Writer, economist, & journalist. Editor, @TheIndiaForum. Earlier Editor, @epw_in. Before that with @the_hindu, @deccanherald

Hyderabad, India
Joined March 2007
Rammanohar Reddy retweeted
Living for 50 years at the same address. Voting in every election since the 1970s. Today, the Election Commission says he cannot be found. His name is Faiyaz Ahmed. He is 74, a retired professor of mechanical engineering at Jamia Millia Islamia, and he has lived in the same home for more than five decades. Under SIR, he is untraceable. His wife Anjum Ara, 62, lives in the same house. Under SIR, she has permanently shifted. They never moved. Election Commission moved them out of the voter list. This is Okhla, Delhi - Citizens groups went door to door in just two polling booths, covering 258 households over seven days. They found at least 100 voters wrongly marked absent, shifted, dead or duplicate. That was two booths. Across Okhla, nearly 1.6 lakh names appeared on the Commission's list of absent, shifted, dead & duplicate voters & more than 67,000 voters were put on the notice list. Okhla has seen the second highest rate of deletions. If two booths hide 100 wrongful cases, the question isn't whether there's a problem. It's how big the problem is. Look at who the Commission erased. 🔹Faiyaz Ahmed's son says he handed in completed enumeration forms for both his parents to the BLO. His own name made it to the draft roll. His parents' names did not. 🔹Naeemuddin, a former government adviser, has lived at the same address for 30 years. He went to his BLO himself. BLO took his photograph and got his signature on a form. He was still marked permanently shifted. He stood in front of the Commission's own officer and was recorded as gone. 🔹Ravi, 37, is alive. Under the voter ID card he was issued in 2023, he is listed as dead. His record now sits under a different EPIC number that no one ever told him about. 🔹Md. Farid Anwar's family was told by the BLO that his name had been deleted before the revision began. Yet his name appears on the SIR deletion list, with his form marked uncollectable. The two official explanations cannot both be true. And what is the remedy for these citizens? Form 6, the form for new voters. A man who has voted for half a century is told to apply as if he were voting for the first time. His record is wiped and his voting history is gone, and what was his right becomes an application. More than 110 people left that hearing holding Form 6. None of them should have needed it. Commission says it is holding weekend camps so that no eligible voter is left out. Around 20 voters who spoke to The Hindu had never heard of these camps. Some didn't even know who their BLO was. The clock is running. Form 6 applications close on October 30. The final roll will be published on December 4 Any voter who doesn't find out in time loses their vote without ever knowing it happened. In Karnataka, voters are being declared dead on forms they never filed. In Delhi, voters who stood before officials are being marked absent. Different states, same pattern: the Commission makes the mistake, and the citizen pays the price. Questions must be answered - 🔹Who verified Okhla's nearly 1.6 lakh deletion-list entries, and did anyone actually knock on those doors? 🔹How was a voter who personally appeared before the BLO, was photographed and signed a form, recorded as "permanently shifted"? 🔹Why are voters registered for decades being forced to re-enrol as new voters instead of having their original records restored? 🔹Why did not a single official attend a public hearing where more than 150 affected voters came forward? 🔹Will the October 30 deadline be extended, and will every person on the deletion list be personally informed? In 7 days, citizens & volunteers did what the Election Commission failed to do in months. They found the voters it lost. The vote belongs to the citizen, not the Commission. A name deleted wrongly is a citizen silenced. thehindu.com/news/cities/De…
At least 100 voters from two polling booths in Delhi’s Okhla constituency were found to have been wrongly classified as absent, shifted, dead or duplicate (ASDD) during the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, a public audit covering 258 households over seven days found. ✍️@suruchiarchives thehindu.com/news/cities/Del…
8
137
5
198
11,159
Boss 62 is just 26. And no it is not what the Galgotias said.
I am convinced 62 is just another number. I tested this doing an eight kilometres trek yesterday. And today I complete 62 years of my existence on earth. Time to move on from what I am doing and chart a different path
2
5
482
Rammanohar Reddy retweeted
Dreze simply illustrated the grotesque concentration of wealth and the staggering inequality between labour and capital. Neither becomes any less consequential because the billionaire happens to be Indian. When you cannot challenge the argument intellectually, you attack the scholar by resorting to insinuations about research funding, racial whataboutery and the familiar bogeyman of Western interference. The difference between economic scholarship and ideological servility could not have been clearer.
