I see there is already a move towards anger on the #NUFC transfer front over a left back no one had heard of before Craig Hope mentioned him. People acting like we don’t move quick enough when the issues have been wages and players desire to come. Remember Woltrmade…
542
Stuart Mulheron retweeted
Replying to @smulhero
Agree. It’s the length of time these things have been an issue, going back years with some highlights in the middle. That concerns me. A lot of them are results of very deliberate decisions, for eg building a squad largely of very similar player profiles.
My favourite #NUFC is the ‘get him gone’ about Howe and when the question comes on who comes in…the reply is ‘that’s not my job’…it’s not your job to get rid of him either but you still have an opinion on it 🤣. Make that make sense
1
205
You can pick faults but we still had so many openings second half. Much better as frustrating as it is #nufc
117
I used to love the Bobby Robson approach when behind. Put the extra forward on Eddie…go direct. Wissa alongside Woltemade would have been the play
165
We’ve made lots of changes but no one seems to know what they are meant to be doing? Always nervous when bits of paper go on the pitch #NUFC
401
Stuart Mulheron retweeted
#PSR #FFP #SCC all exist because a select few clubs who had good timing with their success didn't like @ChelseaFC and @ManCity using private investment to rain on their parade. The @premierleague get a load of stick for it, but they're restricted due to #UEFA rules
Some people will dismiss the Isak statement and some will feel it’s a good thing. Either way, we all need to move forward and focus on a strong squad and a united club. It’s gone, can’t change it. Some players will still be his friend, doesn’t mean they are disloyal to #NUFC.
3
243
Stuart Mulheron retweeted
PSR Is Strangling Supporters Dreams - It's Time for Change
@RorySmith defense of PSR in @ObserverUK perfectly encapsulates everything wrong with the current regulatory mindset. His argument - that ambitious clubs should simply "sell better" - reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of how these rules operate in practice and whom they truly benefit.
Rory dismisses Villa and Newcastle's concerns by pointing to our spending since promotion.
This misses the point entirely. The issue isn't historical spending - it's the regulatory ceiling that prevents sustained competition with the established elite.
Rory suggests Newcastle and Villa's problems stem from poor selling. This ignores the brutal reality: when regulations force you to sell your best players to comply, you're not "trading well" - you're dismantling what you've built.
#AVFC qualified for the Champions League then had to sell Luiz, Diaby, and Duran.
Newcastle qualified for Europe, then faced identical pressures. This isn't poor trading - it's systematic dismantling disguised as financial responsibility.
Meanwhile, Chelsea spend €300+ million by "selling" assets to themselves. The regulations don't prevent spending - they favor those sophisticated enough to exploit loopholes while punishing straightforward investment.
Rory’s dismissal of the "Red Cartel" theory ignores reality. When Villa qualified for Europe, UEFA’s SCR rules immediately kicked in, limiting us to 70% of revenue on squad costs while non-European clubs face no such restrictions.
The system literally punishes success.
UEFA's own settlement with Villa proves the point: €20 million in potential fines, transfer restrictions that require selling before buying, and 3 years of financial monitoring. For what? Investing to compete.
The regulations aren't revenue-neutral. They're rigged toward clubs with established commercial advantages.
Chelsea's London location generates €546m annually versus Villa's €310m. That €236m difference creates massive PSR headroom before considering player sales.
When regulations tie spending to revenue, they entrench existing hierarchies. Villa can't outspend #MCFC because we can't out-earn them - and the rules ensure we never will.
Rory argues regulations protect competition, but they've achieved the opposite. Look at the Premier League’s top six the last decade. The same clubs, in marginally different orders, year after year.
#LCFC 2016 title proved competition was possible. Current regulations ensure it never happens again. That's not protecting sport - it's preserving sporting cartels!
Rory’s F1 comparison - F1 introduced cost caps to improve competition, but crucially, they applied equally to all teams. Premier League PSR creates different rules for different clubs based on revenue and European qualification.
