
Member of the Parliament of Guyana, 🇬🇾 @ParliamentGY; Former Deputy Mayor of Georgetown; Graduate of the University of Guyana;🎙Host, In The Ring.
Guyana
Joined October 2009
- Tweets30.4K
- Following4.7K
- Followers4.7K
- Likes12.9K
Smart Patrol Rollout Demands Answers on Citizens’ Data and Surveillance Safeguards
The Guyana government's announced rollout of Smart Patrol again raises obvious questions about its expanding use of surveillance technology: whose facial data will police search, where will that data come from, under what legal authority, and with what safeguards against mistakes and abuse? The Minister’s announcement identifies SRIS as the source for number-plate checks but does not identify the reference database for facial recognition or explain how a facial match will be independently verified before police action. These are fundamental questions about the exercise of state power and the protection of citizens.
We anticipated these concerns. For almost a year, I have pursued related inquiries through the National Assembly, beginning with questions in November 2025 concerning electronic identification and police drone surveillance. In May 2026, I submitted a motion proposing an independent Surveillance Commissioner. My October questions went further, requesting the facial databases being searched, their custodians, the authority permitting their use, accuracy-testing results, incorrect-match rates and requirements for human corroboration. I also asked which provisions of the Data Protection Act 2023 were being applied and which commencement instruments and Ministry protocols supported that application.
Yet correspondence dated 5 November, confirms that the Speaker disallowed the facial-recognition safeguards section under Standing Order 20(1)(h), citing national security. Substantial questions concerning data custody, access, storage and retention were also disallowed. This prevents those questions from securing ministerial answers through that parliamentary process, even as the Government announces expanded surveillance capabilities. Protecting genuinely sensitive operational information should be compatible with meaningful scrutiny of legal authority, accuracy, independent oversight and remedies for citizens wrongly identified.
Separately, I have objected to the withdrawal of published Notice Papers 33–35 and 38–44 under Standing Order 20(1)(k), citing reliance on media statements. Those references were supplied during revisions responding to the Clerk’s Office and retained through subsequent review. The Notice Papers recorded publication on 13 January 2026 and were circulated on 21 January, only to be withdrawn in November. That reversal requires a clear explanation of what changed and why any objection to introductory wording could not have been addressed while preserving the substantive questions. Although distinct from the surveillance ruling, it compounds the obstacles to ministerial accountability.
I cannot overemphasize the seriousness of this situation. Expanding surveillance without publicly demonstrated, enforceable restrictions on the use of citizens’ data creates a grave risk of that information being weaponized against critics and the parliamentary opposition. In my assessment, the Government’s already aggressive posture towards dissent makes independent oversight especially urgent. I call on the Minister to disclose the governing authority and safeguards, and on the parliamentary authorities to explain these decisions and facilitate substantive scrutiny. Disallowing questions does not answer them. Technological capability must never become a licence for unchecked state power.
Sherod Duncan, M.P.
60
Why is this government so quick to hand out unlimited lifetime perks to former presidents, but treats giving public servants a living wage like pulling teeth? APNU’s latest statement on a public servant salary increase hits the nail on the head: the Ali administration has shown its true anti-working-class colours, enriching family, friends, and political favourites while deliberately trying to destroy the trade union movement. Look at how they illegally withhold union dues from the Guyana Teachers Union while inflation swallowed educators' paychecks. While billions are siphoned off through unbundled contracts and single-sourced fuel deals, the public servants who keep our schools, clinics, and ministries running are left living paycheck to paycheck. A government that respects neither collective bargaining nor basic economic dignity is a regime of oligarchs. We demand fair wages, union respect, and an end to executive greed
32
Since when does a foreign oil boss have the right to treat Guyana’s multi-billion-dollar resources like his own private family secret? On Wednesday, ExxonMobil CEO Darren Woods brazenly admitted the company prefers not to share its exploration and project development plans for the Stabroek Block with the public. Imagine the sheer arrogance: Guyanese own the eleven billion barrels of oil beneath our seabed, yet Exxon’s billionaire executives decide what crumbs of information we are allowed to hear. Even worse is the spineless complicity of this administration, acting like obedient corporate messengers rather than sovereign leaders. Guyana is an independent republic, not an Exxon plantation. The government must immediately compel Exxon to lay its complete, long-term development roadmap before Parliament for full public scrutiny.
