Interested in arguments, not arguing. Mostly looking at all things sex, gender, politics, identity and trying to work out what it means

UK
Joined September 2021
New "mostly peaceful" meme has just dropped
There it fucking is. The BBC just called the France riots “mostly peaceful”
15
I missed this the first time around. This is the ACTUAL European Commission. Wild
The battle of narratives is going strong. Our countries are a recurring target. It is time to act to tell the stories that make us strong. Let’s live our own story! Protect what matters - our democracy.
1
35
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Replying to @AlecTorelli
Good point! I saw a story about a guy being murdered in Leeds, but i looked out my window and couldn't see any a dead body. OK, maybe he was actually murdered, but he was personally was less than 1% of the popualtion, so what was all the fuss about?!
1
5
39
This type of derrangement needs to be studied....
I don’t blame immigrants specifically, although some would have been involved. No, I blame the hard right for introducing violence and destruction to an otherwise legitimate nationwide protest. Is Le Penn behind a Trumpian January 6th Capitol riot I ask myself?
16
Im glad this "queer socialist" has finally clicked that islamists will destroy the heritage of ALL countries, not just western European ones. Well done!
I’d you’re shocked at the damage in France to an old town hall you’ll be horrified to hear what’s happened to the beautiful old buildings and heritage of the Palestinians, Lebanese, Syrians, Iraqis and Afghans
16
*watches well documented far left riot" "Hmm... must be the far right!"
It doesn’t make sense that protests over the education system would escalate into this level of violence. Someone may be benefiting from the chaos. It could be far-right groups infiltrating the protests, setting things on fire to fuel the “deport immigrants” narrative. Or it could be the government itself, using the violence as a pretext to crack down on the protests and avoid addressing the protesters’ demands. Either way, we should be asking who stands to gain from this escalation. I don’t know I’m just not buying people becoming this violent just to “have a better education.” 🤨
1
3
32
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Replying to @NickCohen4
"Yes the Left are burning down our civilisation, but just imagine if the Right got in!" - Norm Macdonald 2.0
4
23
1
1,043
7,051
Every 'progressive' commentator seems to be doing some weird version of the Norm Macdonald meme "Yes the Left are burning down our civilisation, but just imagine if the Right got in!"
If Jean-Luc Mélenchon gets to the 2027 presidential run off, Le Pen will win by a landslide and that will be France, Europe and Ukraine fucked
36
This is your brain on gender
Replying to @poz_woods
Yes biologically they are women, but with a beard and working penis. I thought the argument was that trans women (without a penis) should be on a men's ward. I thought the possession of a penis was the perceived danger?
1
23
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Replying to @1OnlyTylerTrout
So true. The people who developed that should have spent their time not washing and shouting "free palestine" like you - that would drive human progress in the right direction, yes?
1
1
3
Progressive woman feels uncomfortable around gender non-conforming women. Explain to me again how trans isnt just the most regressive shit out there
Does this mean that hospitals have to put trans men on female wards? Because that would make me very uncomfortable.
1
1
46
Vaguely Rational retweeted
"I want them to be authentic by regurgitating the exact thing every other progresisve celebrity and corporate is saying and if take a stand against that im going to cry about how its not the stand I wanted them to take" You people are embarrassing
1
5
38
You are probably assuming this is a parody account but its actually a law professor. Apparently lying about being raped is concrete proof of being raped.
Rape cases are easy to prove. If the victim says she didn’t consent, that’s it-case closed. Perp’s *opinion* of a victim’s consent is irrelevant BECAUSE the victim alone owns her body & decides who touches her. Doesn’t matter what he thinks. Only matters what he does. #Cornell
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
In New York, prosecutors must prove lack of consent beyond a reasonable doubt; the accused never has to prove consent. NY Penal Law §130.05(2)(d) also defines non-consent partly by what a reasonable person in the actor's situation would have understood. lebedinkofman.com/defending-agai… law.cornell.edu/nyctap/I07_005…
36
This is a 'must read' summary of every nonsensical, debunked piece of trans gish gallop, all packages in one place for you. Its suddenly not 2021 anymore....
John there is no scientific truth that JK is spewing. It IS biased bigotry. Here is how Scientific research views being a Trans Woman. transgender woman through biological, neurological, genetic, & psychological lenses, showing that gender identity is a complex interplay of internal neurobiology rather than solely determined by external anatomy at birth. Major medical and scientific organizations—including the American Medical Association and the American Psychological Association—recognize transgender identities as a natural aspect of human diversity. Brain Anatomy and Neurobiology Brain structure: Neuroimaging studies show that the brain structure & functional patterns of transgender women often share features that align more closely with their gender identity rather than their assigned sex at birth. Machine learning analysis: Structural MRI studies, such as research published in PMC, have found that a transgender woman's estimated brain sex index shifts along a spectrum between cisgender men and women, leaning toward their lived gender identity. Genetics and Hormones Genetic variations: Research, including a study from the Hudson Institute of Medical Research, identified specific genetic variations related to how sex hormones like estrogen & androgen are processed in transgender women. Prenatal development: Scientific models suggest that prenatal hormone exposures & genetic factors interact during critical windows of development to influence the differentiation of the brain independently of external genitalia. Physical Performance & Sports Science Physiological shifts: Studies tracking athletes on gender-affirming hormone therapy (such as data discussed via PBS NewsHour) show that muscle mass, hemoglobin levels, & strength parameters decline over time, though the timeline varies depending on the specific metric (taking anywhere from months to several years to shift). Ongoing debate: The scientific community continues to study the nuanced balance between physiological retention of certain traits & athletic inclusion, with findings remaining a subject of active research across sports medicine bodies Psychological Well-Being and Transition Effectiveness of care: Scholarly reviews, such as comprehensive data analyzed by Cornell University, show that the vast majority of people who undergo gender transition experience dramatic improvements in overall mental health, self-esteem, and quality of life. Reduction of distress: Access to social, psychological, and medical support effectively alleviates gender dysphoria and lowers rates of anxiety, depression, and suicidality. IF you want to further Debate I welcome you to do so.
25
TIL this is how you campaign for inflationary pay rises and extra tea breaks.....
When our members stand with Palestine, they’re standing with their colleagues, for freedom, dignity, and self-determination. The values we fight for internationally. So let's keep organising, marching – together, until Palestine is free. From my speech on Saturday.
16
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Replying to @AaronBastani
I know this is not your point but the even sheer concept of calling for a ceasefire on the 10th of October is absolutely outrageous! Its the equivalent of smacking someone in a bar on the back of the head and saying "hey, let's not resort to violence" before they turn around
5
1
38
2,613
I can't belive he actually said this
This quoted post is unavailable.
1
103
If I were Humza I wouldn't be playing the "let's use the behavoir of a minority of Mulsims to draw inference about the motives of the majority" game. Not a great plan!
When Muslim fought against Nazis, as part of the British Indian Army, thousands of them sacrificing their lives - was that also incompatible with the British way of life? Lowe's language is comparable to rhetoric used by Nazis against Jews. As deplorable now, as it was then.
32
This is a really weird take. Do you want the tiger killed for 'revenge' or something? If not then you seem to agree with sharron
These “rights” activists really leave their humanity behind the minute they pick up their phones don’t they. When someone shows you who she is believe her the first time….
1
111
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Please explain what you think should have happened here, but try and do it in a way where it sounds like it might be realistic in doncaster, and not just like a movie you watched
2
1
3
224