Jay Mac (@jaymac) header
Jay Mac (@jaymac) profile picture

Ads man. A decade of Google Ads, now experimenting with AI Ads.

Joined April 2020
I've had multiple clients test ChatGPT Ads and then pull the spend to put it back on Google Ads. It's a dropped ball so far from OpenAI, the insane context they have they're not turning it into the highly converting ad platform many (inc. me) expected. Still time to fix it...
3
1
1
33
8,509
Not a great sign that advertisers are dipping their toes into ChatGPT Ads then walking away rather than jumping in for more. I'm seeing the same on a smaller scale. Everyone is waiting for results to improve - that actually needs to happen pretty soon to keep brands engaged.
2
280
Interested to see these ChatGPT Ads that click-to-chat. It makes sense to continue the conversation in the format the user is already in. But shifting the conversation more specific to the brands products/services. I think it's a winner, after a learning curve.
1
226
Part of so many changes since launching I suppose but it is pretty difficult to know what's working in ChatGPT Ads. It's clear it's miles off converting compared to Google Ads but it's even hard to know why some ads do better than others, especially the targeting settings.
2
163
A lot of this growth has to be experimentation. I'm really not sure how many advertisers will be seeing ROAS comparable to other channels yet. Sure some big brands are using it as a mass awareness play. But to get advertisers to stick, the results are going to need to improve.
154
It's still funny to me how Microsoft Ads just waits for Google to do something, leaves it a few months then adds it. Not a bad strategy really as often takes that long for Google to find its feet for their new features. Will test as Bing still slept on for certain industries.
1
132
The greatest trick Google ever pulled. Getting everyone to pay to show for their own brand. I remember the days when this was unthinkable as part of your ad spend.
1
100
My monthly consulting income: The dip is when my first child was born. Had my best year beforehand in the run up. Then once things settled I kicked on even further. The motivation is like nothing else.
It seems that my own experience aligns with the data: being a father correlated with me a being a more successful entrepreneur. Buffer had started to decline prior to our first kid being born, and was at it's bottom by the time the second arrived. I can wholeheartedly say that having kids gave me a whole new level of ambition, and also made me have much greater conviction about working through obstacles to turn Buffer around. Raising kids alongside turning Buffer around has simultaneously been the most fulfilling and most challenging chapter of my life. I hit a patch of depression within this phase too which I've recently emerged from.
1
4
169
And so it begins... The subtle art of getting more clicks from the ChatGPT Ads team. A small description appearing before ads now.
1
1
158
Finally, something new from ChatGPT Ads! This is what I've been waiting for. It might not work in its first iteration but I want them to innovate and test stuff like this. Can't work out if this will lead to warmer leads or lower quality yet though.
1
1
136
We're a long way from this playing out. Yet I still think it probably will, at least directionally. The context AI search has is just too valuable for ads not to work. They just haven't found out how best to utilise it yet. Yet...
1
2
100
The fact that conversion rate is not a shown metric in ChatGPT Ads is quite telling...
1
129
Here's an early performance overview of ChatGPT Ads campaigns for a B2B vehicle leasing company. Click-through rates hovering around 1%, and an average cost per click of around £2. We're pretty pleased with that, but more so the conversion numbers are really strong. The conversion in question is a form submission lead enquiry so quite meaningful too. There's no doubt we'll continue this and add more budget. However I'm seeing much lower conversion stats in other industries. So it seems to be a game of finding what sectors/niches fit this style of advertising.
2
3
372
Time running ads to AI agents. I'm studying this with great interest. Not sure this is how it will be most effective and far from its likely final form (my guess is this method gets penalised). But ads to AI agents is going to be a huge market I'm sure.
4
158
You think this would be a useful feature within ChatGPT Ads. It's absolutely awful. (for now...)
126
Neat tool from Adthena. Booking(.)com account for ~10% across all markets. Chat makes sense for travel, personalised trip planning then show an ad to match. I'm not sure how close that match is currently, once it's more embedded can see this working very well.
1
131