idharudhartales.blogspot.com…
*IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 159- THE UNEASY MAHARAJA.*
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
Uncle ji, please help!”
I was leaving the banquet hall toilet when a desperate voice stopped me.
The groom stood with his sherwani lifted above his waist. His friend was kneeling before him, struggling with something I couldn't see.
For a moment, I feared I had interrupted something obscene. I turned to escape.
“Uncle ji! Please!”
Closer inspection revealed the crisis. The nada of his pyjama had developed a knot that refused to open.
Nature was calling urgently. The knot wasn't listening.
Fortunately, they had summoned a Sardar. A turban pin, a baaz, is invariably available for emergencies. A little manipulation with my pin, and the knot surrendered.
The groom dashed inside. I emerged feeling like a decorated rescue officer.
Two drinks later, I checked on my patient. Disaster again! His friend had retied the nada so loosely that the pyjama was preparing to desert.
Every few minutes, the groom tugged at his trousers beneath the magnificent sherwani. A man pulling up his pants is hardly regal. Doing it beneath royal embroidery is pure comedy.
“Mainu ki!” I thought, returning to the bar.
A sip of rum awakened the inventor in me. Why not elastic-waist pyjamas? Better still, side pockets in sherwanis through which a groom could discreetly hoist his slipping trousers?
Another sip brought wisdom
A sherwani is perhaps the only *garment in which a man looks like a Maharaja while enjoying fewer freedoms than a prisoner.*
Why wear such unfamiliar armour on your wedding day?
I imagined the family conference.
His fiancée: “You'll look so handsome!”
His sister: “Bhaiya, don't be boring!”
His mother, delivering the decisive blow: “Beta, meri khushi ke liye!”
The groom had surrendered before the battle began.
Days later, another wedding confirmed my suspicions.
An old friend was wearing a splendid sherwani at his daughter's marriage. Knowing him for twenty years, I knew whose idea it wasn't.
His daughter had exercised her constitutional right to dress her father.
He smiled magnificently for the camera. But standing beside him, I noticed his shoulders twitching.
He was itchy.
Not an ordinary itch, but one lodged precisely where his hand couldn't reach through the stiff sherwani. He discreetly rubbed the embroidery, hoping the itch would understand the message.
His mouth smiled. His eyes searched desperately for somewhere private to scratch.
At our weddings, a man dresses like a Maharaja. The illusion lasts until he tries to sit, scratch or visit the toilet.
Later, I asked a young lady why people must wear clothes in which they couldn't sit, eat, scratch or visit the toilet comfortably.
She looked horrified.
“Uncle ji, it's my wedding! Everyone must look good and make it memorable. Comfort doesn't matter.”
“And nature's call?”
“We can take medicine to control it!”
I stared. Here was a generation ready to suspend bodily functions for Instagram.
What if the medicine failed? Worse, what if it worked too well? Would the photographer capture the moment the groom's eyes popped out?
The sherwani must be perfect. The lehenga magnificent. The photographs unforgettable. Whether their occupants can breathe is apparently a minor administrative detail.
As for women's wedding attire, I shall say nothing. Years in the Army taught me never to open a second front unnecessarily.
After all, I had survived one groom's nada. I wasn't going to risk an entire lehenga.
*Photo mein muskaan, andar toofaan!*
Jai Hind!
Critique welcome.
IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 158- JAZBA MEDAL
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
“Why do you want the names of the officers who recommended reducing Agniveers' leave to 30 days?” asked my friend.
“I want to recommend them for the Jazba Medal. Imagine the tremendous service they have rendered to the nation! Thirty days of annual leave and thirty days of casual leave saved. What patriotism!”
My friend smiled.
“Sir, I doubt saving money was their intention. They were probably looking for a quick fix.”
“Quick fix?”
“Yes. Someone must have pointed out that during four years of service, an Agniveer would spend six months in training, considerable time on leave and some in transit. Effectively, he might serve for only about 28 months. So, instead of examining the problem, somebody simply reduced the leave.”
“Brilliant! Less leave, more soldiering!”
“Sir, have you spoken to any Agniveer from South India or the Northeast?”
“Of course! I belong to the Madras Regiment. I have met several. Excellent boys! Full of josh!”
“What did they say about leave?”
“Well, I didn't ask. I was impressed by their training and enthusiasm.”
“So you saw their josh but never asked about their problems?”
That hurt. Particularly because he was right.
“Let me tell you about an Agniveer I met while flying to Kerala,” he continued. “The boy was going home on leave and was quite upset.”
“Why?”
“He said, ‘Sir, train se jao toh aadhi chhutti khatam. Aur plane se jao toh ek mahine ki tankhah!(If you travel by train half your leave exhausts. And if you travel by plane a full month’s pay)’”
That struck me. Even a gora planning leave for Indian soldiers had planned clear 56 days at home for a jawan. Which is equal to two menstrual cycles. Maybe that is why they banned marriage for Agniveers. Still 30 days of leave is far too less.
