J Barger (@bnroj) profile picture

🧙

Joined October 2013
Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)Photo by J Barger (@bnroj)
After a year and a half of genocidal atrocities, the editorial boards of numerous British press outlets have suddenly come out hard against Israel’s onslaught in Gaza. The first drop of rain came last week from The Financial Times in a piece by the editorial board titled “The west’s shameful silence on Gaza,” which denounces the US and Europe for having “issued barely a word of condemnation” of their ally’s criminality, saying they “should be ashamed of their silence, and stop enabling Netanyahu to act with impunity.” Then came The Economist with a piece titled “The war in Gaza must end,” which argues that Trump should pressure the Netanyahu regime for a ceasefire, saying that “The only people who benefit from continuing the war are Mr Netanyahu, who keeps his coalition intact, and his far-right allies, who dream of emptying Gaza and rebuilding Jewish settlements there.” On Saturday came an editorial from The Independent titled “End the deafening silence on Gaza — it is time to speak up,” arguing that British PM Keir Starmer “should be ashamed that he said nothing, especially since Mr Netanyahu has now announced new plans to expand the already devastating bombardment of Gaza,” and saying that “It is time for the world to wake up to what is happening and to demand an end to the suffering of the Palestinians trapped in the enclave.” On Sunday The Guardian editorial board joined in with a write-up titled “The Guardian view on Israel and Gaza: Trump can stop this horror. The alternative is unthinkable,” saying “The US president has the leverage to force through a ceasefire. If he does not, he will implicitly signal approval of what looks like a plan of total destruction.” “What is this, if not genocidal?” The Guardian asks. “When will the US and its allies act to stop the horror, if not now?” To be clear, these are editorials, not op-eds. This means that they are not the expression of one person’s opinion but the stated position of each outlet as a whole. We’ve been seeing the occasional op-ed which is critical of Israel’s actions throughout the Gaza holocaust in the mainstream western press, but to see the actual outlets come out aggressively denouncing Israel and its western backers all at once is a very new development. Some longtime Israel supporters have unexpectedly begun changing their tune as individuals as well. Conservative MP Mark Pritchard said at the House of Commons last week that he had supported Israel “at all costs” for decades, but said “I got it wrong” and publicly withdrew that support over Israel’s actions in Gaza. “For many years — I’ve been in this House twenty years — I have supported Israel pretty much at all costs, quite frankly,” Pritchard said. “But today, I want to say that I got it wrong and I condemn Israel for what it is doing to the Palestinian people in Gaza and indeed in the West Bank, and I’d like to withdraw my support right now for the actions of Israel, what they are doing right now in Gaza.” “I’m really concerned that this is a moment in history when people look back, where we’ve got it wrong as a country,” Pritchard added. Pro-Israel pundit Shaiel Ben-Ephraim, who had been aggressively denouncing campus protesters and accusing Israel’s critics of “blood libel” throughout the Gaza holocaust, has now come out and publicly admitted that Israel is committing a genocide which must be opposed. “It took me a long time to get to this point, but it’s time to face it. Israel is committing genocide in Gaza,” Ephraim tweeted recently. “Between the indiscriminate bombing of hospitals, starvation of the population, plans for ethnic cleansing, slaughter of aid workers and cover ups, there is no escaping it. Israel is trying to eradicate the Palestinian people. We can’t stop it unless we admit it.” It is odd that it has taken all these people a year and a half to get to this point. I myself have a much lower tolerance for genocide and the mass murder of children. If you’ve been riding the genocide train for nineteen months, it looks a bit weird to suddenly start screaming about how terrible it is and demanding to hit the brakes all of a sudden. These people have not suddenly evolved a conscience, they’re just smelling what’s in the wind. Once the consensus shifts past a certain point there’s naturally going to be a mad rush to avoid being among the last to stand against it, because you know you’ll be wearing that mark for the rest of your life in public after history has had a clear look at what you did. This is after all coming at a time when the Trump administration is beginning to rub Netanyahu’s fur the wrong way, recently prompting the Israeli prime minister to say “I think we’ll have to detox from US security assistance” when Washington went over Tel Aviv’s head and negotiated directly with Hamas to secure the release of an American hostage. The US is reportedly leaving Israel out of more and more of its negotiations on international affairs in places like Yemen, Saudi Arabia, and Iran. Something is changing. So if you’re still supporting Israel after all this time, my advice to you is to make a change while you still can. There’s still time to be the first among scoundrels in the mad rat race to avoid being the last to start acting like you always opposed the Gaza holocaust.
