Pinned Tweet
Shaykh al-Islām al-Harawī said:
❝The second level [of the sought] is to:
1.relieve the servant from the outcomes of their shortcomings
2.spare them from reproach
3.give them control over the consequences of their errors,
as He did with Sulaymān peace and blessings be upon him. When he killed the horses, He carried him on the gentle wind—so he was given a substitute for the horses. He did likewise with Mūsa peace and blessings be upon him when he threw the tablets down and grabbed his brother’s head. He did not blame him like He blamed Adam, Dāwūd, Nūḥ and Yūnus peace and blessings be upon them.❞
Source: Manāzil al-Sā'irīn
Ash’arīs claim the Salaf only condemned the Kalām of the Jahmīs and Mu’tazilīs.
When in reality, every Ash’arī Kalām manual uses the same argumentation method of Ajsām and A’rāḍ, and hence would fall under Ibn Surayj’s condemnation.
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
Shaykh al-Islām Abū Ismāʿīl al-Harawī:
“I am a Ḥanbalī as long as I live, and if I die, then my final testament to the people is that they become Ḥanbalī.”
📚 Ibn Rajab, Dhayl Ṭabaqāt al-Ḥanābilah, vol. 1, p. 121.
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
Great example how the asharis resort to doing ta’wil and forcing their metaphysics onto Ibn Battah. Also, those who said that Ibn Battah’s statement regarding knowledge goes against our view is simply either confused or dishonest. The first part is regarding foreknowledge which is why he says ‘he knew’ and Ibn Taymiyyah himself agrees Allah knows what will occur before it does lol.. so acquiring new knowledge being negated is regarding not knowing what would occur and then knowing it after. Clearly we negate this. He then says at the end that Allah does not see us doing something until we actually do it. He isn’t saying there’s some تعلق عدمي or any of this sort. He’s saying Allah (ie the object) does not see another object do something until they do it. It’s clear as day that this necessitates a change. Coping and saying it doesn’t just makes you look worse tbh
al-Imām Ibn Taymiyyah brought nothing new.
The way Ash’arīs and neo-Ḥanbalīs try to single him out is a red-herring.
Fakhr al-Dīn al-Rāzī said:
Allah Most High maintained truthfulness throughout the Qurʾān, avoiding all falsehood. Yet every poet who abandons falsehood for truthfulness produces inferior poetry. Observe how Labīd ibn Rabī’ah’s and Ḥassān ibn Thābit’s poetry declined after embracing Islam, their Islamic verses being inferior to their pre-Islamic ones. Nevertheless, Allah, despite avoiding falsehood and exaggeration, produced the Qur’ān with the eloquence you observe.
Why were we not born in heaven?
al-Imām Shams al-Dīn Ibn al-Qayyim said:
When Allah ﷻ sent Adam, father of mankind, down from Paradise, He did so for wisdoms beyond minds to grasp or tongues to describe. His descent was thus the very essence of his perfection, so he might return in the best state.
Allah ﷻ willed that Adam and his descendants taste enough of this world’s toil, grief, worries, and afflictions to magnify in their eyes the worth of entering Paradise in the Hereafter.
For a thing’s beauty is revealed by its opposite. Had they grown up in the abode of bliss, they would not have known its worth.
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
A Benefit from Imām Aḥmad
Imām Aḥmad was asked about an individual, so he replied:
“He was a liar who fabricated ḥadīths.”
The man who asked then said, “I am his paternal cousin.”
Imām Aḥmad replied:
“Allah's help is sought, there is no favouritism in religion.”
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
Ibn Furak also mentioned:
“As for what is established through transmitted reports, there is no objection to affirming attributes reported in revelation, using their transmitted terms and affirming their **meanings** in a manner befitting Him, such as the two hands, the face.
Ibn Furak:
❝It was said: {Everything will perish except His face}: Himself.
And it was said: The meaning is ‘except that by which His Face was sought.’
And it was said: Its meaning is ‘except Himself’; and that He has a Face, and that is our position.❞
The recent discussions about DCT reminded me of this verse.
The Jinn seemingly know what ‘good’ is and assume that God would do it, and they know what ‘evil’ is and assume God wouldn’t do it.
The Quran is intentionally careful, theologically.
The scholars (like Ibn Taymiyyah) mention that absolute, unqualified evil is never attributed to Allah. One of the examples that they use is Q 72:10. When the Jinn talk about “evil” being intended for those on earth, the doer (فاعل) of this potential evil is omitted and remains unspecified. But when the Jinn talk about “what is right” being intended for those on earth, they refer to Allah as the doer.