Imagine an Agniveer from Kerala posted in Kashmir, or one from the Northeast serving in Rajasthan. By the time he reaches home, his mother has barely finished welcoming him before he must start worrying about the return journey.
“And what could the planners have done?” I asked.
“Sir, they could have recommended air travel for Agniveers posted far from home, particularly where surface travel consumes several days. And I am very sure this Government would have agreed to such a proposal.”
“But that would have required somebody to make a case for the soldier rather than merely adjust figures in a file.”
I was reminded of a story from the Indian fables.
Some monkeys, shivering in the cold, mistook a firefly for a spark and tried to light fire with it. A bird repeatedly warned them that it wasn't fire. But the monkeys were so busy implementing their brilliant solution that they refused to listen.
“But why would intelligent and brilliant planners recommend such a thing?” I asked.
“Sir, haven't you heard the old philosophy of career management followed by Smart Alecs the world over?”
“Which one?”
‘Neeche wale ka tel nikalo, upar wale ki malish karo (Extract oil from subordinate, and use it to massage the boss).'’
I laughed.
“That's rather harsh.”
“Maybe, Sir. But whose inconvenience was reduced? The administration's. And whose inconvenience increased? The jawan's.”
I thought for a moment.
“So you don't think these people deserve the Jazba Medal?”
“Certainly they do, Sir. But first, let us test their jazba.”
“How?”
“Stop their leave encashment. Reduce their salaries by half. Tell them it's necessary for national savings.”
“And then?”
“If they accept cheerfully, give them the medal.”
I sat quietly.
My friend wasn't finished.
“After all, Sir, it is very easy to demonstrate patriotism when somebody else is paying for it.”
Jai Hind!
*IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 157- GAADI GHODA*
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
“Gadhe! You could have got yourself killed!”
That was my father's reaction when I told him how an LTTE militant had slipped through our cordon during an operation in Sri Lanka.
A lady journalist had come to cover our operations. Suddenly, I discovered great affection for the local children and began distributing toffees, hoping the photographer would capture my humanitarian side.
The photograph appeared in a national magazine under the heading ‘Sri Lanka: IPKF gains public acceptance in Batticaloa’
I was thrilled. My father was furious. Apparently, he was worried that due to such distractions I or my jawans might get killed.
That was my first lesson in the hazards of publicity.
Unfortunately, the desire to see one's face in the media survives retirement. In fact, retirement makes it worse. Nobody wants your opinion, while everybody else's opinion seems to be on television.
When Agnipath was announced, a news channel called.
“Sir, we are organising a debate on Agnipath. Would you join us?”
My heart leapt.
National television! My face on the screen! Defence Expert flashing below my name.
But I acted pricey.
“Let me see.”
“Sir, we pay five thousand rupees.”
Five thousand!
My reluctance somewhat negotiable.
But what would I say?
The soldier in me had reservations about Agnipath. Camaraderie, regimental spirit and No Man Left Behind are built on trust and selflessness. Would young soldiers competing for limited permanent retention develop the same spirit?
I had my doubts.
“Sir, shall I confirm?”
“Give me ten minutes.”
I began looking at the courses of action as per the appreciation format, in the Staff College entrance examination.
A revolutionary reform! Younger Army! Reduced pension bills! More money for modernisation! Disciplined youth returning to society!
With a little imagination, I could make it sound like the greatest military innovation since gunpowder.
Who knows? Such enlightened thinking might impress the right quarters. Some respectable post-retirement appointment might follow.
Kam se kam gaadi-ghoda toh milega!
Not bad.
Then I remembered a television debate where a junior participant had publicly ridiculed a senior retired officer. The anchor had thoroughly enjoyed it. I hadn't.
What if some youngster questioned my understanding of soldiering while the anchor screamed, “One minute, Brigadier!” without allowing me even ten seconds?
Suddenly, I heard my father's voice.
"Your jawans once trusted you with their life on your word. And now you are calculating what your words might fetch you. Five thousand today, gaadi-ghoda tomorrow. Is that what your rank was worth?”
That hurt.
I picked up the phone.
“Sorry. I won't be able to join.”
Then, on 4 November 2026, came the announcement of major changes to Agnipath.y
I felt relieved.
Imagine if I had declared the original scheme the finest military reform in history. I would now be explaining, with equal conviction, why changing that magnificent reform was an even greater reform.
And somewhere in heaven, my father would certainly have been watching.
I could almost hear him.
“Ab kaise apni shakal dikhaoge? Bahut shauk tha na apna thobda TV par dekhne ka!”
I smiled.
In Sri Lanka, my longing for a photograph had allowed a militant to escape.
This time, my longing for television fame had nearly made an a** of myself.