117
808
92
2,125
97,665
Somehow I would have expected it to find a fixed point closer to the original.
asking ai to perfectly replicate this picture of dwayne “the rock” johnson 101 times
1
1
5
869
The most important story of the past quarter century, and our lifetimes, is the rise of China. It is also the backdrop for the chaos we’re undergoing today. My weekend essay for @unherd : unherd.com/2025/04/why-china…
1
16
8
32
6,838
Running through music’s complex emotions. Footage from Geffen Records in Los Angeles on March 31, 1991. Joni spent the day reviewing the music video for “Come In From The Cold,” doing a photoshoot and an interview about her recent album release. ‘Night Ride Home.’
9
46
4
341
11,695
Trump has had some wins. He has charged RFK with fixing America’s rotted health system. And he’s making noises about abolishing NATO—which outlived its usefulness a generation & a half ago. Nonetheless, many Trump loyalists—& many nonaligned people who’d been optimistic about the new administration—are beginning to acknowledge a growing disappointment. IMO people’s biggest hopes were vested: · In the ending of war · In the revealing of secrets · In the return of free speech · And in at least some power shifting away from the oligarchic class so favored by the Democrats. The permanent state seems to have had other ideas. Two months in, Trump 47 is looking rather like Trump 45: - Those who were touted as admin picks during the transition—Douglas Macgregor, Thomas Massie, Ron Paul, Candace Owens, Matt Gaetz, Daniel Davis, Adam Boehler (even Tucker Carlson)—but who were not sufficiently enthusiastic about Israel—were left out of the team. - The Cabinet that did eventuate has no members of the MAGA-hatted rank-and-file who thronged his rallies. It’s mostly billionaire developers, hedge fund bosses, senior bankers, venture capitalists, investors, corporate attorneys & professional politicians. - After condemning Biden for using bombs instead of diplomacy with Yemen, Trump is now bombing Yemen. - The Russia-Ukraine war was not ‘ended on Day One’. - The Trump-brokered Gaza ceasefire was ended unilaterally by Israel—obviously by pre-arrangement. The mass slaughter of civilians has resumed. There have also been… - No Assange or Snowden pardons. - No RFK files, MLK files or Epstein files. - No 9-11 files. (Israeli involvement? Saudi involvement?) - No COVID vaccine files (e.g. govt purchase contracts), and no documents on the Congressional ‘sexual misbehavior‘ slush fund. - No news on how Ukraine’s 2014 Maidan coup was orchestrated, & by whom. - Nothing on Thomas Crooks (first shooter) or Ryan Routh (second shooter). - Nothing on ‘chemtrails’, or whatever they are. - No audit of Fort Knox. - No Pentagon audit. - And nothing on who blew up Nordstream. Finally, having quite justly complained of the curbing of his side’s free speech, Trump is now deporting legal residents for what they say in public. This is not a partisan attack on Trump. The Democrats were as bad or worse. It’s a reflection on the power of vested interests—on their ability to rig & corrupt the political system, whoever is elected. The principles of the US Constitution are timeless, but its mechanics are designed for another age. Thus, even the mighty Trump must bow to the donors, the oligarchs, the Israel lobby... Changing this won’t require 'politics' within today’s hopelessly skewed system—it’ll involve new democratic architecture. [Adapted from my book, The Mechanics of Changing the World: Political Architecture to Roll Back State & Corporate Power. (Constitutional structures to oligarch-proof our world.)]
