Geordan with a G retweeted
“It didn’t start on the 7th of October 2023”
1. Jerusalem Nebi Musa Riots 1920
2. Jaffa Riots 1921
3. Hebron Massacre 1929
4. Motza Massacre 1929
5. Safed Massacre 1929
6. Jaffa Riots 1936
7. Tiberias Massacre 1938
8. Farhud Massacre, Baghdad 1941
9. Tripoli Pogrom 1945
10. Jerusalem Commercial Centre Riots 1947
11. Aleppo Pogrom 1947
12. Aden Riots 1947
13. Haifa Oil Refinery Massacre 1947
14. Convoy of 35 Ambush 1948
15. Ben Yehuda Street Bombing 1948
16. Jewish Agency Bombing 1948
17. Hadassah Convoy Massacre 1948
18. Kfar Etzion Massacre 1948
19. Oujda and Jerada Pogrom 1948
20. Tripoli Pogrom 1948
21. Cairo Jewish Quarter Bombings 1948
22. Expulsion of 850,000 Jews from Arab Countries 1948–1970s
23. Ma'ale Akrabim Bus Massacre 1954
24. Kfar Chabad School Attack 1956
25. Libya Pogrom 1967
26. Baghdad Public Hangings of Jews 1969
27. Avivim School Bus Massacre 1970
28. Lod Airport Massacre 1972
29. Munich Olympics Massacre 1972
30. Kiryat Shmona Massacre 1974
31. Ma'alot School Massacre 1974
32. Savoy Hotel Attack 1975
33. Zion Square Bombing 1975
34. Coastal Road Massacre 1978
35. Nahariya Attack 1979
36. Beit Hadassah Hebron Attack 1980
37. Vienna Synagogue Attack 1981
38. Rue des Rosiers Attack, Paris 1982
39. Rome Great Synagogue Attack 1982
40. Achille Lauro Hijacking 1985
41. Neve Shalom Synagogue Massacre, Istanbul 1986
42. Israeli Embassy Bombing, Buenos Aires 1992
43. AMIA Bombing, Buenos Aires 1994
44. Jerusalem Bus 18 Bombings 1996
45. Mahane Yehuda Market Bombing 1997
46. Other Second Intifada Bombings 2000–2005
47. Dolphinarium Massacre 2001
48. Sbarro Massacre 2001
49. Beit Yisrael Bombing 2002
50. Park Hotel Passover Massacre 2002
51. El Ghriba Synagogue Bombing, Djerba 2002
52. Hebrew University Cafeteria Bombing 2002
53. Jerusalem Bus 2 Massacre 2003
54. Maxim Restaurant Massacre, Haifa 2003
55. Istanbul Synagogue Bombings 2003
56. Ilan Halimi Murder, Paris 2006
57. Mercaz HaRav Yeshiva Massacre 2008
58. Mumbai Chabad House Massacre 2008
59. Itamar Massacre 2011
60. Toulouse Jewish School Massacre 2012
61. Burgas Bus Bombing 2012
62. Brussels Jewish Museum Attack 2014
63. Three Teens Kidnapping and Murder 2014
64. Har Nof Synagogue Massacre 2014
65. Hyper Cacher Attack, Paris 2015
66. Sarona Market Attack 2016
67. Sarah Halimi Murder, Paris 2017
68. Mireille Knoll Murder, Paris 2018
69. Tree of Life Synagogue Massacre, Pittsburgh 2018
70. Jersey City Kosher Market Attack 2019
71. Beersheba, Bnei Brak and Elad Attacks 2022
72. Neve Yaakov Synagogue Attack 2023
73. El Ghriba Synagogue Shooting, Djerba 2023
74. October 7 Massacre 2023
75. Jaffa Light Rail Attack 2024
76. Capital Jewish Museum Attack, Washington 2025
77. Ramot Junction Shooting 2025
78. Heaton Park Synagogue Attack, Manchester 2025
79. Bondi Beach Hanukkah Massacre, Sydney 2025
Geordan with a G retweeted
I am happy to join 6,000 prominent scholars, legal experts to sign a letter rejecting Gaza genocide charge. jpost.com/israel-news/articl…
include historian Niall Ferguson, Israeli historian Benny Morris, Holocaust historian and former US Special Envoy to Monitor and Combat Antisemitism Deborah Lipstadt, Tel Aviv University professor emerita and former Yad Vashem chief historian Dina Porat, historian and author Simon Sebag Montefiore, UCLA professor Judea Pearl, and Brandeis University professor emeritus Jonathan Sarna.
Geordan with a G retweeted
Worth noting that the human shield strategy would be pointless if they believed Israel was willing to just target indiscriminately.
The only reason to do this is because Hamas/PIJ believe that having a child act as a human shield makes an Israeli action less likely.
Geordan with a G retweeted
"I burned your house, raped your daughter, and murdered your parents, but I'll give you back the son I kidnapped and tortured if you drop the charges. No? Well, it's clear who the monster is here!"
Geordan with a G retweeted
The US bombed Serbia to stop the Muslim genocide, propped up Israeli-Palestinian peace groups, and secured aid in Somalia. 9/11 wasn’t “blow back”, it was jihad against the perceived head of the free western world. This is stated in Bin Laden’s “Letter to the American people”
Geordan with a G retweeted
Replying to @mehdirhasan
Wait are you saying it's wrong to demand people compensate others for an atrocity they had nothing to do with?
What a concept
Geordan with a G retweeted
imagine telling someone with no context that the ppl who celebrate the event that led to this were the ones who “supported” the ppl on the left
Geordan with a G retweeted
Replying to @ControlBothSide
(1) Even Hamas claims 70K total deaths, including combatants, not all civilians. So you are outdoing Hamas itself in propaganda.