Jai Hind!
BARSATI CAPTAIN
A photograph taken in Sri Lanka in 1988. Actually in field I was given temporary rank of Captain on paper. This was because the CO felt that in the high threat environment in case I get killed the parents should be able to get higher benefits. Had not worn the badges of rank of a Captain. One day the Adjutant called that a photograph with Captain's epaulet is required for pasting on the appraisal form. A camera was sent to the far flung post for photograph. But no one realised that I don't have Captains epaulets.
So a Subedar and a Lieutenant's epaulets were combined to make barsati Captain out of me.
Jai Hind!
IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 156 -T SHIRT WALA FARMER
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
“You can't understand the miseries of a farmer. After all, no one in your family has ever been a Kissan.”
My host made this observation over lunch at a five-star hotel. I was still recovering from the shock of seeing the menu prices when his remark brought me back to my senses.
He was wearing a T-shirt displaying a magnificent tractor fitted with speakers large enough to address an election rally. The speakers proclaimed, “NO FARMERS, NO FOOD, NO FUTURE.”
I felt guilty. My great grandfather had sold our agricultural land, thereby depriving three generations of our family of the moral qualifications to discuss farming.
Fortunately, the waiter arrived with our food, giving me an opportunity to contemplate the farmer's miseries.
The Bhindi Masala reminded me of the terrible itching caused by the tiny hairs on the plant while harvesting it. The chapati brought visions of a farmer threshing wheat in the scorching heat of May, with dust and chaff entering his eyes, nose, ears and practically every opening God had provided in the human body.
Then there were sugarcane leaves cutting the farmer's arms, chillies burning his fingers and paddy fields shrivels and wrinkles his feet submerged in muddy water for hours.
I shuddered.
My great grandfather had certainly shown remarkable foresight. By selling our land, he had ensured that his descendants would suffer from income tax rather than itching, cuts and muddy feet.
I continued eating, chewing my food and my insult and guilt together.
“Tea or coffee after lunch?” my host asked.
“Tea,” I replied.
Another mistake.
I imagined women plucking tea leaves on slippery hillsides, their fingers aching while leeches enjoyed a free breakfast on their ankles. Coffee growers battled insects and damp undergrowth. Cardamom growers spent hours bending to collect tiny capsules while mosquitoes collected their share of blood.
And here was I, sitting in an air-conditioned room, occasionally complaining, “Chai mein dum nahin hai. Thodi kadak banao.”
I looked admiringly at my host. He was enjoying his lunch with the satisfaction of a man who had already discharged his responsibility towards the farming community by purchasing the appropriate T-shirt.
Meanwhile, the fish on my plate reminded me of the hard life of fishermen.
“Yeh clear karo,” my host instructed the waiter.
I looked up. Half a chapati, some dal, a generous helping of sabzi and nearly half the fish remained on his plate.
“Didn't you like the food?” I asked.
“Loved it. Excellent!”
“Then why leave so much?”
“Arre Tipu, I cannot afford to overeat. One must look after one's health.”
“Then why take so much?”
He looked surprised.
“What's the problem? I paid for it.”
The waiter hesitated.
“Sir, shall I pack the remaining food?”
“Rehne do. Itna sa khana kaun le jayega?”
I remembered a line from the Taittiriya Upanishad:
“अन्नं न निन्द्यात्।” — Do not disparage food.
Apparently, our ancestors had forgotten to mention five-star hotels.
The farmer had done his duty by producing the food. My host had done his by paying for it.
The dustbin, apparently, was expected to do the eating.
IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 155— AUTHOR IN YOU
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
“Pure shit!”
That was my mentor's verdict after reading the first ten pages of my first novel's manuscript.
It hurt. I had spent months writing it. I had hoped for praise, perhaps a few corrections. Instead, I had received a literary court-martial.
I summoned my courage.
“Sir, at least tell me why.”
“First, your vocabulary. Why use words that send the reader reaching for a dictionary? Are you writing a novel or conducting an English examination?”
He had a point. Somewhere during my education, I had acquired the belief that difficult words made a man appear learned. Apparently, I had mistaken vocabulary for wisdom.
“Second, your sentences are too long. By the time the reader reaches the end, he has forgotten the beginning.”
“But, Sir, I am trying to explain everything.”
“Have you ever tried filling a spoon under a fast-running tap?”
“Yes, Sir.”
“What happens?”
“Most of the water spills.”
“Exactly! Your sentences are the tap. The reader's mind is the spoon. You pour words faster than he can absorb them. Most of what you write simply flows away.”
He saw the tutti-frutti-flavoured confusion on my face.
“And third, you write as though you are sitting on a mountain of knowledge and your reader is somewhere down in the valley.”
“But, Sir, water flows from a higher level to a lower level!”
He smiled.
“Let us assume you and your reader are two cups. Yours is full. His is empty. Now pour your water into his cup from two feet above. What happens?”
