Historian of Palestine | PhD | Founder of Palestine Nexus ↓

Joined November 2013
6 🧵s to make sense of Israel/Palestine: 1) A history Palestinian non-violent resistance 2) A history of Hamas 3) A history of Israel's ethnic cleansing Palestinians 4) A history of Israel's wars on Gaza 5) A history of Gaza 6) A history of Israel’s use of disproportionate force
1,029
4,410
417
9,534
1,792,119
The Board of Deputies is the most important British Jewish organization. Here is its President, Philip Rosenberg, @PhilR_R, proudly shaking hands with a genocidaire, Gideon Saar, Israel's Foreign Minister since November 2024, a man who has helped slaughter tens of thousands of Palestinians, thousands of Lebanese and thousands of Iranians. The only thing worse than the industrial scale slaughter of an entire people is signing a piece of paper that says Zionism = Racism. The moral decay of British Jewish leaders is at its great point in history. A leadership drunk on apartheid & genocide linkedin.com/posts/philip-ro…
2
45
1
72
1,984
Zachary Foster retweeted
Today, Brad Lander, rabbis, and other New Yorkers accompanied Palestinian farmers during the olive harvest. For that, they were detained by the Israeli government.  Harvesting olives is not illegal. The occupation is. I am thankful that Brad has been released. But other New Yorkers remain detained, and they must be released immediately. The same Israeli government detaining them has committed a horrific genocide against Palestinians, killing more than 74,000 people over the last few years alone.  The detention of these New Yorkers must end. The occupation must end. The genocide must end.
1,142
3,238
138
24,999
522,227
As predicted, the Jewish terrorists arrested for brutalizing & nearly murdering the American journalist Heidi Levin have been released. In Apartheid Israel, impunity is a virtual guarantee for Jewish terrorists. xitter.cf/mrose_may/status/21129…
10 Jewish terrorists get a slap on the wrist (probably less than 24 hours of detention before their release, if history is any guide) for having nearly beaten to death a journalist. At this rate we'll need ~500-1000 white, Jewish Washington Post journalists and / or ~500-1000 white European or American Zionist diplomats to nearly get beaten death to make a dent in Israel's terror network of militias in occupied Palestine.
3
125
4
220
2,485
"Zionism is vast, enormous unbelievably successful rescue project." -Haviv Rettig Gur This is a lie. It's the single biggest lie Zionists tell about Zionism. Zionism was never about rescue. Zionism would be more accurately described as an anti-rescue movement. Zionists sabotaged countless rescue efforts & condemned hundreds of thousand of Jews to death in their greatest hour of need throughout the 1910s, 1920s, 1930s, and 1940s. Let's dive in. 1890s-1914: Before 1914, the Zionist leadership rejected 61% of Jews hoping to colonize Palestine. They were rejected because they were too poor, too persucted. The Zionists wanted wealthy Jews who could bring capital to Palestine to infuse in the Jewish colonies' flailing enterprises. And so, the Jews most likely to suffer from pogroms in the 1880s, 1890s, 1900s and 1910s doubled as the Jews most likely to be rejected by the Palestine Office in Jaffa, led by Menachem Sheinkin & Arthur Ruppin. It was essentially an anti-rescue office sup.org/books/jewish-studies… 1918-1922: hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian Jews fled their homes after the deadliest wave of pogroms to date, leaving tens of thousands killed. Many were looking to Palestine as a safe haven. The Zionist movement categorically rejected them all. The Zionists wanted builders of a nation, not refugees “weak in body and soul.” publish.iupress.indiana.edu/… As Chaim Weizmann said: “Even one percent that’s bad will spoil a great many good people,” He was so worried about the influx he actually persuaded the British authorities to reduce Jewish immigration quotas in the early 1920s, just as Ukraine’s Jews were in their greatest hour of need. haaretz.com/israel-news/2021… 1922: In Urmia, Iran, Jews faced anti-Jewish violence and famine, forcing thousands to seek refuge in Baghdad during & after World War I. The Zionist office in Baghdad wrote to Jaffa that these refugees needed a safe haven. The Zionist leadership said no: They wanted pioneers, not refugees. They were all rejected publish.iupress.indiana.edu/… 1920s-1930s: The Zionist immigration policy was highly selective: immigrants were screened for health, skills, capital & ideological fitness. Sick & diseased Jews were rejected. Orphans, widows, rape victims, famine survivors & bankrupted Jews were “wounded in body or spirit” & therefore rejected. Those seeking to