Jane Westfall retweeted
💬 | SOMBR on advice he received from Taylor Swift:
“One of the best pieces of advice the legend has given me. The person I look up to most has given me. The amazing pop star. Is that if these hate comments go away, maybe you’re not at your peak anymore. I think it’s a privilege to be receiving these and rise above it. Ever since she gave me that advice, it’s really changed my perspective and has helped.”
Jane Westfall retweeted
A Oxford PhD student got flagged for submitting AI-generated work.
His advisor called it the most sophisticated research process he had seen in 20 years.
The student had not used AI to write a single word.
Here is the workflow that got him reported.
He starts every essay with a diagnostic he calls brutal. He dumps his rough argument into Claude and asks one question: what are the three weakest logical jumps in this reasoning, and where would a hostile examiner attack first? The AI does not write his essay. It destroys his draft, and then he rebuilds from whatever survives.
Most students using AI are doing the opposite. They hand Claude a topic and ask it to write. He hands Claude his thinking and asks it to find every place where that thinking falls apart. The difference between those two approaches is the difference between outsourcing your brain and sharpening it.
The second step is the one that made his advisor go quiet. He uploads the five most important papers in his field alongside his draft and asks Claude what claims in his argument contradict or oversimplify what these authors actually found. Most PhD students cite papers they have skimmed once. He cites papers he has been forced to genuinely reckon with, because Claude keeps catching the places where he got them wrong.
The final move is almost unfair. Before he submits anything, he pastes his conclusion and runs one more prompt. He asks what a philosopher of science would say is missing from this argument and what assumptions he is making that he has not defended. His essays come back from reviewers with phrases like unusually rigorous and demonstrates rare critical depth, and his committee has no idea that the depth came from a machine asking him harder questions than any human in his department was willing to ask.
The academic integrity hearing lasted three hours. The panel asked him to rebuild his methodology from scratch in the room. He opened his laptop and showed them exactly how the workflow ran, prompt by prompt. They did not just clear him. They gave him the highest grade in the department's history and asked him to present the process to faculty.
Here is what that story actually means. What took most PhD candidates six months of back-and-forth with advisors, he was compressing into a single session because he had figured out something almost nobody else has. AI does not make your thinking better by replacing it. It makes your thinking better by attacking it faster than any human critic ever would.
He was not using AI to write. He was using it to think harder than he could alone.
The tool is the same one everyone has. The workflow is the part nobody is teaching.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
This is Haishan Yang. He is an expelled doctoral student at University of Minnesota. He was caught using ChatGPT (not Claude) on a written exam that banned AI. He lost his appeal and failed his lawsuit against the university after being caught. He never studied at Oxford.
share.google/TJtWCZwAePAKYG…
share.google/dEpJJmMV5wNu8O…
#discovercardsucks TERRIBLE practices (yet good customer service) - never got an online order-> put in a dispute - they err'ed on the side of the merchant even with evidence the item wasn't delivered. #discovercard @discovercard #unbelievable
2
3
11
Jane Westfall retweeted
Excited to announce that @spatial_labs is launching its first Retail Store this Summer @ Platform, Culver City 🎉
In a bold new move, we’re pushing the boundaries of NFC technology further than ever in the consumer products space.
Read our announcement.
spatial-labs.com/news/spatia…
We are thrilled to formally announce the Spatial Labs Retail Store — Coming to Platform in Culver City, Summer 2024.
This move is in line with our long-term mission to make technology an extension of the human experience in a much more accessible way.
spatial-labs.com/news/spatia…
People Are Airing Out The Boomer Complaints They 100% Agree With buzzfeed.com/alanavalko/boom… via @buzzfeed
68
You know you watch too much TV/streaming when by accident you carry your remote control out to get the mail … ha #streaming
39
"OldMan Child" - dating woes. #datingwoes Just like the #manchild🤯☹️ of our 30's... yet now in their 60's and still a Child.
38
MAMA ANT - the new easy to remember acronym for the Magnificent Seven stocks. #MamaAnt #magnificent7
Meta
Alphabet
Microsoft
Apple
Amazon
Nvidia
Tesla
MAMA ANT. :-) 😆
1
32
morningstar.com/news/marketw…
Cop out… yes there ARE companies with earnings increases and they continue to layoff workers …such a cop out for #jensenhuang to use blanket capitalism to shrug off real concerns
25
Newsom could’ve started with healthcare workers at $20 an hour. now one of the only hot meals low income families used to get is now too expensive. Every healthcare worker should get paid at least $20 an hour, especially those looking after our older generations. Shame.
33
Why doesn’t OopenAI simply make their voiceover product cost prohibitive to scammers, and/or make it subscription only so most businesses are their customers not scammers and because of this cost consider hiring a voiceover person /human instead.
43
‘Getting To Zero’ highly recommended to transform from conflict to connection, from survival to ‘thrival’, victim to victory. #connection #communication #transformation #thrive #authenticity #secure-relationship #conflictisinevitable #fightfair #staytogether @JayGaddis
50
Humans are biologically social beings. We thrive in community.
Wellness starts with 'We'. Illness starts with 'I'.
137
Jane Westfall retweeted
Read this thread twice. Don’t understand 90% of it.
Perhaps it is because of the limits of my vocabulary —or is it just pure jargon monoxide?
I had five or six ideas about what unlimited interactivity could mean. My first thought was, being introverted, it sounds awful.
Replying to @lindayaX
X is the future state of unlimited interactivity – centered in audio, video, messaging, payments/banking – creating a global marketplace for ideas, goods, services, and opportunities. Powered by AI, X will connect us all in ways we’re just beginning to imagine.
Jane Westfall retweeted
Re-imagining a new way to support families and caregivers in this country #IsOneOfMyFavoriteThings
Listen to Why Care? with @reshmasaujani and Care.com CEO Tim Allen wherever you get your podcasts: https://xitter.cf/t.co/YVYtsCADqa
