71
252
44
686
146,893
This year, I read ten important historical novels: Jane Eyre, Middlemarch, To The Lighthouse, Bleak House, Portrait of a Lady, Anna Karenina, Life and Fate, Heart of Darkness, Madame Bovary, and The Magic Mountain. Reflections: • Four of these are more than 800 pages long. The Magic Mountain and Portrait of a Lady, while shorter, are not short. Of the ten, 5 are British, 2 are Russian, and there was one from each of France, Germany, and the US. • For me the clear standouts are Middlemarch, Bleak House, Karenina, and Life and Fate. I would enthusiastically reread any of them. If I had to choose just one to go to again, I would probably select Middlemarch. There's something memorably compelling in Eliot's affection and empathy for almost all of her characters. If Succession is a show with no likable personalities, Middlemarch is the opposite. Bleak House is a close second. Life and Fate is quite different to the others: it’s not exactly entertaining (or even notably well-written), but it is true and profound. (Most works designated “important” are not, but Life and Fate surely merits that as well.) If kindness is one of the core adjurations of Life and Fate, Eliot is the author that most embodies it. • I'd underestimated Dickens's lyricism. I had thought of him as a master of the plot (contra Nabokov), but he is just as accomplished in prose itself. “Chesney Wold is shut up, carpets are rolled into great scrolls in corners of comfortless rooms, bright damask does penance in brown holland, carving and gilding puts on mortification, and the Dedlock ancestors retire from the light of day again. Around and around the house the leaves fall thick, but never fast, for they come circling down with a dead lightness that is sombre and slow. Let the gardener sweep and sweep the turf as he will, and press the leaves into full barrows, and wheel them off, still they lie ankle-deep. Howls the shrill wind round Chesney Wold; the sharp rain beats, the windows rattle, and the chimneys growl. Mists hide in the avenues, veil the points of view, and move in funeral-wise across the rising grounds. On all the house there is a cold, blank smell like the smell of a little church, though something dryer, suggesting that the dead and buried Dedlocks walk there in the long nights and leave the flavour of their graves behind them.” • Three of these four were written by authors in their 50s (Eliot, Tolstoy, and Grossman). Dickens was a mere 41 -- and this shows. The plot is very entertaining, and immensely intricate, but the characters are somehow flatter. So, maybe one lesson from the set is simply that wisdom is real, and that skill in the domain of fiction compounds for quite some time. • Russian literature puzzles me. Why did it suddenly become so good in the 19th century, and why did it decline so much in the 20th? I don't think the latter answer can just be a story of oppression, since we got many great works during Stalin’s reign. But what's the best Russian novel since Master and Margarita? On the issue of the rise, I often encounter explanations claiming that it was related to Russian intellectuals being excluded from political influence and consequently retreating to the artistic domain -- but this feels obviously inadequate. Again, how does this explain the post-Bulgakov decline? And where are the great, say, Saudi works of the past 50 years? • Whatever happened to the novel around the turn of the century (Conrad, Woolf, Mann in my reading) was not obviously salutary. All three are interesting works, and there is something very distinctly modern in Woolf's in particular, but they simply don't compel -- at least for this reader -- the way their predecessors do: maybe it's just the particular selection, but I was generally looking forward to finishing the early 20th century works, and a bit disappointed when completing those dating from before 1900. The dislocation that Blom describes in Vertigo Years is clearly manifest. Woolf's “Mr. Bennett and Mrs. Brown” essay, and her claim that “human character changed” in 1910, is consistent with the turn in the novels. She was speaking of different works, but her assessment rings true in a broader way: “Yet what odd books they are! Sometimes I wonder if we are right to call them books at all. For they leave one with so strange a feeling of incompleteness and dissatisfaction.” • I should note that some of Woolf’s descriptions are great, even if her brooding interiority leaves me ultimately unenthralled. “The house was left; the house was deserted. It was left like a shell on a sandhill to fill with dry salt grains now that life had left it.” “He lay on his chair with his hands clasped above his paunch not reading, or sleeping, but basking like a creature gorged with existence.” • Tom Wolfe attributes modern architecture and the international style to a post-1917 sympathy for the proletariat and a desire to strip indulgent bourgeois ornament from our construction, and, yes, Schoenberg explicitly motivated atonality in egalitarian ideals, but this set of novels makes me doubt the political explanations. You can clearly see the embrace of some kind of disharmony in the books, and I don’t think Conrad was trying to make any Marxist point. I still struggle to explain what happened, but I think I would reverse some of the standard causality, and it seems to me that the coopting of communist ideals is probably itself downstream of the broader social unease that also gave rise to these artistic tides. Blom’s description of the rise of various mental disorders -- neurasthenia and the like -- seems relevant. (All of this does make me want to better