Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd) profile picture

Past President New Jersey Psych Assoc., 40+ yrs. experience with 25+ in forensics; dedicated to appreciating the unique needs of each person. (tweets ≠ endorse)

Montebello, NY
Joined February 2011
Photo by Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd)Photo by Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd)Photo by Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd)Photo by Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd)Photo by Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd)Photo by Jeffrey C. Singer (@jsingerphd)
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
Is Israel committing war crimes? John Spencer (@SpencerGuard) wrote an evidence-based assessment for CNN. I recommend reading it in full, but I'm going to post some key takeaways here. John is chair of urban warfare studies at the Modern War Institute (MWI) at West Point, codirector of MWI’s Urban Warfare Project and host of the “Urban Warfare Project Podcast.” He served for 25 years as an infantry soldier, which included two combat tours in Iraq and has written a number of books. - Noncombatants make up about 90% of casualties in modern wars, in populated urban areas. War is hell. - "war crimes must be assessed on evidence and the standards of armed conflict" - Hamas "indisputably violated multiple laws of war." They directly targeted civilians, took hostages, raped, and tortured. Using "human shields for its weapons and command centers and by purposely putting military capabilities in protected sites like hospitals, mosques and schools" is also a war crime. - "Israel’s right to immediate and unilateral self-defense [is] in accordance with Article 51 of the UN Charter" - Proportionality: People misinterpret this concept as "equal numbers of civilian casualties on both sides." "proportionality is actually a requirement to take into account how much civilian harm is anticipated in comparison to the expected concrete and direct military advantage, according to UN protocols," he writes. - The key is that the military objective is of high value. He brings up a case when the intended target is the senior Hamas commander who oversaw all military operations in the northern Gaza. - A key distinction is that an attack has to raise to the level of “military necessity,” (like killing military targets), not "an illegal goal (causing civilians to suffer)." - A key distinction is that an attack has to raise to the level of “military necessity,” (like killing military targets, remove the rockets and ammunitions depot, etc), not "an illegal goal (causing civilians to suffer)." - Spencer says that the IDF does something that he has never seen other militaries do in all of his experience: they alert people of pending air strikes, giving them time to evacuate. - Israel should "continue to cooperate with the US in facilitating the entry of humanitarian supplies into Gaza (though it’s reasonable to block fuel, which Hamas can use in its attacks and which the group is also stockpiling while refusing to share it with its own people)." - "Like all similar conflicts in modern times, a battle in Gaza will look like the entire city was purposely razed to the ground or indiscriminately carpet bombed – but it wasn’t," he says, calling it "a careful defensive campaign to ensure Israel’s survival."
81
392
52
973
99,599
Here's part of a PBS documentary from Shifa Hospital in 2006, before Hamas' coup in Gaza, showing how terrorists roamed the halls and intimidated doctors to only do what they wanted. Now that Hamas controls the hospital, does anyone doubt that the doctors cannot do anything Hamas doesn't allow?
8
223
23
313
19,048
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
“As supplies of virtually every basic human necessity dwindle in Gaza, one group in the besieged enclave remains well-stocked: Hamas.” “One group?” It is literally the government. “Hamas’s stockpiles raise questions about what responsibility, if any, it has to the civilian population” I’d say. nytimes.com/2023/10/27/world… – at Israel
177
677
58
2,362
1,253,541
It is a bit odd that the people who keep reminding Israel to follow international law - which it is, having layers of lawyers in the IDF checking the legality of every air strike aimed at Hamas - have so little to say about: * Hostage taking (grave breach of Geneva IV) * Indiscriminate rocket fire (principle of distinction) * Spreading terror among civilians (Rule 2 CIHL) * Human shields (Rule 97 CIHL) * Staging attacks from residential areas (Article 51(7) of AP1) * Rape (crime against humanity) * Murder (crime against humanity) * Torture (crime against humanity) * Extermination (crime against humanity) There are plenty others - using hospitals and ambulances as cover for attacks, storing weapons in mosques, using children as soldiers, wearing uniforms of the enemy to attack, not giving advance warning of attacks on civilians, threatening journalists, targeting civilian airports. Where are the condemnations of each of these violations of international law?
