
Interested in economic growth and state capacity. Previously India country director @IDinsight; PhD Economics, Oxford; Trade Policy Advisor, Vanuatu.
New Delhi, India
Joined May 2009
- Tweets1.5K
- Following1.1K
- Followers770
- Likes387
I mean, a list of best restaurants in India that doesn’t include Gulati or RJD or Bukhara, nothing from Lucknow or Jaipur or Amritsar, isn’t a list of India’s best restaurants. It’s a list of the ones with the most paid-up PR capital.
Ah, a long rant coming up. I have many thoughts, might just write a longer piece later. But here are my initial thoughts.
Every year, the CNT Top 50 Restaurants in India list comes out and I find myself asking the same question: what exactly are we defining as “best”?
Fine dining, tasting menus and chef-led restaurants are an important part of India’s evolving food culture, and many of the restaurants on this list absolutely deserve their flowers. But they are not the beginning and end of India’s restaurant culture.
This year, Mumbai and Goa alone account for 26 of the 50 restaurants. Bengaluru has six. And while there are restaurants from places like Kasauli, Karaikudi and Shillong on the list - which I love seeing - the map of “India’s best restaurants” still feels remarkably small.
Because the Indian restaurant scene is so much bigger than our metros. And even within our metros, some of the most exceptional food isn’t necessarily happening in the kind of restaurants we traditionally associate with these lists.
In Bengaluru alone, I think of places like Malgudi Mylari Mane, Super Naati and Fireside, where they actually cook over firewood. I think of the incredible food coming from the city’s Northeast communities, and places like Roots & Fern in Kammanahalli.
These are restaurants I find genuinely exciting. Places with a strong sense of place, community, technique and identity.
That’s really what I wish lists like these would explore more.
What about the tiny family-run restaurant doing one regional cuisine exceptionally well? The neighbourhood place people have been eating at for twenty years? The restaurant preserving a cooking technique that’s disappearing elsewhere? The small kitchen cooking food from a community that rarely gets represented in mainstream food media?
And what about Mysuru, Mangaluru, Lucknow, Indore, Surat, Nagpur, Kozhikode, Kochi, Madurai, Guwahati, Bhubaneswar - or the hundreds of other cities and towns where people are cooking extraordinary food?
Every year, I hope the definition of “best” gets a little wider.
Not instead of the restaurants already being celebrated. Alongside them.
Because there is so, so much more to India’s restaurant story than what can fit into the usual dining map.
cntraveller.in/story/the-bes…
Filling the Air Suvidha 2.0 form and having throwbacks to “why does the district matter in Delhi? What do you mean we don’t live in New Delhi or south Delhi?!”
Would just love to know how many AEs actually respond, and if they don’t, if the helpline works.
BDA is now more Pro-Citizen & Transparent!
We have divided the entire city into sections and assigned dedicated Executive Engineers (AE/AEE/EEs) for each area. These engineers are fully responsible for all BDA-related works in their jurisdiction.
Now you can easily find the responsible AE/AEE/EE for your area!
Just visit the BDA website and check the interactive map.
bdakarnataka.in/jurisdiction…
Facing any issue or encroachment?
→ Look up your section on the map
→ Contact your AE/EE directly
No response? Call our 24x7 Helpline: 94831 66622 — we will take immediate action.
Your area, your engineer, your voice.
@Captain_Mani72
#BDA #NammaBDA #ProCitizenBDA #TransparentBDA #BengaluruFirst
So weird to be binging on Narcos Mexico and watching gruesome murders and kidnappings in 1980s Guadalajara... and NYT 2023 is encouraging us to go there to celebrate queer diversity.
Karan Nagpal retweeted
Because the best writers aren't providing just knowledge, they are providing wisdom too. That wisdom comes in the form of novelty and asking new questions—two things an AI can't do yet.
Let me show you with an example.
Lots of PTSD reading this thread!
A long time ago, when struggling with this topic, @BrownstoneEcon shared this b'ful paper on the intellectual history of household definitions, which reveals the high-modernist instincts lying at the heart of our efforts: journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf…
Great thread on why being so deeply embedded in a particular context helps you do development economics better:
Karan Nagpal retweeted
1/4 Happy to report that our paper (@jo_ruchika, @krnaa, @therealfraker) on using voter rolls for household sample surveys in India is out in Field Methods! journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.…
A major challenge with all of India’s Covid systems - from Air Suvidha to the beautiful ICMR & NIC portals - is that they assume all of India lives in villages, and everyone knows their GP, tehsil, block, and district. So these systems fail for Mumbai, Delhi etc.
This is an amazing initiative and I love (and have frequently used) @open_phil's Cause Prioritization Framework. It would be great if OP can over-weight submissions from outside the EA community, and find a way to get submissions from non-Twitter-elites.
“What new cause area should Open Philanthropy consider funding?” Today we’re launching the Cause Exploration Prizes to gather thoughtful answers to this question and others that help us best use our resources causeexplorationprizes.com/
Karan Nagpal retweeted
Years in the making @NITIAayog recently launched the National Data & Analytics Platform! Managed by @IDinsight & @devdatalab, we hope the platform will improve access & use of Indian govt data.
Read more about the platform in @bsindia: bit.ly/3wL2Yhj
A friend asked Jean Dreze: "how has economics helped in your work?" "It's often been a hindrance."
Reading @MittaliSethi's article, I'm thinking the same way about "digital data systems" - they are becoming a hindrance to actually using data.
Often, Excel is enough to excel :)
Some labour of love. It took us eight months to write, edit and think through the details of this article. The intention was to bring alive challenges on the field and talk to whoever works with nutrition on ground. Please do share feedback. :)
idronline.org/article/health…
Researchers working in DRC have reinvented the Zamindari system, and feel pretty good about themselves: aeaweb.org/research/state-ca…
"In the Central group, state agents were responsible for door-to-door collection...In the Local group, city chiefs took control of collection efforts."
Great points by @kadambari_shah and @VibhavMariwala on potential for data use - esp thinking critically about frequency & granularity, rather than relying just on NSS/Census. Two additional points and a dilemma:
1. Policymakers should *want to use* the data rather than… (1/2)
'Indian State was set up to control, not govern. Data-driven policy-making can be antidote'
@VibhavMariwala, senior analyst and @kadambari_shah, senior associate, IDFC Institute, write
Illustration: Ramandeep Kaur @RKaurArtDesign
#ThePrintOpinion
bit.ly/3FGuoZA
Now the dilemma: Kadambari & Vibhav rightly say that all this data should also be open to citizens and researchers. But no politician has the incentive to make bad news public. And sometimes data doesn’t get collected, lest it show the govt in a bad light. So sometimes… (4/n)
…we will have to balance this tradeoff between getting data to be actually used, and making it public for citizens, researchers etc. I don’t yet know how to reconcile these imperatives. Lots more to explore here! (n/n) (thanks to @rahul_tverma for getting this article on my TL!)
















