Holy Shit, this is a nuclear bomb on 230
Section 230 does not grant immunity from suit just a legal defense.
We are about to see waves of lawsuits hit social media big tech
🚨🚨🚨 VINDICATED 🚨🚨🚨
For eight years, I have argued one simple thing:
Facebook was never given “immunity” from being sued.
But that is exactly how my case was killed.
Facebook told the court Section 230 gave it immunity from the lawsuit itself, not just a defense to my claims. They did not have to prove good faith, prove they acted lawfully, or really prove anything.
The court adopted that argument almost verbatim and threw my case out with prejudice before discovery, amendment, or any real examination of what Facebook actually did. Essentially, I was not allowed to sue them because of Section 230 “immunity.”
In every filing I kept saying: that is not what the law says.
Eventually I was told I was entitled to my “opinion,” the issue was “definitively decided,” that I was “perpetually relitigating” it, and my lawyer was even warned about continuing to press it or face sanctions.
Except there was a YUGE problem:
Nobody had ever actually decided whether the law provides "immunity from suit."
I told the Ninth Circuit exactly that in March 2025. I did not simply tell them they were wrong. I told them they had never actually considered the immunity question. My motion was denied.
Then, seventeen months later, California v. Meta happened.
Meta again argued that Section 230 had repeatedly been treated as immunity from suit and therefore immunity should be “implied.” In other words, repetition had become the substitute for actually deciding what the law says. That's crazy.
However, this time the Ninth Circuit actually examined the question. They finally did their job.
It admitted its earlier use of “immunity” had been “somewhat loose,” said cases are not precedent for things merely "assumed," and then held:
Section 230 is a defense to liability, NOT immunity from suit.
That is the exact distinction I have been fighting over for eight years.
So yeah, I was right, that is vindication.
The courts have long treated immunity as settled simply through repetition. Have you ever been told this is already settled? It wasn't.
The Ninth Circuit just said that prior usage was not binding because the question had never actually been formally considered, Congress knows how to create immunity when it wants to, and Congress did not do that here.
So after eight years of being told this was long settled, I was proven correct on both points: it had never been settled, and when the Ninth Circuit finally settled it, the answer was the one I had been arguing all along. There is no immunity.
Now, this does not mean I have already won my underlying case.
It means the legal premise used to stop me from ever getting my case heard has now been completely rejected by the appellate court that controls my case. In plain English: the immunity used to kill my case never existed so my dismissal is not based on law.
The question now is whether the courts have the integrity to acknowledge what happened and reopen a case that resulted in a grave miscarriage of justice. I got screwed.
We shall see.
But this is much bigger than me.
Big Tech’s harms are not limited to allegedly addicting kids to social media.
Their business models give them enormous punlisher control over businesses, audiences, advertising, visibility, money and livelihoods.
If a platform uses that power unlawfully, the question should be whether what it did was legal.
The answer cannot simply be:
“Section 230. We’re immune. Case over.”
That world just ended!
I do not expect miracles from the District Court. They have already shown they will not follow controlling law.
But if it refuses to fix this, the appeal goes right back to the Ninth Circuit.
And this time the Ninth Circuit has already answered the question:
Section 230 is a defense. It is not immunity from suit.
Eight years later, the law finally says what I have been saying all along.
There is no Big Tech immunity!
🚨🚨🚨 VINDICATED 🚨🚨🚨
For eight years, I have argued one simple thing:
Facebook was never given “immunity” from being sued.
But that is exactly how my case was killed.
Facebook told the court Section 230 gave it immunity from the lawsuit itself, not just a defense to my claims. They did not have to prove good faith, prove they acted lawfully, or really prove anything.
The court adopted that argument almost verbatim and threw my case out with prejudice before discovery, amendment, or any real examination of what Facebook actually did. Essentially, I was not allowed to sue them because of Section 230 “immunity.”
In every filing I kept saying: that is not what the law says.
Eventually I was told I was entitled to my “opinion,” the issue was “definitively decided,” that I was “perpetually relitigating” it, and my lawyer was even warned about continuing to press it or face sanctions.