His work was funded by Ford Foundation and McArthur Foundation. How many million years would it take to those "100 workers" to match billionaires like Henry Ford and John McArthur? Or is this calculation meant only for the non-white billionaires? Saving Indian souls - backed by western business - is a very old game.....
2
145
34
555
27,026
How does this square with the nation-wide summary revision that has been announced? The 2 in parallel will be an admin nightmare. And it seems to me that it is the summary revision that should have been done in the first place. And will it replace the “tainted” SIR. @vrsrini ?
As the Election Commission launches a special drive in 20 states to bring back voters “left out” in the SIR, its officers are staring at a unique problem: persuading lakhs, possibly crores, of people to fill Form 6, the “Application Form for New Voters,” which asks them to declare they are applying “for the first time.” Form 6 is the right route back, and officials say signing it invites no legal action. But people who’ve voted for decades balk at calling themselves new, and many believe the declaration is false. Against that backdrop, Maharashtra’s CEO has proposed a fix: drop “New Voters” from the title, and let the deleted say they were enrolled before and cite their old EPIC number. Break by @vallabhozarkarr indianexpress.com/article/in… via @IndianExpress
2
321
Indeed. It is a rollback by now carrying out yet another exercise. A government under siege tries to do what it considers making amends. But this is exhausting and confusing voters. A shambolic exercise by @ECISVEEP . Report today by @sreeparna_c in @the_hindu
The announcement of the Special Summary Revision and the new provisions is a virtual rollback of the SIR by the @ECISVEEP
1
3
6
308
You can’t find a more biting cartoonist than @MANJULtoons these days. But someone is not looking sinister.
1
180
And if you do, you must give your address, email address & phone number. So take care if you don’t agree with their pre-determined conclusion: Popn. Changes are not due to fertility/mortality trends but due to “abnormal factors” like “illegal immigration”. @the_hindu @vijaita
1
4
7
351
More evidence, if needed, of what #SIR is really about. Detailed analysis today by @vrsrini and co author in today’s @the_hindu And no reply from the @ECISVEEP to this.
1
34
1
44
1,927
Fine piece today by @PalshikarSuhas linking the politics of re-democratisation today to the movements of the past and the agenda of the future. What is to be done. As someone else asked.
1
19
1
30
1,213
How India now dominates in global inequality. #ViksitBharat it sure is.
India replaces China The crucial role of India for global inequality reduction. Consider this graph that shows international inequality using GDP per capital (in PPP terms) for all countries, weights them by countries’ populations, and thus obtains a Gini that is the most important component in explaining the evolution of global inequality between individuals.
1
9
6
848
Look at the photos on page 1 of the global press today. The world is watching. Shame on the Indian state. Of course, the, er, "foreign hand" is putting them out. (Indian newspapers, those photos must be on your feed too)
2
7
392
Rammanohar Reddy retweeted
Al Jazeera speaks to the 25-year-old man who built an AI-powered app to help India’s detained protesters get home safely after police drop them off at the city’s outskirts. Here’s how it works.
98
1,835
53
6,447
195,904
Rammanohar Reddy retweeted
A heartfelt message by a parent, K Sharad Haksar to Neha Bora. “When I got married, I knew I wanted only one child. And in my heart, I hoped it would be a girl. I was blessed with a daughter. The first time I held her, I made her a silent promise. You will never have to share my time. You will never have to wait for my attention. Whatever I have, you will get all of it. I had seen families with four or five children. Parents running from morning to night, and still some child was always left waiting. I also felt our country has too many people, and nature is paying for it. One child felt right. It felt responsible. For years, I never questioned it. Then this year, I saw Neha Bora. She is 29, a PhD student at JNU, a theatre artist from Khatima, a small town in the hills of Uttarakhand. When the NEET paper leak happened, she sat down at Jantar Mantar for students she did not even know. Children who had studied for years. Parents who had spent their savings on coaching and still lost. She did not eat for 23 days. She was 66 kilos when she started. She lost more than 7. Near the end, doctors were taking her blood three or four times a day. The night I read that, I could not sleep. I kept seeing my own daughter in her place. On a hot Delhi road. Thin. Tired. A doctor holding her wrist again. And I knew I would not be able to stand there and watch. I would have begged her to stop. But Neha did not stop until the work was done. And when it was over, she said her body had forgotten how to eat. It had to learn again, like a baby. Even then, still weak, she went to Bihar to meet more than 600 students who had been arrested. She