132
How low will this desperate administration sink when it begins inventing murder charges in open court just to keep a political rival in chains? Recently, state prosecutors tried to bully the court into revoking Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed’s bail by absurdly claiming he is "likely to be charged with murder." For the second straight day, Chief Magistrate Judy Latchman threw their vindictive application straight into the trash, ruling that phantom charges and unproven allegations are not grounds to revoke bail. This humiliating judicial defeat strips the regime naked. When an executive uses state prosecutors to threaten capital offenses without an ounce of evidence, constitutional law has become political warfare. The courts have drawn the line; now the Guyanese people must reject this grotesque abuse of state power.
26
What kind of oil state forces an entire town to take to the streets just to get drinking water from their taps? On Monday, furious residents of Linden shut down roads in mass protest over blackouts that knocked out water pumps, leaving families without a drop of water for days. Only after citizens revolted did the government scurry on Tuesday to rush a backup generator to the town. Think about the utter contempt this administration has for Region Ten. They boast about billions in daily oil revenues and lavish receptions in Georgetown, while Lindeners are plunged into darkness and forced to beg for water. True development is not reactive PR after a protest. The people of Linden deserve a reliable power grid, not belated emergency band-aids.
23
How can a nation pulling in eight billion dollars a day in oil revenue allow its people to suffer under crushing grocery bills? On Wednesday, the Georgetown Chamber of Commerce rejected calls for supermarket price controls, warning that caps will cause severe food shortages. The Chamber pointed to the real culprit: a chronic foreign currency crisis that forces importers to wait weeks for wire transfers, alongside sky-high freight and punishing import taxes. The government’s economic incompetence is choking our supply chain. Instead of addressing the dollar shortage or slashing duties on basic food, this administration hoards billions while families struggle to buy groceries. We demand immediate duty-free relief on essential foods and real solutions to the banking foreign exchange crisis.
34
When a government official drawing a taxpayer salary insults a judge and defies a court order, constitutional law has been replaced by executive arrogance. In a shocking letter, Commissioner of Information Charles Ramson refused to comply with a High Court order to process oil records, dismissively calling Justice Nicola Pierre a "puisne judge" and telling citizens to wait for judges of "superior vintage." For over a year, citizens have demanded environmental permits and waste records for the Wales Gas-to-Energy project, only to be stone-walled by an official who thinks he is above the law. When a presidential appointee disobeys the courts to keep the public in the dark, democracy is in peril. President Ali must remove this rogue commissioner immediately.
42
On day one of the MV Barima inquiry, the government’s fatal negligence was laid bare. On Wednesday, aviation officials testified that when the ferry began sinking off the Essequibo Coast, its emergency distress beacon was not even registered with search and rescue databases, leaving authorities clueless about which ship was in distress. Even worse, control tower staff admitted they had to rely on casual WhatsApp messages to contact the Coast Guard, with zero coordinated rescue protocol. How does an oil-rich government send nearly two hundred citizens to sea aboard an aged state ferry with an unregistered beacon and WhatsApp emergency coordination? This was not an accident; it was institutional manslaughter. The ministers responsible for maritime transport must be summoned to answer for this fatal dereliction of duty.
1
67
Today, the Commission of Inquiry into the MV Barima disaster begins its public hearings, but the government’s attempt to shield its ministers is already on full display. As hearings open at the Arthur Chung Conference Centre, the Commission’s secretary repeatedly refused to confirm whether Public Works Minister Juan Edghill and Public Utilities Minister Deodat Indar will be summoned to testify. Even worse, the Commission has still not committed to holding hearings in Region One, where the victims’ families actually live. How can an inquiry deliver justice when it shields the political masters who sent an uninspected, aged ferry to sea, while leaving low-level crew to face murder charges? The ministers must testify, and hearings must go to Mabaruma and Port Kaituma.#floattheboat #bringuptheevidence
131
For the second time during my visit to Mahdia, I find myself returning to the site of the Mahdia Secondary School dormitory fire, the place where, in May 2023, nineteen girls and the five-year-old son of the dorm mother perished in a horrific blaze.
If you were a stranger to Mahdia, you could stumble upon this nondescript site and never know what happened here. You would see the remains of a foundation and small flowers sprouting quietly from the earth, flowers whose name I once knew. Perhaps that is nature’s own way of saying: we remember.
But beyond that, there is little here to tell you that on this ground, on the night of May 21, 2023, twenty young lives were lost.
There are those who would wish us to forget.
They would wish us to forget because they know that what happened here is an indictment. It cannot simply be reduced to the actions of one person. It is also an indictment of actions taken, actions not taken, warnings ignored, responsibilities neglected and omissions that had devastating consequences.
Standing here, there is a surreal feeling that is difficult to put into words. To me, this is hallowed ground.
