20 years ago today: It’s monkey business as usual at the Ninth Circuit.
A divided panel, in an opinion by higher primate William Fletcher, disrupts established principles of administrative law as it rules both (1) that a plaintiff with a “particularly close emotional attachment” to a chimpanzee named Terry has standing to challenge the Department of Agriculture’s decision not to adopt a draft policy providing guidance on how to ensure the psychological well-being of nonhuman primates, and (2) that the decision not to adopt the draft policy is judicially reviewable.
Judge Alex Kozinski concludes his thorough dissent with this summary:
“The majority expands the law of standing beyond recognition. It unmoors administrative law from sound principles of judicial review, and insinuates the federal courts into sensitive policy judgments that are the exclusive province of the Executive Branch. It ignores the teachings of the Supreme Court and misapplies the precedents it relies on. It will cause no end of mischief. Count me out.”
2
2
1,513
It’s peculiar to see other Republican senators attacking Cornyn for his use of the blue slip, as it’s a safe bet that every senator has used blue-slip power, especially as leverage before a nomination is made, in ways that he does not want publicly known and would not want to be second-guessed on (including knocking out highly qualified candidates).
Um, not a brilliant idea for Senate Republicans to get rid of the blue slip just before they start a long stretch (probably at least six years) in the minority.
🚨 JUST NOW: Senate Republicans are REFUSING to get rid of the blue slip "tradition" being used by Sen. John Cornyn to unilaterally block a key Trump judicial nominee
They could circumvent this in TWO SECONDS!
THUNE'S TEAM: "Blue slips are a long-standing committee tradition that the chairman of the Judiciary Committee Republican and Democrats have honored."
The nominee, Elliot Gaiser, runs the DOJ's Office of Legal Counsel and was picked for a Dallas-area federal judgeship
Democrats take over in January, time is running out!
Ed Whelan retweeted
Sigh. If you bust Cornyn’s blue slip, he’ll just vote against the nominee in committee anyway! He can block anyone he damn well feels like blocking, with or without a blue slip. This score settling is just as tedious and unproductive as the anti-Trump kind.
🚨 JUST NOW: Senate Republicans are REFUSING to get rid of the blue slip "tradition" being used by Sen. John Cornyn to unilaterally block a key Trump judicial nominee
They could circumvent this in TWO SECONDS!
THUNE'S TEAM: "Blue slips are a long-standing committee tradition that the chairman of the Judiciary Committee Republican and Democrats have honored."
The nominee, Elliot Gaiser, runs the DOJ's Office of Legal Counsel and was picked for a Dallas-area federal judgeship
Democrats take over in January, time is running out!
If Democrats pander to Trump’s vanity, is there any limit to what he’ll give them?
As I wrote three weeks before the midterms: I’d especially worry about a deal over a Supreme Court nomination. If Democrats offered to fund one of Trump’s vanity projects in exchange for being able to pick his Supreme Court nominee, mightn’t he be tempted by the offer?
Ed Whelan retweeted
This is a genuine post from the president of the country that used to lead the democratic world
Ed Whelan retweeted
An actual post from the president about Putin, who:
* helps Tehran target U.S. servicemembers and assets in the Middle East;
* launched Europe's deadliest war since WWII, resulting in hundreds of thousands killed, the unlawful deportation of Ukrainian children, & systematic torture;
* launched the Chechen War, destroying Grozny & killing thousands of civilians;
* supported Assad;
* kills critics such as Navalny, Litvinenko, Skripal, Nemtsov, Politkovskaya;
* downed MH17, killing 298 people;
* dismantled democracy in Russia;
* and so much more.
Ed Whelan retweeted
BTW, there are 52 authorized federal district judgeships in Texas, and there are another 28 judges serving in senior status. So the attention some are giving to the Gaiser nomination is wildly out of proportion to its significance. (That of course doesn't speak to whether Cornyn's obstruction is warranted.)
It's vastly more important that the Senate confirm the pending nominees to the Fifth Circuit and the Eighth Circuit. Whatever misgivings you might have about them, they're markedly better than the appointments a Democratic president elected in 2028 would make (with no blue-slip obstacle).
If the blue-slip policy is discarded, a Democratic president will be able to fill all judicial vacancies in Texas (and elsewhere) with liberals. With the blue-slip power, Cruz can block bad nominees in Texas.
Replying to @JohnCornyn
@JohnCornyn is a disgrace. Bravo to @SenTedCruz! The blue slip policy is silly and should be discarded.
Ed Whelan retweeted
Imagine if a Democratic president did what Trump is doing to NATO, Ukraine and Canada, while appeasing Russia and China. Republicans in Congress would be raising hell (and rightfully so), demanding impeachment. Fox News would be covering it nonstop.
Instead, most Republicans just shrug and pretend they don’t see what Trump is doing. The few who actually speak out are usually the ones on their way out.
It will take years to repair the damage Trump is doing to our country and our alliances.
Ed Whelan retweeted
New in Confirmation Tales:
When Ronald Reagan set out in 1981 to nominate the first female justice, Sixth Circuit judge Cornelia Kennedy was the most obvious candidate.
Of the eleven women then sitting on the federal courts of appeals, Kennedy was the only one with a clearly conservative record. When liberal groups opposed her elevation from the district court to the Sixth Circuit, conservative Republican senator Orrin Hatch hailed her on the Senate floor as “probably the most exceptional woman judge in the country.”
Yet Kennedy lost out to a virtual unknown, Sandra Day O’Connor. Why that happened offers lessons about the pressures and incentives that shape a president’s selection of a Supreme Court nominee.
I have a mix of thoughts on the Elliot Gaiser nomination that probably no one will like in toto. I’ll limit myself here to two of them:
1. Some years from now (if not much sooner), Gaiser will be happy that he’s not a district judge in Texas. The job isn’t a good match for his formidable abilities.
2. If you’re angry at John Cornyn over one district-court seat, you should be a billion times angrier at Donald Trump. His stupidities cost Republicans the Senate, probably until at least 2033, so he’s blown the opportunity to replace one or two justices, a dozen or so appellate judges, and even more district judges. And if a Republican is somehow elected president in 2028, he will have a tough time appointing any judges.
BTW, there are 52 authorized federal district judgeships in Texas, and there are another 28 judges serving in senior status. So the attention some are giving to the Gaiser nomination is wildly out of proportion to its significance. (That of course doesn't speak to whether Cornyn's obstruction is warranted.)
It's vastly more important that the Senate confirm the pending nominees to the Fifth Circuit and the Eighth Circuit. Whatever misgivings you might have about them, they're markedly better than the appointments a Democratic president elected in 2028 would make (with no blue-slip obstacle).
I wrote a paper in law school 41 years ago on whether the Ninth Circuit should be split. (I concluded no.) Four decades from now, some other law student will write on the same topic.
Replying to @mike_frags
If you’re going to add seats to CA9, you also need to break it up. The time has come. There’s a great @JeffFlake bill or two on the topic—easy amendment.
2
12
3,200
I was also struck by this weird footnote. (If she wants to write that in a separate opinion, that would be weird enough. But why does court append this footnote to lineup?)
Fed Soc features lots of different voices at its events, including some MAGA. That doesn’t make it MAGA.
I just listened to an Advisory Opinions episode where @DavidAFrench assured the audience that FedSoc is not MAGA. No mention was made by him or by @whignewtons (who attended) of Hemingway’s featured role, or of Rubio’s disgusting praise of mocking laws when you have swords.
Ed Whelan retweeted
Confirmed, 49-43: Confirmation of Executive Calendar #968, Richard Wesley Bennett to be United States District Judge for the Southern District of Texas.



