“Some spills over the sides.”
“And some splashes out. Worse, the reader must struggle to catch what you are pouring. Why make him work so hard? Bring your cup close. Pour gently, something like pouring beer in the mug.”
I was beginning to feel less like a novelist and more like a bartender.
“Remember,” he continued, “you are not writing to prove how intelligent you are. You are writing to communicate.”
Then came my first assignment.
“Write something. Simple words. Short sentences. No showing off.”
I worked for a week, removing difficult words, shortening sentences and sacrificing expressions I had considered literary masterpieces.
He read my revised effort.
“Achha hai.”
My heart leapt.
“But it has no feeling.”
My heart returned to its original position.
“Sir, now what?”
“Writing should be like good ice cream. You finish eating it, but the taste lingers. Your reader should be left with a smile, a tear, anger, regret—something!”
He handed me another assignment.
“Write one or two sentences each on stupidity, regret, royalty and achievement. Don't describe the emotion. Make the reader feel it.”
A week later, I returned with four examples drawn from military life.
He read them and shook his head.
“These convey your feelings as a soldier. Remember, everyone is not a soldier! Even your fellow soldiers may not have had the same experiences. Your reader may be a teacher, a shopkeeper, a homemaker or a child. Find experiences everyone understands.”
Another week. Another attempt.
This time, I abandoned the battlefield and searched for inspiration in everyday life.
I handed him my revised answers.
*STUPIDITY:* The feeling I got as a child when I stood on a chair, leaned against its backrest and brought the whole thing crashing down. You surely feel stupid if it's a repetition.
*REGRET:*. The feeling when you step into dog shit and realise that looking where you were going would have been considerably easier than cleaning your shoe.
*ROYALTY:* The feeling of sitting on the toilet in the morning, newspaper in hand, with nobody to disturb you. For those precious minutes, you are the undisputed ruler of your kingdom.
*ACHIEVEM......
Please click the link in comments to read the rest.
IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 154 — THE CREEPERS. Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
“Always run to the target and check your score. Never let anyone carry your rifle or rucksack unless you are injured. And when you rise in rank, open your own car door.”
That was Subedar Diwan Singh, an old soldier from my native place, giving me advice I would remember for life.
“Dada ji, why all these precautions?”
He smiled.
“As you rise in rank, people will compete to make your life comfortable. Someone will carry your rifle. Someone will open your door. Someone will laugh at your jokes, however poor. And someone will praise your shooting even when you have missed the target!”
“That sounds rather pleasant,” I said.
“Of course! That is why it is dangerous.”
He leaned forward.
“The day you stop checking your target, you will start believing their lies. The day you stop carrying your load, you will forget its weight. And the day you allow others to think for you, you will lose your judgment.”
He paused.
“Remember, son, the greatest danger may not be the enemy in front of you, but the flatterer behind you.”
A few days ago, I remembered Subedar Diwan Singh while attending the centenary celebrations of the UPSC.
The invitation prohibited electronic watches and remote car keys. Rather than risk trouble at security, I left my car and mobile phone at home and travelled by Metro.
I carried some cash—an ancient instrument of survival that had served humanity remarkably well before smartphones arrived.
We were required to be seated by 9.30 a.m., although the programme would begin only at 11. Naturally, I arrived at 9.15. Old military habits die hard.
With no screen to stare at, I had something increasingly rare.
Time to think.
My thoughts wandered to a high-mast floodlight tower at Hari Nagar Bus Depot. Creepers had climbed its tall structure, winding themselves around the pole and spreading across the framework until they began covering the lights.
Subedar Diwan Singh's warning returned.
Wasn't this how people in power sometimes became prisoners of their own admirers?
First came assistance. Then loyalty. Then admiration. Gradually, an inner circle formed, anticipating every wish, applauding every decision and ensuring that unpleasant truths seldom disturbed the person at the centre.
History was full of such creepers.
Stalin discounted warnings of Hitler's impending invasion. Saddam Hussein's commanders, fearful of displeasing him, concealed military weaknesses. Even NASA's Challenger disaster exposed how organisational pressures could prevent critical warnings from reaching decision-makers.
Different circumstances, but a common danger: the growing distance between authority and reality.
And the creepers need not be wicked. Some genuinely admire their leader. Some seek advancement. Others simply fear displeasing him.
At precisely eleven, the reception committee hurried out.
The Prime Minister was arriving.
I watched Modi ji enter. I admire him as a strong leader who has given the country confidence and momentum. Yet I have serious reservations about two of his decisions—the Agnipath scheme and the sudden COVID-19 lockdown, which caused immense hardship to poor and vulnerable workers.
I wondered how often those in power receive advice they would rather not hear.
Perhaps frequently. Perhaps rarely.
From where I sat, there was no way of knowing.
