Anand Kumar (@anandoff) profile picture

What I’m reading & listening to

Joined October 2009
Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)Photo by Anand Kumar (@anandoff)
Anthropic draft: "Product visions for early 2025" June 15, 2023
9
41
12
714
171,119
Another awesome robot by Disney. Very bullish on their future theme parks.
78
351
103
2,782
293,422
Anand Kumar retweeted
Looking back at an exponentially improving technology & you will see how momentum led to R&D which overcame tech barriers The fact that reasoners were developed at exactly the moment AI pre-training slowed is how Moore’s Law works, too: new technique appear to maintain the trend
Prediction: LLMs in their current form may not be able to do everything, but AI now has enough momentum that this won't matter. Beam engines couldn't do everything either, but they were enough to set off the Industrial Revolution.
8
16
171
30,137
I’m not surprised this has 10k likes, but I think it’s pretty bad advice. And often actively destructive to both company culture and performance. In fact, it’s a pretty employee-hostile chart and an abdication of leadership responsibility. Let me explain… The critical assumption underpinning this entire chart is that a single individual contributor, or manager, can resolve the problem That is very often not the case. And what happens when you create a “bring me solutions not problems” culture is that people stop bringing you problems! That is very bad!!! There’s a great Colin Powell quote about this. I hate war analogies in business, but I think it’s relevant here: “The day the soldiers stop bringing you their problems is the day you stopped leading them. They have either lost confidence that you can help them or concluded that you do not care. Either case is a failure of leadership” Do you know what is a good way to get blindsided by big fucking issues? Telling people to solve everything themselves, or that they need to have proposed solutions It is just as likely that they are feeling a *symptom* of a really big problem. Maybe they can solve the symptom. But it doesn’t solve the problem. There is a deep Root Cause Analysis exercise that should be happening. Something structural is broken. Incentives are wrong. Whole departments are misaligned on strategy. The business is missing a critical piece of infrastructure and everyone is doing a dumb workaround Encouraging individual heroics often exacerbates these issues, and kicks the can down the road on the real problem. It is not this person’s problem to solve. It’s your problem. You’re the leader. You need to go investigate. Most importantly though, I think this chart is an abdication of leadership responsibility. Your job is to clear blockers and drive alignment. Yes, your job is to teach people to march up this chart of self-sufficiency for problems within their scope. But they can’t do that without a culture that allows, and even encourages just as much “Level One: There is a problem” identification as Level 5 celebration of autonomy The way that I think about this is that everyone in my department - from the Directors down to the Individual Contributors - is on a constant journey to improve their Problem Identification ability. Is this a problem that can be solved by me, or do I need to escalate this? That’s the right filter. The number of problems that can actually be solved by an IC using this pyramid is quite small. Managers, a bit bigger. Directors, bigger still. Lot of time wasted, and problems unsolved, because cultures are built demonizing problem identification
I stole this idea and now use it with every single employee. It’s the best illustration I’ve seen of teaching someone to be high agency. It says there are 5 levels of work: Level 1: “There is a problem.” Level 2: “There is a problem, and I’ve found some causes.” Level 3: “Here’s the problem, here are some possible causes, and here are some possible solutions.” Level 4: “Here’s the problem, here’s what I think caused it, here are some possible solutions, and here’s the one I think we should pick.” Level 5: “I identified a problem, figured out what caused it, researched how to fix it, and I fixed it. Just wanted to keep you in the loop.” Using this framework, here’s what I say to every new employee… You will live at Level 4 from Day 1 and as we build trust you will rise to Level 5. Being high agency doesn’t just mean tackling problems in this way. It means your entire way of working should be oriented to being a Level 4+ employee. Plz feel free to steal it as well. And ty @stephsmithio for the framework!
148
208
27
3,362
554,506
Anand Kumar retweeted
sora can create beautiful emotional long form content. it's still a little annoying to create and stitch together clips outside the app, but we are going to get that fixed this was created by @hemanth_asir at openai: a short film on history of technology
56
54
29
753
48,486
A recent reflection, based on conversations with economists and policy leaders, is that there are two superficially similar but importantly different perspectives one can hold with respect to US manufacturing: * Affinity for manufacturing and physical production is an anachronistic fetish, embodied by populists with outdated attraction to hard hats and clanging forges. A great deal of manufacturing has departed the US, which is certainly fine and probably even quite good. It's unpleasant labor, and countries ought to each specialize in their respective comparative advantages. * Manufacturing is the ultimate network effects and economies-of-scale business. As services are substituted by AI, and as datacenter deployment accelerates, the relative importance of manufacturing is likely to grow. To think that one can pick and choose sectors in which one will excel ("let's win in drones but not in dishwashers") is a fallacy. Manufacturing is hence of paramount strategic importance. However, we don't know how to make the US the world's preeminent manufacturing power (given its cost base and given the current center of gravity in China) -- indeed, we don't know whether it's even possible -- and this is a significant strategic problem for the country. I have zero direct expertise here, but my outside view is closer to #2 than #1: it seems that the ecosystems and supply chains create strong gravity across the board. I also asked @elonmusk, who has clearly done more over the past decade to advance sophisticated US manufacturing than anyone else, and this appears to be his view. Most economists, on the other hand, are much closer to #1, and I don't think that the economics profession considers the absence of good ideas for reviving US manufacturing to be a problem of particular significance. (There are lots of snide epithets about the efficacy of industrial policy.) It seems to me that there's even some amount of backwards reasoning happening, where, because we don't know how to do #2, #1 is subconsciously a much more comfortable position to hold. Talking about winning particular manufacturing sectors feels to me a bit like talking about winning individual biological research sectors or winning particular software sectors. That is: it seems that the strong default assumption should be that "the place that is best at biology research sector X will also be best at sector Y", and similarly in software, because the skills and inputs needed are so transferable. As such, my guess is that if the US seeks meaningful sovereignty or preeminence in any of drones, robotics, solar, batteries, pharma, etc., we need to bite the bullet, and win at manufacturing across the board. Overall, I'd love to read more arguments for and against these perspectives, particularly from those with direct expertise.
259
302
107
2,751
715,811
Anand Kumar retweeted
I’ve come back to G.K. Chesterton’s definition of courage more times than I can count
31
650
42
4,902
254,076
If I had to come up with a short description of the opposite of my political philosophy… “price controls on insurance” might be it
2
1
1
40
881
Anand Kumar retweeted
Random thoughts: Listening to the audiobook while reading the text is the ultimate cheat code for deep focus. h/t @samhinkie
9
3
2
106
13,499
Anand Kumar retweeted
USPS pioneered the low-cost labeling approach (in the 1980s!) far before Scale AI’s popularity
2
19
3,179