(2) People dying in war is not "murder," not legally, and not ethically. Did the Allies "Murder" several million people in World War II?
(3) The deaths are a result of Hamas invading Israel, taking hostages, hiding behind civilians and refusing to surrender long after they had lost the war militarily. Their hope was that useful idiots like yourself would pressure/blame Israel instead of them. Why do you choose to be a useful idiot?
Geordan with a G retweeted
It doesn't matter how many academics, activists & NGOs allege @Israel is/was responsible for genocide in #Gaza. What matters is the methodology they use to arrive at that conclusion. Without exception, their method is flawed - which means the popular "genocide" claim is as well.
As anyone who cares enough to read the Genocide Convention knows by now, this egregious int'l law crime involves committing an enumerated act with "intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such" (pic 1).
"Intent" is emphasized there because this is the component that usually differentiates correct from flawed methodology.
A convincing methodological approach would start by identifying what strategic objectives have been officially expressed by 🇮🇱 gov't then evaluating whether battlefield conduct is consistent with those objectives or, instead, with intent to destroy Palestinians as an identity group in whole or in part as such.
For example, @netanyahu announced 2 weeks after 10/7, just as full-scale ground ops were getting underway, that strategic objectives of the military campaign in Gaza were, "Destroying Hamas's military and governing capabilities, and bringing the captives back home" (pic 2). Almost two years later on 2nd anniversary of 10/7, he affirmed 🇮🇱 “will continue to act to achieve all the aims of the war: return all the hostages, destroy the Hamas regime, and ensure that Gaza no longer poses a threat to Israel" (pic 3).
So strategic objectives expressed by 🇮🇱 have been consistent throughout the campaign. Since intent is usually the decisive "genocide" element, convincing methodology must start with what the stated intent is (if it's known, as it is here) & evaluate conduct from there.
Any guesses how many of these "reputable" academics, advocacy groups & activists have adopted that method? If you answered "zero", congratulations ... you are 💯 correct.
Instead, EVERY SINGLE ONE of these bullshit "genocide" allegations adopts the exact same bullshit methodology.
That is, each takes a handful cherry-picked statements from a few 🇮🇱 officials, most of which are misrepresented and/or taken out of context, to construct the illusion that @IDF intent in Gaza is actually to destroy Palestinians in whole or in part as such rather than Hamas. I've attached an excerpt of @hrw report as but one example of this flawed methodology (pic 4).
It's a hoax. And it has been from the beginning. But the more ppl/groups/orgs make this bullshit allegation, the more convincing it seems to the uninformed masses - like Glenn here - who simply don't know any better.
Speaking of Glenn ... no one whose opinion matters believes or claims that "the term 'genocide'" is limited only to "successfully slaughtering everyone in a population as quickly as possible."
Committing prohibited acts with intent to destroy a specified identity group in whole or in part as such doesn't require that. It's almost comical that Glenn claims "the belief that [genocide] only covers that act is part of the confusion and/or misinformation on this question" since no one who can read the Genocide Convention actually does believe that.
Framing the "belief" in those terms only to "discredit" something that doesn't exist is an example of the constructed strawman rhetorical technique. This is one way of spreading misinformation - exactly what Glenn claims these imaginary "Israel supporters" whose views he has constructed are doing.
Also: 🇬🇧 🇺🇸 + "much of Europe paid for, armed and otherwise enabled most of it" because ... that's right. It's not ACTUALLY a "genocide."
The truth is that the claim 🇮🇱
"committed genocide in Gaza" actually IS a "laughable delusion that only crazies assert." It's just unfathomable how far it's spread from "fringe" to mainstream because so many progressive zealots - like Glenn here - are duped by #legaldisinformation for ideological reasons since they so badly WANT to believe the "genocide" lie.
There are many Israel supporters who treat the claim that Israel committed genocide in Gaza as if it's some sort of fringe, laughable delusion that only crazies assert.
In fact, this conclusion has been endorsed by most major human rights groups (including Israeli ones), leading scholars of genocide (including leading Israeli scholars and countless Jewish ones), duly constituted international tribunals, many countries around the world, UN inquiries, and all kinds of associations of scholars.
You can dismiss them all as bigoted and anti-Semitic if you want (groups or scholars criticizing Israel are reflexively dismissed as such). But the conclusion that Israel committed classic genocide in Gaza is not some assertion that only gets made by random internet accounts. It's approaching a consensus in the world of groups, tribunals and scholars most qualified to adjudicate the question.
(The term "genocide" includes far more than "successfully slaughtering everyone in a population as quickly as possible," and the belief that it only covers that act is part of the confusion and/or misinformation on this question).
Also: the US, UK and much of Europe paid for, armed and otherwise enabled most of it.
Geordan with a G retweeted
you know people like to say Americans have no culture but my German neighbors are throwing a party tonight and i can hear their music from my living room and almost every song on their playlist is American. you are all fish that don’t realize you’re swimming in water.
Geordan with a G retweeted
The greatest trick Hamas ever pulled was building ~500 km of bomb shelters, provoking a war, refusing to let even a single civilian take shelter there, and convincing the world to blame Israel for their deaths.
Is the bigotry in the room with you now?
Actually at the time I called it a ‘terrorist atrocity’ and ‘horrific attack.’ But these people are so gripped by hatred of Muslims, so deranged, so bigoted, so unhinged, that they’ll lie and fear-monger about anything to do with Islam or Muslims.
Gad Saad blamed Islam for his family’s plight; the same people mad at me for my snarky response to his bigotry would never be okay with a Palestinian refugee blaming Judaism for his plight. The hypocrisy, alongside the bigotry, is brazen.





