immigrate to Palestine for reasons other than ideological commitment to the cause, such as in search for a safe haven, were rejected. Those who could not afford to pay large sums of money for their immigration certificate or who could not bring enough capital to sustain themselves in Palestine for a year or more or whose skill sets were not relevant in Palestine’s economy were also rejected. publish.iupress.indiana.edu/… and cambridgescholars.com/produc… In 1933, despite Hitler’s rise to power, and despite the increasingly dire situation faced by Europe’s Jews, most Zionist factions continued to support a highly selective immigration policy -- i.e. young, healthy "pioneers", capitalists and professionals -- no refugees. publish.iupress.indiana.edu/… As Ben-Gurion put it in 1933, the Zionist movement was “not primarily engaged in saving individuals … in the event of a conflict of interest between saving individual Jews and the good of the Zionist enterprise … the enterprise comes first.” researchgate.net/publication… Between 1933-1939, two-thirds of German Jewish applicants were rejected, while those accepted were lamented as low quality “human material.” books.google.com.mx/books/ab… During the late 1930s and 1940s, it got worse: For decades, tension had simmered between Jewish Zionists and Jewish humanitarians. For the former, the goal was a Jewish State in Palestine. For the latter, the goal was Jewish safety and prosperity, be it in Palestine, Argentina or Mauritius. In other words, there were the Jews who focused on rescue, on the one hand, and there were the Zionists, on the other. The Zionists were on the anti-rescue side. That's because the Zionists were worried the Jewish donor class would fund rescue efforts over colonization of Palestine. And so the Zionists insisted that the two goals were actually just one goal, that the only way to rescue Jews was to rescue them to Palestine, even if that meant a lot less rescue. The mental gymnastics went something like: in the future, hypothetical Jews would be in need of hypothetical rescue and that the hypothetical Jewish State would be hypothetically focused on that, and that goal trumped the real rescue needs of real Jews today. And so Zionists around the world squashed rescue effort after rescue effort, because these were efforts to rescue Jews to places other than Palestine. At the Evian Conference held in France in 1938, the Dominican Republic President Rafael Trujillo offered to issue up to 100,000 visas for Jewish refugees from Central Europe and settle them in an agricultural colony that became known as the Sosúa settlement. The Zionist movement quickly shot down the idea. dukeupress.edu/tropical-zion and palestineremembered.com/down… In 1938, when British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain suggested Tanganyika in Africa as a possible site for German Jewish refugees, Reform Rabbi and president of the AJC, Stephen Wise, said “I would rather have my fellow Jews die in Germany.” books.google.com.mx/books/ab… Zionist representatives also shot down a British proposal for a settlement of five hundred Jews in British Guiana. dukeupress.edu/tropical-zion 1940: When President Roosevelt proposed a joint plan with Britain in 1940 to admit 150,000 refugees into the US, Zionist leaders opposed it as "treason." Roosevelt ultimately scrapped the initiative, admitting to British officials, “we cannot put it over because the dominant Jewish leadership won’t stand for it.” jstor.org/stable/23881817?se… and archive.org/details/whatpric… 1943: British Zionists sabotaged a motion signed by 277 Members of Parliament calling on the Government to provide asylum in British-controlled territories for victims of Nazi persecution. Both the president of the [Jewish] Board of Deputies, Selig Brodetsky, and the general secretary of the Zionist Federation, Lavy Bakstansky, worked to collapse the initiative on the grounds that the rescue effort omitted any reference to Palestine. google.com/books/edition/Zio… Zionist leaders in the United States also pushed for a Palestine or nothing policy. They rejected a piece of legislation known as the Alaskan Colonization Act, which would have settled ten thousand refugees a year in Alaska over a five-year period, including many Jewish refugees. dukeupress.edu/tropical-zion The Zionist focus on statehood rather than rescue did not come without controversy, even if some Zionists were happy to say the quiet part out loud. As the chairman of the Jewish Agency’s Rescue Committee in Palestine Yitzhak Gruenbaum put it in 1943, “we have to stand before this wave that is putting Zionist activity into the second row… we do not give priority to rescue actions… Zionism is above all - it is