Writer, blogger, editor. Love wild woodland gardens & city jungles, song & dance (also tweet poetry, food and politics) co-editor @sceptical_scot

Scotland
Joined August 2011
Ripple effect Little Sparta
1
2
25
Swinney needs to show competence. He also needs a plausible plan to plug a £5bn funding gap forecast for the end of this decade through (so far unconvincing) radical public services reform.
Friends in the North? “Working together would help to promote Burnham’s devolution while also helping Swinney re-establish the Scottish government’s reputation for competence” @simeonkerr giftarticle.ft.com/giftartic…
20
Fay Young retweeted
But it’s true. Scotland is almost certainly the most centralised country in Europe.
It's SNP conference weekend and The Sunday Show begins with a clip of Andy Burnham's Friday speech where he claimed Scotland was the most centralised country in Europe. It wasn't as shocking as it should have been. People are now conditioned to BBC Scotland's BritNat corruption.
19
20
219
12,122
Friends in the North? “Working together would help to promote Burnham’s devolution while also helping Swinney re-establish the Scottish government’s reputation for competence” @simeonkerr giftarticle.ft.com/giftartic…
1
42
Uplifting. And we can create the habitat. In Scotland too. At the weekend I met a young beef farmer successfully rearing grass-fed cattle. She says improving the health of pasture has stopped erosion. Now no soil runs from her fields into the river
If you create the habitat, nature will find its way home. For nearly 20 years, we’ve farmed sustainably and regeneratively, planting trees, restoring habitats and making room for wildlife. And this is the reward. A magnificent tawny owl, just outside my bedroom window. What a privilege to see such a beautiful wild creature so close to home. Give nature a little space, a helping hand and time, and it has a wonderful way of moving in. Sometimes the most precious things we grow on a farm aren’t crops.
1
41
If you create the habitat, nature will find its way home. For nearly 20 years, we’ve farmed sustainably and regeneratively, planting trees, restoring habitats and making room for wildlife. And this is the reward. A magnificent tawny owl, just outside my bedroom window. What a privilege to see such a beautiful wild creature so close to home. Give nature a little space, a helping hand and time, and it has a wonderful way of moving in. Sometimes the most precious things we grow on a farm aren’t crops.
35
63
5
593
5,324
Does Scotland know how to engage with the EU? Can we bring the right people together? “Or are we too involved with promoting a fictionalised version of ourselves to engage with this opportunity?” Questions in new Sceptical Brussels-postcard sceptical.scot/2026/10/is-sc…
28
Ten years on from the Brexit decision, does Scotland actually know the EU we might now be open to having closer relations with? Sarah English, a Brussels-based Scot, poses pertinent questions in her first Sceptical postcard from Brussels sceptical.scot/category/inte…
36
Denmark is raising its retirement age to 70. French election candidates pledge to reducing it to 60 or 62. Denmark's debt to GDP ratio is 27%; France's is 117%. You reap what you sow. cnn.com/2025/05/23/business/…
136
1,474
206
9,966
832,429
Fay Young retweeted
On the substack this week... I looked at how states are being increasingly overwhelmed with AI written slop. It's gumming up every process. Britain is particularly vulnerable. How bad has it got and what can we do about it? samf.substack.com/p/drowning…
4
11
3
147
76,448
Ah. Woke up this morning. Sun shines, frost sparkles, birds sing, red squirrel rummages in crisp autumn leaves. Let’s look after it.
2
83
With deteriorating fiscal positions in many OECD countries, the debates on the size of the state will continue to be at the forefront. What these figures show is that the political economy is getting more complicated as more than/nearly half of the electorate are net dependents on public employment/welfare/social payments. Now, those of us who do believe in the importance of the social state know that it is reductive to simply divide the electorate using these parameters. The political economy will be more complicated eg consider the use of public services by private sector employees and the extent to which the private sector draws on public goods. But this is an important debate.
The biggest, and stupidest, myth in European politics, particularly popular in France, is that Europe suffers the consequences of "austerity" and "neoliberalism". In the biggest 5 countries in Europe, more than half of the population makes its income from the state, less than half from the private sector. This is what makes the problem of reducing the welfare state so impossible: more than half of the voters are net recipients. No surprise that Italy's budget has not been balanced in 100 years, France's in 50 years (ooh la la, l'austérité!!): -France: 30 million from the state versus 21m private sector workers. State spending is 57% of GDP, taxes more than half the economy. The budget hasn't been balanced in the lifetime of most French (since 1974). - Germany: 35 million adults from the state, versus 34 million from the private sector. 10% of the population is registered as severely disabled. Public spending is over half of GDP. Germany has had a continuous budget deficit since 2019. -Italy: 23 million from the state, versus 20.5 million private-sector workers. Public spending is 51% of GDP. Italy has had a budget deficit every year since 1925, for 100 years. - Spain more people get their income from the state since 2024: 18.21 million from the public sector versus 17.9 million people working in the private sector. Since 2025, Spain also had more government employees than self-employed workers (autónomos) for the first time in history. State spending is at 45%, budget has not been balanced since 2007. - UK: 54% of households now receive more in state benefits than they pay in taxes. State spending is 44.5% of GDP, taxes (40%) are at their highest since 1950, the budget hasn't been balanced since 2001, and 1 in 5 new cars is paid by the government through a bizarre state disability scheme (Motability).
3
6
465
Beyond irresponsible. What part of enforcing a law passed 86-11 by the Senate does the President and his advisors not understand? It’s unconscionable that this administration is capitulating to a Russian dictator who illegally invaded Ukraine and butchers innocent civilians every single day. If the President wants to actually bring down energy prices, he can do it by solving the Iran problem, not by doing a solid for Vladimir Putin. apnews.com/article/russia-sa…
7,044
8,505
833
35,347
1,327,488
Fay Young retweeted
Replying to @KennyFarq
Methinks he doth protest too much? Prof J Mitchell throws interesting insight into Swinney’s role in the campaigning party which hasn’t yet adapted to government
John Swinney leads a party skilled in campaigning but what about governing? On final day @theSNP conference, @ProfJMitchell tracks progress of a party yet to complete painful transition from party of protest to professional party of government sceptical.scot/2026/10/is-th…
1
1
1
114
The emphatic Swinney is not an attractive Swinney.
3
1
4
1,588
John Swinney leads a party skilled in campaigning but what about governing? On final day @theSNP conference, @ProfJMitchell tracks progress of a party yet to complete painful transition from party of protest to professional party of government sceptical.scot/2026/10/is-th…
5
1
2
411
Quick add from ScepticalScot editor, since X deleted our account a few years ago (we were mistakenly described as 7, so below age of consent) it’s difficult to enter the news feed But readers still find their way to sceptical.scot/
27
A refreshing read. Putting place before politics in realistic reform of local government, Keith Yates, offers a bracing but stimulating read for @scotgov with clear alternatives to unworkable plans for new regional authorities sceptical.scot/2026/10/unlea…
44