28
216
16
486
17,822
Finally someone says it! “It is important to also recognize the attacks by Hamas did not happen in a vacuum.” And isn’t it great that the person who said it is UN Secretary General Antonio Gutteres, who presides over the organization that has played a defining role in creating, sustaining, and nourishing the fertile soil from which Hamas has sprung? Let us examine the evidence (Part 1, Part 2 in the first comment): Exhibit A: UNRWA. This still temporary agency, established more than 70 years ago to settle the Arab refugees from the war of 1948 (Israel settled the Jewish refugees), was unable to carry out its mission throughout the 1950’s due to the complete refusal of the Arab refugees (later to be known as Palestinians) to be settled, knowing that this would mean they have abandoned their ongoing war against there being a state of sovereign and free Jews anywhere in the land. Having failed in its resettlement mission, UNRWA was then hijacked by the Palestinians themselves to become the organization that enables Palestinians, uniquely among all the world’s refugees, to persist in the view that they do not need to accept new realities, new borders, and can go on thinking of themselves as perpetual refugees, generation after generation, until such moment that they can turn back the clock, have a “redo” and win the war against there being a state for Jews anywhere in the land. UNRWA, its compounds, its education system, its almost exclusively Palestinian staff, have been the womb in which not only a unique Palestinian identity was consolidated, but one that was singularly focused on “revenge” and “return”. As a result, from the planners and perpetrators of the massacre of Israeli athletes in the 1972 Munich Olympics, to the current planners and perpetrators of the Oct 7 mass massacre, every generation trained murderers rose up to realize the dream of “return”, “Free Palestine” and “From the River to the Sea”. (For more on this you may read this post of October 13 xitter.cf/einatwilf/status/17128… or the book “The War of Return” for the full and definitive review of UNRWA’s uniquely destructive goal in sustaining the Palestinian dream of “no Israel”) Exhibit B: A whole administrative UN structure devoted uniquely to Palestinians In 1975, the carefully developed Soviet replacement for the Tsarist “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” known as respectable “It’s only Anti-Zionism” was inserted into the UN through the “Zionism is Racism” UN General Assembly resolution. While the resolution was repealed in 1991 under US pressure, the entire infrastructure that it erected remained intact. These include three UN bodies with staffs and budgets that only exist to promote the Palestinian vision that the Jews deserve no state in any part of the land and it is worth noting that no other people have an entire division in the UN Secretariat dedicated to it: (1) The Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People (CEIRPP) (2) The Division for Palestinian Rights (DPR) (3) The Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Human Rights Practices (SCIIHRP) (For more on this go to ajiri.us/about)
Dear Western funders of @UNRWA - What exactly did you think you were supporting all these years? When you sustained, nourished, supported and indulged Palestinians, generation after generation, in the belief that uniquely among the world’s peoples in the wake of WWII, they don’t need to accept new realities, new borders, and move on with the lives; that they possess a non-existent “right of return” into Israeli sovereign territory, that their land was “stolen” and that they have the right to take it “back” by “all means” - what exactly did you think the outcome would be? Peace? Two states? Ever since the publication of “The War of Return: How Western Indulgence of the Palestinian Dream has Obstructed the Path to Peace” @Adi_Schwartz and I met with numerous Western diplomats from the countries that fund UNRWA. We explained to them that the Palestinian ethos, as sustained by UNRWA, has always been focused on a singular goal: no free Jews in the land, no sovereign state for the Jewish people on any part of the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Hence “Free Palestine” and “From the River to the Sea”. We explained that by indulging Palestinians in the notion that the war of 1948 is not over, that they are somehow, now into the fifth generation “refugees” from that war, and that they possess a non-existent “right of return” into sovereign Israel, by which they can undo Israel’s existence, UNRWA and its funders are ensuring that there will always be new recruits for Palestinian terrorism, whether Fatah or Hamas. We explained the UNRWA provides ideological sustenance and international legitimacy through the letters “UN” and continuous Western funding, for the Palestinian belief that Israel is a temporary aberration in the region and that the clock on it could be turned back through “return”. Almost everywhere we were met with dismissal and disbelief - “it’s just about the occupation”, “they need better conditions in Gaza”. We begged those official to stop “Westplaining” and give Palestinians the respect of taking them at their words, actions and key decisions for over a century and realize they all amount to one thing - a singular dedication to eradicating the Jewish state. If anything will come out of the current hellscape, let it be that the world will see the Palestinian “cause” for what it is, stop indulging it, and maybe, just maybe finally lead them, 75 years too late, to “embrace defeat” (the name of John Dower’s book about Japan in the wake of WWII) and become a people focused on building a nation rather than destroying one.