But Subedar Diwan Singh's warning was not meant for soldiers alone. It applied equally to kings, presidents, prime ministers and anyone whose position attracted an ever-growing circle of admirers.
I was particularly pleased when the Prime Minister spoke of the bravery of Captain Smit Machchhar aboard a Flydubai aircraft. It was heartening to hear courage acknowledged at such a national gathering.
.....please click the link in comments to read the rest.
IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 153— THE INVISIBLE SOLDIER
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
“What made your country so advanced in warfare?” asked the Presiding Judge.
“My Lord, it began in the Iran–US war.”
The courtroom fell silent.
“That war taught us 2 things. We had the national will to fight any powerful enemy. But if we competed in buying bigger military toys, our treasury would empty before his armoury.”
“Toys?” asked the Defence Minister.
“Tanks, guns, aircraft, ships, missiles. Every generation wants something bigger, faster and costlier.”
“What changed?”
“Drones. The sky became full of them. Like mosquitoes.
Justice Coconut slapped his neck.
“Everybody wanted anti-drone weapons. Guns, missiles, even drones to kill drones. Unfortunately, the mosquito was often cheaper than the bullet.”
“So you jammed them?”
“We tried. But the same spectrum supported civilian communications, commerce and essential services.”
“What did you do?”
“Something extraordinary happened. Our politicians started thinking.”
The courtroom laughed.
“Somebody studying Ukraine and Iran asked a simple question. What must a drone do before it can kill a soldier?”
“Carry a weapon?” suggested Ladyfinger.
“No.”
“Locate him?”
“Exactly.”
I let that sink in.
“We couldn't hide every tank or gun. But individual soldiers were different. Instead of spending everything on destroying the enemy's eyes, we invested in becoming difficult to see.”
“Invisible soldiers?”
“Not Harry Potter, My Lady. Better camouflage, coatings, materials and reduced signatures. Enough to confuse detection and delay targeting.”
The Defence Minister frowned.
“Expensive!”
“Less expensive than replacing dead soldiers and destroyed equipment. Naturally, the Big Toy Lobby objected.”
“Who?”
“People who believe military modernisation must be large enough to appear in a parade.”
Even Ladyfinger smiled.
“The government then examined technological plans prepared between 1990 and 2015. We had ignored the disruptive technologies like drones and artificial intelligence.”
“What happened to the planners?”
“Mass purging. Even a few retired experts were called back to explain why the future had arrived without consulting them.”
“Were they punished?” asked Coconut.
“Some were. The environment changes, suddenly, everybody became interested in predicting the real future. Not the copy paste type. ”
Laughter returned.
“But something useful emerged. We stopped asking which bigger weapon to buy and began asking what military effect we needed.”
The Minister interrupted.
“Ridiculous! Should we discard our new fleet because ships are visible?”
“Certainly not. But perhaps somebody is already wondering how to defeat your expensive warship without buying another warship.”
“With what?”
“Imagine hundreds of small autonomous underwater devices or drones. Some observe. Some confuse sensors. Others threaten a ship when circumstances permit.”
“Tiny toys against my fleet?”
“Minister, the point isn't whether my imaginary machines work tomorrow. It is whether your fleet is prepared for an enemy who refuses to fight on your terms.”
“They need batteries, guidance, identification!”
“Of course. Those are engineering problems, with serious safety and control requirements. The strategic question comes first.”
“Which is?”
“Why compete with the enemy's strength when you can change the problem?”
Coconut leaned forward.
“So what made your country advanced? Drones? AI? Invisible uniforms?”
“No, My Lord.”
“Then?”
“We stopped worshipping weapons.”
Silence.
“A tank, aircraft, missile or rifle is only a tool. The moment an army falls in love with its tools, somebody invents a cheaper way to defeat them.”
The Presiding Judge studied me.
“And you discovered this 20 years ago?”
“No, My Lord. We rediscovered something ancient.”
“What?”
“Original thinking is cheaper than imitation. But it requires considerably more courage.”
The Judge struck his gavel.
“Court adjourned.”
Coconut said.
“Brigadier! Doesn't your execution worry you?”
Read answer in the blog
6
534
IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 152 – WHO IS THE DOG?
Brig PS Gothra (Retd)
Not very long ago, beside a very important sea, there was a very large desert.
Three animals lived there: a rich Camel, sitting on more oil than water. A proud Persian Leopard, whose spots never changed. And a Fox, smaller than everybody else, but with sharp teeth and an even sharper brain.
For years, the Camel and the Leopard fought each other. And the Fox slept peacefully.
Then, on March 2023, the Fox saw the Leopard was drinking tea with the Camel. A Panda had invited them both to Beijing, poured the tea himself, and made them shake hands.
The Fox rang up his oldest friend, the Eagle across the ocean.
“We have a problem. The Leopard has made peace.”
There was a long pause.
