Pinned Tweet
Lucy #Letby is Innocent and not Guilty
40 minutes discussion on what a defence expert witness could have advised defence barrister for summing up.
youtu.be/pAGZQWVKriY?is=mcGz… – at Ballachulish, Scotland
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
A reminder. Another innocent person locked up for life with Evans’ involved.
CPR in babies can cause harm including death. Yet Dewi Evans not only wrongly said that couldn’t happen in Summer Peace’s case but also missed her pneumonia - as he did in Child D’s case (and others) in the Lucy Letby trial. Both Summer’s father and Lucy are serving life in prison. share.google/UYqxEWMiEzteO2c…
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
The justice system in England and it's standards of what qualifies as expert evidence is at rock bottom. An urgent investigation and rapid changes are needed.
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
It gets worse and worse. More concerning revelations about Peter Hindmarsh, the insulin expert in the Lucy Letby case. He was an expert witness in another case after he was barred from clinical practice in April 2023. theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
"Christopher Morris talks about one of the most significant British legal cases of the 21st Century"
Thrilled that @CPMorris1234 will be discussing his book about Lucy Letby with @johnsweeneyroar at the Oxford Literary Festival: oxfordliteraryfestival.org/l…
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
In the trailer for his forthcoming interview with Dewi Evans, @nickbarberx has chosen to highlight the following statement from Evans:
“She was getting better at harming these babies”.
Let's examine the validity of that comment.
Firstly, for the purpose of this exercise, I will assume that Lucy Letby genuinely attacked infants. Obviously this is not true, the conviction of Letby is clearly wrongful.
This is what happened to the first five infants that Lucy Letby supposedly attacked:
Child A – died
Child B – did not die
Child C – died
Child D – died
Child E – died
Of the first five infants in the case, four of them passed away – an 80% 'success' rate.
Let's now examine the next nine infants:
Child F – did not die
Child G – did not die
Child H – did not die
Child I – died
Child J – did not die
Child K – did not die
Child L – did not die
Child M – did not die
Child N – did not die
Of the next nine infants in the case, one of them passed away – an 11.1% 'success rate'.
For the first five infants in the case, the supposed attacker was 7.27 times more successful, or 727%.
I am therefore struggling to see how she “was getting better at harming these babies”. By what measure could you possibly say this was the case?
Furthermore, for the first five infants Letby supposedly used the injection of air on every occasion, and was successful 80% of the time.
Child A – air embolism
Child B – air embolism
Child C – air via nasogastric tube / air embolism / whatever Evans has made up since the trial
Child D – air embolism
Child E – air embolism (frankly it's an utter farce that anyone could suggest air was involved)
She then did the following:
Child F – insulin (unsuccessful)
Child G – milk (unsuccessful)
Child H – no plausible proposed mechanism (unsuccessful)
She then returned to air for Child I:
Child I – air via nasogastric tube / air embolus / whatever Evans has made up since the trial (successful)
This was successful. So she then moved away from air again:
Child J – malicious airway obstruction (unsuccessful)
Child K – tube extubation (unsuccessful)
Child L – insulin (unsuccessful)
Having been unsuccessful on these cases, she then returned to air, but less successfully than previously:
Child M – air embolism (unsuccessful)
Child N – air embolism (unsuccessful)
I do need to mention that the prosecution case for Child N was so garbled and such obvious crap that it's not really even clear what Lucy Letby is alleged to have done, but air embolism was referenced.
What kind of serial killer does the following:
She has a successful method of murder.
Then moves away from it.
She is then considerably less successful.
She then returns to it and is successful.
She then moves way from it again.
She is unsuccessful again.
She then returns to it, but is now less successful than she was initially.
Let alone, how can she be considered to have become 'better' over time?
That smell you can sense in the air, ladies and gentlemen, is the whiff of utter bullshit; a fragrance that appears to waft around Evans relentlessly.
I will further state as well that to blame Lucy Letby for the death of Child O would be ludicrous. The prosecution case has been completely annihilated, and the comments of Evans in relation to this infant are preposterous. And Child P died due the obvious mismanagement of a pneumothorax. On a competent unit, both of those infants would have had a considerably better chance of survival.
If you do blame her for those deaths, even then her 'success' rate for the 12 other infants in the case is 25%, compared to 80% for the first five.