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
Trusting one's supposed spiritual state despite transgressing against the Sharīʿah?
Imām Ibn Qudāmah al-Maqdisī al-Ḥanbalī Mentions:
“No one should be deceived by himself or place his trust in what he imagines to be the righteousness of his religion and the strength of his faith. For whoever transgresses the limits of Allah the Exalted and looks at what the Sharīʿah has forbidden him to look at, protection is withdrawn from him and he is left to himself.”
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
Can @HarounKanj use the little IQ he has to explain to us why al-Bāqillāni, in responding to the belief that Allah is everywhere, said that Allah is in fact on the Throne and cited verses about good words ascending to Allah ﷻ in the upward direction? (He can’t.)
At this stage of Ash‘arism, its Imams used the arguments of Ahl al-Sunnah primarily to appease them. Their later Imams labelled anyone who used such arguments a “Mujassim.”
Replying to @HarounKanj
This is another example of intellectual dishonesty. Actually, for this individual, it's more of an IQ problem.
Every one of those brightly coloured scans 😃 is proof against him and his sect, but he can't track what's been stated, just like the atheist quote he put up yesterday.
The most famous Mu’awwil admits Ta’wil does NOT work for Allah’s Yadayn in Q 38:75
Ibn Furak said in his Tafsīr: ❝{For what I created with My two hands}: These are two hands, an attribute by which He created Adam and favored him over Iblīs. It is not permissible for its meaning to be an emphasis that creation is attributed to Him, because that would nullify the basis of his superiority over Iblīs, since He created Iblīs just as He created him.❞
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
Imam Qiwām al-Sunnah al-Aṣbahāni al-Shāfi‘i (d. 535 AH) on the deception of Ibn Kullāb (the father of Ash‘arism):
#ClassicalPureShafiiyyah
❝[The Mu‘tazilah] sought to undermine the foundations of the religion, but when they failed to achieve their goal, the Kullābi followed them and devised a form of theological discourse whose outward appearance was agreeable, but whose inner reality was destructive. He said: ‘I do not say that the Qur’an is created, but I say that what is found in our muṣḥafs is not the speech of Allah. Rather, it is an expression of His speech, while His speech is eternal and subsists in His essence. I do not deny Allah’s istiwā’ (establishment over the Throne), but I do not say that He established Himself over it by His essence. Nor do I deny the Hand or the Face, but I interpret them figuratively.’ Thus, he interpreted them in a manner that departed from the understanding of the Companions and the Tābi‘ūn.❞
Imām Aḥmad said:
❝The Qur’an is the speech of Allah, uncreated in every respect, in every manner in which it is expressed, and in whatever state it may be. It will never be created, ever.
Allah, Blessed and Exalted, said: {And if any one of the polytheists seeks your protection, then grant him protection until he hears the speech of Allah.} and He did not say: {Until he hears your speech, O Muḥammad.}❞
al-Sunnah by al-Khallāl
The physical appearance of al-Imām Ibn Qudāmah
❝He was of full stature, white in complexion, radiant of face, with intensely black eyes, as though light emanated from his face because of his beauty. He had a broad forehead, a long beard, a straight nose, joined eyebrows, a small head, delicate hands and feet, a slender body, and was in full possession of his senses.❞
al-‘Ukbarī retweeted
The Ḥanābilah have the fewest creedal differences among them due to the preservation of their Imam’s statements and the clarity of those statements, as Imam Ahmad lived at a time when it had become necessary to refute falsehood in detail, unlike the Imams who came before him.
Long before modern biblical scholars questioned the historicity of the saints rising from their tombs in Matthew 27, the Muslim scholar al-Juwaynī (d. 478 AH) raised the same objection. He wrote:
❝This story is extraordinary in its strangeness, if it had occurred exactly as he described it, it would have been among those miraculous and astonishing events that give rise to every conceivable motive for reporting them. Knowledge of it would have reached everyone, near and far, and its account would have been constantly related and discussed even by people who had not devoted themselves to recording the events of the Messiah, peace be upon him, and documenting his history.
How, then, could someone who had undertaken to record his accounts, peace be upon him, and the remarkable aspects of his extraordinary deeds, simply cast aside an event so astonishingly extraordinary?
And then, for three [Gospel writers] to neglect an extraordinary event such as this!”❞
Source: شفاء الغليل في بيان ما وقع في التوراة والإنجيل من التبديل






