understand 1848.) • The railway, and its attendant social upheaval, features repeatedly, and maybe most memorably in one chapter of Middlemarch. I hadn't appreciated just how significantly disruptive a force it was perceived as being even at the time. (Given the scale of the construction that was entailed, maybe this shouldn't be surprising.) More broadly, there is some sense of a society in transition through most of these works: these aren't neat and timeless tales. You have the rise of the bourgeois and broader urbanization in Bovary, the emerging social consciousness in Bleak House, the exposure of the shabbiness of Victorianism and its gender expectations in Lighthouse, and the postwar shell shock of Magic Mountain. • The works written before 1900 are primarily about romance (Bleak House the exception, with romance only a subplot), and those written afterwards (Conrad, Mann, Grossman, Woolf) are emphatically not. I don’t know what to make of this. Perhaps just an accident of the selection. • Ruxandra Teslo points out that there’s a moral gravity in the 19th century works that seems foreign today: people treat their own characters as important constructions in their own right. In a similar vein, I was struck by Grossman’s conception of freedom: he perceives it more as the right to self-define than a more typical liberty of action. Perhaps because actions were so circumscribed in Victorian societies (for women) and Soviet societies (for everyone), the seriousness of being weighed heavily. * Money and its mechanics get extensive treatment in the pre-1900 novels. The details of Bovary’s debt were made famous by Piketty, but Eliot also spends time on Lydgate’s financial struggles, and Tolstoy on Levin’s agricultural economics. Pecuniary considerations are absent in the later works. Again, maybe just happenstance stemming from the particular selection, but I don’t get the feeling that it’s just that: I think something about authors’ attitudes to the topic changed. • Today’s scientific papers are far harder to read, and jargon-replete, than those of 1960. However, the novels of the 19th century use significantly more sophisticated construction (and vocabulary) than those of today. What should we make of the countervailing trends? To me, both seem suboptimal. • Pleasure aside, should one read these books? Does one derive moral betterment from doing so? I'm not sure. Probably not in any narrow sense. Ethicists are supposedly no more ethical than regular people -- if deliberate study doesn't help, what hope does mere fiction have? And, anecdotally, I don't consider the humanities majors to be the moral betters of the STEM students. I do think they've helped with my understanding of history, though. This year, I reflected on how the major historical moments that I've lived through -- the weeks after 9/11, the aftermath of Trump's 2016 election victory, March of 2020 -- cannot really be understood in terms of particular events, and must instead be apprehended through the vibes that prevailed. Rather than trying to assemble a logical causal chain, I think it's more helpfully explanatory to see many happenings as simply arising from a mood. History books struggle to capture such sentiments, and understandably so: the historian usually wasn't there; even if they were, vibes are ethereal things, and they feel out-of-place in a work that aspires to footnoted rigor and exactitude. As such, complements are required, and these novels have definitely helped me. This view also makes biography and autobiography seem of greater importance in developing such comprehension. The small details -- that Herbert Hoover's parents used to attend lectures and debates in a nearby town since that was the only entertainment available, that both died before age 35, or that Hoover himself once walked 80 miles in 3 days to join a geology class trip -- say a lot about a period, and are rarely captured in the grand sweep of events. I feel like I gained much more understanding of historical Vienna and of the emotions around WWI from reading Zweig's memoir than from any direct history of the period. • Another argument made for reading these works is to simply better understand humanity and the human experience. There is almost certainly some extent to which this argument is valid, though I always wonder: do they help you better understand humanity, or better understand the kind of people who write books like these? Is Isabel Archer actually reflective of someone in that kind of position, or merely of the kind of hyper-intellectual James family? Karenina is ultimately a kind of demented obsessive (as was Tolstoy) – in learning about her, do we learn about love and its travails, or simply about unusually unstable personalities? • There’s clearly some value in reading them for somewhat tautological reasons: they're worth reading because they are the books that we’ve decided are worth reading. They form part of our cultural context, and other works probably make somewhat more sense and are more memorable when interpreted through their lens. They are intellectual capital cities: you sorta have to go to Paris and New York in order to understand the rest of the world, and whether you “enjoy” them isn’t really the operative question. • Ultimately, a utilitarian case for better understanding history or even humanity would not be my primary argument for why one might choose to read them, though. With self-consciousness about the platitude, they are simply some of the finest intellectual achievements of humanity, and worthy of engagement for that reason alone: a deeper appreciation for excellence is itself a valuable thing.