“Isn’t peace a good thing?”
“Today the Leopard drinks tea with the Camel. Tomorrow the others will join them. And one day, they will make your dollars worthless.”
The Eagle stopped smiling.
Seven months later, on 7 October 2023, a Mongoose living just across the Fox’s fence attacked him without warning. The Fox was furious. He spun around to face the Leopard.
“That’s YOUR friend!”
The Leopard shrugged. “My friend, yes. My servant, no.”
Soon a Porcupine in the northern hills started shooting quills over the fence as well.
The Fox hit back, hard. The Eagle flew in to help him. And stones began landing near the Leopard’s own den.
The Leopard did some quick maths. Fighting the Fox and the Eagle together would be foolish. So he remembered a story his grandfather used to tell.
A farmer had a cow that refused to give milk. He begged her, pushed her and pulled her. Nothing worked. So one day, the farmer tied his dog in front of the cow, and every time the cow refused, he beat the dog. The dog howled. The cow panicked. And the milk came.
The Leopard’s whiskers twitched. If you can’t scare the cow, make the dog scream.
He looked around the desert. There was no shortage of dogs. He assessed that if he used the stick called Hormuz, the dogs would scream. Then he realised that a Jackal living beside the sea had another stick called the Bab al-Mandab Strait. That could make the rest of the dogs scream too. And the trouble started drifting towards the Camel’s own tent.
The Camel stormed over to the Leopard. “I am choked because of YOUR friends!”
The Leopard coolly said, “My friends, yes. My servants, no.”
The Camel had heard that line before. Somewhere. Quite recently.
He narrowed his eyes.
“Tell me something. In your grandfather’s story… who is the dog?”
“Depends.”
The Camel gulped. “And the farmer?”
The Leopard looked at the Fox, Eagle and his own reflection.
“That, my friend, is the job everybody here is fighting for.”
Meanwhile, sitting under the only wall in the desert, the Panda went on munching bamboo.
Nobody threw stones at him or shot quills at him or touched his ships.
He was busy selling things to everybody. Including the stones.
Just then an Indian Elephant came lumbering up the road, pulling an oil tanker. The road was blocked.
“Who started all this?” he asked.
Silence.
“Fine,” sighed the Elephant. “Then who is winning?”
Every single animal pointed at himself.
Then the Elephant looked at the price board at the petrol pump.
“Strange. You are all winning……and I am paying.”
The Panda strolled over, all smiles.
“Petrol expensive?”
“Very.”
Panda’s smile grew wider.
“Have you considered an electric car? I have one to sell you.”
The Elephant saw the caption on the wall behind the Panda:
न कश्चित् कस्यचिन्मित्रं न कश्चित् कस्यचिद् रिपुः ।
अर्थतस्तु निबध्यन्ते मित्राणि रिपवस्तथा ॥
— महाभारत, शान्तिपर्व
“There are no permanent friends and no permanent enemies.
Friends and enemies arise from considerations of interest.”
— Mahabharata, Shanti Parva
The Elephant read it twice and said to the Panda.
“Now I understand why you hadn’t taken anybody’s side.”
The Panda smiled.
“I have. Mine.”
Jai Hind.
Note:- Your wisdom is solicited in the comments
4
501
On the occassion of Animal Transport Remembrance Day. I remember a muleteer in the family youtu.be/j9Ak7fLC0Kk?si=T9MQ…
26 September is celebrated as Animal Transport Remembrance Day to honour the valour, courage and sacrifices of the mules and muleteers, who served with exceptional endurance and unwavering dedication across high-altitude regions, jungle terrain and other challenging operational environments.
Their indispensable role in sustaining forward posts, ensuring uninterrupted logistics support and assisting communities during natural disasters remains an integral part of the proud legacy of the Army Service Corps #ASC.
1
313
*IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 151- PADDING AND DECEPTION*
Brig PS Gothra
As the court convened, the Principal Judge said, “Brigadier, yesterday you promised us something about padding.”
“Yes, My Lord. I did. But I have decided not to tell that story. A lady heard about it and objected rather violently. She said it does not behove a retired Brigadier to tell sexist stories.”
Justice Ladyfinger shook her head. “This is 2047. Who is this regressive lady? If you remove all that, your stories will become insipid.”
“So today, instead of padding, I will tell you about deception. In September 2044, after its Defence Acquisition Planning Conference, the Republic of Kaddu announced that it was acquiring S-800 air-defence systems.”
The Defence Minister interrupted. “So what? We had the superior S-900.”
“Exactly, Minister. You had the S-900. You also had nearly five times as many systems as Republic of Kaddu.”
Coconut leaned forward. “Then how the hell did they win the war?”
