Melani Finn (@afinnthing) header
Melani Finn (@afinnthing) profile picture
London
Joined September 2017
Photo by Melani Finn (@afinnthing)Photo by Melani Finn (@afinnthing)Photo by Melani Finn (@afinnthing)Photo by Melani Finn (@afinnthing)
Melani Finn retweeted
Replying to @sharrond62
Cat check: Sharron Davies sits in the House of Lords, where she sets laws. You cannot remove her by voting.
123
681
15
7,007
78,324
In 2018, hard Brexit ads from a mystery account @mainstreamuk started flooding the internet. Tory MP Damian Collins raised it as eg of how social media platforms are used by unknown actors using untraceable money to undermine our democracy. A year later, Ian Austin, an ex Labour MP later ennobled by Boris Johnson launched a campaign to ‘restore civility’ to politics. He did so by spending £134k on Corbyn attack ads from the same @mainstreamuk account. It was run by a man called Ben Tait who has now been revealed to be an anonymous troll, @habibi_uk. We still have no idea where any of this money came from. To the people defending Ben Tait, you are defending astroturfed fake grassroots campaigns. You are defending the multi-billion social media companies that enable it & profit from it. You are defending a system in which none of us have any idea who is influencing our politics. And, crucially, who is paying. You are defending oligarchy.
Ok. Here’s a new puzzler from those of you following the Habibi scandal. (And yes, it definitely *is* a scandal). How come I was tweeting at @mainstreamuk the campaign we now know he ran way back in 2018? 1/
39
1,164
18
2,659
46,342
Melani Finn retweeted
Abdul El-Sayed is damned good at this.
703
6,509
171
39,910
1,436,153
Melani Finn retweeted
Zohran Mamdani is what leadership looked like before Americans became slaves to corporate interests.
448
2,544
150
18,561
2,912,329
Melani Finn retweeted
All that media out there lapping it all up - and it takes the Eye to get there. As usual.
18
427
22
935
43,149
Melani Finn retweeted
Cuba is a Socialist country and one of the poorest in the world suffering under a 60+ year economic blockade by the richest country in the world. Guess which one has better healthcare, life expectancy, literacy, lower infant mortality and every type of crime. It ain't the USA.
60
667
10
2,150
21,105
Melani Finn retweeted
Berlin’s iconic Kraftwerk venue hosted an exclusive launch event for an arms firm developing AI-powered weapons and military technology. German company Helsing unveiled a new AI-powered military targeting system – pitched as the European rival to that of US spytech giant Palantir – at the legendary music and cultural site on 11 November. Helsing states that its objective is to “help protect our democratic values and open societies”, selling products under categories including “air combat” and “precision strike”. According to German newspaper Die Zeit, Kraftwerk was transformed for the Helsing event to resemble a military command post, with combat vehicles parked outside, bomb-sniffing dogs checking bags and security personnel wearing bulletproof vests. Film projections reportedly depicted soldiers and tanks, and guests included people dressed in military uniform. An influencer even shot a paid Instagram advert titled “Europe’s answer to Palantir” on site, Heist Magazine reported. Kraftwerk – whose Tresor Foundation hung posters reading “NO WAR!” on its outer wall in 2022 before the Russian invasion of Ukraine – has since faced backlash. “Call me conservative, but I don’t think weapon companies should launch their products in techno clubs in Berlin,” one Berlin-based DJ posted on social media. Kraftwerk’s head of sales said in response to a request for comment: “I should have declined the booking... My decision turned Kraftwerk into a platform for the promotion of weapons and military AI one morning and did serious damage to the venue’s reputation. “This was a serious error of judgement. Commercial considerations do not excuse it.” Helsing’s new military targeting system, Clarity, follows AI-assisted platforms used by the US and Israel associated with the killing of civilians in Palestine, Lebanon and Iran. According to a Pentagon investigation, this includes a strike on a school in southern Iran in February that killed more than 150 people, 120 of them children. Helsing’s technological development has in part been supported by €600m in funding led by an investment firm founded by Spotify founder Daniel Ek.
3
16
2
43
8,839
Melani Finn retweeted
If your job over decades has been to smear, defame and demonise anyone having the audacity to show solidarity with Palestinians and you’ve chosen anonymous social media accounts as your modus operandi you need to give your head a wobble. And if your mates are trying to defend your weirdo actions then they need to give their heads a wobble too. This obsessive and bizzare behaviour is an attack on free speech, damages our democracy and is an attempt to silence those that speak out against the injustice of occupation and genocide.
