The beauty of a mountain is an observable reality; the claim that a supernatural being created it is an interpretation. You are entitled to see God in nature, but you cannot turn your interpretation into an established fact simply because the mountain exists.
Replying to @darmyball
You and I could go up a mountain. The view is sublime. I think "God is awesome for having created this amazing view". You could feel as I do but not attribute the beauty before you to God. But if God created what we're looking at, my belief and your unbelief don't change the fact
1
7
Someone else may attribute it to geology, cosmology and billions of years of natural processes. Neither person's feelings determine the mountain's origin. The universe does not become evidence for every explanation humans invent about it.
1
1
You're still confusing two separate questions: whether a person existed and whether the historical narratives attached to that person are reliable. The Tel Dan Stele is significant evidence for the existence of a Davidic dynasty.
Replying to @darmyball
I get that. But when it comes to the Bible, my point is that even the mere existence (not the miracles) of key figures is doubted. Someone will readily believe Plato existed, but doubt the existence of King David even though there's archaeological evidence for David, not Plato
1
10
Historical evidence is assessed by its quality, independence and context, not by whether a person appears in a religious text.
Mistake is assuming that proving one biblical character existed somehow validates the entire religious narrative surrounding him.
1
1
That's a convenient way to make your belief immune to scrutiny: when evidence supports your position, you call it confirmation; when it doesn't establish your claims, you accuse the sceptic of being unwilling to accept facts.
Replying to @RedCChillies @darmyball
Over the last 150 years, archaeologists have found evidence corroborating some of what's in the Bible but as I said, "evidence" will never be enough for those who have decided not to accept facts. The cry for more and more evidence isn't a desire to be convinced by the facts.
1
6
Archaeology has corroborated certain biblical places, people and historical events. It has not independently verified every biblical narrative, let alone established supernatural miracles.
1
1
And that is precisely the distinction you are avoiding. Nobody needs to prove Plato performed supernatural feats before accepting that he existed. His existence is a historical question, not a supernatural claim.
Replying to @RedCChillies @darmyball
Historical evidence for Plato comes mainly from his own surviving writings, testimony from contemporaries and students, and early manuscript fragments rather than contemporary physical artifacts. There's archaeological evidence of the existence of King David - non biblical
2
13
Finding archaeological evidence for a biblical character is not the same as proving the Bible's supernatural narratives. A real person can exist inside a story that contains exaggerations, legends and mythology.
1
1
Interestingly, the Bible itself provides examples of what happens when questioning crosses the boundaries of religious authority. Read Numbers 12, Numbers 16 and Romans 9:20. The issue isn't whether questions are technically permitted;
Replying to @darmyball
The verses demonstrate that dialogue and debate are welcome. Your initial insinuation was that debate and questioning are not permitted, which is false.
2
19
Numbers 16:1–35 – Korah and his followers challenge Moses and Aaron's authority, and the rebellion ends in divine judgment.
Deuteronomy 17:12 – Rejecting the authority of the priest or judge is treated as a serious offence.
1
2
That's a false equivalence. Plato is not believed to have performed supernatural miracles, parted seas or built an ark to preserve humanity from a global flood. His existence is supported by historical references, writings and a broader body of contextual evidence.
Replying to @darmyball
The reality is that the existence of Plato is easily believed and less scrutinised than the existence of Moses or Noah. Religious claims (and the existence of religious figures) are actually subjected to more scrutiny. And even when evidence is presented, doubts persist!
1
17
Moses and Noah come with extraordinary historical and supernatural claims that require a different standard of evidence. The more extraordinary the claim, the stronger the evidence required. The problem isn't that religious figures are scrutinised too much..
1
2


