Pessimist of the intellect, optimist of the will. Editorial lead at AJ+. Views are my own, not those of my employer. RT ≠ endorsement

New York
Joined May 2010
With a shepherding community, Khirbet al-Marajim. These people don’t have much, but he had a horse. Settlers stole it.
11
261
7
758
10,816
Tony Karon retweeted
Correct me if I am wrong, but from a distance it seems the main stakes of the Israeli election is if Eisenkot can prevail it will help liberal zi*nists in US legacy media continue to play make-believe about what it is they support.
3
2
1
36
1,980
Tony Karon retweeted
Why does Iran remain defiant in the face of severe economic pressure and threat of renewed war? In our new piece in @ForeignAffairs Narges Bajoghli and I examine what is being missed in how Iran sees the state of play There is no doubt that Washington has dealt significant damage to Iran. But the Islamic Republic does not believe it is unraveling. In fact, Tehran thinks that it will defeat the United States—and it isn’t hard to see why. The Iranian government did not merely survive the U.S.-Israeli bombardment. It retaliated ferociously, damaging American military bases and obstructing the Strait of Hormuz. Its people are paying a hefty economic price thanks to damage caused by the war and Washington’s cutoffs, but much of the population has rallied around the flag and seems to accept that hardship is necessary if Iran is to defend itself. As a result, Tehran has been emboldened. Its officials may not see eye to eye on each tactic. But they share the same ambitions: evicting U.S. forces from the Persian Gulf, forcing Washington to remove all its sanctions, and getting the United States to accept that Iran is a great power. This agenda might sound overly audacious, given that Iran has been materially weakened. But the Islamic Republic thinks its aims are within reach. It believes its military can drive U.S. troops from the Persian Gulf by continuing to strike American bases directly and by getting Arab countries to push the United States to leave. It thinks that by wreaking havoc on energy markets, it can force Washington to lift economic restrictions, as well. Tehran’s theory of victory, in other words, is that it can hold out and inflict enough pain that the United States will end its containment of Iran. But strategically, the conflict has been disastrous. U.S. officials believed that punishing aerial bombardments and sweeping efforts to degrade the Iranian economy would bring the Islamic Republic to its knees. They didn’t. Washington hoped that assassinating Khamenei would prompt a mass antigovernment uprising. That scheme also failed. Instead, Khamenei’s death brought out the Islamic Republic’s ardent supporters. They marched every night in the country’s main cities and were eventually joined by Iranians of other political hues, who rallied in support of their homeland. When the war started, Turkey planned to accommodate 70,000 Iranian refugees. But few people fled. In fact, as the war progressed, many Iranians living abroad returned home, including long-exiled cultural figures, journalists, and politicians, such as the singers Mohsen Namjoo and Bijan Mortazavi. This surge in nationalism is not an endorsement of the Islamic Republic. Many Iranians remain deeply unhappy with the country’s leadership. But the anger at their government has been subsumed by their anger at Washington. Previously, most Iranians were skeptical of the Islamic Republic’s claim that the United States was bent on their country’s destruction and in fact hoped Tehran would seek better relations with Washington. But the bombings of Iranian cities and U.S. President Donald Trump’s repeated threats to annihilate the country’s civilization (saying, for example, that he might “blow the entire nation up” and drive it “into hell with no chance of survival”) have changed attitudes. Iranians across the political spectrum now do think that the United States wants to obliterate their country—or at least make it capitulate to every American demand. foreignaffairs.com/iran/iran…
151
21
415
56,966
Tony Karon retweeted
The death penalty is inadmissible because it is an attack on the inviolability and dignity of the person. The common good can be safeguarded and the requirements of justice can be met without recourse to capital punishment: effective systems of detention have been developed that protect citizens while at the same time do not completely deprive those who are guilty of the possibility of redemption. #NoDeathPenalty
25,131
15,607
6,373
122,467
12,533,015
Tony Karon retweeted
I honestly can't believe that this level of repression would ever be seen in New Delhi. It is beyond shocking.
Despite the State, on this dark day ordinary people did whatever they could to defend our freedom of Speech, right to assemble, above all our right to vote. And save democracy in New Delhi. The State was out in full force, afraid of it citizens defending their rights.
52
278
14
925
30,189
As a Palestinian, I want more people to understand our history, our dispossession, our pain, and our right to live in freedom. Mamdani and Abdul are breaking stereotypes, shifting the conversation, and making Palestine impossible to ignore in American politics. We can criticize him. We can push him. We can disagree with him. But calling him a traitor because he doesn’t meet everyone’s ideological expectations? That’s not strategy. That’s shooting ourselves in the foot. We need to start asking ourselves: are we trying to win arguments, or win people?
