Cyril Mitchell retweeted
I often wonder at the naivety of the independence movement when I look back on the period leading up to the 2014 referendum. I include myself in that criticism. We thought, with some justification, that the way to restore Scotland's independence was to put political and electoral dominance in the hands of one party. I myself argued that only this single-party approach could possibly work against the power of the British state. It could have worked. It should have worked.
What we did not reckon on – and what now seems, with hindsight, the utmost folly – was how that single party would be changed as a consequence of being given the kind of power we gave to the SNP and, by extension, to the all-too-fallible people into whose hands we delivered it.
We should have known better. I should have known better. But at least I have learned from my earlier mistakes. At least I have the humility to admit that I made those mistakes. Far too many continue – against all evidence and against all reason – to believe that they were not and are not wrong to put total faith in the party that the SNP has become.
Arguably the most crucial of all the hard truths that Scotland's independence movement must recognise if Scotland's cause is to progress is that the SNP has comprehensively betrayed that cause and is no longer to be trusted.
thenational.scot/politics/26… #EndTheUnion #ScottishUDI
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
As a hill to die on, Marra's choice of reversing Brexit is as good as any, I suppose. But die, he will. Of that we can be sure. No issue is better designed to whip up far-right fervour than the 'threat' of England-as-Britain rejoining the EU. Farage will be rubbing his hands in glees as he dusts off the anti-EU playbook that blessed us with Boris Johnson and the successors we imagined couldn't be any worse, only to find them rising to that challenge with alacrity.
It will be interesting to watch how the campaign to rejoin the EU develops. My pittance is on the campaign being based on an assumption that the UK can return to the status quo ante. Those who believe this are in for a shock. Few realise how privileged the UK was within the EU, with all manner of exemptions and derogations. There's no going back to that place. It no longer exists.
Before the bunfight gets fully underway, I want to call dibs on a name for the unfolding fiasco. Regardless of the hair-trigger sensitivities of prudish moderators, I will insist on calling it Fuxit.
thenational.scot/news/267150…
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
This was always the danger with using the term 'colony' to describe Scotland's situation rather than the term 'annexed territory'. By calling Scotland a 'colony', we invite people to deny this almost reflexively on the grounds that Scotland's situation isn't like this or that generally recognised instance of colonisation. Or even with some caricature of a colony. Although I wouldn't accuse Jonathon of resorting to that.
What I do find with much of Jonathon's writing on Scotland's constitutional issue is that it tends to make me think of Maslow's hammer, or the law of the instrument:
"When the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail."
When the only conceptual framework a commentator has is class warfare, every situation has to be shoehorned into that framework.
Jonathon refers to "the class questions which fuse with debates about independence", as if this 'fusing' was natural and inevitable and in no way requiring of any effort on the part of the writer. I am mindful of all the other ideological perspectives which somehow "fuse with debates about independence". Indeed, I wonder if there is any ideological perspective which hasn't been 'fused' with Scotland's cause at some point.
I was a bit surprised to find Jonathon resorting to a line I'm more accustomed to seeing deployed by Unionist trolls:
"Scots participate freely in elections, and British political institutions include Scottish representatives."
All right! We participate freely in elections! But they are elections to British institutions. Likewise, those Scottish representatives sit in institutions created and controlled by the British state.
Also, I'd suggest that "contested political authority" and "colonial subordination" is a distinction with little difference.
thenational.scot/politics/26…
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Replying to @JamesMelville
Jesus Christ! Nicola Sturgeon made calls, had meetings, deleted messages, told no one, then remembered nothing!! She's a damn disgrace and embarrassment to Scotland & I hope she doesn't return!
Nicola talks of "the country" on Kussenberg what country would that be ye wee traitor?
@theSNP
any SNP Sturgeonite, hasn't worked out how she fucked you over,
Listen to her on Kuenssbeg
'I like Andy Burnham and I hope he can sort this country problems out"
"This Country"
I fuckin hate her,
@bbclaurak
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
If any SNP Sturgeonite, hasn't worked out how she fucked you over,
Listen to her on Kuenssbeg
'I like Andy Burnham and I hope he can sort this country problems out"
"This Country"
I fuckin hate her,
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
I cannot believe the BBC is wheeling out Nicola Sturgeon as a political commentator.
I know they're struggling financially, with millions refusing to pay the TV licence, but this really is scraping the barrel.
Sturgeon's political career ended in disgrace, and after decades campaigning for Scottish independence, she packed her bags and moved to London.
Now she's lecturing us on British politics from the BBC sofa.
You couldn't make it up.
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Replying to @cyrilmitchell23 @bbclaurak
The London Bubble's 'useful jock idiot' to wind up independence supporters. Fortunately for the BBC, there are no Scottish politicians of any real merit, post Salmond.
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Nicola Sturgeon is political dead meat. She wasn't even yesterday's politician yesterday. Why is she still being given headlines as if she were important? Her place in history is as the person who holed the SNP below the waterline and set back Scotland's cause by at least one decade and possibly two. Her only usefulness now lies in her being a reminder of mistakes the independence movement must never repeat.
thenational.scot/news/266878… #EndTheUnion #ScottishUDI
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Replying to @CockertonMark
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Badenoch has forgotten that Thatcher sold off the family silver, Cameron ruined public services with austerity, Johnson ruined the economy for a generation with his Brexit deal. Then he pissed £billions up the wall with dodgy Covid loans and PPE contracts.
Then we had Mad Lizzy!
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Dear @JohnHealey_MP , did you know that the State Pension pays £241 per week?
Your proposed new Minimum Wage pays £528 for 40 hours.
HOW THE FUCK DO YOU EXPECT WE PENSIONERS TO LIVE ON LESS THAN HALF THE MINIMUM WAGE?????
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Replying to @conor_matchett
Scotland voted 62% remain. Remove settler's from the Yes/No and it's 72% Yes. No other country allows settlers to vote in constitutional votes.
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
So my Dad worked from age 16 to 65. Paid tax and NI all through career.
He now gets state pension, less than £1k every 4 weeks.
He has £170,000 in his private pension. Can take 25% interest free but then pay 48%(!!) on the rest. How the fuck is the govt entitled to that?!! 😡😡
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
The only oil producing country anywhere where no oil is processed, it's all taken elsewhere to benefit others. The worst of it though? - Scots let them.
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Here’s the incomparable Dave Allen discussing how to teach your child the time. It’s one of the most perfectly delivered stand up comedy performances of all time. Absolute genius.
Cyril Mitchell retweeted
Scottish oil bypassed to England
Scottish renewables power bypassed to England
Scotland food & drink exports bypassed to English port
Are we meekly accepting this really?
Cyril Mitchell retweeted

















