Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak) header
Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak) profile picture
West Bengal, India
Joined April 2016
Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)Photo by Niladry Sarkar (@nilspeak)
Replying to @nilspeak
From the attacks on ED officials to women’s mass allegations of atrocities by local TMC leaders, this interview of Professor Bhattacharya puts the recents developments in West Bengal’s Sandeshkhali into context. You know what happened but to know why it happened read this one.
2
1
849
This unfortunate trend is quite old but for the sake of record worth stating again. Since long @BJP4India and @INCIndia talks only to the journalists they find ‘friendly’ or ‘accommodative’ or both. Important regular interactions between the party and the media persons works on basis of these parties respective media department’s ‘assessment’ of journalists. It’s an elaborate exercise of ‘judging’ the media. Quite long lists are maintained in the media departments of Congress and BJP. The party leaders know well about the editors and reporters who are ‘friendly’ to their party and who aren’t ‘trustworthy’. Even dailies and tv channels ensure that their beat reporters of Congress and BJP are in ‘good books’ of the media department of the party they are covering. Haven’t found any Delhi editor who will dare keep someone who is perceived to be fiercely independent minded reporter on the most important beat of covering BJP and Congress. The media departments of the Indian political parties should be blamed for it. Say, if someone is perceived as pro-Modi or ideologically aligned to BJP he/ she will be never invited to Congress’s events. And, if someone is perceived to be softer to the Gandhis or professionally criticising @RSSorg activities there is no way he/she would be invited to any special events of BJP. This divide is sharp and deep. This division is based on an unprofessional approach of the media in-charge of respective parties. As a result the reporters get into a survival mode. They ‘adjust’ their image to get information and insights. The dangerous trend has resulted in disadvantage for talented journalists. Many senior journalists of 80s and 90s have fantastic experience of covering both parties for long but these days my young friends covering @INCIndia have no clue of what’s happening in @BJP4India and same is true for reporters covering BJP. Many reporters vision of national politics is skewed because they never get a big picture. The ideological differences between the parties have percolated down in media. I am not arguing that journalists have no biases and ideological positions. But, ‘intense insecurities’ of the media departments of Congress and BJP have impacted contemporary journalism so much that there are hardly any incisive political reports on the front pages. @Jairam_Ramesh @Pawankhera @SupriyaShrinate @anil_baluni @Ashish_HG @deepakmhaskey
31
37
12
158
108,133
Niladry Sarkar retweeted
A short banter, a long contrast. In a crowded nighttime setting, @RahulGandhi asks a group of young men for a “cool story bro.” They hit back with the classic Gen Z deflection: “Tell your mom.” He doesn’t pause, doesn’t look for a handler, doesn’t stiffen. He smiles and returns it with “You tell my mom.” That 11-second exchange quietly exposes several things at once. It requires enough everyday English to catch the line in real time. Not lecture-hall English. Street English. The kind that doesn’t need a teleprompter or a translator hovering nearby. Even if the words were later explained, it still needs context awareness — the ability to recognise that “tell your mom” here is not an insult or a request for a formal message, but an invitation to play. Many people in public life process everything through a single, rigid frame and miss the register entirely. Then comes the harder part: the security to stay in the moment. To smile, lean in, and enjoy the exchange instead of treating it as a trap or a slight. That level of comfort in an unscripted crowd is rare. It is the opposite of the rehearsed, tightly managed public appearances where every interaction is pre-cleared and any deviation is treated as risk. Even with all of that, producing a light, cheeky retort on the spot is a separate skill. Presence of mind under mild social pressure is not the same as reading from a prepared text. What follows is equally revealing. There is no later framing of the moment as an unacceptable dragging of one’s mother into public mockery. No wounded statement. No demand that family be kept outside the banter. The clip simply ends with the smile still there. And finally, the last contrast: even if someone did choose to treat a casual line about “mom” as an offence, they would still not convert that same mother into campaign capital. One side can absorb a joke about family and move on. The other has spent years turning family references into electoral currency while remaining visibly brittle about any unscripted mention of the same. None of these steps is automatic. Language, context, real-time confidence, wit, and the refusal to weaponise or over-protect family are all visible in the same brief interaction. The absence of any one of them would have broken the exchange. The absence of several of them is why certain styles of politics cannot even enter the frame.
