Pinned Tweet
I'm setting up a economic history newsletter. If interested please subscribe to How the World Became Rich markkoyama.substack.com?utm_…
Mark Koyama retweeted
Thanks Brian - I feel your pain- I see you struggling with this for the same reasons I did when reading the MMT book by @StephanieKelton
I'm at the end of @IsabellaMWeber's book.
My lens while reading was "where do we actually disagree?"
I still can't figure it out.
Often, she describes how economists think but then attaches beliefs/values that aren't needed.
Take the carbon tax discussion as an example:
I think Brian spent way more time on this than I would have!
I'm at the end of @IsabellaMWeber's book.
My lens while reading was "where do we actually disagree?"
I still can't figure it out.
Often, she describes how economists think but then attaches beliefs/values that aren't needed.
Take the carbon tax discussion as an example:
1
29
1,690
Mark Koyama retweeted
In the current @EJ_RES, ‘Culture and Gender Differences in Honesty’ by Caroline Graf, Andreas Pondorfer, Jonathan F Schulz doi.org/10.1093/ej/ueaf137 @JF_Schulz @RoyalEconSoc #EconTwitter
This is a great primer on Schumpeter's great idea (ideal for students with applications to the music and rideshare industries).
This is cool stuff but what reason do you have for thinking he decline was gunpowder? (As opposed to the well-documented role of the Tudor state in repressing traditional aristocrats and promoting new men like Wosley and Cromwell)
Mark Koyama retweeted
Bu arada, 1513-1880 yılları arasında kadı sicillerindeki 266 bin Müslüman erkeği gözlem olarak kullanarak İstanbul’daki sosyal mobiliteyi ölçen çok ilginç bir yeni makale yayınlanmış.
Makale, temelde bir babanın toplumsal statüsünün oğlunun geleceğini ne ölçüde belirlediği sorusundan hareket ediyor. Bunu hem unvanlar üzerinden hem de (daha kısıtlı bir örnekleme dayanarak) servet üzerinden ölçüyorlar.
Makalenin birçok bulgusu var, fakat ben en önemli bulduğum 2 figürü aşağıya bırakıyorum. Aşağıdaki 2. fotoğrafta, baba ile oğul arasındaki toplumsal statü ilişkisinin dönemler boyunca nasıl değiştiğini görebilirsiniz. 1550-1650 arasında bu ilişki belirgin biçimde zayıflamış; yani kuşaklar arası sosyal mobilite artmış. Ama 1650-1800 arasında yeniden güçlenmiş. Bu da özellikle elitler arasındaki statü aktarımının daha kalıcı hale geldiğine ve toplumsal hiyerarşinin daha kapalı bir yapıya büründüğüne işaret ediyor. 1800 sonrasında ise eğilim yeniden tersine dönmüş: Baba ile oğul arasındaki statü bağı zayıflamış, dolayısıyla yönetici sınıflara erişim yeniden kolaylaşmış.
Yazarlar servet üzerinden yaptıkları analizde de benzer bir dönemsel örüntü buluyorlar. Bunu da aşağıdaki 3. fotoğrafta görebilirsiniz.
Kısacası, en azından İstanbul örneğinde, 1550-1650 dönemi sosyal mobilitenin belirgin biçimde arttığı; 1650-1800 dönemi bu hareketliliğin azaldığı; 1800 sonrasındaysa, muhtemelen 19. yüzyıl reformlarının da etkisiyle, sosyal mobilitenin yeniden yükseldiği bir dönem olarak öne çıkıyor.
Mark Koyama retweeted
New working paper!
Q: Was the rise of the factory “deskilling"?
TLDR: Technology has benefited skilled workers for the past 100 years, but contemporaries—from Smith, to Ricardo, to Marx—thought it reduced demand for skilled labor during industrialization. They were right.
Nice to see my colleague Mitch Harvey's piece on the Act of Union on MR!
Tuesday assorted links marginalrevolution.com/margi…
Mark Koyama retweeted
My new Introduction to Microeconomics course at Tulane University (Spring 2027).
Three goals: think like an economist, develop independent and critical thinking, and learn to use AI to deepen understanding, strengthen reasoning, and become more productive.
sebastiangaliani.com/wp-cont…
The Center of Human Progress looks to be an amazing project - a new kind of think tank aimed at better understanding economic progress - and I am very happy to be an affiliate.
