Eric Weitz (@ehweitz) header
Eric Weitz (@ehweitz) profile picture

Founder @ The Weitz Firm, LLC | Juris Doctorate President @ Pennsylvania Association for Justice

Pennsylvania, USA
Joined August 2010
Healthcare talks constantly about learning from mistakes… but it still relies heavily on systems that ask people to report those mistakes after the fact. That’s necessary, but also insufficient. A nurse may hesitate to report an event because of fear, exhaustion, workplace politics, or the belief that nothing will change. A physician may see the same event through a different professional lens. An institution may have legal and financial reasons to keep difficult facts closely held. So the record of what went wrong is often incomplete from the beginning. That should concern anyone who believes reporting alone is a safety strategy. A true safety culture requires more than a form or a committee meeting after someone has been harmed. It requires active surveillance for patterns before the catastrophic event arrives. Aviation learned long ago that serious safety improvement depends on understanding failures openly and systematically. Healthcare has often chosen a more private path through peer review. Maybe secrecy encourages candor in individual cases. But we should be honest about the larger question. Where is the evidence that secret processes have reduced preventable harm at scale? If the goal is safer care, the system has to be built to find problems before patients pay the price.
67
An opening statement isn’t an argument. Which matters more than lawyers sometimes realize. Jurors arrive knowing almost nothing about the people involved or the facts that brought everyone into the room. They don’t need a performance. They need a clear story of what happened, who was affected, and what the evidence is expected to show (and why the case is in court). When a lawyer overpromises in an opening, the damage doesn’t wait until closing argument. I’d argue the jury starts measuring every witness against a claim that may have been made too confidently. And it’s an uphill battle from there.
96
Pennsylvania has about 12 to 13 million citizens, and about 7 million hospital days a year. That's people in the hospital for a full day, not including outpatient visits or diagnostic testing. Preventable medical error is the third leading cause of death in the United States. For all of Pennsylvania, only about 2,000 malpractice cases are filed each year.
83
The longer I try cases, the more time I spend looking for the weaknesses in my own case. Younger lawyers are often trained to focus on the helpful facts. - Find the best documents - Find the best expert - Build a solid argument All of that matters… but every case has a problem somewhere. A difficult fact. A witness who may not land the way you want. A legal issue that deserves more respect than you’d prefer to give it. If you don’t find those things first, the other side will. And they’ll decide how the jury first encounters them.
103
Continuity of care and access to a shared record aren't the same thing. The confusion started when electronic records became standard. Everything is in one place. Every note, every test, every specialist's recommendation. The assumption that formed alongside that convenience is that a shared record produces shared understanding. But time has demonstrated that this isn’t the case.  A physician opening a chart has access to everything. That's different from a physician who spoke to the cardiologist yesterday, reviewed the physical therapy notes this morning, and is now synthesizing both against what they're seeing at the bedside. One is information. The other is care. When institutions conflate the two, patients end up with complete records and fragmented treatment. Sure, the chart documents what happened. But it doesn't replace the thinking that used to happen between the people responsible for the patient.
1
83
Many assume the best trial lawyers are the ones who exude the most confidence. I used to believe that too. Certainty reads as conviction, and conviction reads as strength. The problem is that absolute certainty, before a trial that involves human beings doing unpredictable things in real time, tends to create a blind spot exactly where you can least afford one. Every argument has a point where it's most vulnerable. Find that point before the other side does, and you control how it gets addressed. Ignore it because your certainty doesn't permit it, and you hand that control over at the worst possible moment. The more effective posture is confident open-mindedness. Take the position. Hold it. But genuinely entertain the challenge, because if one person in a room is thinking it, others are too. There's a method that's been around in trial work for decades: start with the bad outcome, put it on the table, and walk through the investigation together. You aren't telling the jury what to think. You're leading them somewhere they can arrive at on their own. That's harder to execute than projecting certainty. It's also considerably more persuasive.