A little outside my usual lane, but this needs to be said. 1/2 Since Abdul’s interview with Ezra Klein, I’ve watched parts of our movement go after him. On Wednesday, protesters chanted “traitor” at Zohran. I know I’ll be attacked for saying this, but I can’t stay quiet anymore while we turn on two of the most powerful advocates for Palestine in US politics. I think we’re missing the bigger picture. Zohran and Abdul are not only reaching millions of Americans outside our bubble, they're changing the way those Americans see Arabs and Muslims. For decades, Hollywood portrayed us as terrorists and religious extremists, a threat to the West. In Reel Bad Arabs, Jack Shaheen documented how Hollywood systematically depicted Arabs as villains across more than 900 films, and that was even before 9/11. I have no doubt that this dehumanization contributed enormously to the lack of empathy Palestinians received for decades. Now look at Abdul and Zohran. They're putting Arabs and Muslims in the middle of American political life as competent, principled American politicians, talking about healthcare, housing and the things that affect Americans' daily lives, without abandoning Palestine. A perfect example of that is Abdul's interviews on Fox. If you haven't seen them, I urge you to watch them before passing any further judgment. He was so compelling and so eloquent that even Jesse Watters, the Fox host, said afterward: “I like him. I don’t want to like him. I like him for some stupid reason.” And it's not just that. Zohran warned that Gaza was on the brink of genocide on October 13, 2023, and Abdul was calling it a genocide by October 21. Long before they became prominent political figures, they took enormous risks by challenging the boundaries of acceptable political discourse. And look how much those boundaries have shifted since. Without a doubt, Zohran taking that stance and winning in New York home to the largest Jewish community outside Israel was one of the biggest drivers of the broader shift we’re seeing within the Democratic Party. Kamala Harris, who many hate for denying and enabling the genocide in Gaza is now endorsing Abdul, who calls Gaza a genocide and wants to stop arms sales to Israel. If that isn't a win for the movement, what is? And yet instead of celebrating it, we're angry at Abdul for receiving her endorsement. Abdul did all this while also acknowledging the Jewish trauma from the Holocaust in his interview with Ezra Klein. Isn't that exactly what we've always wished politicians would do: represent all their constituents, including Jewish people, while refusing to compromise their moral principles? And that trauma is real for Jewish people. What we Palestinians hate is how Israel has used that trauma to justify our oppression and dispossession. Just to clarify: I don’t agree with everything they both say either. In the Ezra Klein interview, I wish Abdul had talked more about Palestinian trauma and what happened in 1948 as people don't understand it in the same way we all understand the trauma of the Holocaust. But why does the responsibility of explaining that fall solely on him? Yes, he could have done better, but so could we as a movement.
43
168
15
882
39,488
Tony Karon retweeted
Victor Wembanyama, interrogé sur le mouvement lycéen en France (via @MaximeAubin1) : "Ce qui me touche, c'est que ce n'est pas quelque chose de totalement inconnu pour moi. J'étais au lycée à Nanterre, qui était déjà un bastion des blocus à l'époque. J'étais lycéen il n'y a pas si longtemps. J'ai eu la chance de m'extraire, c'est une situation que j'ai la chance de ne plus vivre. Ce sont des inégalités systémiques, des problèmes tellement profonds... Je suis content que les lycéens, les jeunes en général se fassent entendre, car je les entends et je les soutiens. Et j'espère que les gens qui sont tout là-haut en feront de même".
339
6,032
462
39,882
1,902,649
I don’t understand what those protesters aim to accomplish! If Mamdani hangs a Sinwar poster at city hall, then what? What impact would that have? Was Nelson Mandela a “sellout” for acknowledging the suffering white Afrikaaners endured in concentration camps in the 2nd Boer War? Was Mandela a “traitor” for saying Afrikaners as a collective group were not put "in the accused dock" or held collectively guilty for the sins of apartheid? Attending a vigil for Israelis & Palestinians doesn’t mean capitulating, throwing Gaza under the bus, drawing false symmetries or covering up the genocide! Mamdani is still consistently speaking up about Israel's crimes & atrocities, & is trying to build a broad coalition to do something about those crimes. In coalition building, there's a difference between a comrade (with whom you agree 100%) & an ally (with whom you may agree on one or two issues & work together towards them). Saying "I would only work with comrades who fully agree with me" is the recipe for dooming your movement to remaining a tiny ineffective minority. The goal is to unite the many against the few, not the few against the many.