“That,” said the Brigadier, “is where the story becomes interesting. Soon after receiving the S-800s, the Republic of Kaddu began displaying them to the public. One week, seven or eight systems appeared at different locations. The following week, apparently different systems appeared elsewhere. Then more appeared. Each time, the crews were changed. The vehicle markings were changed. The equipment numbers were changed. Photographs appeared in newspapers and on social media. Naturally, intelligence agencies began counting. The numbers kept growing. Your intelligence people concluded that Kaddu possessed considerably more S-800 systems than had originally been estimated.”
The Defence Minister shrugged. “Nothing wrong with that. In military intelligence, it is safer to overestimate the enemy than underestimate him.”
“Normally, yes.” The Brigadier smiled. “But only if the enemy isn't deliberately helping you overestimate him.”
The courtroom went quiet. “The Republic of Kaddu wasn't displaying its strength. It was padding its strength.”
Justice Ladyfinger laughed. “So you managed to bring padding into the story after all.”
“My Lady, this padding is completely gender-neutral.”
Even the Defence Minister smiled. “But Kaddu had another purpose,” the Brigadier continued. “Their displays provoked a reaction—if they could flaunt their S-800s, why shouldn’t you display your superior S-900s?”
“What was wrong with that?” said the Minister.
"Nothing—if Kaddu merely wanted to see them.”
The Minister stopped smiling. “They wanted something else?”
“They wanted to touch them. Kaddu’s sleeper agents mingled with visitors and secretly attached tiny trackers to the S-900s.”
The Defence Minister stared at him.
“And when war began, they knew where your S-900s were. They destroyed them, clearing corridors for their aircraft and missiles.”
Coconut frowned. “But we destroyed many of their S-800s too.”
“My assumption is that you destroyed exactly what they wanted you to destroy.”
“Meaning?”
“Decoys.”
The Defence Minister sat upright.
“What evidence do you have?”
“Two days before my arrest, I saw an intelligence summary. It mentioned two Indian civilians who had repeatedly visited the Republic of Kaddu during the previous eighteen months.”
“So?”
“The moment I saw their names, several things suddenly fitted together. They manufactured military decoys.”
Silence.
“First, they made a small number of S-800s look like a large number. Second, they induced you to publicly display your own S-900s. Third, they used those displays to track your systems. And fourth, when the war began, you may have expended costly weapons destroying targets that were never real.”
Justice Ladyfinger leaned forward.
“So one deception created another?”
“No, My Lady. One deception induced us to deceive ourselves. But let me tell where is the fault.”..
Link in comments to read the rest
*IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 150 — MINI-SKIRTS AND STRATEGIC THINKING*
Brig PS Gothra (Retd.)
"You may begin, Brigadier,” said the Presiding Judge. “Do you really believe they lack strategic thinking?”
“Not at all, My Lord. Your military officers and bureaucrats are probably among the brightest young people in the country when they enter service. They are the chosen ones.”
“Then what goes wrong?”
“They forget the objective.”
“Explain.”
“Perhaps an anecdote will help. In 1984 about 63 years ago, I appeared for an entrance examination at a mass communication institute in the capital of my country New Delhi. Unfortunately, my seat was surrounded by young ladies wearing mini-skirts. I knew all the answers. Instead, I spent my time helping the girls around me. Naturally I failed.”
The courtroom laughed.
“A few years later, I found myself sitting in an ambush at midnight. The ground was wet. Mosquitoes were biting and some ambitious insect had started crawling up my underwear. I couldn't even move to remove it without compromising the ambush.”
I paused.
“Sitting there, I wondered: Had I concentrated on my own answer sheet that day, perhaps that night I might have been sitting beside one of those mini-skirts.”
“Stick to strategy and thinking,” said the Judge.
“My Lord. Intelligence gives you options. Strategy requires remembering the objective. My objective that day was to pass the examination. Somewhere between the first and second mini-skirt, I forgot it.”
The Defence Minister leaned forward.
“So what happens to our bright officers?”
“Two things, Minister. A few remain excellent strategic thinkers. But, unfortunately, they employ their finest strategic thinking on the wrong battlefield. Their careers, My Lord.”
The courtroom became quiet.
“I have seen otherwise brilliant officers analyse their bosses with greater accuracy than they analysed the enemy. They know what the boss likes, what he dislikes and which idea he wants to hear.”
Justice Ladyfinger laughed.
“You are exaggerating.”
“Perhaps, My Lady. But I have seen considerable operational planning devoted to inaugurations, ribbon-cuttings, seminars and the unveiling of coffee-table books that nobody subsequently opens.”
I straightened myself.
“Then there is the problem of stealing credit, that requires higher strategic ability. A subordinate produces the idea. Somebody else prepares the presentation. A third fellow executes it. Then, at the appropriate moment, the strategic thinker appears and says—"As I had visualised…”
“And the others?” asked Justice Coconut.
