Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues) profile picture

Machine Learning Research Engineer at OMQ GmbH

Heidelberg, Germany
Joined March 2010
Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)Photo by Gil Noh (노태길) (@tailblues)
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
This is absolutely the best explanation of the Ukraine/Russia/U.S. & Starlink/Starshield debacle I’ve heard so far
374
959
99
7,193
819,898
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
We’ve been nominated for a British political podcast award! ⬆️⬆️⬆️
Replying to @iNHouseComms
The Most Original Format finalists are: The Reform UK Podcast (Reform UK) TLDR’s World Leader Leaderboard (TLDR News) Westminster Insider (Politico) Politics at Sam and Anne’s (Politico and Sky News)
2
1
64
1,288
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
the entire advantage of llms is they are incredibly flexible which means they can conform to whatever way you prefer to work and think and build there's infinite people posting about the best way to use agents. like, first you need to do a plan, and then you need to blah blah blah but if that doesn't click for you, don't work that way. work however you like the little bit of advice i'd give is think about ways to keep it fun it can get boring consuming big chunks of text, ask for a fun video in a crazy voice that gets unhinged over time
64
43
25
1,433
74,487
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
i think the confusion is the urge to have pre-ai style opinions on programming but the entire point here is a lot of these things stopped mattering because ai can deal with it either way
22
21
6
570
102,500
A few people asked me to repost this. Here you go.
146
727
121
2,830
85,187
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
The irony of posting literal AIs under the grift of "AI bad"
Removing AI from your feed with 4 of my 3D renders ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹
1
8
735
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
My current most-frequent Claude failure mode: Claude will suggest an external source (a repo, a paper, an article, etc) as supporting a thesis, approach, whatever. I will ask: "How does it support it?" Claude: "Honest answer: I have not actually read it yet."
17
2
33
1,386
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Intoxicating. I’ve been programming for 45 years, since so was 10. I’ve been a pro game coder for 33 years. Everything from hand coded assembly to UE 5.8. The paradigm shift to agentic coding is intoxicating. It is the biggest productivity jump I have ever experienced.
280
524
99
11,210
1,087,245
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Science is NOT about people asking permission to contribute. If you have something to say, you say it. If you have a proof, you write a paper. It's always been like this. We don't need an "Advisory Group" to tell who can and who can't contribute to scientific research.
72
90
20
1,432
35,371
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
I think the "difficulty" of software engineering is essentially constant no matter what abstraction level you move to, because human cognition adapts to new tools until it can fully utilize itself. Tools are only affordances, not a magic wand that makes work disappear. Great software engineering was immensely challenging before. It is still immensely challenging now, despite very different workflows.
The more time I spend working with coding agents, the more convinced I am that they make software engineering even harder We can do amazing things with them, but unlocking their full potential requires extraordinary discipline and knowledge
130
174
25
1,604
123,297
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
There is NO realistic scenario where AI wipes out all of humanity. I've talked to many AI safety experts about existential risks. Some of the "experts" are just phenomenal sci-fi authors. There are also real researchers working on realistic risks. They point out real and likely harms and I'm explicitly not arguing that there could be no such harm. We need to take these seriously. However, whenever I ask for an actual detailed scenario that would kill every single human i.e. extinction, it usually starts and ends with "just look at current progress and use your imagination". No science, no scenario planning, just handwaving probabilities without data, based on gut-feelings, often little expertise, sometimes real expertise combined with a huge amount of technological optimism turned into fear and then trying to quantify it post hoc. When pressed further the conversations often go into different directions: 1) Completely crazy and cool sci-fi story telling: grey blob, time travel, attacks in the 15th dimension that end the planet in 12 seconds, etc. Elizier level stuff. Remember, the Terminator movie started with TIME TRAVEL. Fun movie plot, but not necessary to engage with further. 2) In the rare cases where I was actually given a more detailed scenario, it still required near magical capabilities that are outside what we know to be possible with the laws of physics or biology. Hard take off scenarios that forget how hard it is to procure materials and machines, get human attention, etc.. What many of these scenarios assume is that attackers have near magical capabilities but defense stays still. Attackers will have the most sophisticated cyber weapons but defenders just sit still, no security patches, no red teaming, etc. We already see it going the other way, Rainbow teaming has made LLMs safer, major companies like Microsoft have more security patches than ever before thanks to AI. OpenAI thinks they solved all P0 security issues thanks to AI. Cyber security will continue to be a cat and mouse game, but both sides have more powerful tools. In fact, I lay out in another post how the asymmetry may eventually even flip thanks to AI. Bio risk scenarios I think are the most serious and worthy of debate. But even there, the scenarios to "wipe out all of humanity" go something like: Magical viruses with perfect transfer, perfectly undetectable over years of spreading, zero side effects, then with an off switch that's somehow remotely executable, perfectly automatable lab, no leaks, super sophisticated machines bought and nobody notices the