A Kentucky mother shot her two little boys, 9 and 6, in the head inside their home. Then she walked next door and collapsed on the neighbor’s driveway after telling him what she had done. An hour and a half later, barefoot in a sheriff’s office interview room, claiming she had shot herself in the ear, she wanted the detective to understand one thing:
“I know I look crazy, but I’m not crazy.” That’s Tiffanie Lucas, 32, of Shepherdsville, Kentucky. She told him she loved her boys so much and would never hurt them. Then she explained who was really to blame:
Video games. YouTube. And “someone” who “put something upon my house.”
On November 8, 2023, a neighbor walked out to his truck and found Lucas collapsed on his driveway. According to deputies on the scene, she told him she had shot her kids. He went next door and found Jayden Howard, 9, and Maurice Baker Jr., 6, with gunshot wounds to the head. Both boys died at the hospital.
When a deputy got her off the ground and asked why she couldn’t stand up, she said, “I just don’t feel like it.”
At the sheriff’s office, she told deputies she had shot herself in the ear. They checked. There was nothing there.
In the video below, you’ll see the bodycam from that day: the interview room, the driveway, the deputy checking her ear, and Lucas accusing the detective’s phone of going off every time she spoke. Then the boys’ aunt in court, and the sentence.
She later told police it was an accident, and that the gun must have gone off after she left it in the bedroom. Investigators didn’t believe her. Her defense first pursued an insanity claim.
In October 2024, she pleaded guilty to both murders with no deal, leaving her sentence entirely to the judge.
On November 22, 2024, Judge Rodney Burress sentenced her to life in prison on both counts, the maximum she faced. The boys’ aunt told her: “I often see these court shows where the defendants are forgiven by the victim’s family, but not today. Not by me. I will never forgive you.”
Jayden’s grandmother reminded her the family would have taken the boys: “You could have gave them kids to us. But you have been selfish.”
Under Kentucky law, she will likely be eligible for parole after 20 years. The prosecutor says it’s very unlikely she’ll get it.
Two boys, shot in their own home. A mother who blamed the PlayStation.
Was this a mother in a psychotic break, or a killer who knew exactly how “crazy” would sound?
A Cleveland mom left her 16-month-old alone in a playpen for 10 days while she vacationed in Detroit and Puerto Rico. The baby starved to death. Before calling 911, the mom changed her into a clean outfit. Then she told the officer the baby had cried “last night,” and said:
“When I see her, she looks like really, really dry.” That’s Kristel Candelario on June 16, 2023, in an armchair in front of a police body camera. While she was gone, a neighbor’s doorbell camera recorded Jailyn screaming. Her mom was posting this:
A photo of herself barefoot and smiling on a beach, captioned: “The time that is enjoyed is the true time lived.”
On June 6, 2023, Kristel left Jailyn in a playpen at their house on West Boulevard with a few bottles of milk, and left town. Her parents, who were looking after her older daughter, thought she was home with the baby.
It wasn’t the first time. Neighbors said she once asked them to watch Jailyn for a weekend that turned into a month and a half. Right before the trip, she had left her alone for two days.
She got back early on June 16. The medical examiner said Jailyn weighed 13 pounds, seven less than at a doctor’s visit two months earlier. Her eyes were sunken. There was feces under her fingernails and in her mouth. The playpen liner was soaked through. Cause of death: starvation and severe dehydration.
In the video below: the bodycam that morning. She tells the officer Jailyn had been vomiting “Monday and Tuesday” and that she gave her Tylenol. Investigators say she wasn’t even in Ohio on those days. Then her sentencing, nine months later.
In February 2024 she pleaded guilty to aggravated murder and child endangering. Her lawyer said she had stopped taking her antidepressants and had attempted suicide in 2023. Her parents asked for mercy. Through an interpreter she told the court, “I am not trying to justify my actions, but nobody knew how much I was suffering.”
Judge Brendan Sheehan called it “the ultimate act of betrayal” and gave her life without parole. “I see photos of you on a beach while your child was eating her own feces in an attempt to survive,” he said. “The only difference will be that prison will at least feed you and give you liquids that you denied her.”
She never laid a hand on Jailyn. She just left her in that playpen for 10 days. Was life without parole the right sentence, or should prosecutors have gone for the death penalty?
He shot an 18-year-old high school football player in the head during a robbery. Then 17-year-old Danta Wright sat in court smiling while the victim’s family cried, and told the room: “I’ll be home soon.”
Jordan Klee was a senior at Pioneer High School in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and wore No. 42 on the varsity team. On an October afternoon in 2016, a maintenance worker found him on a dirt path outside the condo complex where he lived. He had been shot once.
Within days, police arrested three teenagers. At a hearing the next June, Wright admitted that he and two friends had tried to rob Klee. Asked where he shot him, he said: “In the top, by his head.” Asked whether that shot killed him, he said: “Yes.”