necessary to sound this whenever a holocaust diverts us from our war of liberation in Zionism.” researchgate.net/profile/Ton… He repeated the point in 1946. “I will not demand that the Jewish Agency allocate a sum of 300,000 or 100,000 pounds sterling to help European Jewry,” he wrote. “Let them say that I am anti-Semitic… I think that whoever demands such things is performing an anti-Zionist act.” No wonder the Zionist “rescue” committee was given little in terms of resources, funds or personnel, and even declined to accept funds contributed by the United Jewish Appeal for the rescue of Jews in Europe. Its leader thought saving Jewish lives was anti-Zionist. books.google.com.mx/books/ab… Most efforts to rescue Jews to safer places abroad during WWII were sabotaged by the Zionists, who insisted on a Palestine or death policy. After WWII, it got worse. I've written about that here: palestinenexus.com/articles/… Most everyone understands that Zionism was catastrophic for the Palestinians. But, for Jewish supremacists like Haviv, Palestinians do not matter, so they have to invent other feel-good if fictional stories about what the Zionist movement was. Haviv -- do you still believe in other fairy tales you were told as a kid like Santa Clause and the tooth fairy? I've summarized some of these points in this piece below. For more content like this, subscribe to my substack: zacharyfoster.substack.com/p…
He's phenomenal and kudos to @havivrettiggur and @breakfastclubam for this great interview and discussion.
20
130
15
336
9,182
fascism on live stream in the most moral apartheid state in the world
Twelve soldiers + police showed up in Taybeh olive field to stop a single Palestinian olive farmer from harvesting a single tree. After harassing him for 30+ minutes, a car full of some sort of special police officers stormed in and violently arrested the journalist/activist @the_andrey_x. One of the arresting officers shoved me, then showed me his bloody elbow and said I did it to him. (So if they take me next, that’s probably their pretense.) Second and third videos are other angle of the shove (including it here to be safe). Fourth video is from just before—the major military operation to stop a farmer from picking olives. Fascist state.
4
74
3
217
2,728
Zachary Foster retweeted
Horrific. Israel has shut down the borders which carries an impending danger on millions of people stranded in the occupied territory. And it’s not making enough noise around the world.
The markets are completely empty of vegetables and fruit. There is danger ahead.
29
989
17
1,537
18,484
And the @washingtonpost headline didn’t even mention she works with them????
Wow… This is so bad I can’t even correct it. So many words but no mention of Israelis as the attackers and source of violence, or Palestinians as the victims of Israeli occupation.
46
156
3,438
It’s common for Zionists to not call Israel by its name but instead call it “the Jewish State” or comical exaggerations of the point, “the world’s only Jewish State.” This is a rhetoric tool to obfuscate criticism of it … my gosh if I criticize the Jewish state … does that mean I’m against Jews? This obsession with going out of your way to remind me it’s Jewish reminds me of the “Jewish crime” columns that would appear in Nazi newspapers in the 1930s. This too was a rhetorical tool to get you to think Jews are criminals. … my gosh there is so much Jewish crime all the time!
22
24
3
142
4,646
Zachary Foster retweeted
This is what it looks like to cower before authoritarianism. You don't call out a white supremacist president even when he uses classically antisemitic language because you're afraid he'll retaliate against you. jewishcurrents.org/the-shame…
The term “Shylock” is rooted in a longstanding antisemitic stereotype. Regardless of intent, its use can reinforce harmful tropes about Jews and normalize language that has long been used to target the Jewish community.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
The term was used (for at least the second intent in as many years) by President Trump. forbes.com/sites/siladity… Important context to point out the user of the term regardless of intent.
36
172
4
899
27,060
Antisemitism has gotten so bad in the UK that 23,000 Jewish children in the UK have been slaughtered in the past 3 years. Ohhh wait sorry it's the antisemitism industry that supports the country -- Apartheid Israel -- that has murdered 23,000 children.
BREAKING: A landmark government report is set to reveal the vast scale of antisemitism in English schools and colleges, Sky News can exclusively reveal. The report, written by former schools inspector Sir David Bell, will on Wednesday set out 27 recommendations to create change.
