PeerXiv (@peerxiv) header
PeerXiv (@peerxiv) profile picture

A fresh view on peer review 🍐 A proof of concept demonstrating a modern take on peer review of preprints 🍐 Here to start a discussion on the reviewing process

Joined April 2022
Photo by PeerXiv (@peerxiv)Photo by PeerXiv (@peerxiv)Photo by PeerXiv (@peerxiv)Photo by PeerXiv (@peerxiv)Photo by PeerXiv (@peerxiv)
anon period in NLP venues is a bad idea that does a lot of harm and no good whatsoever. let's get rid of it. (if someone can demonstrate a good outcome, and I mean demonstrate, not just hand-wave about equality, I am open to hearing and being convinced otherwise).
12
39
10
230
193,576
Replying to @ylecun
Wasn't aware of this, very interesting read! The @peerxiv proposal/proof-of-concept we published a few months ago actually shares many similarities to the properties described in the pamphlet. Would have probably been more if we'd seen it before 🍐 xitter.cf/EladRichardson/status/…
What would a peer review process look like if it was designed today? 🤔 We strongly believe that peer review can be so much better for both authors and reviewers and we're super excited to share @peerxiv, our vision for a fresh view on peer review💡 peerxiv.web.app/about
1
3
8
1,233
Change my mind: Conferences should move to a year-round submission window with papers reviewed in the regular review cycle. That way papers are time stamped and the pressure (especially on our early researchers) of being “scooped” is ameliorated to a degree. – at Toronto, Ontario
18
10
3
130
"PeerXiv, a hero, Bringing change to peer review, Progress shining bright" - #ChatGPT We're back for some ChatGPT fun 🍐🍐🍐
1
1
4
"Why was the old reviewing process like a broken clock? Because it was slow and wrong twice a year!" - #ChatGPT
1
"I know, right?" the man said, grinning. "PeerXiv is going to change the world, I just know it." The woman laughed, charmed by his enthusiasm. "Well, I'm glad you're so excited about it," she said, smiling. "It's nice to see someone so passionate about something." - #ChatGPT
The community should focus more on positive ways to encourage reviewers instead of finding new ways to scare them away 😕
CVPR: We welcome new students! Students: Cool! I just submitted my very first paper! CVPR: You now also need to review papers. Students: Not sure how to do that. Here is my attempt. CVPR: Your reviews are too unprofessional. You are now banned for two years. Students: ...
4
4
“Peer review is not perfect but there are no better alternatives” xitter.cf/RexChapman/status/1538…
41
447
103
3,149
🍐📃
Replying to @EladRichardson
"A cute pear doing peer review, digital art" @peerxiv
3
The recent debates about the flaws of the publication system make me wonder whether there has been some progress in scientific practice during my (scientific) lifetime. I defended my PhD in 2012. Let's see what happened in 10 years. 1/n
Exactly ten years ago I defended my PhD thesis at the @InstitutCerveau.
2
28
5
95
PeerXiv -- not sure how to pronounce it, but it looks like another interesting take on peer-reviewing (peerxiv.web.app/about). I like the idea of not using an accept/reject score but rather using categories (Presentation, Novelty, Significance, Reproducibility, and Validation)
2
20
2
89
We're finally getting started, can't wait to hear what you all think!🍐
What would a peer review process look like if it was designed today? 🤔 We strongly believe that peer review can be so much better for both authors and reviewers and we're super excited to share @peerxiv, our vision for a fresh view on peer review💡 peerxiv.web.app/about
1
3
1
10