Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie) header
Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie) profile picture

Sports PT. Athletic injury RTP, with a focus on ACL. Papers → what I’d actually do Monday. DPT · SCS · CSCS

Minneapolis / Twin Cities, MN
Joined February 2016
Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)Photo by Braidy Solie (@braidy_solie)
In pro football after ACLR, “return” isn’t one number. Meta-analysis of 20 studies (n=1,992): pooled RTS ~92% (95% CI 88–94%), mean ~261 days (~8.7 mo). Match play took longer than training (278 vs 203 days); concomitant procedures stretched timelines vs isolated ACLR (294 vs 229 days). High heterogeneity—benchmarks, not guarantees. Key Provider Considerations: counsel training vs match separately, and build in extra time when meniscus/cartilage work is bundled. link.springer.com/article/10… #SportsMedicine #ACL #ReturnToSport
1
1
7
1,755
Patellar/quad tendon ACL grafts: 20.3% of male athletes had a thigh muscle injury in year one vs 9.1% hamstring grafts. Clinical takeaway: I'd keep eccentric-specific quadriceps strength training within the return-to-performance program. Retrospective. doi.org/10.1002/ksa.70695
48
Time from ACL injury to surgery belongs in the gait check, not only the chart. Across 16 studies, people operated 12+ months after injury had a lower peak knee flexion moment (bending load) walking than controls (SMD -1.97, 95% CI -3.77 to -0.17). Association; I² 88%.
1
1
101
Ankle dislocation with no fracture is rare. Reduced on the field, no surgery. Now the timeline rides on the soft tissue: deltoid, lateral ligaments, syndesmosis, capsule. For a guard, the test is a stable ankle under lateral load and anchoring in pass pro.
#Steelers G Mason McCormick, who was carted off in an air cast on Sunday, suffered a dislocated ankle that unbelievably did not feature a fracture, sources say. No surgery needed, as the ankle was popped back in place on the field. There is a chance he’s back for the playoffs.
40
Put the whole women's squad on ACL prevention, not just poor screeners. Pro soccer: women's ACL rate 1.19 vs 0.69 per 1,000 match hours (1.69x men), more often non-contact. Clinical takeaway: I'd build it into every warm-up. Registry cohort, not causal. doi.org/10.1002/ksa.70692
2
126
Revision ACLR changes the question: check the cartilage, not only the graft. In 331 futsal players, chondral lesions were found in 55.9% of revisions vs 16.2% of primaries (OR 6.36, 95% CI 2.94-13.74). Mostly low-grade; not significant at Grade 2+.
1
1
1
127
Let the diagnosis guide the return-to-sport timeline. Pro men's soccer: pubalgia (pubic-bone pain) was 6.4% of hip/groin cases but the longest median absence: 41.5 days. Clinical takeaway: I'd let it set expectations. Public data, unconfirmed diagnoses. doi.org/10.1002/ksa.70677
46
The ACL is completely tore. Don’t need MRI to confirm complete ACL injury/tear. Why? The tibia will sublux/slip out only AFTER a complete ACL tear. MRI will confirm damage to secondary structures such as the lateral meniscus. journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs…
#Lions star Aidan Hutchinson is feared to have suffered a significant knee injury that knocks him out for the foreseeable future, per me and @MikeGarafolo. More details coming. But Detroit is not expecting good news on the injury suffered celebrating an early sack.
1
78
Cost alone shouldn't pick the ACL graft. A 5-year model barely separated them. BPTB: $3,917, 4.589 QALYs. Quad tendon: $4,901, 4.612. QT won 55.7% of simulations, BPTB 44.3%. I'd ask what the donor site will tolerate in rehab first. It's a model, not patient outcomes.
1
1
92
Young athlete, little bone loss, Bankart (labrum) repair: plan for recurrence, not a one-and-done fix. n=96, age ≤24, ~5 yr: 33.3% recurred, 19.8% revised. Contact sport was tied to failure. Clinical takeaway: I'd flag contact risk pre-op. Case series. doi.org/10.1177/036354652614…
1
118
Use the hamstring:quad ratio after ACLR as a signal, not a clearance test. n=3,458: each +10 in the 6-mo ratio, OR 0.81 for revision by 2 yr. AUC 0.64: poor at picking who fails. Clinical takeaway: I'd pair it with quad strength. Cohort. Association. doi.org/10.1002/ksa.70679
1
143
Return to sport after ACLR is not return to preinjury level. In a meta-analysis of 25 studies (7,174 patients after primary ACLR), 79.3% returned to sport but only 44.1% returned to their preinjury level. The ACL-RSI readiness gap between those who got back to preinjury level and those who did not widened over time (mean difference 16.09 at ≤6 months → 18.64 at 6–12 months → 27.07 after 12 months). Key Provider Considerations: • Functional gaps (strength LSI, hop LSI, IKDC) stayed smaller and more stable across time windows than the readiness gap. • IKDC differences stayed below usual MCID cutoffs, so a “pass” on PROMs can still miss the readiness story. • Clinical takeaway: I’d keep serial ACL-RSI past the usual clearance window, not just a single mid-rehab score, before clearing preinjury-level sport. Caveat: systematic review and meta-analysis of observational comparisons; association, not proof that raising ACL-RSI causes return. doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2026.…
68
A contact ACL tear and a non-contact one aren't the same knee. Across 482 primary ACL surgeries, contact tears had 2.68x the odds of a higher overall structural damage grade, after adjustment. I'd read the surgical report before borrowing a non-contact timeline. Association.
1
1
1
96
Quad tendon ACL graft, with or without a kneecap bone plug: similar early results. 5 studies, 996 vs 1,279 knees. None found a gap in graft failure or return to sport. Both kneecap fractures (in surgery) were plug cases. 1–2 yr follow-up.
1
1
3
232
Teen ACL surgery with growth left needs alignment checks until the growth plates close. 1 year after transphyseal ACLR (tunnels drilled through open growth plates), 28% had a 10+ mm shift in leg alignment vs the other leg, 73% of them toward knock-knee (valgus). Key Provider Considerations: • The median change was small (2.9 mm). The risk sits in a subset, so the median hides it. • 16-17% also had a 5°+ angle change at the femur or tibia. • Clinical takeaway: for a still-growing athlete, I'd confirm alignment follow-up is planned through skeletal maturity and flag any new knock-knee look to the surgeon. Caveat: 91 patients, ≤2 years of growth left, 1 year of follow-up. Only 1 patient (1%) was recommended for treatment, so this is a reason to watch, not to worry. doi.org/10.1177/036354652614…
63