297
311
121
3,534
815,724
If the Democratic Party is to become a democratic party, the first job of a new DNC Chair is to get super-PAC money out of Democratic primaries. AIPAC and other billionaire-funded super-PACS cannot be allowed to select Democratic candidates.
2,381
5,896
554
49,147
1,762,919
I'm sure most of you have figured this out, but for those that haven't: The biolab, black-ops, money laundering operation, known as Ukraine, is likely to lose support under the Trump admin As a result, NATO and the US state dept are trying desperately to provoke Russia into a response that dramatically escalates the war and make exiting it near impossible For three years, the Biden administration slow rolled increasingly provocative measures. From surveillance assistance to shirt range munitions to black-ops troops and training, to F-16's to HIMARS to land mines to ATACMS. Now, they are considering sending them nukes. Every step of the way, Russia drew a new red line. Every step of the way, the Biden admin pretended they would go no further. Every step of the way, the neocons in America and NATO used Russia's sanity as an excuse to become more insane. "Look, they said this was a red line. They didn't launch nukes, so let's go further." I don't need to explain how dangerous that game is and where it inevitably leads. At some point Russia will respond and it will be catastrophic. Peace negotiations have been on the table since days after the war began; agreed to in principle by Ukraine and Russia while nearly a million Ukrainian and Russian men (who are now dead) were still alive. Scuttled by Antony Blinken, Jake Sullivan and Boris Johnson. Hopefully Putin holds off and hopefully Trump follows through on negotiating peace early next year. In the meantime, I hope everyone is reassessing our membership in NATO. It's arguable whether the institution was ever interested in peace but it couldn't be more clear that NATO is now the war making existential threat to humanity that they would have you believe Putin is.
215
1,122
92
5,592
150,930
No matter how things turn out, remember that it is someone else's fault (probably you, the voter)--it can't be the candidate, can't be the campaign, can't be the insiders who dictated all of it. Our rulers cannot fail, they can only be failed.
2
3
11
778
Ada Lovelace continued. A common feature of the Ada industry is to latch onto things she is stated to have done and use them to walk her with famous scientists and advanced ideas, a sort of name-dropping by proxy on acid. Thus some "mathematics education" acolytes at Oxford gratuitously enrolled her in the company of Hamilton and quaternions (!) but that's a story for another day. The technique often involves attributing to Ada things which were actually originated by Babbage and his vehicle Menabrea, who had already written up the core of the Analytical Engine before Ada got near it. Babbage had communicated these ideas to Menabrea in 1840, and corresponded extensively with him until they were finally published in 1842, in French at Geneva. Only then did Ada get involved, first as a translator, then as an author of notes, again under Babbage's (initial) supervision, which were only published in 1843. Few who attribute things to Ada bother to check whether Menabrea's paper already contains whatever it is (insert very advanced idea here) that she is supposed to have originated or suggested. This has become so egregious that in Babbage's Complete Works (1989), the Menabrea paper is attributed solely to Ada Lovelace! An extraordinary violation of scholarship. A blushing footnote admits, but does not explain why, this departs from previous practice (which has Menabrea as the author, Lovelace the translator and annotator, and matches how the text itself is written). If the editors wanted to clarify authorship they should have listed Babbage as primary author, Menabrea secondary, and Lovelace a distant third. Because we know that Babbage directed both Menabrea and Ada's notes and supplied a list of worked examples to both that he had been building for years. Instead the editors confused LLMs training on their nonsense forever after. A pox on them. Let's take program traces as an example. These are already in Menabrea's paper, as anyone can easily verify. But they come of course from Babbage, who was, again, the first "programmer" in that sense, as many have pointed out (e.g. Anthony Hyman and Alan Bromley, who knew Babbage's scribbling books best) but others have mysteriously neglected to notice. They use exactly the notation that Ada wrote remarks about, and which she got Babbage to clarify for her. But once that is conceded, all enthusiasm for claiming so much