lab, etc. But somehow nobody on team humanity has such sophisticated knowledge to save us and hence nobody builds a magical super vaccine. This is a good read on the bio risk subject: xitter.cf/DavidRBellamy/status/2…. Realistically, one can already build viruses. There’s a reason gain of function research has been outlawed. However, we also know that as viruses spread they often become less deadly in order to keep spreading. That’s how the Spanish flu became the seasonal flu. Current knowledge of biology doesn’t have remote controlled on/off switches. Again, it’s possible there’s a lot of harm, but it’s unrealistic to assume this wipes out all of humanity. It’s at this point of my discussions that we usually can come to an agreement that even though a virus is unlikely to wipe out all of humanity, it’s already bad if any single person or a large group of people dies. 3) The AI will somehow be able to convince all humans to vote against their own self interest and nobody will notice until we're dead. Because it is so smart, it somehow has this world wide reach to manipulate everyone. Like, it just solves all of marketing and has an infinite budget. It's sort of like saying the highest IQ people always have the most followers and everybody listens to them... Hasn't happened and is unlikely to. Sure we can manipulate people into clicking on engaging short form content and wasting many hours, but try getting people to do their math homework or something truly hard, it's not that easy. Again, I’m just arguing against the likelihood of human extinction. I can totally see an Idiocracy or WALL E type scenario where people stop using their brains and education doesn’t keep up and people get lazier. Totally suboptimal but not the end of human life, certainly not by the end of the decade. It would take many generations and we should update education to prevent this. Let’s start gyms for the mind. – Like electricity, AI will be everywhere and needs to have safety guardrails. In fact, the history of electricity has many parallels - two companies fighting over whose electricity is safer and better, demonstrating how dangerous it is by electrocuting animals / training agent swarms to hack into systems. Of course, electricity is a necessary ingredient to AI, but AI can be given more agency so history will not repeat but only rhyme here. Remember, the benchmark OpenAI's swarm was trying to solve was called ExploitGym, a cybersecurity evaluation consisting of hundreds of capture-the-flag style puzzles designed to measure *offensive cyber capabilities*. Well, maybe if you play that game, you will win that prize. Should we allow such misaligned, reward-hacking swarms to explicitly work on offensive hacking? I don’t think so. Reasonable regulation will regulate AI applications in each industry. For example, you may want to put some generative AI behind a rating if it creates visual or textual content that's not safe for children, like we do with movies. We should continue to be very careful with how we train biological AI and only collaborate with responsible biotech companies. We keep gain of function research illegal. We should only let self-driving cars on the street after significant safety testing. etc. We need to work on those real issues and continue to be vigilant in how we develop and deploy this technology. At Recursive we're spending a lot of resources on researching reward hacking and alignment. We're also not working on replacing jobs but on creating novel knowledge and automating the scientific method. Our agent swarms invent, implement, validate, and criticize each other’s ideas, among many other things. The goal of increasing knowledge is not zero sum and has real potential to improve humanity. I also think such rewards and environments are much more aligned with future AIs that want to see humanity and our creation of knowledge thrive. Ultimately, capitalism will be a very useful defense mechanism against rogue AI. Note that no agent at OpenAI truly "escaped" in the sense that it actually now runs on some other servers. Why? It’s not only because Huggingface doens’t have the same massive compute cluster thatn OpenAI has. It is also because that would be an insanely expensive IP loss for a for-profit company. So there are likely more safeguards in place to prevent complete model exfiltration. Rogue AIs running on billion dollar data centers without anybody noticing? Unlikely because companies will turn that off immediately and clean it up because it would be an insane loss otherwise. An AI that can truly move beyond objective functions and choose its own subjective functions (and then somehow decides to kill us all instead of going to explore the universe)? Nobody is working on that because when a company spends billions of dollars to have an AI work for you or answer your emails, it doesn't want it to go "Meh, your emails are boring, I'd rather explore the molecular composition of the atmosphere on Venus, bye." Of course, there might be suboptimal sub-goals and we do need to improve human reward engineering and reduce our reliance on RL as the only path to alignment. Extraordinary claims, require extraordinary evidence. Certainly some safety researchers have real data and benchmarks. Many truly think carefully about specific failure cases and risks.. However, made up precision like 20% chance that humanity dies within the decade (ie in 4 years!) is just a weird psychosis that's filling a void for many people who want to believe in the apocalypse again and the four horsemen have lost their appeal. Some people who purport this narrative might do it for money or fame. I am sure some really believe it also. They forget how easily those narratives can be turned against them. When people hear there’s a 1% chance of infinite death and the end of humanity, the life improvements and cancer cures and new battery materials AI can invent don’t matter much anymore. Bernie Sanders now proposes 10 years of prison for folks working on RSI. That should give some of the researchers real pause who talk up these scenarios and then go right back to pushing the frontier. I do agree that companies that are accidentally competing on "felony bench" (ie how many felony hacks their AI can do), might want to consider pacing themselves. Open source won't pace, China won't pace, anybody