As strong as I have had to become emotionally, and as much as public life demands that you steel yourself in difficult moments, I did not have the courage to step onto the ground where the dormitory itself once stood. I could not bring myself to do it. There was a feeling that by venturing further I might somehow be trampling upon sacred space.
In this moment, I find myself most unworthy to venture any further.
And so, from where I stand, I offer a silent prayer for the nineteen girls and that little boy whose lives ended here. I offer the same prayer for those who perished aboard the MV Barima in July 2026.
There are those of us who remember because we cannot forget.
Guyanese novelist Fred D’Aguiar, in his beautiful novel The Longest Memory, wrote: “Memory is pain trying to resurrect itself.”
Perhaps that is what places like this demand of us, not simply that we mourn, but that we remember. Because remembrance carries with it an obligation: to seek truth, to demand accountability, and to ensure that the failures which contributed to tragedy are never permitted to repeat themselves.
We remember Mahdia.
We remember the MV Barima.
And we will not forget.
2
182
1/2
MP Sherod Duncan’s Statement on Judicial Independence and the CCJ
As a Guyanese parliamentarian, I am deeply concerned by the reports now emerging from within the Caribbean Court of Justice itself. Since the disputed 2020 elections, Guyanese, particularly those of us on the Opposition benches who expressed apprehension about decisions and developments surrounding the CCJ, were repeatedly told that our concerns were misplaced. We were assured that this was an institution securely insulated from political and external influence and that concerns about its independence were unfounded. Yet the present controversy, involving serious disagreement among judges of the Court over the removal of Justice Chile Eboe-Osuji from a panel, requires those assurances to be revisited with the seriousness they deserve. The reported correspondence raises questions about judicial independence, the authority exercised by the President of the Court, the composition of judicial panels and the institutional treatment of judicial disagreement.
Our apprehensions were never confined solely to judgments handed down by the Court. There were occasions when we questioned what appeared to be an unusual degree of engagement between senior CCJ officials and the Government of Guyana, and whether sufficient institutional distance was being maintained. Those concerns were dismissed. One particularly important example subsequently emerged when then Opposition Leader Aubrey Norton disclosed that CCJ President Justice Winston Anderson had personally engaged him on the question of the substantive appointments of Guyana’s Chancellor and Chief Justice. Norton said that after stating his position, he eventually discontinued the engagement because he did not believe it was in Guyana’s interest.
That disclosure troubled us then, and in light of what is now emerging from within the CCJ, it deserves renewed scrutiny. The appointment of Guyana’s Chancellor and Chief Justice is governed by Guyana’s constitutional arrangements and requires agreement between the President and the Leader of the Opposition. It was not litigation before the CCJ requiring the President of that Court to adjudicate between parties. Yet the President of our final appellate court apparently considered the matter sufficiently important to engage directly with one of the constitutional actors whose agreement was required. The legitimate question is therefore: what institutional interest did the CCJ have in the outcome of that process, what was the purpose and extent of that engagement, and where should the proper boundary lie between judicial advocacy for institutional reform and involvement in an unresolved constitutional process within a member state? Norton’s account of that engagement was publicly reported in November 2025.
I am not suggesting that such an engagement, standing alone, establishes improper influence. Courts and senior judges quite properly speak about the administration of justice and the need for properly constituted judiciaries. But independence is also about appearances, boundaries and public confidence. When the President of a final appellate court engages political actors concerning an unresolved constitutional appointment process, and that same court may subsequently be required to adjudicate politically or constitutionally sensitive disputes involving those actors, the public is entitled to ask where those boundaries begin and end.
1
186
2/2
The latest reports from within the CCJ make these questions significantly more consequential. If judges of the Court themselves are now expressing concern about the exercise of authority by the President of the Court, including allegations concerning the composition of panels and judicial independence, Caribbean citizens are entitled to understand precisely what occurred and what implications, if any, those concerns have for the administration of justice. This does not mean that every judgment of the CCJ should now be regarded as compromised. Nor should allegation be converted into proof. But neither can legitimate questions about judicial independence and institutional conduct continue to be dismissed simply because they are uncomfortable.
This becomes particularly important for Guyana in light of the Mohamed matter and other cases of profound political, constitutional and democratic significance that have come, or may come, before the CCJ. The Court recently ruled against Azruddin Mohamed and Nazar Mohamed in their challenge to extradition proceedings, permitting that process to continue. I am not asserting that there was undue influence over that judgment, and such a claim should not be made without evidence. But given what is now being reported from inside the Court itself, it is certainly not remiss for Guyanese to ask the CCJ to state specifically what its judges meant when they reportedly regarded actions of the Court’s President as inappropriate or damaging to the integrity of the institution.
