Myth vs Law — Mobile recharges
Myth: Prepaid recharges carry no GST; only postpaid bills add it.
Law: Every telecom plan carries 18% GST. On prepaid it's already inside the price: a ₹349 recharge is ₹295.76 + ₹53.24 GST. Postpaid and broadband bills show it on top, so ₹899 + 18% = ₹1,060.82. Same rate, shown differently. A business can claim that GST as credit when the invoice carries its GSTIN.
#MythVsLaw #GST #GSTIndia
3
Two GSTAT Kolkata orders on credit:
2026 (11) TMI 480 — s.16(5) overrides the s.16(4) time limit for the years it covers, and booking IGST credit under CGST/SGST by mistake is a technical error, not a reason to deny it.
2026 (11) TMI 481 — a TRAN-1 entry in Table 5(a) instead of 7(a) doesn't defeat an otherwise eligible claim.
#GST #GSTIndia #ITC #GSTAT
17
Two GSTAT orders worth noting, one a clear loss:
2026 (11) TMI 483 (Dehradun) — appeal not maintainable where the APL-05 was never properly filed despite chances to cure the defects.
2026 (11) TMI 482 (Kolkata) — proceedings under s.73 can't be used to decide whether transitioned CENVAT credit was admissible under the earlier law.
#GST #GSTIndia #GSTAT #TransitionalCredit
21
2026 (11) TMI 487 — Allahabad High Court
Registration was cancelled on a system-generated notice that named no officer and no office.
Held: such a notice is invalid. A taxpayer must know who is acting and where to respond, and a cancellation built on a faceless notice can't stand.
#GST #GSTIndia #GSTRegistration #AllahabadHC
11
2026 (11) TMI 486 — Bombay High Court
An appeal was rejected as time-barred by counting the limitation as a flat 120 days.
Held: the period is three months, plus one more month that can be condoned, and both are counted as calendar months, not days. The day-count approach can't be used to shut out an appeal filed within that window.
#GST #GSTIndia #Limitation #BombayHC
7
Myth vs Law — Cab rides
Myth: App cab rides carry 18% GST.
Law: The ride itself is taxed at 5%. On Ola/Uber-type apps the platform pays that GST, so a ₹400 fare carries ₹20. The app's own booking or platform fee is a separate service at 18%: ₹30 fee → ₹5.40. Metered taxis and autos you hail directly are exempt, but the same auto booked through an app is taxed.
#MythVsLaw #GST #GSTIndia
5
2026 (11) TMI 204 — GSTAT Ernakulam
After a notice, the assessee paid tax and interest within the prescribed period, yet a penalty was imposed.
Held: s.73(8) bars penalty where tax and interest are paid in that window. Disputed IGST credit backed by invoices and a CA certificate was allowed, and earlier payments had to be adjusted. Nothing remained due.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section73 #GSTAT
10
Two GSTAT Lucknow orders on cancellation notices:
2026 (11) TMI 284 & 285 — a notice alleging wrongful ITC must name the suppliers, their GSTINs and the periods. Oral intimation can't fill that gap, and the appellate authority can't cure a vague notice with new grounds or undisclosed inquiry reports. Cancellations set aside.
#GST #GSTIndia #GSTRegistration #GSTAT
13
2026 (11) TMI 123 — GSTAT Agra
Suppressed turnover was worked out from seized diaries, and invoices produced later were brushed aside.
Held: each disputed entry must be examined and reconciled with the books and returns, with a transparent computation. Not producing invoices at the first visit doesn't by itself prove suppression; invoices produced later must be verified. Unexplained figures can't sustain tax or penalty.
#GST #GSTIndia #SuppressedTurnover #GSTAT
10
Two Allahabad HC orders:
2026 (11) TMI 441 — where the notice has hearing fields, the date, time and venue must be filled in, even if a reply was filed; otherwise the assessment and appeal orders fall.