“You recruit racehorses, My Lord. Then the system gradually converts many of them into mules. Strong. Dependable. Hardworking. Excellent at carrying loads. The system consumes their strategic thinking ability. A young bureaucrat spends years fire fighting, handling law and order, revenue, elections, floods, VIP visits, court cases, complaints—and files generated by people who believe that movement of paper is evidence of progress.”
“And police officers?”
“Same problem. Except their phones ring more often—and almost everybody calling knows somebody important.”
“And military officers?”
“They have a different problem.”
“What?”
“The tight leash.”
“What leash?” Asked Justice .....
Click the link given in comments to read the rest.
Thank you sir for reposting with that comment. We give lessons free of cost. So when you achieve something it is better to pat your back in whichever platform. Regards.
I seriously didn't get as to why there was a need to post this.....unless sir ji bhi #NEET coaching centre ke raste par ja rahe hain!
👻🤣
3
12
1,147
Brig P S Gothra (Retd) retweeted
I seriously didn't get as to why there was a need to post this.....unless sir ji bhi #NEET coaching centre ke raste par ja rahe hain!
👻🤣
Brig RK Bhatia (Retd) and I are proud to inform you that all the candidates who listened to our Military History lessons on @brigsspeak_ or read our lessons from deltatac.shop are going to pass in the subject in DSSC Entrance exam 2026. Analysis of the papers is given below. We will give full support in Mil History and Current Affairs for DSSC 2027. Limited support in TAC A and Science and Mil Tech like giving likely questions as we don't have access to prescribed study material.
Brig RK Bhatia (Retd) and I are proud to inform you that all the candidates who listened to our Military History lessons on @brigsspeak_ or read our lessons from deltatac.shop are going to pass in the subject in DSSC Entrance exam 2026. Analysis of the papers is given below. We will give full support in Mil History and Current Affairs for DSSC 2027. Limited support in TAC A and Science and Mil Tech like giving likely questions as we don't have access to prescribed study material.
*IDHAR UDHAR KI BAAT 149 —THE EYEBROW THEORY IN WARFARE - Brig PS Gothra (Retd.)*
The Presiding Judge said, “Brigadier, you may continue.”
“My Lord, Helen, Julia Roberts and Madhubala were known for thinner eyebrows. Pamela Anderson, Deepika Padukone and Alia Bhatt have, at different times, carried bolder eyebrows. All were considered exceptionally beautiful women. The problem is that millions of women copied whatever eyebrow style happened to be fashionable. A particular eyebrow may look wonderful on one face and ridiculous on another.”
Justice Ladyfinger instinctively touched her own eyebrows.
“Today,” I continued, “AI can even help you. The principle is simple: first understand your face. Then choose your eyebrows.”
The Presiding Judge looked irritated.
“Brigadier, stick to warfare.”
“That, My Lord, is warfare. Force structuring is exactly like eyebrows. You created three Integrated Theatre Commands in 2032.”
“Yes. After years of deliberation,” said the Defence Minister.
“Precisely. By the time you implemented the answer, the question had changed. With the advent of AI and other emerging technologies, geographically rigid theatre commands are no longer the optimum mechanism to achieve jointness. Considering the size of your country, the strength of your armed forces and the nature of your threats, perhaps even a single integrated command structure might have served your requirements. But you created three—partly because other countries had theatre commands, partly because the arrangement served certain vested interests. Or perhaps, you created three because one commander was considered too dangerous.”
“So you are suggesting we should have retained the old system?”
“No. That would have been equally foolish. Warfare had already moved beyond merely coordinating the Army, Navy and Air Force. Today there is economic warfare. Cyber warfare. Information warfare. Psychological operations. Diplomatic pressure. Lawfare. Subversion. Technology. Finance. Trade. Sanctions. Supply chains. Narratives.”
I paused.
“The greatest misunderstanding of your generation was believing that warfare belongs to soldiers. It does not. Warfare belongs to nations.”
Even Justice Ladyfinger was listening.
“You established Integrated Theatre Commands,” I continued. “What you really needed was something different—a War Headquarters.”
Justice Coconut leaned forward.
“What would this War Headquarters do?”
“It would bring together the instruments of national power to achieve a particular objective. Military commanders would sit alongside people dealing with diplomacy, intelligence, cyber, technology, economics, information, law and other relevant national capabilities.”
The Defence Minister objected.
“You want bureaucrats to fight wars?”
“No, Minister. I want the nation to fight its wars. Modern wars may begin long before the first bullet is fired. Your currency can be attacked, markets manipulated, population influenced, diplomatic space constricted, technology denied and supply chains disrupted. If you wait for somebody to fire the first bullet before admitting that the war has begun, you may already have lost half of it.”
The Presiding Judge frowned.
“Surely the military still matters?”
“My Lord. The question is whether it is producing the desired effect.”
“Explain.”
Read the rest by clicking the link in the comments.

