glory for a simple device just evaporates. Now let's examine these program traces. They don't really work. Because they claim to handle arbitrary values but they don't. Take x^n or n!, essential to the power series that Babbage relies on for everything. To calculate them for an arbitrary n you need a looping or recursion mechanism. Menabrea himself pointed that out in a brief aside but then left it out of the subsequent discussion and execution traces. Ada never mentions it. There are no explicit operations for loops and we have to infer how they would have worked. But they would have to be invoked in any program, and there would have to be operations to do so. A general way would be a conditional statement like IF and a GOTO mechanism. Menabrea even mentioned a scratch register variable, for an efficient loop counter, but you would need a way to address it, and that is not provided anywhere (only constants and ordinary store variables are ever addressed in the discussion and examples). If you look at the supposed program traces you will quickly work out that for say x^n where n=4 they really show a plain or vanilla hard-wired program x*x*x*x, even though they are written as if n is a variable with value 4 and X^n is being calculated. How would you actually use n? Where are the loop operators? If you think that there is an implicit loop that has just been suppressed with all its details (!) you will bump into the fact that Babbage's variables are named, not addressed. And the traces all necessarily use named variables. A loop would have to reuse the names and could not grow them. Thus there was no loop in mind during their construction. There is absolutely no evidence that Ada understood this omission, since it would have been trivial to qualify (the text contains much flanneling of that kind, but not for this critical point.) To put it brutally, the traces are impossible and do not show workable programs. Once Alan Bromley realized that Babbage only had named storage (try doing data structures that way) it sent him to a deep state of depression. He felt like all his work trying to revive Babbage had been for nothing (somewhat of an overreaction I think, since Babbage would have crossed that bridge but just never got to it because he was too busy moping.)
An entire industry has been built around the idea that Byron's daughter Ada Lovelace was a great mathematician and the world's first computer programmer. Both of these claims are based on verbose notes she made to her 1843 translation of an 1842 paper by Menabrea about Charles Babbage's Analytical Engine, an analog cogwheel-and-pinion computer which existed mostly on paper only (see drive.google.com/file/d/16qx…). Both claims are entirely false. Here I will address the issue of her mathematical abilities. Dorothy Stein was the first to point out in 1985, based on reading Ada's correspondence with Mary Somerville and Augustus de Morgan that Byron's daughter appeared to have very weak mathematical abilities. She could not do simple algebra. It is easy to verify this, without resorting to her manuscripts, by actually reading her published 1843 notes to Menabrea, a step few if any people ever seem to have taken the trouble to do. After all they're very long and use a lot of symbols. Here I will address only those on the Bernoulli numbers and their supposed calculation (see Note G in the paper). But this is just the basking seal on top of the iceberg, so to speak: the whole paper is riddled with bellowing nonsense, of which more later. Babbage had been planning to use the Bernoulli numbers (from the power series expansion for a common expression involving e^x) as an example for his engine since 1835, as he wrote to Nathaniel Bowditch that year. In his memoirs he admitted (long after the fact) that he had worked out the details of this for Ada, "to save her the trouble". We can now see how this worked. What Babbage had given Ada was just a brief sketch, which she expanded, in her prolix style, to match her understanding of the material. The crux was that Babbage wanted to accumulate calculations of Bernoulli numbers, as you would when constructing a table, something like his earlier Difference Engine, which used cumulated finite differences to do calculations of numerical results for tables. With some simple manipulations of the power series for e^x, see attached, an expression for the next odd indexed Bernoulli number can be obtained from the preceding ones. (Similar reasoning applies to the even indexed ones.) That follows from this relationship, a linear dependency, which we will write as equation (8), see attached A_0 + A_1*B_1 + A_3*B_3 + .... + A_(2n-1)*B_(2n-1) + B_(2n+1) = 