This is another statement of utter idiocy from Evans which is simply complete tripe. And yet, I think he is genuinely demented enough to believe the abject nonsense that he comes out with. He has backed himself into an irretrievable corner with his palpable rubbish and flagrant arrogance, and now all he has left is the embarrassing spectacle of grimly clinging to his blatantly erroneous belief system.
This is why Evans can't and won't face a credible interviewer.
The reality is that Evans should never have been allowed anywhere near this case. Anyone with two brain cells to rub together understands this, let alone the litany of more qualified professionals who have, rightly, eviscerated his 'work'.
I say this sincerely: I hope you understand what you're getting yourself involved with by platforming Evans. This will stick to you for the rest of your life. I hope you're prepared for that.
#LucyLetby #LucyLetbyInnocent
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
These parents look to be another victim of the idiotic expert witness and cruel sentencing systems. Their child became ill and they were convicted of manslaughter for not doing enough to get help in a period of just eight hours.
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
Interesting:
Hindmarsh went on to produce a crucial expert report in August 2023 that the CPS used to support a case against two Birmingham parents, Damion and Tamara Thomas, who were accused of neglecting their son Joshua, 12, before he died.
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
BREAKING: Lucy Letby ‘insulin expert’ Prof Peter Hindmarsh was praised by West Midlands Police over his ‘key evidence’, used in convicting Tamara Thomas of killing her child, 6 months after Letby’s case - but Hindmarsh and the CPS had again kept his practice ban, arising from unsafe use of the drug, secret from the jury (via @Guardian) theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
Read this follow up from @PeterElston1 for the families, not the headlines.
Peter's latest piece looks at the babies outside the trial. According to the documents he's seen, prosecution experts suspected deliberate harm in around 15 more babies. None were charged. In January the CPS confirmed there would be no further charges.
Think about what that leaves those families with. Their baby's care was looked at in a criminal investigation, and then nothing. Whether they were told, and how much, I don't know. Thirlwall only covered the trial babies. Nobody is looking at their care now.
That's exactly why I keep asking for a proper independent review of the Countess. Not just for the families in the trial. For all of them.
If your baby was at the Countess or Liverpool Women's between 2011 and 2016 and you've ever wondered whether they were part of the investigation, you can ask Cheshire Police directly.
Here is a follow up article to my recent one about the "doctored" roster chart, titled Lucy Letby Case: The Evans and Bohin Double Act and More Allegations of Inflicted Harm that Never Went Anywhere.
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) announced on January 20, 2026, that it would not bring a further 11 criminal charges in relation to nine babies against Lucy Letby after reviewing evidence submitted by Cheshire Police in July 2025. This blog draws on leaked disclosure documents to set out the suspicions cited by Drs Sandie Bohin and Dewi Evans in relation to 15 babies. The extent to which the nine babies on Cheshire Police's July 2025 charging application were among these 15 is not known but it is likely to be to a high degree.
mephitis.co/post/lucy-letby-…
#letby #lucyletby
Absolutely appalling.
Professor Hindmarsh comes across as dangerously arrogant.
Doctors, Nurses, Paramedics have missed diagnoses of new type 1 diabetes with DKA, but parents found grossly negligent for missing the diagnosis. Medicine is difficult.
@GuerrillaCarl – at South Ballachulish, Scotland
It just keeps getting worse.
The disgraced Lucy Letby insulin expert witness who was barred from giving medical advice on insulin went on to give vital testimony in another case MONTHS LATER.
Use of expert witnesses in our justice system is broken.
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Replying to @TheBMA
@TheBMA No.1 priority for the future of the medical profession should be for @gmcuk defunding, disbandment & a new impartial independent medical regulator to be set up
The BMA is examining whether 223 doctors whose data were mistakenly shared with the Times newspaper by the General Medical Council are entitled to financial compensation
bmj.com/content/395/bmj-2026…
.@ClarkeMicah, @mellycatslave, @MartynPitman
@gill1109, @rob_goudie
On the Letby case and an expert witness for the prosecution, Dr Hindmarsh: This is the second version of a preliminary list - using information from mainly
@LucyLetbyTrials, @david_conn, @DebbieKennett, @JabesAllowed, @LucyLetbyFOI, and @ACLMoss.
(I may have missed something. If you have any suggestion for corrections, additions, exact dates, please let me know with direct sources.)
7 July 2022: Dr Hindmarsh wrote his three reports for Baby L. He wrote three reports and the final report was dated 7 July.