106
A patient walks into a specialist's office carrying results from 3 prior appointments. An internist, a neurologist, and an orthopedic surgeon have each reviewed their respective tests, reached the edge of their lane, and referred forward. The specialist reviews what falls inside their discipline, runs their own tests, and returns a verdict: inconclusive. The patient leaves with no answers and a referral to a fourth physician. What happened at no point was someone sitting with the full picture and asking what the pattern across all of it suggests. The chart contained everything. The thinking required to connect it across disciplines happened nowhere.
107
A case sat in litigation for years. Rural Pennsylvania county. Small court system, slow docket. The other side appeared to be doing what experienced defense teams do: delay, stay guarded, give nothing away. My perception throughout was that we were being stonewalled. At the very end, when both sides finally sat down and were genuinely candid with each other, I found out something that reframed the entire case. There had been a complicated internal fight on the other side, between companies, between insurance carriers, about who would bear the cost. It had nothing to do with the merits. It had everything to do with a structural conflict that was invisible from where I sat. Once it came out, creative solutions emerged that weren't available while everyone was guarded. The lesson I re-learned is one I've known for thirty years and apparently needed to learn again: you never really know what's happening inside another organization. What looks like obstruction sometimes reflects internal chaos that has nothing to do with you. Lack of candor, even in the name of good advocacy, can hurt your own side. If people can just sit down and talk, they can usually resolve more than either side expected.
112
Prediction:  Within the next few years, the first major lawsuit naming a health system specifically for implementing inadequate AI will be filed and will succeed. The conditions for it already exist in nearly every major hospital in the country. 70 to 80% of hospitals and physicians use AI tools in clinical settings in some form. Only 8% of physicians surveyed could identify the safeguards their institution had in place around those tools. Algorithms are influencing clinical decisions at scale right now, without the oversight frameworks required for any other medical device. I've looked for the case that names the AI itself as the source of harm. It hasn't been filed yet, but it’s coming.
90
There's a difference between having access to someone and actually reading them. That difference matters in law, in medicine, and probably everywhere else involving human judgment. Interpersonal communication is losing ground to mediated communication across every professional environment. Emails now read like texts. Depositions move to video. Motion practice that used to require two lawyers in a room gets resolved asynchronously. Each of those changes removes a layer of information. Humans have spent a long time developing the ability to read micro-expressions, body language, and hesitation before an answer.  That capacity operates automatically, well below the level of conscious thought. Screen-mediated communication takes part of it away. The effect isn't uniform either. A witness in a lawyer's office, surrounded by unfamiliar people with a court reporter present, has their guard fully raised.  The same witness deposed from their own office, on their own turf, is sometimes more candid than they would have been in person. The environment shapes the testimony before a word is said. What's getting lost across law, medicine, and everywhere else isn't efficiency. It's the information that only exists in a room.
109
The "delay, deny, defend" playbook isn't a pejorative invented by plaintiff lawyers. It's a documented institutional strategy with a clear financial structure behind it. While a claim is being litigated, reserves sit and earn interest. Delay long enough, and some injured plaintiffs exhaust their resources, lose witnesses, or simply give up. Force expensive litigation and fewer attorneys will take the next case on contingency. The system wasn't built around this model by accident. It persists because it works, financially, for the side running it. Every year it continues, people with legitimate injuries either never file, can't find representation, or run out of time while the other side waits. That's a feature of the playbook. Even though it’s described as a flaw in the system.
1
1
116
When people seek accountability after a preventable medical error, they're usually looking for three things: - The truth about what happened - Accountability for the harm that was done - And confidence that it won't happen to someone else
105
If you're preparing for the next trial the same way you prepared for the last one…  There's a good chance you’re following a formula, but not doing much thinking yourself. Almost like some sort of superstition. Preparation rituals accumulate over a career. Practically subconsciously. Someone said to do it this way, it worked once, and it became the standard. The problem is that every case carries a different story, a different jurisdiction, a different jury, and a different set of facts that don't fit inside the last framework. Working hard and working smart are two different commitments. Personally, I consciously check myself to make sure I’m not pigeonholing my thinking. The last thing I want is to mistake familiarity for preparation.