86
782
121
2,241
280,149
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
Sorry but I'm not going to be your good Jew. I'm not going to identify as "white" and privileged, while the people who hate me for being Jewish have no trouble identifying my race. Not going to play the hierarchy game in the oppression olympics. - I don't care if you're Irish, Polish, Italian, Black, Indian, Asian, etc...we all have our own experiences & many have faced discrimination. I'm not going to condemn Israel for defending itself. (We can talk about specifics of actions and debate that, but I'm not going to pretend that the murders, torture, rape, and kidnapping of innocent civilians were somehow justified for ANY reason or were somehow about "resistance.") I'm not going to apologize for killing Jesus either, because I did not. Nor am I going to say that Jews are "overrepresented" in... (Are they also "overrepresented" when they've helped invent the things that save or improve your life?) They contribute. Instead of petty jealousy, it is worthy of respect. And perhaps something others can learn from and strive for. No. I'm not going to be a "good Jew."
830
915
103
7,326
695,126
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
If a terrorist organization invades American homes and murders and maims American civilians and children and rapes American women and mutilates American bodies and butchers, burns, and beheads American babies and abducts American hostages and guns down hundreds of young Americans at a music festival and massacres 10% of an American town… Would you expect your government to enter into a ceasefire with the very terrorist organization that committed all those atrocities against Americans on American soil?
1,359
1,927
286
8,954
1,169,426
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
Replying to @IlhanMN
WATCH: Students at @nyuniversity ripped down posters of the missing women and children that Hamas terrorists took hostage:
3
5
20
2,968
Replying to @IlhanMN
Show me the part where you used your platform to call for Hamas to release all the innocent Israeli civilian hostages.
8
6
170
5,456
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
Replying to @IlhanMN
I would like to see you demand: a) The safe return of all those kidnapped b) The voluntary disarming of all Hamas militants c) The immediate surrender of all Hamas militants to stand trial Otherwise, your claims for peace are not legitimate.
26
14
2
184
7,829
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
1. If all Israel's enemies lay down weapons, everyone knows that it will bring peace and prosperity to the region. If Israel lays down weapons, everyone knows that Israel will cease to exist that very day. And we saw what that would look like... 2. The massacre that we witnessed, children and women and elderly taken as hostages, show that Hamas is like ISIS. It is NOT a war for territory or sovereignty. Instead of using the billions of dollars poured into them by the international community to create a prosperous nation alongside Israel, they turned Gaza into an oppressive murderous regime that kills its own people and indoctrinates children to kill the Jews and all infidels. It’s a religious war. 3. At all times Israel gives access to medical services to Arabs from both Gaza and Palestinian Authority, and provides humanitarian aid and basic necessities to Gaza. Arabs in Israel proper are doctors, lawyers, heads of medical departments in major hospitals, high ranking military commanders, heads of police precincts, Supreme Justices, members of parliament and members of coalition. This is NOT apartheid, and there is no moral equivalence.
390
1,195
141
4,316
620,561
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
14,743
13,459
5,845
61,706
19,259,422
Children and adolescents who have been physically assaulted are nearly twice as likely as their peers to develop mental illness after the assault — and the risk is even higher in the first year after an incident, research suggests. washingtonpost.com/wellness/… #MorrisPsychGroup
1
1
27
There are steps that you can take as a peer to cultivate more robust social networks focused on support rather than co-rumination, helping enhance your own well-being and that of your #coworkers. 🔗psychologytoday.com/us/blog/… #Burnout #Venting #MentalHealth #MorrisPsychGroup
1
1
33
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
Study findings: 1)So many people qualify for "Prolonged Grief", it was big mistake to include in DSM-5-TM 2)Most long grievers see their grief as normal/don't want to be labeled sick 3)Long grief predictors: Loss of child or spouse/Loss via violence or OD sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
13
48
5
186
33,270
Adult children experience distress watching our #parents succumb to the rigors of #aging. In his #blog article, Dr. Singer shares several points to help minimize this #stress. 👇 morrispsych.com/coming-to-te… #MorrisPsychGroup
1
1
25
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
4
3
Jeffrey C. Singer retweeted
So proud to be part of this documentary project: The Hidden Truth | HG Distribution hgagnondistribution.com/en/t…
3
5
1
8