He took a plea deal for second-degree murder. At sentencing in July 2017, Klee’s family read their statements. “I’ve lost my only child, my son, my baby, my friend.” Wright smiled and nearly laughed. When it was his turn to speak, he didn’t apologize. “I just want to tell y’all I’ll be home soon… I love my family.”
Judge David Swartz said he was tempted to throw out the deal and send the case to trial. A felony murder conviction would mean life in prison, he warned, and he’d die there. During a recess, Klee’s family asked him not to, so they could move on. He kept the deal: 25 to 52 years. Wright’s lawyer said some people “display fear by smiling.” The two other teens pleaded guilty and got 15 to 40 years each.
“Home soon” means his early 40s at best. That’s the earliest he can be released.
In the video below, watch him grin through the family’s statements, then watch the judge lose it.
The judge wanted life. The family wanted it over. Did they make the right call?
5
7
856
“Aiden Fucci, your deplorable actions are unforgivable, and I will pray every day that you stay in prison.” Stacy Bailey said it to the teenager who killed her daughter, a few feet from him in a Florida courtroom. Then she told the judge: “Please do not for one second think that he could be rehabilitated at any point. He is beyond saving.”
Her daughter, Tristyn, was 13, a cheerleader in St. Johns County, Florida. On Mother’s Day 2021, she went into the woods near her neighborhood with a 14-year-old classmate. She was stabbed at least 114 times. That classmate was Aiden Fucci.
Before the sentence, Tristyn’s older sister, Alexis, stood at a jar. She dropped in 114 aqua stone hearts, “one for each of the 114 stab wounds that my sister had to endure.” Then their mother added two white ones: one for Tristyn’s younger sister, who lost the chance to be a big sister, and one for herself, for the joy and future she’d lost. “For us,” Alexis said, “justice does not exist in this case and closure does not exist in this case.”
Fucci had pleaded guilty just as his trial was about to begin. He wrote the judge a letter: “I’m sorry for all the pain I caused to the Bailey family.” It apologized to his own parents and to the community, but not to Tristyn.
Judge R. Lee Smith wasn’t moved. It wasn’t a crime of passion, he said, and it wasn’t because Fucci felt rejected by her. “There was no reason. There was no purpose.” It was done “for no other reason than to satisfy this defendant’s internal desire to feel what it was like to kill someone.” He sentenced Fucci, then 16, to life in prison.
Because Fucci was a juvenile, Florida law gives him a sentence review after 25 years. An appeals court has since upheld the sentence. The Baileys now run the Tristyn Bailey Foundation, which teaches kids about online safety.
In the video below, Judge Smith explains why there’s no excuse, as Fucci sits in a red jumpsuit and stares down at the table. Then her father, Forrest Bailey, steps up to the microphones outside the courthouse. He doesn’t mention Fucci once. He talks to his daughter: “We are so extremely proud of the person that you were in your time here. … There are no words. We love you. And we will always be the Bailey Seven.”
Her mother says he’s beyond saving, and the law says he gets a review in 25 years. Should he ever get a second chance?
1
3
459
Jared Bridegan stopped his car to move a tire out of the road. It had been put there so he would stop. When he got out, he was shot, and some of the bullets went through the car, inches from his 2-year-old daughter in her car seat.
Yesterday, the man prosecutors call one of the “architects” of that ambush was sentenced to life in prison. His wife is next.
February 16, 2022, Jacksonville Beach, Florida. Bridegan, 33, was a senior design manager at Microsoft and a father of four. That night he had dropped his 9-year-old twins off at his ex-wife’s house, as he did regularly. Minutes later, he was dead on the side of the road. His ex-wife, Shanna Gardner, and he had been in a long, bitter custody fight over the twins. She had remarried, to Mario Fernandez Saldana. After the shooting, she moved across the country to Washington state.
Investigators traced a blue pickup seen on security video to Henry Tenon, a former tenant of Fernandez Saldana’s. His DNA was on the tire in the road. A matching tire turned up at the rental property where he had lived. Prosecutors said Fernandez Saldana recruited him, helped get the gun and paid him at least $10,000 afterward. When Tenon was arrested, Fernandez Saldana allegedly wiped his phone and tried to sell the property.
There was no DNA, footage or witness putting Fernandez Saldana at the scene. Prosecutors said that was because of how the killing was planned. In August, the jury convicted him of first-degree murder anyway. “Mario did not break us,” Bridegan’s widow, Kirsten, told the court at his sentencing.
Tenon admitted to being the gunman and pleaded guilty, then took the plea back and said he won’t testify. Gardner has pleaded not guilty. They will be tried together in May.