3
635
83
2,506
104,255
Melani Finn retweeted
Replying to @ADZanderWest
How patronising! We all know people who are being failed by the health service & fobbed off with a bit of mindfulness & CBT - when they actually need medical diagnosis & treatment. You're trying to paper over cracks & doing folk a great disservice. 🤬
1
8
250
Melani Finn retweeted
Victoria Derbyshire, "You will be asking some young disabled people to live off £80 a week.. Could you live off £80 a week?" Labour's Employment Minister Andrew Western, "There will be some losers - Alan Milburn has been very clear with that" Genuinely shocked a Labour gov is doing this.
256
827
109
2,596
100,836
Melani Finn retweeted
“So many children that I met in Gaza said nothing. They didn't scream, they didn't cry, they stared.” Heartbreaking remarks by Dr. @Tanyaalih at DAWN’s 2026 Gala, confronting the horrors Israel's attacks inflict on Gaza’s children, and the crisis of impunity enabling them. Watch her powerful speech.
261
4,041
280
6,300
154,405
Melani Finn retweeted
When Keir Starmer tried to slash benefits for disabled people, principled Labour MPs joined Greens and campaigners across the country to say 'not in our name.' Now Burnham's government are hoping to bully them into silence so they can force through welfare cuts. Shameful.
75
1,029
30
2,793
31,208
Melani Finn retweeted
🚨 One English council handed a solar businessman more than £600M of public money. The BBC has now tracked him down to a luxury apartment in Bucharest. This is the Thurrock Council scandal, one of the biggest financial disasters in British local government history. The key players: - Liam Kavanagh, known as "Mr Sunshine", selling investments in solar farms - Sean Clark, Thurrock's finance director, who found the money to invest with him How the loop worked: 1. Thurrock borrowed huge sums from other councils across the UK, often arranged with a few emails 2. At one point it owed MORE THAN £1BN to other councils 3. That money went into Kavanagh's solar businesses 4. The investments threw off millions in income, so it looked like a triumph while councils faced cuts 5. Its own financial adviser, Arlingclose, called it "pretty extreme", warned the chance of it blowing up was high, and eventually cut ties 6. The council kept borrowing and investing anyway What Thurrock alleges the money paid for, according to the BBC: - a £12M private jet - a yacht and a fleet of supercars - a country house loved by Jane Austen - a Damien Hirst pickled sheep - a £250,000 revolving bed Then it all came crashing down. Thurrock effectively went bankrupt. Central government had to step in with HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS of taxpayers' money. The council is now suing Kavanagh, accusing him of deceit and of diverting millions for his personal benefit. He denies any wrongdoing and says he honestly believed he was entitled to use the money as he did. Why this matters for you: When a council gambles and loses, it is local residents and UK taxpayers who end up covering the hole. And the borrowing came from other councils across the country. That is how one town's bet ends up on everyone's bill.
48
716
47
1,201
57,779
Melani Finn retweeted
He is sanctioning Israeli companies with little to no presence in Britain, so it will have no material impact. He isn't sanctioning JCB, a British firm which destroys Palestinian homes and builds illegal settlements - or Elbit, which makes weapons used to enforce the occupation
We said we would act, and we are. Today we’re sanctioning those blocking aid from entering Gaza, and companies supporting illegal settlement expansion in the West Bank. We will not be bystanders in the destruction of the two-state solution.
86
1,409
26
3,393
42,833
Melani Finn retweeted
I've been skimming through the Milburn Review, and I genuinely struggle to comprehend the sheer SHORT-SIGHTEDNESS of what's being proposed. And, of course, @Helen_Whately, below, is already salivating at the prospect of slashing sickness benefits, like some sadistic accountant who sees human suffering as an opportunity to balance the books. But let's look at what's actually being proposed... We're talking about fundamentally restructuring the welfare system for under-25s, stripping disabled young people of vital financial support, while simultaneously handing taxpayers' money to private employers to incentivise recruitment. And here's the staggering part. Employers receiving the government's £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant are NOT required to retain employees for any minimum period. They're not even required to demonstrate they've created an additional job! This is one enormous WEALTH TRANSFER. Taking financial security away from some of the most vulnerable people in society, while funnelling public money towards private employers without sufficient guarantees of sustainable employment. So what exactly are WE being asked to fund? Genuine pathways out of poverty? Or a revolving door of subsidised employment, with vulnerable young people potentially dumped straight back into unemployment and financial insecurity? And those who genuinely can't work? Are we simply prepared to push them further into poverty from the outset? WHERE THE FUCK IS THE ACCOUNTABILITY? What happens when the subsidies end? How many of these young people will still be employed in 12 months? Two years? Five years? We're talking about the future of an entire generation, yet still confusing short-term corporate initiatives with the fundamental economic transformation that's desperately needed. And perhaps most absurdly, why should a disabled 24-year-old receive fundamentally different financial protection from a disabled 26-year-old? Does their disability suddenly