100
Every trial I've started has had one thing in common: Not one has gone according to plan. Jurors have had medical emergencies. Witnesses become unavailable at the worst possible moment. Documents the other side supposedly couldn't locate for years suddenly appear mid-trial. Preparation doesn't exist to prevent those moments. It exists so that when they arrive, there's enough command of the material to respond without losing the thread. The psychology of trial work is the same as athletics in that sense. Your history in the courtroom can bury you or lift you, depending entirely on how you process what came before. Past losses can make you hesitant at exactly the wrong moment. Every case is a new at bat. What you carry to the plate is a choice.
114
One of the hardest conversations in my practice begins with a few sentences people don’t expect “I think something preventable happened to you.” “I think your instincts are right.” “And I may still be unable to help you.” People often assume that a clear medical error automatically leads to a viable malpractice case. It doesn’t. The law requires proof of specific things. Causation can be difficult. Underlying conditions can complicate the evidence. The cost of obtaining records, retaining experts, taking depositions, and trying a case can exceed what a jury could reasonably award. That doesn’t make the harm less real. It means our justice system is neither sufficient nor designed to address every preventable injury. Some lawyers avoid this conversation by saying they have a conflict or don’t handle that type of matter. I understand why. It’s a hard thing to say to someone who’s looking for a path forward. But people deserve a straight answer. The most painful part of this work is knowing someone can be right about what happened to them and still have no workable path to accountability.
112
The cases where harm is most obvious often have the most elaborate defenses. That's not a coincidence. When something went clearly wrong, and the facts aren't genuinely in dispute, the litigation strategy tends to change. The question stops being whether harm occurred. It becomes whether accountability can be made uncertain enough to avoid. Causation gets challenged across a chain of contributors.  Responsibility gets distributed across systems, specialties, and time. What the patient experienced gets reframed against a backdrop of pre-existing conditions and inherent medical risk. In other words, the more undeniable the outcome, the more sophisticated the architecture around it tends to become.
1
1
119
A family comes in after a catastrophic medical error. They’ve already spent months trying to understand what happened. They have records, unanswered questions, and the unmistakable feeling that someone is avoiding a straight conversation. They want three things… The truth, accountability, and confidence that another family won’t walk through the same experience. Our system is built to address only part of that. A lawsuit can produce evidence. It can create financial accountability where a preventable error caused real harm. It can sometimes give a family answers they couldn’t get before. But it cannot restore a lost life, return a limb, or give back years that should have belonged to someone. The change families often care about most is frequently the hardest to secure. An unfortunate reality of how this system works.
129
If an expert's opinion requires a jury to accept an increasingly elaborate chain of unlikely events… The argument isn't getting stronger. It's getting less credible. The goal of expert testimony is clarity. When the underlying facts are difficult to defend, that goal sometimes silently changes. Theories grow more complex. Alternative explanations multiply. The argument moves from what most likely happened toward what could theoretically be constructed to fit the outcome the client needs. At that point, the jury isn't being asked to weigh evidence. They're being asked to accept conditions that strain common sense. Possible and credible are not the same standard. And juries understand the difference, even when they can't articulate it.
1
163
When a preventable medical error occurs, the patient isn't the only one affected. The clinicians involved often carry guilt, fear, and emotional trauma as they try to process what happened while navigating a system built around blame and legal risk. Improving healthcare requires supporting both patients and providers, because a culture of learning is far more effective than a culture of fear.
1
109
The most dangerous professional habit is convincing yourself that something new has made something proven obsolete. The fundamentals of persuasion haven't changed because AI exists. The principles behind building credibility in a courtroom are the same as they were thirty years ago. Sure… new tools can extend what's possible. But they don't replace the underlying logic that makes anything work. This is why the professionals who struggle most with new technology aren't the ones who resist it. They're the ones who adopt it as a substitute for thinking rather than a supplement to it.
105