2026 (11) TMI 440 — an appeal five days beyond the condonable period was admitted on medical certificates, so the dispute is decided on merits.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section107 #AllahabadHighCourt
9
Two Madras HC orders:
2026 (11) TMI 431 — ITC can't be denied only because returns were late, if they were filed within the extended period under s.16(5); February–March 2020 returns filed on 3 November 2020 qualify.
2026 (11) TMI 433 — a late GSTR-9 attracts the s.47 late fee only; no separate s.125 penalty for the same delay.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section16 #MadrasHighCourt
11
2026 (11) TMI 429 — Madras High Court
GST on royalty: the show-cause proceedings may go ahead to adjudication after objections and a hearing, but implementation of any assessment, including recovery, stays in abeyance until the Supreme Court decides the nature of royalty.
#GST #GSTIndia #Royalty #MadrasHighCourt
12
2026 (11) TMI 437 — Allahabad High Court (partly against the assessee)
A notice uploaded only on the portal, with no hearing, led to an assessment.
Held: the assessment goes back for a hearing. But interest under s.50 applies automatically once liability is determined, even if the show-cause notice didn't mention it; s.75(7) doesn't bar it.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section50 #AllahabadHighCourt
8
Myth vs Law — Toll plazas
Myth: GST is charged on the toll you pay.
Law:
• Toll for access to a road or bridge is exempt (Notf 12/2017-CT(R)), even when a private concessionaire collects it.
• FASTag fees charged by the bank, such as issuance or card fees, are financial services: 18%.
• Toll is a user charge, not a tax.
#MythVsLaw #GST #GSTIndia
10
Two orders against the taxpayer:
2026 (11) TMI 434 — Calcutta HC: interim protection from investigation refused; whether it would cause a miscarriage of justice needs the case diary and the State's side first.
2026 (11) TMI 428 — Madras HC: a challenge to show-cause notices failed where the officer had considered the replies and reconciliations; the remedy is a further reply and adjudication.
#GST #GSTIndia #ShowCauseNotice #HighCourt
11
On cancelled registrations:
2026 (11) TMI 438 — Karnataka HC: cancellation for not furnishing bank details (Rule 10A) set aside, since that ground wasn't in the show-cause notice.
2026 (11) TMI 442 — Madras HC: restoration after non-filing, but pre-cancellation returns, tax, interest and late fees within 45 days, and unutilised ITC can't be used for those dues.
#GST #GSTIndia #GSTRegistration #Rule10A
15
Two Madras HC orders on the s.128A waiver:
2026 (11) TMI 432 — if no order issues within three months of the applicant's reply, the waiver is deemed approved (Rule 164); a rejection passed after that doesn't undo it.
2026 (11) TMI 430 — self-assessed tax already paid doesn't exclude waiver of the related interest and penalty, and an SPL-05 approval can't be voided outside Rule 164's exceptions.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section128A #MadrasHighCourt
7
2026 (11) TMI 436 — Allahabad High Court
A demand was confirmed without a personal hearing, and for more than the show-cause notice proposed.
Held: an adverse order needs a hearing, and notices or reminders giving no date, time or venue don't meet it. Under s.75(7), tax, interest or penalty can't exceed the amount in the notice. Order quashed; fresh proceedings only in accordance with law.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section75 #AllahabadHighCourt
13
Myth vs Law — Donations
Myth: GST applies when you donate to a charity or temple.
Law:
• A donation with nothing supplied in return isn't a supply: no GST.
• A plaque saying "donated by" isn't advertising: no GST (Circular 116/35/2019).
• If the donor gets publicity in return, it's a taxable service at 18%.
• Rooms let by religious trusts at up to ₹1,000 a day: exempt.
#MythVsLaw #GST #GSTIndia
5
Two Allahabad HC orders on personal hearings:
2026 (11) TMI 296 — a notice that asked for a reply but gave no date, time or venue for a hearing, with none afforded, vitiated the adjudication.
2026 (11) TMI 293 — not filing a written reply doesn't forfeit the right to be heard; marking the hearing 'not applicable' isn't enough.
#GST #GSTIndia #Section75 #AllahabadHighCourt
18