did not go home to rest. She went to the ones who had stood by her. I am a dowser. Every day I work with energy. I have learned that anger is heavy. It burns out fast. Nobody can live on anger for 23 days without food. Only love can carry you that far. Then I read that her father was in the Army, and the family kept moving from one posting to the next. My wife's father was also in the Army. I never call him my father-in-law. To me, he is simply Papa. My wife studied in 13 schools. Thirteen first days. Thirteen times walking into a class where nobody knew her name. Thirteen goodbyes to friends she never saw again. Army children learn to smile, pack their bags and start again. Nobody asks them how much it hurts. I see that strength in my wife every day. I saw it in Neha too. In Ranchi, a man threw ink on her face and called her anti-national. She said she had already faced pellets and lathis in Delhi. Ink would not scare her. Ink washes off. In energy work, we say that what people throw at you only stays if you take it in. She seems to know this without ever holding a pendulum. Her family did not agree with her. There were fights at home. But during the hunger strike, her mother came to Jantar Mantar. I don't know what they said to each other. I don't need to. I am a parent. I know what a mother feels when she sees her child weak and thin on a road, and still standing. Every argument is forgotten in that moment. All that is left is: this is my child. Neha said she has not spoken to her father yet. I don't know him. But I am a father too, and I know how hard it is for men like us to say some things out loud. So if he cannot say it yet, let me say it for him, from Chennai. Beta, we are proud of you. Now go and eat something properly. Somewhere in all this, a thought came to me that I never expected. I wish I had one more daughter. One like Neha. This takes nothing away from my own daughter. She is my world. She always will be. But Neha made me ask myself a hard question. We spend our whole lives keeping our children safe and helping them get ahead. Do we ever teach them to look back at who is being left behind? And if one day they stand up for someone else, will we stand next to them as Neha's mother did? Or will we ask them to come home and stay quiet. Our job is to protect that light, even when it scares us.
433
2,771
130
12,543
376,664
Ha, ha...foreign hand in stenographer's story. HMV. They never give up do they? I mean "the sources", trying everything possible to save a besieged government. They have an accomplice in good old godi media willing to lend "a hand" (weak pun).
India cannot afford complacency about attempts by external actors to manipulate its political debate, weaken confidence in institutions or exploit domestic grievances. Covert foreign sponsorship of political mobilisation would compromise that accountability by allowing undisclosed interests to influence public decisions without accepting responsibility for the consequences. Therefore, protecting the electoral mandate from external disturbances requires an effective capacity in the law enforcement agencies and counter intelligence agencies to identify and investigate organised interference. (✍️ 𝗦𝗵𝗶𝘀𝗵𝗶𝗿 𝗚𝘂𝗽𝘁𝗮) Catch the complete story : hindustantimes.com/india-new… 📲 For News on the go, Download HT app. Click hindustantimes.com/s/14lS24m
179
Rammanohar Reddy retweeted
Most Indians don't know this, but the Dreze family are literally academic royalty in Belgium. Jean's brother the late Xavier Dreze was a highly regarded Marketing professor at UCLA's Anderson School of Management. He was one of the very very few who could do both modeling and consumer behavior research. He died very young at age 48. His obituary says he was a true polymath with multiple academic and sporting talents. Jean's father the late Jacques Dreze was an economist at the Université Catholique de Louvain. He was a highly regarded economist and the first president of the European Economic Association. He has collaborated with nobel laureates Robert Aumann and Franco Modigliani and his publication record is comparable with the best in the field. Jean Dreze could have had a very cushy life with his family legacy, white skin and European passport. Even in India, he could have been a social butterfly flitting in and out of five star hotels and running think tanks funded hy veated interests. Instead, he took Indian citizenship, learnt Hindi and roughs it out in rural Jharkhand. He designed many schemes and his footprint is all over Indian economic policy. You may like him or hate him. But Jean Dreze is more Indian than anyone who was born Indian, including you and me. He chose to be Indian. And he has dedicated his life to India. Think of this the next time some illiterate journalist asks "Who is Jean Dreze?"
357
1,376
149
6,554
283,635
Rammanohar Reddy retweeted
This photo by Raju Shinde of @HTMumbai is heartbreaking, angering and iconic. I don’t know if on the next day, HT carried it as the lead image on Pg One but if I were there, this one was a no brainier. #photojournalism #CJPprotest #Mumbaiprotest #HindustanTimes
39
409
16
992
20,032