46
406
2
1,573
16,490
The Palestinian national identity is inclusive: you can be a Palestinian Muslim, Christian, Druze, Bedouin, Jew, Samaritain and many others** **note: historically, many Jews in Palestine considered themselves Arab, and were considered Arab by others, i.e. they were considered "sons of the country," but the Zionist movement incinerated the idea that Jews could be Arab and thus (tried to and) mostly did kill that identity. [palestinenexus.com/articles/…] By contrast, the Israeli national identity is not inclusive because it does not even exist. Zero people on planet earth have an "Israeli" nationality on their passport. For Israel, you can have a Jewish nationality or an Arab nationality or any number of other nationalities. But you cannot have an Israeli nationality in Israel. The problem with an "Israeli" nationality is that it could be construed to be inclusive and fail to distinguish between Jews & untermenschen and thus it cannot exist.
6
32
1
73
3,394
The most popular myth about the Palestine question is the Zionists "accepted" partition. The accepted partition the same way they accept ceasefires today. They say they accept in public ... but plan to and then violate every single aspect of the agreement. As for partition plan, 0 Zionist political parties accepted the partition of Palestine. As one historian put it, "none of the Zionist parties gave up the aspiration to restore one day the unity of the country ... "The left parties, too, were adamant in their insistence on a unified state. Only five days after the UN resolution was adopted, Ahdut Haavodah, which was committed to the indivisibility of the Jewish state as an absolute historical and spiritual imperative, repudiated the view that “partition is the best or shortest way of realizing greater Zionism.” To be a Zionist means to believe lies are facts. source: books.google.com.mx/books/ab… p.33
19
164
11
355
7,226
If 7 Israelis had been killed by Palestinians today, they would have called it a barbaric massacre. But when Israel kills 7 Palestinians in Gaza, Donald Trump called Netanyahu"a great wartime Prime Minister" & "an even greater partner for peace." wsj.com/opinion/board-of-pea…
🚨 Israeli forces killed at least 7 Palestinians in multiple attacks across Gaza on Tuesday, including a 15-year-old boy and a married couple, and wounded at least six others, Felesteen reported. At least four children have been killed since Sunday. Five Palestinians, including two children, were killed in Gaza yesterday. Those killed today include: 
🔹 A husband and wife, Akram Yassin and Dina Abu Bakr, killed when an Israeli strike hit their apartment near al-Shifa Medical Complex in western Gaza City, setting it on fire. (🎥 1) 
🔹 A boy, Majd Mohammed Fakhri Hassan, 15, shot dead by Israeli forces in Qizan Rashwan, south of Khan Younis, a day after an Israeli drone killed two boys, Walid Shakshak, 13, and Youssef Abu Ghali, 14, in the same area. (📸 2) 
🔹 A Palestinian man, Karam Ahmed Abu Huzayma, killed in the al-Samouni area of Gaza City's Zeitoun neighborhood. 
🔹 Another man, Baraa Mohammed Maarouf, killed by Israeli artillery fire in the Wadi Gaza area. 
🔹 Another Palestinian man, Karam Riyad Abu Ibtihan, killed in an Israeli strike on al-Sawarha cemetery in al-Zawayda that also critically wounded a second man. 
🔹 A man, Mahmoud Khalil al-Mutawwaq, killed by an Israeli drone strike in Jabalia refugee camp.
6
83
2
232
2,909
I cannot think of anything more quintessentially Zionist than expelling Palestinians out of Palestine and replacing them with Jews. ⤵️
An Israeli settler announces that Halutzei Aza, an outpost promoting the resettlement of Gaza, has taken another step toward becoming a permanent settlement. She invites Israelis to join them,openly calling to establish Israeli settlements in the devastated Palestinian territory.