Replying to @CFHumanProgress
Mark Koyama (@markkoyama)
Professor of Political Economy, Hamilton School, University of Florida
Mark Koyama is an economic historian studying state capacity, institutions, and the origins of sustained economic growth. He is co-author, with Jared Rubin, of How the World Became Rich: The Historical Origins of Economic Growth (2022). 30/
hamilton.ufl.edu/people/mark…
Mark Koyama retweeted
Introducing the Center for Human Progress, a think-and-do tank rooted in cultural evolution, behavioral science, and economics.
The world isn't short of great ideas. It's short of the systems to deliver them. The barriers to implementation are typically in the people layer - norms, incentives, and other aspects of culture. 🧵
centerforhumanprogress.org/
Mark Koyama retweeted
There is a strangely widespread view on the UK housing left that private developers will never build enough to reduce prices. It is the result of a strange parochialism (England is the world.)
I struggle to wrap my head around the logic; so maybe I’m missing something, but it is quite clearly empirically false.
All you have to do is look for examples outside recent UK history.
In the past (e.g. 1930s) developers built sufficiently that prices fell and housing became much more affordable in real terms.
In the Austin metro area, there’s been a huge increase in supply from developers recently, resulting in large falls in house prices/rents.
I think there’s a version of Pennycook’s claim that is sort of true: most development being done on a few big sites by big developers isn’t going to deliver enough homes fast enough.
But the whole point of planning reform and cutting build costs is to massively increase the supply of developable land and competition between developers.
Mark Koyama retweeted
Somehow I missed this, but the statement from Lit prize denying they'd given the prize to AI writing is itself blindingly obvious AI to anyone who uses it. "Human-centered. Evidence-led. Thorough. Multiple lines of evidence, not a single score. Every account aligned." Come on...
Nothing is more embarrassing that the opining about whether economics is or is not a science by people with no actual interest or knowledge of the field
This open access volume contains a very interesting piece on Smithian growth in the Islamic Middle East by Maya Shatzmiller
Mark Koyama retweeted
You have no idea how much English history - stuff we literally never knew before, including even high-political stuff - is to be found in the archives of other countries.
Mark Koyama retweeted
As Joel Mokyr once said: "The responsibility of economic historians is to remind the world what things were like before 1800."
Read this review to see how bad it was . . .
Spoiler: really bad!
Plague, gruel and bad teeth: why do people idealise the olden days? economist.com/culture/2026/1…
Mark Koyama retweeted
Last weekend, I read Domar’s classic 1944 paper “The ‘Burden of the Debt’ and the National Income.”
As is often the case, I was familiar with the basic result by the time I was an undergrad: you can run a permanent government deficit and still keep the public debt-to-output ratio constant under certain conditions on the real interest rate, the economy’s real growth rate, and the primary surplus. In fact, you can even reduce the public debt-to-output ratio asymptotically to zero and still run a government deficit every year.
But I had never read the original paper. The language is often difficult to follow (yes, leaving the formal model in the appendix makes everything much harder; you’ve got to love math!). Yet the insight per paragraph is truly outstanding. Domar was an incredible economist.
Nowadays, I spend most of my days thinking about how public debt interacts with AI and fertility. Both forces put the fiscal path of many Western European countries in a very difficult position: AI will push up the real interest rate more than the growth rate, and falling fertility will lower the growth rate. In Domar’s terms, the gap between the real interest rate and the growth rate moves in the wrong direction. I truly do not see how France or Spain can avoid a debt crisis over the next decade unless they undertake serious reforms.
To wrap up: read Domar’s 1970 paper “The Causes of Slavery or Serfdom: A Hypothesis” as well. That is a heck of a paper, a true classic. Someone should write a scholarly study of Domar as an economist. If you are working on the history of economic thought and searching for a topic, Domar is low-hanging fruit.
Here is the promised essay on the topic (with references) markkoyama.com/p/the-state-a…
My substack essay on the myth of state-driven industrialization in Prussia is up.
The State and Prussian Industrialization (State Capacity Liberalism in Prussia, Part 3) open.substack.com/pub/markko…

