become more expensive at 25? Does their rent change? Their food bills? Their need for dignity and independence? OF COURSE IT FUCKING DOESN'T! Yet we're contemplating a system that transfers financial security away from vulnerable young people, while directing public money towards employers without adequate guarantees of lasting employment. This is the fundamental problem with treating welfare primarily as a COST to be reduced, rather than social protection that allows people to live with dignity. Where's the long-term vision? Where's the investment in genuinely sustainable employment, education, healthcare, infrastructure and an economy that creates opportunities for EVERYONE? Where's the commitment to protecting those who simply cannot work? Instead, we're in danger of weaponising poverty as an incentive to force people into employment, while rewarding businesses for offering opportunities that will most likely disappear as soon as the financial incentives do. A functioning welfare state protects people from poverty. A functioning economy provides meaningful opportunities. WE NEED BOTH. Otherwise, we're not fixing the crisis. We're simply recycling it, at an enormous human cost. And politicians celebrating the prospect of cutting support for vulnerable people should seriously question what the hell they've come into politics to achieve. #MilburnReview @ZackPolanski @TheGreenParty @andyburnham @UKLabour
What’s in the Milburn Review? (Mostly) the right diagnosis, bold ideas copying our plans on sickness benefits – but an unprecedented expansion of the role of the state and no plan to get the benefits bill down. A thread🧵
44
480
36
1,039
26,534
Melani Finn retweeted
Which of these two conversations wins as the best ever exchange on UK political twitter ?
8
31
1
225
17,985
Melani Finn retweeted
Yes, this is a major part of this story. This broader network including habibi, GnasherJew and Labour Against Antisemitism frequently target left-wing Jews like Justin Schlosberg, Andrew Feinstein, Stephen Kapos, Michael Rosen etc. Quite often, when the true identity of these agitator accounts are revealed, they turn out to be run by non-Jews. But this story isn't just some snowflakey reaction to robust online discourse. There are massive real-world implications about how this network operates. First, many of the accounts in this network are anonymous. They say defamatory things about people who cannot defend their reputation - you can't sue anonymous amounts or put social pressure on named individuals to retract defamatory statements. Second, these accounts directly feed into alarmist stories in the right-wing press: the type of story that calls Misam Harriman or Linkeker racist. These are absurdities. It is genuinely absurd that they are being accused of anti-Jew hate. Madness. Yet these accounts provide grist to mill for the press to go after public figures who criticise Israel or challenge the status quo. These stories are important. They send the message to other celebrities or politicians that speaking out, even mildly, about Israel, can see your words taken out of context, driving media coverage, and then driving you out of your job. They also create a sense of ambient, unrelenting crisis; that there is an epidemic of hate seeping into every corner of our society; that it is so pervasive that even the nice guy from the footy has been infected. Most often this becomes coded and couched in Islamophobic terms - just look at how often habibi goes after pro-Gaza Muslims. The right-wing press is adept at using this to feed into broader "clash of civilisation/anti-immigration" rhetoric. This empowers and emboldens the far-right, but also builds elite consent for attacks on civil liberties and protest. Third, the "evidence" these accounts produce feed into formal processes. Labour Party files show that there are loads of complaints submitted to the Labour Party with evidence from Habibi and GnasherJew. Some emails show GnasherJew advising people on complaints. Habibi, using a Gmail address, had complained directly to the Party in certain cases. Mish Rahman has confirmed that candidates were blocked from standing for the Labour Party based on dossiers with Habibi evidence - the Starmerite bureaucracy, which routinely blocked left-wingers for nonsense, were provided with the ammo they needed to transform the Party by habibi and other agitators. This is genuinely mad: anonymous agitator accounts, who code most expressions of pro-Gaza views as hate, and who routinely target left-wing Jews, were being used as the evidential bedrock to decide who could and couldn't be an MP or councillor. Finally, there is the human cost. People's lives have been upended, sometimes destroyed, by this tiny ecosystem. It's sometimes caused real pain. In The Fraud, I used the story of the Jewish Labour Party member Riva Joffe to illustrate this. Joffe was born to parents who fled antisemitic pogroms in Eastern Europe, and who were forced to flee South Africa (where they had settled) because they became anti-apartheid activists. Joffe became a respected psychoanalyst in the UK. In 2021, on her deathbed, she was sent a letter by the Labour Party saying she was being investigated for antisemitism. Her "crime" was to share an invite on Facebook to a BDS event at a university. The complaint was submitted by "David Gordstein" - the made-up identity created by Euan Phillips, a spokesperson for LAAS. Joffe spent her last weeks answering a charge the she was antisemitic, based on a complaint from a made-up identity. Joffe died while under investigation for antisemitism. The Party refused to tell her son if the case had been resolved after she died. If you think any of that is OK, then you need to have your head checked.