0. (8) where the B_i are the odd Bernoulli numbers, and the A_i are coefficients which, as Ada failed to understand, actually depend on n too and are not constants. To get an expression for B_(2n+1), use your arithmetic superpowers to deduce (8*) B_(2n+1) = -A_0 - A_1*B_1 - A_3*B_3 - .... - A_(2n-1)*B_(2n-1) It is a step that sorely puzzled Ada though. She felt compelled to come up with an explanation anyway. She appears to have landed the world's smallest grappling hook on the phrase "linear dependence", probably used by Babbage in conversation with her. Scanning the equations she convinced herself that this "linear dependence" must apply to the index n, which she triumphantly concluded was dependent on its distance d from 0. So she wrote down some useless tautologies about that. Since you cannot do anything with them, she left them out there and simply moved on to point out that terms not listed in (8) must be zero (!) and wrote down a tautology involving multiplication and division by one, in which she gets the (irrelevant) indexes wrong for good measure (see attached for this extraordinary gibberish). This concludes her explanation. It has stood unexamined since 1843 by people who solemnly pronounce on the evidence it shows for her advanced abilities (!) Why didn't Babbage notice this nonsense and correct her, supplying the necessary arithmetic superpowers? Correspondence shows that once she started writing her "notes", at his suggestion, she would accept no correction, So one assumes he simply stopped reading it, or at least commenting on it. Don't dare presume to alter what I, a daughter of Byron, write! So much for that. Not realizing that the A_i terms depend on n too had further implications. You need to recalculate them when accumulating Bernoulli numbers iteratively, a step that eluded her and which undoes much of the sort of computational "saving" that Babbage was claiming. Indeed the execution trace (for the paper only contains such traces, not programs as such) doesn't work. Indeed none of the traces given in the paper for terms involving n could ever have been produced by Babbage's machine. More on that later. And on Ada's information that one can calculate a divergent (or indeed oscillating) infinite series on a computer, term by term. And why Babbage chose to use Menabrea and less successfully, Ada, in the first place. Not to mention what Babbage meant by The Enchantress of Number (hint: it was not Ada). Do not adjust your set.
7
36
8
332
44,653
This is the most detailed model of a human cell to date, obtained using x-ray, NMR and cryoelectron microscopy datasets. ‘Cellular landscape cross-section through a eukaryotic cell.’ - by Evan Ingersoll and Gael McGill.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
“Obtained” is potentially misleading—this is a simulation. Attribution to the original creators: gaelmcgill.artstation.com/projects/Pm0JL…
748
4,541
875
26,137
1,943,269
From SteveSailer dot Net: Harvard economist Raj Chetty advises Kamala on how he personally saved Charlotte, NC. Will anybody besides me ever take Chetty's data seriously enough to critique it? stevesailer.net/p/raj-chetty…
2
35
6,486
we need a wikipedia for autobiographical sketches eventually with AI that helps you explore causes of events in your life
1
73
Oh No! Piece Of Ear Shot Off Trump Begins To Grow Into Second Trump buff.ly/4f6iidF
113
623
66
6,353
323,563
Earlier this year my wife decided to watch Law and Order: SVU from the beginning. It began in 1999. The show tries to stay topical with the news. Some observations.
395
4,231
851
76,482
22,088,746
460 years after his birth, always worth seeing this Shakespeare infographic again… 🥧
119
1,154
230
5,644
434,378
If you have to move to North America and still want to have the same climate as back in the old country.
479
2,254
717
25,280
3,411,127
This painting is over 100 years old. It was made by a Swedish illustrator called John Bauer, one of the most important artists you've never heard of. His revolutionary art influenced everything from graphic novels to animated films to video games, and here's why...
356
6,656
468
67,969
7,278,581
they somehow found every type of guy who worked at a gas station in 2002 and threw them together in a band for one brief glorious moment
This quoted post is unavailable.
24
218
3
3,058
163,858
This was the original cover for the 1972 album 'For The Roses' and was Joni's initial response to the music business, as heard in the song 'For The Roses.’ With a purchase of ‘Joni Mitchell Archives, Vol. 3: The Asylum Years (1972-1975)’ from jonimitchell.com, you will receive a 7’x7’ art print of the cover. Pre-order here: jm.lnk.to/JMAVol3
7
35
4
277
19,586