
#Semiotics Research Fellow @UniTartu #AI #IW M : https://xitter.cf/t.co/x2azlLBqLW + building community @technosemiotics
cyberspace
Joined May 2011
- Tweets777
- Following694
- Followers356
- Likes480
Pinned Tweet
Just published two papers on the #semiotics of #generative and #synthetic media such as the likes of #LLM #GPT #chatgpt #gpt4 #Bing and any other #AGI fantasies
inftars.infonia.hu/article.p… + researchgate.net/publication…
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
This paper gives a fancy name to a problem you can already feel in your bones
"The Tragedy of the Cognitive Commons." Checking AI output requires deep expertise. Deep expertise comes from doing grunt work for years. And grunt work is the first thing AI eats
So we're building systems that need expert supervision while dismantling the only known process for making experts
The paper calls the shared pool of human expertise the "cognitive commons." Every profession drinks from it. Nobody's refilling it.
By eliminating junior roles, each company is acting totally rationally, and the collective result: a profession that can't catch AI's mistakes anymore because it never learned to do the work in the first place
Who checks AI's homework in 15 years?
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
In 2006, science fiction author Vernor Vinge wrote a novel called Rainbows End. The central plot: a mass digitization project at a university library where books are fed into machines that cut the bindings, shred the pages, and photograph them mid-flight. Destroying the physical to reconstruct the digital.
Marc Andreessen(@pmarca) called Vinge "one of the best forecasters in the world" the following year.
20 years later, the fiction is the press release.
We built the Arctic World Archive in a Norwegian coal mine to preserve human knowledge for 1,000 years.
We are shredding it in warehouses in California to train chatbots.
🦔AI companies are bulk-buying rare books, scanning them through high-speed machines that cut the spines off, and shredding the originals. A service called ISBNdb facilitates orders of up to a million books and keeps buyers anonymous. Pre-2022 books are premium because they're free of AI-generated text. A federal judge ruled the practice is fair use because eliminating the original means only one copy exists at a time. Anthropic hired the former head of Google Books partnerships to obtain "all the books in the world."
My Take
This got to me. A bookseller told 404 Media that rare books with almost no surviving copies are being fed into this pipeline. Books that survived wars, fires, and centuries of handling are being shredded so an AI can learn to write a better marketing email.
ISBNdb's website literally says "'AI company destroys two million books' is not a headline that generates sympathy," and they still built an entire business around making it happen quietly. They offer NDAs as a feature. They coach clients to call it "digital preservation."
I've covered AI companies scraping the internet, torrenting libraries, and stealing music. This is worse because it's irreversible. You can re-upload a website. You can reprint a bestseller. You can't replace the last three copies of an 18th-century botanical text once someone shreds them for training data. And the judge said it's legal. So it's going to accelerate.
"We shred rare books and offer NDAs so nobody finds out" is a legitimate business model in 2026. What a timeline.
Hedgie🤗
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
🦔AI companies are bulk-buying rare books, scanning them through high-speed machines that cut the spines off, and shredding the originals. A service called ISBNdb facilitates orders of up to a million books and keeps buyers anonymous. Pre-2022 books are premium because they're free of AI-generated text. A federal judge ruled the practice is fair use because eliminating the original means only one copy exists at a time. Anthropic hired the former head of Google Books partnerships to obtain "all the books in the world."
My Take
This got to me. A bookseller told 404 Media that rare books with almost no surviving copies are being fed into this pipeline. Books that survived wars, fires, and centuries of handling are being shredded so an AI can learn to write a better marketing email.
ISBNdb's website literally says "'AI company destroys two million books' is not a headline that generates sympathy," and they still built an entire business around making it happen quietly. They offer NDAs as a feature. They coach clients to call it "digital preservation."
I've covered AI companies scraping the internet, torrenting libraries, and stealing music. This is worse because it's irreversible. You can re-upload a website. You can reprint a bestseller. You can't replace the last three copies of an 18th-century botanical text once someone shreds them for training data. And the judge said it's legal. So it's going to accelerate.
"We shred rare books and offer NDAs so nobody finds out" is a legitimate business model in 2026. What a timeline.
Hedgie🤗
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
New meta-analysis (2024) finds human-AI collaboration is task-dependent: performance increases for creative & open-ended tasks (like content creation), but performance drops for decision-making tasks; human-AI collaboration seems to work best when humans already outperform AI
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
I'm now of the opinion that LLM use should be fairly limited for most employees.
The amount damage caused by uncritical acceptance of hallucinations is far greater than I'd have expected. (and I was thinking it'd be pretty bad... it's worse.)
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
I'm increasingly concerned with signals from @EU_Commission that Digital Services Act is a tool for censorship. It was never introduced as such during works. Now it's passed and some EU policymakers appear to intend to use it as such. Unfortunate #DigitalEUambassador
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
Our Canadian friends may appreciate this 2021 document analyzing Google's programmatic business north of the border including the critical trojan horse of GA4 to enable user consent if privacy laws advance. /27 storage.courtlistener.com/re…
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
Google sees hard paywalls for content (like @ft) as a threat to their goals because they can’t scrape the content for their own profit.
They also see all the privacy tools we use (ad blockers, private browsing) as a direct threat to their business.
We knew; just confirmation.
Replying to @jason_kint
For the news orgs and journalists who have been working to find a sustainable business model supported by your audiences, you need to know Google in this strategy document puts subscriptions (eg FT, WSJ) under the heading of "Threats to the Open Web." /8
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
This thread describes why newspapers died. It's not that the internet disrupted the business model, it's murder by Google.
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
wow. an amazing 325 page google strategy document quietly unsealed buried in google antitrust docket. It's gonna take a long thread but I have pulled out the gems. It's from 2017 planning, no doubt Google will just say these were only ideas but many will look very familiar. /1
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
Four women in my beautiful country Iran are at risk of execution for the crime of wanting freedom, democracy, equality, and dignity.
Do you expect me to mourn the killing of a terrorist instead? 😡
Outrage should be for women being killed ny those
terrorists simply for showing their hair!
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
Had an exciting day seeing the @WhiteHouse from the inside to talk about sociotechnical AI safety research! A star-studded visit thanks to a chance view of the VP. Some of the relevant work: arxiv.org/abs/2406.11757
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
Posting a video that shows Harris saying politically damaging things she never said, without making it very clear it's a parody, seems like the definition of defamation.
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
So here we are. Deepfakes being used to manipulate an election.
I guess no one is surprised, but the fact it's spread not by bots or anons but the very owner of @X should probably ring alarm bells.
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
I'm delighted to be able to announce that my next book At Dawn They Came: Soviet Terror and Repression 1917-1953 is scheduled for publication by @HofTotalitarian at the end of September.
It recounts the history of Soviet repression from Lenin's first labour camps through to their fully fledged climax as the Gulag system under Stalin. 🧵
(Yes, the labour camp system began with Lenin, not Stalin. Lenin is sometimes portrayed as the 'good communist' whose ideals were betrayed by Stalin. This, as my book shows, is nonsense. )
Auli Viidalepp retweeted
After a lot of argument, Claude is willing to teach me how to filet a fish by creating interactive tools, but only once I certify that I have handled the fish in an ethical way. And even then it is only willing to go so far.
As models get smarter, guardrails become more complex.






































