Good, but not great, TV critic (he/him)

Brighton AND Hove
Joined May 2009
I am saddened and shocked by Alice Edward's article published today in the @Telegraph and the extent to which it misrepresents my work and that of the special procedures system she was part of until July 2026. telegraph.co.uk/gift/be34cb6… Collectively, we have been unequivocal: Any sexual harassment and violence committed against women and girls on and since 7 October 2023, including hostages in captivity, are grave crimes. Survivors deserve to be heard, and perpetrators must be held accountable. I have said so before, and the full record of my engagement is here:   ohchr.org/en/press-releases/… ; ohchr.org/en/press-releases/… & ohchr.org/sites/default/file… Ms. Edwards claims that I have never condemned the reports of violence, including sexual violence against women and girls on the 7th of October, and that I have hidden behind Israel’s refusal to grant me entry. Both these claims are incorrect. My statement outlining my engagement on and since the 7th October 2023 makes it clear that I have made several démarches to gain access to primary information, survivors,  witnesses, and first responders. As I told the General Assembly on 8 October 2026, the first time a former hostage approached me was in June 2026 at the Human Rights Council. I have since met her and am handling her case under the established procedure open to every victim; where each step is subject to her full and informed consent. Ms. Edwards also leaves out the fact that when she invited me to join her allegation letter relating to the events of 7th of October 2023, I reviewed it in good faith and made written suggestions on 3rd December 2023. In my feedback, I also asked to see the primary information and testimonies Ms. Edwards had received - a normal request between mandate holders. She declined without explanation, which was the first and only time  I have been denied such a request during my mandate. Contrary to me, she did not invite me to any further engagement on Palestine and Israel after that, nor share any information on any related action she may have taken. Statements such as these only serve the wider efforts to discredit rapporteurs, including rapporteurs that criticize Israel for its serious human rights violations. They serve to dismiss every UN finding of Israeli violations of human rights and international law as being biased against the State of Israel. Ms. Edwards should understand this better than most. Since 2024, she herself was publicly accused of bias against Palestinian victims, and even endured calls for her dismissal. Ms. Edwards knows all too well how stressful it is to have your impartiality questioned. Every one of us is doing our best for victims, whoever they are, and wherever they live. The current President of the Human Rights Council was emphatically clear that mandate holders must be able "to carry out their responsibilities free from personal attacks, intimidation or undue pressure." That included Ms. Edwards when she was a rapporteur but is also expected of her today in her current engagement with rapporteurs (since her resignation as a rapporteur).
80
106
10
316
25,815
"Oh, look at that, look at that! Oh, would you look at that!" is a lovely line of commentary
"Would you look at that!" DIEGO GOMEZ SCORES FROM THE HALFWAY LINE! 🤯
3
229
Panellists on a BBC political debate show agree that a plain fact is "strange" and "nonsense"
Jo Coburn: "He also said no state has a right to exist" Dale Vince: "That was a strange thing" Coburn: "Well its nonsense" Do Jo & Dale think Rhodesia had a right to exist? Apartheid South Africa had a right to exist? The UK has a right to exist?
17
107
1,687
The most aggressively dumb thing I've seen in a long time
Interviewing a govt minister Hazarika shows a graph comparing young people claiming PIP to the size of our armed forces & declares it "tells a story about modern Britain" I can't even make a sarcastic comment about our fearless fourth estate, because Hazarika is a Lab politician
3
18
439
Jack Seale retweeted
“Hello and welcome to Newsnight. Tonight, we’re joined by Faiza Shaheen, director of Tax Justice UK. Faiza is an economist and a Visiting Professor of Practice at the London School of Economics. Faiza’s previous roles include Program Head for the Inequality and Exclusion Grand Challenge of the Pathfinders for Peaceful, Just and Inclusive Societies at the Center on International Cooperation at New York University, Director of the Centre for Labour and Social Studies, Head of Inequality and Sustainable Development at Save the Children, and Senior Researcher at the New Economics Foundation. Faiza holds a PhD and MSc from the University of Manchester and a BA in Philosophy, Politics and Economics from St John’s College, Oxford University. She is the author of a range of materials and publications covering the most salient social and economic debates of our times, including inequality, austerity, immigration, and social mobility. Faiza has over 15 years of experience researching the trends and consequences of inequality, as well as designing policies and campaigns to address the causes of inequality and exclusion. Her book, ‘Know your place: How society sets us up to fail and what we can do about it’ was published in July 2023 by Simon & Schuster. To speak over her, we’ve invited Winston Marshall, a podcaster and former member of Mumford and Sons. We hope you enjoy the programme.”