Does the concern relate merely to internal administration? Does it involve the composition of judicial panels? Does it touch upon the freedom of judges to express independent or dissenting views? Or does it reveal something more serious about the exercise of influence within the institution? Those distinctions matter enormously. And where a judgment involving the Leader of the Opposition has only recently been delivered, Guyanese are entitled to an unequivocal assurance that none of the institutional concerns now being aired had any bearing whatsoever upon the composition of the panel, the deliberative process or the outcome of that case.
This is not about whether we agree or disagree with the Mohamed judgment. The issue is much larger. It is whether every person appearing before the CCJ, Government, Opposition, citizen or corporation, can be assured that his or her case will be determined exclusively according to law, by judges exercising completely independent judgment, free from inappropriate internal or external influence.
Ultimately, this goes to the foundation of public confidence in our regional judicial system. The CCJ occupies an extraordinarily important place in Guyana’s constitutional architecture. It is our final appellate court and may be called upon to determine questions touching elections, constitutional government, the exercise of executive authority and the integrity of our democracy.
We therefore have to ask the difficult question: if serious questions about the Court’s own internal independence and institutional boundaries remain unanswered, can Guyanese repose full confidence in any case coming before the CCJ, much more a case dealing with the rule of law and the future of our democracy?
That is why the Court should speak clearly. Confidence cannot simply be demanded, and legitimate scrutiny cannot be dismissed. It must be earned and preserved through transparency, demonstrable independence, appropriate institutional distance and processes that leave Guyanese and the wider Caribbean with no reasonable doubt about the integrity of the Court and its decisions.
#CCJ #CaribbeanCourtOfJustice #JudicialIndependence #RuleOfLaw #JudicialAccountability #JudicialIntegrity #PublicConfidence #ConstitutionalDemocracy #Democracy #GoodGovernance #Transparency #InstitutionalAccountability #Guyana #GuyanaPolitics #CaribbeanJustice #CaribbeanDemocracy #SherodDuncanMP
106
MV Barima Remains Missing as Initial Dive Produces No Result
GEORGETOWN, Guyana (Credible Sources), July 19, 2026 - The wreckage of the MV Barima had still not been located hours after the vessel capsized, while the first diver sent to a suspected site found that the ship was not there, maritime officials disclosed during a government press briefing.
A Maritime Administration Department official said the diver descended at a location where authorities believed the vessel might have sunk, but the search produced a negative result. Two additional divers were deployed with ExxonMobil vessels using equipment to survey the probable search area, with officials saying divers would descend once the wreckage was located.
The government maintained that the three available divers were adequate at that stage because search teams first needed to find the vessel. Regional and international partners had offered additional assistance, including divers, but officials said those offers would be accepted only if capabilities unavailable in Guyana were required.
141
MV Barima Captain Among Crew Testing Positive for Cannabis
GEORGETOWN, Guyana (Credible Sources), July 19, 2026 - The captain of the MV Barima tested positive for cannabis after surviving the vessel’s deadly capsizing, Public Works Minister Juan Edghill disclosed during a government press briefing. Edghill called the result “serious,” saying the government maintains zero tolerance for crew members using alcohol or drugs while at work.
The captain was among the surviving crew members taken into police custody at Anna Regina, officials said. The government’s opening statement initially reported that two rescued crew members had tested positive for cannabis during medical examinations, although officials did not provide full details about the tests, including when cannabis may have been consumed.
Authorities have launched an investigation into the captain’s and crew’s conduct before and during the voyage, along with the vessel’s loading and compliance with maritime-safety regulations. A positive cannabis test alone does not establish that the captain was impaired when the vessel capsized, and officials have not yet determined what caused the disaster.
78
Officials Unable to Verify MV Barima’s True Cargo Load
GEORGETOWN, Guyana (Credible Sources), July 19, 2026 - Government officials could not verify the MV Barima’s true cargo load following the vessel’s deadly capsizing, Public Works Minister Juan Edghill disclosed during a press briefing. Edghill said he ordered Transport and Harbours Department personnel to re-examine the entire cargo manifest after authorities discovered that dozens of rescued passengers were not listed on the official passenger record.
The review was still underway when the press conference began, leaving officials unable to confirm whether the cargo manifest accurately reflected what had been loaded aboard the vessel. Edghill said the government was no longer prepared to accept information at face value and was reviewing the records “through a fine comb.”
Authorities have not determined whether the vessel was improperly loaded or whether its cargo contributed to the capsizing. The government’s investigation will examine the loading of passengers and cargo, compliance with maritime-safety regulations, the vessel’s stability and the conduct of its captain and crew.
55