27 July 2022: Great Ormond Street terminated Dr Hindmarsh's honorary consultant contract.
5-6 Aug 2022: Dr Hindmarsh was at the joint pre-trial expert meeting at Chilworth Manor.
**How Did He Present Himself to the Defence Side?
Have you read the document from that meeting, @drphilhammond ?
10 Oct 2022: Lucy Letby's trial started.
25 Nov 2022: The General Medical Council opened an investigation into Dr Hindmarsh.
25 Nov 2022, Dr Hindmarsh gave evidence to Letby's trial at Manchester Crown Court, telling the jury that the blood sugar of a child known as Child F fell worryingly low for a persistent length of time. (The BBC)
30 Nov 2022: Hindmarsh was informed that the GMC was investigating him.
14 Dec 2022: Dr Hindmarsh told police and prosecutors that he was being investigated by the GMC
21 Dec 2022: UCLH reported clinical concerns to the GMC. Hindmarsh was suspended pending a return to work under close supervision.
Jan 2023: A medical tribunal imposed restrictions: Hindmarsh could work only at UCLH and his clinical work had to be supervised. The tribunal identified a potential risk to the public if he practised without restrictions.
15 Feb 2023: CPS was notified by the police (CC)
17 Feb 2023: CPS discussed the matter with prosecution counsel.
20 Feb 2023: The prosecution told the defence about the investigation by the GMC that their lead insulin expert was being investigated.
24 February 2023: Nick Johnson KC, the lead prosecution barrister, described Hindmarsh to the jury as “the pre-eminent expert in that narrow field” of insulin. Hindmarsh told the court that poisoning was the only reasonable explanation for the blood readings of a baby, referred to as Child L (BBC)
15 March 2023: while the trial was continuing at Manchester crown court, Dr Tim Hodgson, a medical director at UCLH, wrote to the GMC: “On the grounds of safety UCLH are not presently in a position to allow Prof [Hindmarsh] to practise clinically even under supervision. (The Guardian)
*March 2023: He was excluded from clinical practice because his hospital considered him unsafe to treat children in relation to insulin. (The Guardian) Letby’s defence lawyers were never told that Hindmarsh had been excluded from clinical practice, nor of an April 2023 tribunal ruling imposing a restriction. The CPS has also said it was not informed. (The Guardian)
21 April 2023: A medical practitioners tribunal declined to suspend Hindmarsh but ordered that he must be directly supervised in his clinical work. That appears to have had no practical effect because UCLH had barred him from treating patients at all. (The Guardian)
July 2023: The judge summed up the case. The jury remained unaware of the clinical restrictions and exclusion.
Aug. 2023: Lucy Letby was convicted.
Attempted murder of Child F & L (by insulin): Guilty
November 2024: The investigation into Hindmarsh never concluded because, according to GMC records, he "relinquished" his registration in Nov 2024 through a process known as "voluntary erasure".
Nov. 2026: The Guardian reported on this scandal.
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
Replying to @PeterElston1
@PeterElston1 @gill1109 @drphilhammond @doctorcaldwell @guyrowlanduk @CPMorris1234 @NeoDoc11 @MartynPitman @Michelehal7344 @LucyLetbyTrials @LucyLetbyFOI @guardian
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
Three posts in three days on the Hindmarsh story, and wrong on nearly every point that matters.
I've gone through them line by line against the Guardian, the High Court and the medical register, what she got right, and everything she didn't.
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
It's as if Hindmarsh thinks he was doing God's Work or something.
How can untrained parents be imprisoned because they were not good enough doctors? What are the police and CPS thinking? Is there a campaign to imprison as many people as possible?
Ramen.
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
On this point, I think Myers is correct. I haven't found a single decision that went in favour of the defendant. I have found 28 that went against her. Every time the defence applied for something, it was denied.
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
The parents must appeal and the CCRC must refer Lucy’s case on. It beggars belief that charlatans like Hindmarsh, Evans and Bohin can cause so much harm then walk away as the system freezes. No accountability before or after these shocking miscarriages of justice.
Dr Gordon Caldwell retweeted
Doesn't it just.
The wheels are surely about to fall off the #LucyLetby conviction. I cannot see how anyone can possibly still view it as safe and beyond reasonable doubt.
The degree of collateral damage caused by those involved, including Hindmarsh, will be catastrophic.






















