Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu) header
Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu) profile picture

Msc Econ / Classical Liberal / 🏳️‍🌈 / 中 ENG

Joined January 2018
Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)Photo by Roy 🇺🇦 (@realRoyLiu)
My first Substack! Inspired by @GabeEcon, who recently wrote his first blog post, and @captgouda24, who has been doing it for a while now. My goal is to be much less academic, but hopefully it's interesting to read. open.substack.com/pub/roy132…
1
2
1
18
1,997
Very solid visualization of China's government revenue evolution
6
64
6
267
16,293
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
People don't just pretend that the emperor is fully clothed: they will punish dissenters even when they privately know the emperor is naked. Why? Because they want to signal that they are genuine believers, not merely fakers bowing to social pressure. Studies find that people who conform under social pressure will criticize norm-breakers in public, but not in private. This kind of false enforcement creates the illusion of widespread, sincere support for even deeply unpopular norms. The upshot is that it takes only a small number of true fanatics to intimidate an entire group into submission through these cascading effects. journals.uchicago.edu/doi/ab…
56
534
81
2,083
67,090
Top 10 European companies are not that far behind the Americans in terms of revenue, but the top 10s in terms of net profit and market cap are massively behind American companies.
If you are European, this table (which I adapt from @Afinetheorem) should make you pause for a second. These are the top 12 companies in the world by market cap yesterday. A few observations: 1) Ten are from the U.S., one from Taiwan, one from Saudi Arabia (the Saudis are just lucky, so let’s forget about them). 2) All of them younger than me (Microsoft, the oldest, is from 1975). 3) None of them are in the financial sector. All of them are in what is called (I think imprecisely) the “real economy”: computers, chips, AI, social media. 4) Not a single European firm. Are these market caps the reflection of something real? If I look back at the last 60 minutes of my life, I have used products from Apple (the computer I used to write this post), Microsoft (I wrote the first draft of this post in Word), NVIDIA (I proofread this post with Claude, which most likely runs on NVIDIA GPUs), Google (I used Chrome to open X), Amazon (I was listening to Amazon Music while I wrote this post), SpaceX (this is X!), TSMC (the chip in my computer), Broadcom (most likely the designer of at least one of the semiconductors I am using now), Meta Platforms (I just sent a WhatsApp message to @lugaricano about how tough the task ahead of Hernández de Cos is), Tesla (I own a Tesla), and Anthropic. What about Saudi Aramco? I have probably used some imported product that uses oil sold by Saudi Aramco, but that is harder for me to determine. What do I need to say to awaken Western Europeans from their slumber? The original post by Kevin: xitter.cf/Afinetheorem/status/21…
3
68
Another good one on the mismatch between what pensioners receive and what they’ve paid in across generations
1
26
1
120
3,810
Yesterday we announced that we asked President @vonderleyen to withdraw the @euinc_petition proposal. Here is me visiting her to discuss this a few weeks ago. For the record: we are not against against the EU Inc proposal. It's the opposite. We are its biggest supporters. But "business as usual" in Brussel broke several fundamentals. And the commission should get everyone back on the table. Europe doesn't have time for Business as usual anymore. If it would now go into the final step, we end up with a massive PR fiasco. Appreciate your reshares - here is the youtube video as well: youtube.com/watch?v=x1_4b_YK…
92
280
43
1,317
92,843
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
The two following things are true: - On average, a student costs more to a university than the domestic fees - Universities who have the choice tend to accept more domestic students every year By revealed preferences I would infer that MC<domestic fees
3
4
1
43
4,039
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
Retirees are becoming more affluent than ever in high-income countries, with pensions now accounting for one in every four euros the French, Spanish and Italian governments spend on all public goods and services. Why are states still giving them so much? ft.trib.al/6FMJAZb
41
303
41
994
74,112
Why did Spain fall behind Western Europe during the early stages of industrialization? Our new paper with Eduard Alvarez-Palau and @HennebergJordi in Explorations in Economic History argues that a big part of the answer lies in transport and geography👇 #EconHistory
9
104
5
350
18,406
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
the social contract meme in data
29
481
24
6,979
307,418
The most important article of 2026 is this piece by @jburnmurdoch, building overwhelming evidence on the unsustainability of the pension systems in many countries and the broken intergenerational contract. To me this is the single underlying problem explaining the inability of many countries (incluiding my two, UK and Spain) to invest and grow and the malaise in their youth. Every future oriented policy, education, innovation, investment in infrastructure, is being sacrificed to increase pensioners living standards. But the problem is political, and some countries have solved it. E.g. in Denmark the retirement age increases (years later) semi automatically with life expectancy. See the result in the last graph. giftarticle.ft.com/giftartic…
154
1,658
249
6,240
777,838
MARK NO! YOU CAN’T JUST SAY DEPENDING ON THE MARKET STRUCTURE! NORMAL PEOPLE DO NOT KNOW ABOUT COURNOT COMPETITION WITH MERGER EFFICIENCIES OR DYNAMIC OLIGOPOLY WITH ENDOGENOUS INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIES OF SCALE
Mark Carney on Quebecor-Telus deal: "Depending on the market structure, the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition with fewer players under certain circumstances."