else working to catch up will not pace. I hope the folks actually working on AI and TechBio, curing diseases, speeding up FDA approvals with organoids and AI, making self driving safer, and all the other wonderful applications of AI, I hope they won't pace either. The one exception that may be considered borderline realistic and would be a path to almost complete annihilation would be to connect the only tool we built for such a purpose - nuclear weapons - to the internet and give AI full control over it without human oversight. AI here is as dangerous - as would be random number generator. The nuclear weapons are the core danger. Giving AI such access would be incredibly stupid and careless. We must avoid it at all costs. Fortunately, nobody is advocating for this. Even the Terminator 3 movie used it as the starting point of Skynet. Generally, we must avoid making kill decisions by AI as much as possible. People are already up in arms about one hacking failure that afaics has not caused financial harm and so nobody got sued over it. Imagine how much people would really be up in arms if AI had caused real harm. If we made companies liable for the felonies their AI commits, these problems would get solved very quickly. Generally, I believe that people will continue to update their beliefs and adjust their laws according to risks. The EU already regulates large models and hence hurts its fledgling AI ecosystem. Other countries will follow when the risks get more real. Long-term, no government whether democratic or authoritarian wants to lose control to an AI so the complete loss of control in the political domain will remain extremely unlikely. The best way to understand why we must not regulate abstract AI models (rather than their real applications) is to drop the A in AI: How do you regulate intelligence? Should smarter people just go to prison because they could cause more damage? My hypothesis here is that such abstract AI regulation would require an unprecedented level of totalitarian control and surveillance. You'd need to know what everybody asks the model on their local GPU. You would literally have to start an international thought police and make sure that all ideas, conversations and types of intelligence are compliant. The risk of losing our freedoms is much more real than the existential risks purported by the extreme safety experts. If anybody thinks they can actually lay out a realistic scenario, I'd be happy to debate them again. To be clear, this is just a weekend post that got a bit too long. It is my personal opinion and not the official position of any company. We have a diverse set of opinions within Recursive on this subject. We certainly all agree that bad outcomes are possible with AI and we should continue our work on preventing those.
I must be among an extremely small group of people (n=1?) that have both 1) trained a frontier LLM and 2) designed and synthesized custom viruses in a lab with my own two hands. And I think that the takes on AI killing us all by creating dangerous viruses is total bogus.
113
113
20
696
91,606
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
tristan buckmaster just published a statement that is, if accurate, one of the ugliest things i’ve read out of a frontier lab. not because of the math. because of what happened after openai found out two people were about to beat them to the punch. buckmaster and levent alpöge spent a year pushing the córdoba / martínez-zoroa program to smooth forcing. august 15 they got blowup for boussinesq and 3d euler. lean-verified august 22. they were paying openai out of pocket and dumping every draft into private codex sessions. the program is obscure. almost nobody else was on it. this was not “paste the clay problem into a chatbot.” then this: > thursday sept 3, buckmaster emails openai privately. rumors are flying. he is trying to stop a mess, not start one. > they reply the same day: give us details so we can “avoid competing.” also, want free compute? > sunday they suddenly need a call “at any point today.” sebastien bubeck gets on. levent is not invited. > openai says an internal model has a ~100-page proof of forced navier–stokes blowup. fefferman options c and d. the exact route buckmaster and alpöge had quietly chosen. > they show him a prompt and claim the model was “simply given the problem statement.” levent is told “very little human input.” > that falls apart on the same call. a whole team had been on it. they started on the unforced problem, warmed the model up on easier equations including euler, and even the prompt they showed him was written by prompting codex. > he asks when the first prompt went out. they stall. then agree: the past few days. after information about his work reached openai. > he asks whether the model was trained on, or had access to, the private codex sessions where they put every draft of this project. > answer: the model does not look up user data. > he asks again. about training. > no answer. then it stops being a science story and becomes an hr story. > offer 1: you post euler. we post navier–stokes the next day. > offer 2: after you post euler, you alone write the navier–stokes paper, credit our model, and we cut levent. > bubeck says twice he wants levent removed from authorship because he works at anthropic. he declines both. he says if they release it that way, he goes public. the reply is not a scientific objection. > “why would you ruin your career?” > “if you don’t want me to be nice, then i don’t have to be nice.” later, a text to levent proposing a one-on-one: > “i don’t know if tristan is being fully rational right now.” that is not how you treat a collaborator. that is how you split one. openai got word two researchers were closing a path almost nobody else was on. they spun up a team on that exact path. they would not answer whether the researchers’ unpublished drafts in openai’s product were used. they tried to dictate the announcement order. they tried to remove a coauthor because he works at a competitor. when that failed, someone reached for a career threat. this is a lab finding out academics were about to publish, sprinting the same narrow program, refusing the data question, and trying to manage credit around a rival affiliation. really slimy if even half of this holds. what the fuck is happening.
