Replying to @Etienne_Marcuz @britforcig
Oui c'est sûr que, si différence il y a, elle est subtile 👌
1
10
Article here!
csis.org/analysis/european-n…
1
285
If you'd like to read more on Europeans' "Declaration on Key Principles of European security", here is my piece with @CSIS (link in comment).
Big thanks to @maxbergmann and @csiserep team for the feedback!
... si je devais deviner, je dirais que ce n'était pas possible car la décla du 10 novembre est au niveau du NSG/GPN, et non des Chefs d'Etat et de gouvernement, contrairement à celle de Northwood ?
1
23
Replying to @Etienne_Marcuz @britforcig
Une manière d'éviter ces difficultés ("sache que" / "intérêt de") aurait été de délivrer directement le signal : "tout Etat envisageant de menacer les intérêts vitaux de la France ou du Royaume-Uni serait alors confronté à la puissance combinée de nos deux forces".
Mais... 1/2
1
1
92
Replying to @Etienne_Marcuz
Hyper intéressant @Etienne_Marcuz.
En comparant à Northwood, je suis aussi frappé par l'expression "puissance combinée", qui va encore plus loin que "coordonnée". J'imagine qu'on peut "coordonner" de différentes manières, sans nécessairement "combiner" ? Signal renforcé indeed!
1
12
1,876
Signal 4: But Europeans are also anticipating norms. Particularly “risk management and risk reduction mechanisms”.
Europeans are exploring norms that will not impede posture reinforcements. And where the impact of adversary non-cooperation and lack of trust can be managed (7/7)
1
1
68
Signal 3: Europeans’ priority is to strengthen their posture vis-à-vis Russia. They take primary responsibility for their own security.
Priorities listed: defense spending, cooperation on capabilities & planning, defense industrial base, resilience to “hybrid” actions. (6/7)
1
1
64
European security rests on a balance of strength and norms.
Strength without norms can lead to inadvertent escalation – and Europeans have to address a threat that will be durable, right in their neighborhood.
But norms without strength lack credibility. (5/7)
1
1
69
Signal 2: Europeans are demonstrating unity.
They are countering Russia’s narrative that it is “pro-peace” while they are supposedly “pro-war” – the 40 signatories stated they are “committed to peace”. (4/7)
1
1
71
Signal 1: Europeans will not accept being circumvented on these discussions.
They reject Russia’s vision of spheres of influence: the declaration recalls existing principles that underpin European security – and are not up for discussion. (3/7)
1
1
101
The issue: Russia wants to use negotiations on Ukraine to push wider demands on European security.
Russia wants to reshape Europe into spheres of influence, for instance by dictating who can become a NATO member.
Here are signals I’m inferring from Europeans’ declaration. (2/7)
1
1
779