44
260
11
4,365
91,086
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
New working paper from me (and my job market paper): when & where do local politicians decide to change zoning regulations? I find rezonings happen disproportionately on reelection years, especially by politicians in competitive districts, who act primarily to restrict density.
1
48
4
181
10,623
Remarkably bad and unscientific take. The Canadian govs own Competition Bureau released an empirical report that after the legal barriers to entry in telecom were lowered prices fell 35-40% in regions where disrupters achieved even just 5% market share
Mark Carney on Quebecor-Telus deal: "Depending on the market structure, the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition with fewer players under certain circumstances."
4
1
5
1,571
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
This is because the ONS has significantly revised down total labour hours by around 6%. It’s been something of an open secret for a while that the old LFS-based figures were overstating how many hours British people actually work, mainly by undercounting leave and other absences.
This is... remarkable. Basically, a key indicator of the UK economy has been wrong for the past two decades or so. I mean. WTF.
6
16
1
169
7,246
Increasing the number of firms in a market ≠ increasing competition ≠ increasing innovation ≠ increasing welfare (just an off-handed comment)
HE HAS AN OXFORD PHD ON THIS TOPIC, HES LIKELY THE MOST LITERATE PERSON ON THIS ISSUE.
3
106
Consumer preference of wanting to eat delicious stuffs guiltlessly is always there. Technology satisfies that preferences. Interpret the mental reluctance of killing as costs, the cultured meat technology lowered the costs and thus enabled the consumption of it.
This is the future. I stopped eating meat 30 years ago as soon as I learned the truth about factory farming. If we can figure out how to manufacture at scale, consumer preferences will change.
3
29
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
The other British productivity perspective I've found helpful. Relative to pre-GFC, the revisions keep Britain middle-of-the-pack for G7 ex-US on GDP per capita, but around the top for GDP per worker or hour worked. America, across every measure, is decisively ahead.
Here's the chart I'd been wanting to see on the British productivity fracas. The hours-worked series behind the shift went from saying British working hours fell the least in the rich world to, just about, the most. If we believe that, would love hypotheses on what's driving it
6
3
38
3,108
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
Labor economists, get your event study ready. Aguiar et al (JPE 2021) find that recreational gaming is a leisure luxury whose quality improvements explain 38-79% of young men’s decline in work hours. GTA 6 is a large, well-dated positive shock to the quality of leisure.
REPORT: About 1 in 5 salaried workers in the United States plan to take PTO to play GTA 6, with an average of 4 days requested off, according to USA Today. - 27% of Millennial workers plan on using PTO. - 32% of Gen Z workers plan on using PTO. - Four days is the average number of days that were requested off, according to the report. The game has reportedly generated over $1.5 billion in revenue with about 16 million preorders.
8
72
3
554
24,150
Roy 🇺🇦 retweeted
"You should pick the righg econometric tool for your research question." OLS:
5
103
15
1,089
30,481
I've seen so many AI-created UI that they've become a bit disgusting to me... In games, on websites, and even in mods. The worst part is how repetitive they are. It's like if everyone, not just those in maths/econ academia, were using that same ugly LaTeX Beamer PPT template.
1
2
34
Everything about LaTeX is just so ugly. Yeah, it's good for producing papers heavy on maths formulas and stuff, but it's just so ugly.
19