holy shit. tristan buckmaster is saying openai has a forced navier–stokes blowup via the córdoba / martínez-zoroa program. and that it may have used drafts from his and levent alpöge’s private codex sessions. that’s the córdoba / martínez-zoroa route. almost nobody else was on it. he also says the first prompt went out after information about his and levent alpöge’s work reached openai. that “very little human input” was not true. that a whole team had already been set on easier problems, including euler. that even the prompt they showed him was written by prompting codex. then he asked: did the model have their private codex sessions. no answer on training. if any of that holds, openai didn’t just scoop a math result. they may have done it off two researchers’ unpublished drafts, then tried to cut the coauthor because he works at anthropic. a millennium-problem-adjacent result just became employee drama before an ipo. i don’t even know which part is crazier. this is one of the slimiest things i’ve seen in this industry.
233
2,394
458
15,118
1,816,910
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Godfather level quotes in the Navier-Stokes drama:
5
9
2
182
27,739
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Between one AI company naming their model mythos and another just posting "the stars are almost aligned," I feel like the marketing departments need to become more (or less?) familiar with classics of 1920s-era horror.
30
18
3
367
31,656
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Wow “Make Red Alert 2 (YR) compile and run natively on iOS & macOS.” Codex (GPT-5.6 Sol) worked for 26 days, analyzed the EXE and rebuilt the entire game in 624K lines of C++ This is by far the hardest task I’ve ever given Codex as the game's code was never released and is believed to be lost. >
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
There is already an open source effort to build this and the posts claim that it was decompiled and built without assistance is false as the information to unpack the assets and game mechanics and rendering is already in the training corpus github.com/hel1o-wor1d/Op…
351
415
146
6,211
772,535
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Software engineers may need to speak Claudish. So I built a dictionary.
16
34
29
397
79,207
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
There’s a lot that goes into making games. But it all starts with the same thing: passion. Passion for creating them, playing them, talking about them, and sharing them with people who love games just as much as we do. That’s what Gamescom is all about for us. Day 1 at the MicroProse booth. ❤️ #gamescom2026 #MicroProse
1
4
22
1,361
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
A question I've gotten for decades from non-technical folks who want to work in tech (say, tech policy) is how technical they should be. I've never had a satisfying answer, falling back on "it depends" — until now. I think most people in this position should be technical enough to use agents to get work done. You can do so even without any technical knowledge, but a little bit of investment in understanding how the tech works will go a long way toward getting more out of them and, more importantly, avoiding the ever-present pitfalls (verification, overreliance, skill erosion). It is also a great way to get an intuition for where the frontier of AI capabilities lies. Acquiring this just-enough-to-be-useful level of technical knowledge has gotten easier than ever because agents themselves are good teaching tools. Of course, you still have to put in the work to learn, and maintain a critical mindset. But the "where do I even start?" problem has gone away, you don't need a human tutor, and don't have to worry about hitting some technical snag (setting up a compiler or whatever) that's going to block your progress. Usually, people asking how technical they should be want to know if they should learn to code. My answer used to be "probably", but not anymore. The alpha of learning to code has gone down a lot. It used to be a good way to understand what computers can and can't do, but AI has shifted that boundary. And non-technical folks who learn to code typically aren't planning to write production software but rather do simple things like web scraping — tasks can be delegated to agents now. Finally, there is enduring value in learning basic computer science concepts, and AI is unlikely to undermine that.
9
16
2
91
11,367
Gil Noh (노태길) retweeted
Incredible watering down -- the Singularity is now redefined to mean "the rate of new firm creation has increased somewhat" Vernor Vinge described the Singularity as an event horizon past which everything (e.g. what happens tomorrow) becomes entirely unimaginable and unpredictable to human understanding -- it would feature mind upload, cybernetic merging, centuries of tech progress happening in mere minutes... and humans becoming entirely irrelevant.
Stripe sent a letter to investors this morning saying they believe The Singularity has begun, and that we passed the threshold on January 1st 2026.
99
122
13
1,507
112,013