A lot of the people habibi and his anonymous network have attacked ARE Jewish — including a Holocaust survivor Stephen Kapos. So I’m hardly outlining a religious, cultural, or ethnic conspiracy, just the knee jerk reaction of journalists too lazy to look deeper
28
523
28
1,124
38,688
Melani Finn retweeted
“A Labour government should not be taking a penny from people who need support while leaving the structures that generate poverty, insecurity and inequality largely intact.”
The manufacturing of consent for another round of welfare cuts is well under way. And frankly, the whole thing is becoming depressingly familiar. Before Parliament has even seen Alan Milburn’s final report, we’re being treated to a steady drumbeat of media interviews, briefings and commentary telling us that painful choices are unavoidable. That radical reform is necessary. That anyone raising objections simply doesn’t understand the scale of the problem. It’s all quite telling. Because increasingly, I don’t think Labour MPs are the real audience for this exercise. The real audience is outside Parliament: the media commentariat, think tanks and, through their relentless promotion of these proposals as economic ‘common sense’, a currently sceptical public. The objective, it seems, is to turn scepticism into grudging acceptance, then point to that acceptance as evidence that the reforms are politically viable, perhaps even desirable. It’s a familiar process of manufacturing consent. A pincer movement: persuade the public there’s no alternative, then tell Labour MPs the public demands it. And at the heart of it lies a particularly pernicious political trick. Present people with a false choice, then insist they choose. Either we cut financial support for some of the most vulnerable people in society, or we face economic ruin. Either we accept the reforms, or we condemn another generation to a lifetime on benefits. Heads I win, tails you lose. As any first-year debating student knows, once you’ve conceded your opponent’s premise, much of the argument is already lost. But why should we accept the premise? For fellow Star Trek fans, this is our government’s Kobayashi Maru moment. The seemingly impossible, no-win scenario. Kirk’s solution was famously to reprogramme the computer. He refused to accept that the rules of the simulation were the only rules possible. And that’s precisely what we need to do with our political economy. Andy Burnham has already identified the operating system that’s been running Britain for the past 40 years. It’s called neoliberalism. And he’s promised to end it. An economic model that has progressively hollowed out our democracy, stripped communities of economic power, privatised public wealth, weakened organised labour and handed ever greater control over our collective future to financial markets and corporations. A model that disciplines workers through insecurity, while insulating capital from the consequences of its own failures. Indeed, what we’re living with now barely resembles the free-market capitalism its advocates once promised. It’s closer to corporate socialism: public money underwriting private risk, public services guaranteeing private returns, and the taxpayer picking up the bill when things go wrong. Socialism for the powerful. Market discipline for everyone else. And all the while, the same political and economic establishment tells us what is and isn’t possible. What we can and cannot afford. Which choices are ‘responsible’ and which are supposedly beyond the pale. That’s the real significance of manufacturing consent. It’s not just about selling unpopular policies. It’s about narrowing the boundaries of political imagination until the public, and eventually Parliament itself, forgets that alternatives exist. So what does reprogramming the system actually mean? It means replacing an extractive economy with a productive one. It means taxing accumulated wealth more fairly, restoring collective bargaining, taking back democratic control of essential infrastructure, and investing in the industries, services and communities that generate genuine prosperity. It means rewriting fiscal rules that constrain long-term public investment, and ensuring institutions such as the Treasury, the OBR and the Bank of England serve democratically determined economic objectives rather than treating the preferences of financial markets as the final word. It means being prepared to confront concentrated economic power, whether that sits in the bond markets, water companies, property monopolies or tech corporations. And it means recognising that economic policy is not simply about distributing whatever crumbs are left after capital has taken its share. It’s about deciding how wealth is created, who controls it and who benefits. Keynes famously observed that “anything we can actually do we can afford”. That doesn’t mean resources