Except there was a YUGE problem:
Nobody had ever actually decided whether the law provides "immunity from suit."
I told the Ninth Circuit exactly that in March 2025. I did not simply tell them they were wrong. I told them they had never actually considered the immunity question. My motion was denied.
Then, seventeen months later, California v. Meta happened.
Meta again argued that Section 230 had repeatedly been treated as immunity from suit and therefore immunity should be “implied.” In other words, repetition had become the substitute for actually deciding what the law says. That's crazy.
However, this time the Ninth Circuit actually examined the question. They finally did their job.
It admitted its earlier use of “immunity” had been “somewhat loose,” said cases are not precedent for things merely "assumed," and then held:
Section 230 is a defense to liability, NOT immunity from suit.
That is the exact distinction I have been fighting over for eight years.
So yeah, I was right, that is vindication.
The courts have long treated immunity as settled simply through repetition. Have you ever been told this is already settled? It wasn't.
The Ninth Circuit just said that prior usage was not binding because the question had never actually been formally considered, Congress knows how to create immunity when it wants to, and Congress did not do that here.
So after eight years of being told this was long settled, I was proven correct on both points: it had never been settled, and when the Ninth Circuit finally settled it, the answer was the one I had been arguing all along. There is no immunity.
Now, this does not mean I have already won my underlying case.
It means the legal premise used to stop me from ever getting my case heard has now been completely rejected by the appellate court that controls my case. In plain English: the immunity used to kill my case never existed so my dismissal is not based on law.
The question now is whether the courts have the integrity to acknowledge what happened and reopen a case that resulted in a grave miscarriage of justice. I got screwed.
We shall see.
But this is much bigger than me.
Big Tech’s harms are not limited to allegedly addicting kids to social media.
Their business models give them enormous punlisher control over businesses, audiences, advertising, visibility, money and livelihoods.
If a platform uses that power unlawfully, the question should be whether what it did was legal.
The answer cannot simply be:
“Section 230. We’re immune. Case over.”
That world just ended!
I do not expect miracles from the District Court. They have already shown they will not follow controlling law.
But if it refuses to fix this, the appeal goes right back to the Ninth Circuit.
And this time the Ninth Circuit has already answered the question:
Section 230 is a defense. It is not immunity from suit.
Eight years later, the law finally says what I have been saying all along.
There is no Big Tech immunity!
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
Sushi🍣
Thanks for including my OC in this illustration XD
#commission for @WhyTrashEarth
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
Comm result for @WhyTrashEarth !!
Thank you for commissioning :3 ✨✨
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
Airi Venturi 🌎 - Colored sketch commission for @WhyTrashEarth ~
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
#Commission for @WhyTrashEarth 🏝️
Yippie, there's Lia and Nata!
Thanks for including my OC here XD
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
Ty so much for the commission! @WhyTrashEarth
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
"I'm ready to make the air on earth fresh again!"
Commission for @AirVentAware from @WhyTrashEarth 🌏☁️
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
🚨🚨🚨UPDATE:
For those following the evolution of my case against Facebook, we are now two months away from our April 15th filing deadline. A complete first draft is under review, and we are happy to announce that we have already secured multiple amicus briefs in support of this third effort to resolve the Section 230 problem—which, in turn, would address the broader issue of censorship and Big Tech accountability.
If you or someone you know represents an organization interested in filing an amicus brief on this free speech critical matter, please reach out—my DMs are open. Tag any organizations that may have a vested interest in defending free speech and due process online.
For those seeking clarity on Section 230’s direct role in internet censorship, I highly encourage you to read "Section 230 for Dummies." (Link provided at the bottom) This Internet legal battle is winnable—and if the Supreme Court grants this cert, my case could be the turning point. It could change the world as we know it.
This fight is as important as it gets—free speech and due process are literally on the line.🇺🇲
Section 230 for Dummies: socialmediafreedom.org/secti…
WhyTrashEarth 🌎 retweeted
My brother Otis & his family lost their home in the Eaton Fire. Let’s help them rebuild.
donorbox.org/madlibrebuild

