"If you want to lift up the poor, you have to create wealth." "How's that going?" Podcaster and former Mumford & Sons member Winston Marshall discusses taxes with economist and Green Party supporter Faiza Shaheen. #Newsnight
350
1,144
56
5,617
297,620
Jack Seale retweeted
Mothin Ali – apology and Correction   On 18 July 2024, I published a post on my X account in which I stated that Mr Mothin Ali, an elected official and Deputy Leader of the Green Party, was involved in the Harehills riots of July 2024 in which people attacked the police.   That statement was incorrect. In fact, Mr Ali was asked by the police to use his position of trust in the community to help bring about peace on the streets. Mr Ali attended the scene for that purpose alone. He was not involved in the disorder or violence in any way, and on the contrary he was one of the principal reasons of bringing an end to the disorder. I offer my sincere apologies to Mr Ali for my post, the harm I caused, and I have agreed to pay him compensation to vindicate his reputation.
510
951
164
1,198
148,447
I have responded to @lewishamlabour, @vickyfoxcroft, @Ese_Journo, @elliereeves and @JanetDaby regarding the green party's Zionism is Racism motion
66
262
42
739
66,798
It's perfectly in order to say you think the Zionism is Racism motion was unwise, ill-timed or what you will. The trouble is that if you do not say that what's happened since is a mammoth bad-faith campaign of hysteria and intolerance, you are contributing to that campaign.
9
47
5
241
4,316
Everyone here instinctively knows what Labour is doing. They think it's a funny bit of Westminster hoohah, rather than a deeply cynical and racist exploitation of the issue of antisemitism to protect Israel and make domestic political gains... but they know
Jon Craig: "Bridget Phillipson said this isn't an issue of party politics, noooo..." The host & guests grin & laugh When politicians & journalists laugh along at people in power weaponising antisemitism, rather than calling it out.
19
52
1,034
If I'm following correctly the Labour party's current position is that Israel is *probably* doing a genocide, but also that you definitely can't say that the ideology they're doing it in the name of is racist.
Louise Haigh to a govt minister last year: "It is impossible to conclude that this is anything less than a genocide" Haigh is now a senior cabinet minister & the govt continues arming what she called the genocidal Israeli regime. What price principles, eh?
29
262
1
2,823
40,199
Everyone can have bad moments in live interviews but it's becoming a pattern now with senior Greens: Lucas has done this kind of thing twice recently and now @GreenJennyJones has this stunningly weak response to a basic right-wing bad-faith question
"I suspect we might have been..." @AndrewMarr9 asks Baroness Jenny Jones whether the Greens have been 'infiltrated by single-issue Gaza militants'.
4
12
45
1,145
Jones has been around the block a few times, she knows the media only uses "infiltrated", "militant" and "single-issue" to describe people who stand for things the media considers beyond the pale. None of it's real and - unless you agree - there's no reason to accept it
1
112
"infiltrated" = normal party members using normal democratic processes "militant" = arguing strongly, as everyone in politics does all the time "single-issue" = a lie, designed to avoid discussing the substance of an opinion by implying it stems from an unhealthy obsession
56
The Prince Charles Cinema Secures its Future The Prince Charles Cinema is thrilled to announce that we have signed a new 25-year lease with no break clause, ensuring our projectors will keep rolling for years to come. #YouSavedThePCC
163
1,391
396
7,651
252,349
Jack Seale retweeted
In the same session he said to Nigel Farage "There's a lot we disagree on but I defend his right to say it". Really says it all.
The prime minister says the Green Party’s motion opposing a two state solution for Israel and Palestine is anti semitic - and that Labour could not form any alliance with the Greens while that remains its official policy
5
119
2
675
6,973
Jack Seale retweeted
Watch this to the end, you won’t regret it. This is what happens when you’re at happy hour and are reminded you agreed to do an interview about your race.
2,101
3,956
2,286
46,486
8,408,068
Lopez unavailable until January (mange)
👏 @Wolves midfielder Fer Lopez has been crowned September's winner of the Compare the Market Goal Hero of the month award for his winner in the Black Country Derby! 🏆 🔗 efl.com/news/2026/october/13… #EFL
176
10
38
2
498
15,791
Jack Seale retweeted
A friend recently put to me an alarmingly compelling case for why Burnham is going to call a General Election in the next few weeks. I imagine aiming for ~280+ seats and Lib Dem coalition. Is the GPEW ready to run 575 candidates? How long to get a new manifesto agreed? 🤔
14
8
2
24
2,667