At an Oct. 7 vigil for Israelis and Palestinians organized by Israelis, a testimony from a Palestinian victim is read. Mamdani watches on as pro-Palestine protestors hold photos of Sinwar and scream “Mamdani you can’t hide, you’re committing genocide.”
118
213
47
1,238
83,533
Tony Karon retweeted
He is JUST the fucking mayor. How much the hell do u expect him to do?! Stop this madness, ffs. He could’ve easily said NOTHING about Palestine or Israel, stuck to NYC issues, and honestly, nobody could blame him. That’s what a fucking mayor is supposed to focus on. But instead, he’s doing something almost NO American politician is willing to do: saying it loud, saying it clearly, and putting Palestine right at the fucking center of American political discussion. And this is how you respond?! WTF ARE u DOING? You’re attacking one of the very few politicians actually bringing Palestine into the mainstream and you’re making other politicians who might even consider speaking up think twice. At this rate, I honestly wouldn’t blame him if he woke up tomorrow and said, “Fuck this. I’m done with Palestine.” You’re not helping Palestine. You’re fucking scaring people away from it.
229
422
63
4,086
138,553
Tony Karon retweeted
Combined with the fact the US permits unlimited spending on elections, this distribution of wealth is entirely irreconcilable with democracy.
The top 0.1% of Americans now hold more than six times more wealth than the bottom half.
15
301
5
1,528
15,899
Tony Karon retweeted
Trita Parsi
@tparsiOct 7
I guess this is what happens when AIPAC-AI writes your talking points without any human in the chain to check for basic humanity. David Valadao (R-CA-22) literally says that military aid to Israel helps the US because the money goes to the production and TESTING of American weapons systems. "The fact that those weapons are used there and tested there, we are able to learn from that." He goes on to describe it as an "opportunity" to test weapons and learn from it. We knew AI was steering Israel's genocide in Gaza. It appears it is also steering its political strategy in the US...
55
564
17
1,982
61,342
Tony Karon retweeted
The US's elite liberal meritocracy (Booker is a Rhodes Scholar and Yale Law School alum in addition to a Senator), white or nonwhite, are all exactly the same. They are also a model of class loyalty to one another.
. @brett_mcgurk is one of our nation’s great experts on the Middle East and has spent decades working at the highest levels of diplomacy through some of the region’s most consequential moments. I’m really looking forward to reading Brink and learning from his firsthand account of the extraordinary efforts to free the hostages, and confront the extraordinary challenges of the region.
12
37
1
186
5,030
Tony Karon retweeted
“The past three years have made painfully clear that Palestine won’t be liberated or even saved by winning a contest over virtue or visibility on social media — a liberation struggle is always, primarily, a struggle over power, and social media is a simulacrum rather than a site of actual power.” @TonyKaron tonykaron.substack.com/p/why…
3
2
3
472
Tony Karon retweeted
I have not seen a better explanation of Manchester City's case.
94
2,261
114
9,713
751,894
Tony Karon retweeted
Pete Hegseth’s Crisis of Masculinity theintercept.com/2026/07/25/…
Hegseth: "The ideological clowns are out. The patriotic cowboys are in, with testosterone testing on top."
6
11
36
1,609
Tony Karon retweeted
This is deeply disturbing but we must bear witness. Mohammed Al-Najjar's children are weeping over his body in this footage. The reason he is in a shroud is that he was missing his head after Israel murdered him. But will this be picked up widely in Western media? Of course not.
🚨BREAKING: Palestinian journalist Mohammed Al-Najjar was killed today in Khan Younis after an Israeli strike hit his hometown of Khuza’a, south of Gaza Strip. He leaves behind three children who were waiting for their father to return. They were denied even a final farewell after his body was returned to his family without his head.
298
2,483
47
4,401
81,865
For more than two months, I have been working on a truly horrific story about one of the gravest war crimes committed by the United States since Vietnam: The bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh school in Minab, Iran. It was one of the first targets struck in the opening hours of the war on February 28, 2026. At least 156 people were killed in the U.S. cruise missile strikes—120 of them were children and 26 were teachers. We spoke to survivors, first responders, parents, doctors, teachers, psychologists, and other witnesses. Some of them had never before shared their experiences of that day. It would be impossible to do justice to what happened in Minab that day with words alone. In more than 25 years in journalism and reporting on war, I do not believe I have reported on a more heinous single crime. Massacre at Minab: The School That Became a Grave dropsitenews.com/p/minab-sch… Please share this story with as many people as you can.
486
12,963
570
28,163
1,867,884
The gravity of the suffering in Gaza in one photo. Every publication should feature this photo as a reminder of the international community's failure.
2
1
491