15
131
7
847
96,914
Niladry Sarkar retweeted
Work hard in silence. Let success be your noise. 🏆
18,871
211,780
18,863
1,340,623
28,323,900
Niladry Sarkar retweeted
BJP IT Cell discovering Kohli fans
Best Batsman of India? Amit Anilchandra Shah. No helmet, no bat, still clean bowled the entire ecosystem.
28
395
19
6,238
116,069
As a journalist she thinks it’s okay for her to not come up with proper facts in the first place itself! Then she expects someone else to do that job for her🤷 No aunty we don’t troll you out of disrespect but because we think you are shit at your job as you have proven yourself
Calling people 'uncle' or 'aunty' just because they are older than you isn’t banter, wit or a mature argument. It is pejorative ageism. If you want to be taken seriously, challenge the argument with facts rather than rudeness. Neither respect nor arrogance is an age thing. Nor is intelligence.
1
60
THIS. All these oldies just need to be forced out now. Why do newsrooms still have uncs and aunties in their 60s and 70s?
we're literally scarping the bottom of the barrel. these old fucks all of them need to leave the public eye because it's insane how they make everything about themselves when it's not. please retire. embarassing to watch your takes.
2
89
The thing about liberals somehow failing to idolise Messi like Maradona has nothing to do with football. They loved Maradona for his politics. His footballing success meant that global left had found a truly global icon who is not directly into politics.
Replying to @ishaantharoor
That image of Maradona as an avenging angel, as a tribune of a wronged people, transcended borders. His fame grew in the southern-Italian city of Naples, where he turned up in the mid-eighties to play for the city’s local club, Napoli, which had not won anything in recent memory, and whose supporters chafed against the bigotry of northern Italians. “It had been more than half a century since this city, condemned to suffer the furies of Vesuvius and eternal defeat on the soccer field, had last won a championship, and thanks to Maradona the dark south finally managed to humiliate the white north that scorned it,” the late Uruguayan author Eduardo Galeano wrote. “In the stadiums of Italy and all Europe, Napoli kept on winning, cup after cup, and each goal constituted a desecration of the established order and a revenge against history.” Now Messi’s Argentina is the established order, the Goliath shoving the heads of all other challengers in the dirt. newyorker.com/preview/articl…
1
117
From asking Messi to "grow his balls" to absolutely lambasting Lionel Scaloni when he become the coach of Argentina men's football team. Why? Because these two people, according to Maradona's standards were not man enough.
1
30
If only Maradona was not a declared leftist, the same leftists and liberals would have cancelled him every day of their lives. He was no better than the likes of Andrew Tate really. His political correctness saved him.
28
Leftists are are actually writing things like “How can you support Argentina and claim to be pro-Palestine? Argentina has a history of racism and ethnic cleansing against indigenous and black communities?” Read the full article: theoddinaryoutlook.substack.…
31
The Trinamool Congress ceased to exist as a political party in 2011 itselt. They worked more as a venture capitalist firm. Anyone could go to Kalighat (eventually Camac Street) and pitch a business, mostly illegal and in informal sector.
1
37
However, after 2019, IPAC took over the election duty. As a result, in the last few years, the relationship between Kalighat/Camac Street and other TMC leaders has been only about profit.
1
20
So who gets more? Those who have rebelled believe they do. They are the owners after all. And pisi-bhaipo don't even have the state administration anymore.
12
When she says “ultra left” she knows what she is doing there. This madness needs to be stopped right now.
Kolkata, West Bengal: Former West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee says, “...In this situation where violence is taking place, I am appealing to all opposition political parties in West Bengal — you may accept or decline the appeal, that is your right. But if we have to stop the BJP, all parties should unite...” (Source: Mamata Banerjee Facebook)
24