7
179
793
10,816
In August 1946, the Jewish Agency in Palestine, i.e., the government of Israel before it became that, proposed a Jewish state “in an adequate area of Palestine” as follows. Notice Gaza. It has been on the Zionist chopping block since before Israel even existed. books.google.com.mx/books/ab… p.28
20
91
6
245
11,667
Zachary Foster retweeted
Replying to @howardslee
Who fired the first shot of the 1948 Palestine War? Zionists almost always answer this question wrong. They have to. They ideology forces them to obscure the facts of the war. That's essentially what a Zionist lens does to anyone writing history: wraps and distorts the reality. Let's review: On November 20, a week before the Partition Plan’s announcement, the Lehi gang, unprovoked, raided a house near Ra‘anana belonging to the Abu Kishk bedouin tribe and executed five men from the Shubaki family. Seif al-Din Abu Kishk carried out a revenge attack on November 30, the day after the announcement of the plan, ambushing a Jewish bus in the Coastal Plain near Kfar Syrkin, killing five, and then carried out another attack on a bus, southbound from Hadera, killing two more. See Benny Morris, 1948: A History, p.76. This attack is often regarded as the first shot of the war, even though it had nothing to do with the Partition Plan. The organized Palestinian Arab response to the plan was not one of violence, but civil disobedience, a three-day general strike launched by the Arab Higher Committee, the closest thing to a political body representing the Palestinians. (Morris, 1948: A History, p.76). During the first few weeks of the war there was sporadic violence on both sides. And, according to the British, "the spontaneous and unorganised Arab rioting might well have subsided,” wrote the British High Commissioner, had the “Jews not resorted to retaliation with firearms.” (morris, the birth, p.76) But, the Haganah escalation and counter operations, beginning in January 1948, especially its embrace of mass collective punishment, transformed the clashes into a war. In fact, by January, collective punishment became official Zionist policy. “We need to harm them without mercy, women and children included,” Ben-Gurion confessed in his diary on January 1. “During the operation there is no need to distinguish between guilty and not guilty,” he added, since there was no other way to effect the desired outcome, namely, flight. (Pappe, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, p. 69.) Ben-Gurion ordered the Haganah to inflict “collateral damage,” meaning, “every attack has to end with occupation, destruction and expulsion." And, indeed, pamphlets distributed to soldiers reminded them that God “demands a revenge of extermination without mercy to whoever tries to hurt us for no reason.” (Source: google.com/url?q=https://mon…) As one Zionist official put it, the Haganah commanders had concluded that “war was war and that there was no possibility of distinguishing between good and bad Arabs.” (Morris, The Birth, p.100). The British immediately noticed the change in strategy. “The spontaneous and unorganised Arab rioting might well have subsided,” wrote the British High Commissioner, had the “Jews not resorted to retaliation with firearms.” (Morris, the birth, p.76)
15
52
2
145
3,384
Left: In 1948, Jewish militias shot live fire at Palestinians trying to harvest their crops. archive.org/details/birthofp… p. 362. Right: In 2026, Jewish militias setting fires to groves of Palestinians trying to harvest their crops. reuters.com/pictures/israeli… If your ideology (Zionism) leads you to kill Palestinians on an ongoing basis for 78 years for picking olives, maybe the problem is your ideology, not the people picking olives?
In Spring 1948, while Jewish militias were in the process of expelling hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homes, Jewish colonizers in Palestine also began to harvest & steal Palestinian crops from their farms and fields. The reaping was "crucial to the war effort," as one Zionist leader put it. Liberal Zionists don't like it when the Israeli army and its proxy militias steal Palestinian crops in Gaza and the West Bank, yet stealing Palestinian crops lied at the core of the establishment of the State of Israel. What could be more Zionist than stealing Palestinian land and turning it into Jewish land? That is, standing on one foot, Zionism. source: archive.org/details/birthofp… p.361
2
59
2
76
2,858
In Spring 1948, while Jewish militias were in the process of expelling hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homes, Jewish colonizers in Palestine also began to harvest & steal Palestinian crops from their farms and fields. The reaping was "crucial to the war effort," as one Zionist leader put it. Liberal Zionists don't like it when the Israeli army and its proxy militias steal Palestinian crops in Gaza and the West Bank, yet stealing Palestinian crops lied at the core of the establishment of the State of Israel. What could be more Zionist than stealing Palestinian land and turning it into Jewish land? That is, standing on one foot, Zionism. source: archive.org/details/birthofp… p.361
10
162
7
226
6,100
Using the word "Shylock" is infinitely worse than murdering 75,000 people. Sincerely, -the antisemitism industrial complex
12
35
200
4,257
Zachary Foster retweeted
I wont ever forget when you said: “There are no journalists on the ground in Gaza” Bye
50
1,315
18
6,964
77,662