Imagine F1 saying Mercedes could spend €200m because of their commercial success, while Williams were limited to €50m. That's exactly how football operates now.
Nobody advocates unlimited spending. But current rules need fundamental reform:
•Revenue-based limits that account for owner investment
•Equal treatment regardless of historical commercial advantages
•Regulations that encourage competition, not entrench monopolies
•Transparent enforcement that doesn't favor accounting creativity over sporting investment
Villa & #NUFC aren't demanding to "replace the elite" - we're demanding the right to compete with them. The current system ensures that remains impossible.
His article concludes that "sport decided by chequebook is not sport at all." He's absolutely right. But sport decided by spreadsheets and accounting loopholes isn't sport either - it's a rigged game masquerading as competition.
The @premierleague failure to explain these regulations isn't accidental btw. When your rules prevent the very competition they claim to protect, silence becomes the only defensible strategy
@Alex_Berwick @danbardell @theavfcfaithful @LoveMcGrathpod
PSR is not perfect, but the alternative would be ruinous
“The debate over regulation is a battle of stories. The version that is winning is not the right one.”
✍️ @RorySmith
bit.ly/4lzykyH
Stuart Mulheron retweeted
I'm still clinging on to the premise that PSR was a response to finances spiralling out of control rather than keep a "red cartel" status quo.
But there's no doubt that Newcastle and Villa currently, Leeds and Sunderland in the future ( two huge clubs) are disproportionately affected. And all 4 of those clubs could add as much at the very top of English and European football as City, Spurs and Chelsea because all are as big.
Replying to @StanCollymore
The Premier League and UEFA have done their best to squeeze any ambition out of any club looking to disrupt their Big 6.
It's a closed shop.
Stuart Mulheron retweeted
Well it does have something to do with PSR because at one time it didn't exist so some clubs could spend whatever they liked, build a huge club in order to have lots of wiggle room.
And go back in time and most clubs wages to turnover were ridiculously high. PSR affected clubs have to "bribe" quality players with higher wages. 🤷🏽♂️
unavailable
RT @StanCollymore: A lot to unpack.
Firstly, he's under contract, one he willingly signed.
Secondly, and I've experienced this as have a…
This quoted post is unavailable.
Stuart Mulheron retweeted
However the Alexander Isak saga eventually concludes, let’s hope that at some point the player has the good grace to acknowledge the debt he owes Eddie Howe for helping his development into one of the best players in the world and also apologises for causing such chaos.
It’s one thing a player wanting to leave – ambition, short career, levels, finance whatever – but it’s the aggressive way that Isak tries to force his way out - midway through a six-year contract - that also causes such anger on Tyneside. In the middle of this maelstrom, Howe shows commendable calm and patience.
Newcastle’s head coach is being strong, demanding standards of behaviour, yet diplomatically leaving the dressing-room door open in case Liverpool don’t make an acceptable offer (£130m+) and Isak does stay.
Howe deserves huge respect for the dignified, intelligent way he’s handling a damaging distraction. He's trying to prepare his team for what should be an exciting season not knowing who will form his attack, and currently fielding a wide player in Anthony Gordon centrally. He’s dealing with a troublesome transfer window without a sporting director or chief executive.
He’s going into press conferences knowing they will be dominated by questions about a striking striker. In the modern media, and social media, age, Howe has to choose every word carefully, knowing they will be scrutinised forensically and emotionally. He has to pick the right words to send the right message to Isak, to the other players, to potential signings, and to the Newcastle faithful outraged by Isak’s behaviour. Newcastle’s board are fortunate they have such an impressive figure fronting up for them and the club.
Howe also deserves more respect and gratitude from Isak. Since joining in 2022, Isak’s improvement from a very good £63m 22-year-old into an elite performer worth £130m+ is obviously largely down to his own ability and inner drive but Howe deserves huge credit. He makes good players even better.
His coaching, man-management and building a system to bring the best out of Isak helped turn the Swede into a player coveted by Liverpool. Let’s hope Isak respects that one day. #NUFC