are infinite. It means the real constraints on an economy are its productive capacity, people, skills and resources, not the fictional idea that a sovereign government operates like a household with a fixed pot of money. Which brings us back to welfare. Before asking how much we can cut from the social security bill, shouldn’t we first be asking why so many people need financial support in the first place? Why do millions of people work yet still need Universal Credit to get by? Why are housing costs swallowing wages? Why are so many people waiting for medical treatment? Why are insecure employment, poor housing and ill health so deeply embedded in our economic model? Some 3.1 million Universal Credit recipients were already in work in April this year. That’s not evidence of a country overwhelmed by people unwilling to work. It’s evidence of an economy in which work itself too often fails to provide security. Of course, Milburn is right about one thing. Too many young people are being failed. We urgently need better mental health services, apprenticeships, training, employment support and good jobs. And he’s right that this requires serious upfront investment. But here’s the contradiction. If poverty, poor health and lack of opportunity are keeping young people out of work, how does making some of them poorer solve the problem? PIP isn’t an unemployment benefit. It helps disabled people meet the additional costs of living, including costs that can enable them to work. Taking that support away and promising better opportunities later isn’t necessarily a route out of poverty. It risks creating another barrier to escaping it. And that’s why this debate has to be about much more than the merits of one report. There is sufficient wealth in this country to provide a decent social security system. What we lack is an economic model that distributes that wealth fairly, invests productively and gives working people genuine power over their lives. Rising welfare expenditure is not simply the cause of our economic difficulties. Much of it is a symptom of an economy that isn’t working as it should. Until we’re prepared to tackle that underlying failure, taking money away from people already struggling is neither economically convincing nor morally defensible. A Labour government should not be taking a penny from people who need support while leaving the structures that generate poverty, insecurity and inequality largely intact. This feels uncomfortably like the unfinished business of the Starmer government: the same old economic assumptions, dressed up in the language of unavoidable choices. Andy Burnham has promised something different. An end to neoliberalism. A more democratic economy. A state that shapes markets rather than simply submitting to them. Well, this is the test. Because you cannot promise to change the economic operating system while continuing to accept its most damaging assumptions. We don’t have to choose between supporting vulnerable people and building a stronger economy. Done properly, the former is part of achieving the latter. The real choice is between continuing to manage the consequences of a broken economy, or finally having the courage to change the economy itself. And that is the choice Labour should be offering the country.
2
5
311
Melani Finn retweeted
كشفت صحيفة "هآرتس" أن 65% من المساعدات التي دخلت إلى قطاع غزة منذ شهر مارس الماضي تم شراؤها من إسرائيل، وتُقدَّر بـ 49,000 شاحنة، بالإضافة إلى 13,500 شاحنة من مصر، و7,000 شاحنة وصلت إلى قبرص ثم انتقلت إلى ميناء أسدود قبل دخولها غزة، و3,000 شاحنة من الأردن، و2,500 شاحنة من الضفة الغربية. وتنتفع إسرائيل مادياً من شراء هذه المساعدات وارتفاع أسعارها، كما تتقاضى أموالاً هائلة على كل شاحنة كرسوم لوجستية، يتخللها انتفاع للضباط والجنود عبر عمليات تهريب للهواتف والسجائر وغيرها، كان أحد المتورطين فيها شقيق رئيس جهاز "الشاباك" الحالي. كما كشفت الصحيفة أن اتفاق وقف إطلاق النار كان ينص على دخول 18,200 شاحنة شهرياً، إلا أنه منذ مارس وحتى يومنا هذا دخلت 75,000 شاحنة بدلاً من 154,700 شاحنة متفق عليها؛ أي أن ما دخل يمثل 48% فقط. وفي الشهرين الأخيرين، انخفض معدل الشاحنات الشهرية بشكل حاد مقارنة بالشهور السابقة. وللعلم، تضع إسرائيل شروطاً على دخول المساعدات عبر المنظمات الإنسانية والدولية، من ضمنها إلزامها بشراء المواد الغذائية من إسرائيل. فغزة تُعدّ سوقاً استهلاكياً يضم مليوني إنسان طالما وجدت إسرائيل نفسها تحت ضغط دولي لإدخال المساعدات، وكثير من هذه المواد مضر بالصحة؛ كالمشروبات الغازية والسكريات الشيبس، إضافة إلى بعض المنتجات التي يقترب انتهاء تاريخ صلاحيتها، فتتخلص الشركات الإسرائيلية منها في غزة بربح عالٍ بدلاً من بيعها داخلياً بتخفيضات مرتفعة وإتلاف ما يتبقى. وفي الوقت ذاته، تحافظ إسرائيل على معدل منخفض لدخول الشاحنات، بالمخالفة للاتفاق، حتى تُبقي غزة في دائرة الاستهلاك اليومي؛ مما يعني إحداث مجاعة سريعة متى أرادت، وضمان رفع الأسعار بما يُثقل كاهل الأهالي ويُفيد الشركات الإسرائيلية، فضلاً عن تشكيل ضغط نفسي وجسدي مستمر على سكان القطاع.
177
3,003
252
4,587
112,599