Joshua Lens retweeted
Dan Hurley called the five-for-five legal battle across college athletics this season āunfortunateā and āgrossā after the Arizona-UConn game.
āAs an institution and as a program, we chose to follow the rules and the guidelines of the NCAA when they said that the five-for-five rule starts next year. We ignored the calls from lawyers and agents telling us, āHey, these guys will get eligible.āā
āWe all complain that we don't have rules. They did actually give us rules of who could play. Coaches chose not to follow them and to just throw it into chaos in the legal system, and it's just it's wrong.ā
I take my kids to the @IowaWBB game and never thought Iād come home to new news on this front but nothing should surprise at this pointā¦
LSU will no longer roster RJ Luis Jr, per statement from President Wade Rousse.
Tigers menās basketball took one more step here than the football team did, but ultimately ended up in the same place.
1
110
Joshua Lens retweeted
What a remarkably selective account of the law. RJ Luis signed an NBA contract. The SEC maintains that its rules prohibit former professionals from returning to conference competition. LSU's president himself voted in August to reaffirm those restrictions, a fact conspicuously absent from his statement.
The November 13 preliminary injunction does not establish that the SEC's rules are unlawful, nor does it require LSU to roster Luis. And the judge's handling of this case raises serious questions about his understanding of preliminary injunctive relief. Its ordinary purpose is to preserve the status quo pending trialā not to effectively award a plaintiff his ultimate relief before the merits can be adjudicated.
By the time this case reaches trial, the basketball season will likely be over. Luis, and by proxy Will Wade, will have received the very relief he sought, regardless of whether he ultimately prevails. No subsequent judgment can undo games already played. This is not merely a procedural concern; it goes to the integrity of the judicial process.
LSU has chosen to roster Luis. Rousse would prefer to characterize that decision as obedience to a judicial command. There is a considerable legal difference.
Joshua Lens retweeted
For the third straight year, @kayla_karius and @gbphoenixwbb hosted their Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Game, known as āMacklinās Game,ā honoring Kariusā son, Macklin, who passed away in 2021.
This year, players wore jerseys bearing the names of children gone too soon, bringing together 15 other families who have experienced the loss of a child to remind them theyāre not alone. ā¤ļøā¤ļø
The TX Sup Court once famously said judges shouldn't be "super referees" (Yeo). The NCAA is effectively arguing that OH's governor shouldn't be a "super legislator" at a time when NCAA, conferences, & schools actively seek federal legislation. I ā¤ļøsports law & college athletics.
8
309
Wrote about the dormant Commerce Clause's potential application to state NIL laws that attempted to preclude NCAA enforcement within state borders here: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.ā¦. Perhaps some relevance to the lawsuit challenging the Ohio EO.
In a landmark moment, the NCAA is suing a sitting state governor, Ohioās Mike DeWine, over his executive order on eligibility. NCAA calls the EO a āmisguided attemptā to give Ohio colleges a āhall pass to break rules,ā per docs obtained by @YahooSports.
bit.ly/4ytwzK2
2
153
Potentially significant yet also a great reminder that, despite all the recent attention regarding possible increased conference governance, itās not a new concept (āreestablishā).
SEC presidents will meet next week to consider a proposal that would reestablish a year-in-residency mandate for athletes moving within the conference, sources tell @YahooSports.
The move would require athletes to miss a season if transferring from one SEC school to another.
1
114
Grateful to have had the opportunity to serve as an expert witness regarding college coach contracts and NCAA rules
An update š to the breach of contract lawsuit former @LSUBasketball assistant Bill Armstrong filed against the school. Armstrong comes away with $67K after prevailing on one claim. Hereās what @Sportico wrote about the awkward legal dynamic in August:
sportico.com/leagues/collegeā¦
Joshua Lens retweeted
Professor Jill Wieber Lens' article "Men & Wrongful Death for Abortion" was accepted for publication by the Texas A&M Law Review. Lens examines claims that emphasize male harm from abortion in lawsuits against doctors, finding them inherently weak.
More: ow.ly/qrZr50ZNVJO
Interesting read & counter to many other academics' public view: thehill.com/opinion/educatioā¦
1
160
Joshua Lens retweeted
1) Proof? This is rhetoric. Here are the real numbers and the real story:
2) āRevenue for college sports is booming.ā
Maybe at the very top, but 94% of DI athletics programs spend more than they generate, including 49 of 69 āPowerā programs.
Great for the SEC that it distributed $1B. Thatās 16 schools. There are hundreds of schools in DI. What about everyone else?
Maybe you mean the sports supposedly driving all the profits? Still wrong.
76% of DI menās basketball and 67% of DI football programs donāt generate enough revenue to cover even their own operating expenses.
Revenue is NOT profit.
3) āWomenās sports are growing.ā
Great. Letās protect that.
College athletics is intentionally a broad-based participation model. DI schools are required to sponsor multiple menās and womenās sports.
It isnāt a professional league designed to operate only profitable teams.
4) āRatings prove fans like athletes getting paid.ā
No. Ratings prove fans love college sports.
Fans support the front of the jersey. Players graduate, transfer and turn pro. The fans remain.
5) āThere is no chaos.ā
Conflicting state laws. Constant litigation. Rising costs ultimately borne by universities, students, donors and, at many publicly funded universities, taxpayers.
Thatās not a sustainable way to govern a national system.
And turning this debate to race ignores the diversity of the athletes whose opportunities are at stake.
There are nearly 90,000 Black student-athletes across the NCAA and more than half compete in sports other than football and menās basketball.
What about them? Their opportunities matter too.
Using the economics of a small fraction of DI programs to define all of college athletics isnāt the full story. Itās misleading rhetoric.
What about the 94% @ChrisMurphyCT ? Who pays?
And what happens to everyone else?
Joshua Lens retweeted
Marin Byars will be a tremendous representative for the student-athletes in The Big West! #BeBold
š° šļø NEWS | From the Cage to Capitol Hill:
@CSUNPolo's Marin Byars to Represent The Big West in Washington, D.C.
š tinyurl.com/3byc3ves
#š¢š»š¹šš§šµš²šš¼š¹š± x #SurfToSummit x #OURVoice
Yadi-Jose Siri 2021 spring training incident and NLCS HR in Queens FTW
Goold: 'Can you tell my your favorite Yadier Molina story?' I asked. Here are the answers. stltoday.com/sports/professiā¦
76
No lawsuits filed!?
In light of the LSU-SEC situation, the Big Ten once evicted a program that used semi-pro players and ran a collective (slush funds).
The school had to boot the athletes & make serious changes, returning only on its 4th reinstatement attempt.
nytimes.com/athletic/2105540ā¦
1
335

