In the video below, the verdict is read on August 26. Fernandez Saldana is told to rise and hear it: guilty of first-degree murder, then guilty of solicitation to commit a capital felony. He barely moves. He never pulled the trigger, and he still got the maximum.
One man convicted and two to go. The woman in the custody fight and the man who admitted to firing the gun go on trial together in May. Will the next jury convict them too?
3
3
438
He begged his wife and daughters to come home on TV. He already knew where they were: one in a shallow grave, two inside crude oil tanks. He’d put them there himself.
“Shanann, Bella, Celeste, if you’re out there, just come back,” Chris Watts said into the camera. He talked about missing kissing his girls goodnight. “My kids are my life,” he said. “Those smiles light up my life.”
August 2018, Frederick, Colorado. Shanann Watts was 34 and 15 weeks pregnant with a boy the family called Nico. She got home from a business trip around 2 a.m. on August 13. A few hours later, Chris strangled her in their bedroom. Then he loaded her body and their daughters, Bella, 4, and Celeste, 3, into his work truck and drove to an oil site where he worked. The girls were still alive.
He buried Shanann in a shallow grave there and put the girls inside crude oil tanks. Then he went to work. He was having an affair with a coworker.
To reporters, he was a worried husband. Her return home at 2 a.m. was a “traumatic night,” he said, and they’d had “an emotional conversation, but I’ll leave it at that.” The next day he failed a polygraph and confessed to killing Shanann. At first he blamed her for the girls’ deaths. Months later he admitted he had smothered them himself.
He pleaded guilty to avoid the death penalty, which Shanann’s family had asked prosecutors not to seek. In November 2018, he got five life sentences without parole, three of them back to back, plus 84 years. The judge called it “perhaps the most inhumane and vicious crime” he had ever handled. Shanann’s father called him a “monster.”
In the video below is that interview. Watch his face while he begs them to come home. He shifts his weight, he half smiles, and he talks about his wife in the past tense. Investigators later said that interview was one of the reasons they focused on him.
He begged them to come home a day after he put them in the ground. Was it all an act, or did part of him believe it?
2
2
97
“My wife tried to commit suicide.” That’s how Patrick Clancy’s 911 call began. He had come home to a quiet house in Duxbury, Massachusetts, and found his wife badly hurt in the backyard. She told him the kids were in the basement. Halfway through the call, he went down to check on them. “She killed the kids!”
It was January 24, 2023. Cora was 5, Dawson was 3 and Callan was 8 months old. All three had been strangled in the basement. Lindsay Clancy, a labor and delivery nurse, survived her suicide attempt but is paralyzed from the waist down.
She has never denied killing them. Her defense is that she wasn’t criminally responsible: postpartum psychosis, and a male voice she says ordered her to kill the children and herself. Prosecutors said she was well enough to plan it.
Last summer, jurors heard that 911 call. Patrick, now her ex-husband, had to leave the courtroom before it was played. He testified that weeks before the deaths, she had told him she had thoughts of harming herself and the children. After five weeks and more than 80 witnesses, the jury deliberated for six days. In September, they sent the judge a note: “It is with a heavy heart that we report we are unable to come to a unanimous decision.” It was 11 against 1. Mistrial.
On Monday, the judge rejected her lawyers’ attempt to end the case for good on double-jeopardy grounds. That leaves the door open for a second trial, possibly as early as March. Her defense says it will appeal to the state’s highest court. Prosecutors haven’t said whether they’ll retry her on first-degree murder or on lesser charges.
Patrick is also suing her psychiatrist and nurse practitioner for wrongful death. They testified that she repeatedly denied having thoughts of hurting her children. His lawyer says Lindsay herself will contradict that once her criminal case is over.
In the video below, Patrick is on the stand. He describes coming home to a locked bedroom door, “and that’s when I knew something was wrong,” and asking where the kids were: “She said they’re in the basement.” Across the room, Lindsay covers her face and cries. Then he repeats what she told him the voice had said: that if she didn’t do it now, she would lose her chance.
Eleven jurors agreed and one didn’t, so a new jury may have to decide all over again. Should the next jury hold her responsible? Tell us in the comments.
6
5
606
A daughter was about to stand up in court and tell a judge what losing her mother had done to her family. She never got to start. Her brother jumped over a table, grabbed the handcuffed killer by the foot and dragged him out of his chair onto the floor. A second brother came around the other side.
It was July 11, 2019, in Youngstown, Ohio. Jerome Stewart, 23, and Anthony Dees, 30, had not seen Dale Williams Sr. since the day their mother died. Neither of them had a criminal record. Deputies piled in, and one of the brothers was hit with a Taser.
Their mother was Elizabeth Pledger-Stewart, 46. On the night of June 14, 2017, she filed a domestic violence complaint against Williams. The next morning he sat in a parking lot on Market Street for about 45 minutes, waiting for her car. When he saw it, he pulled out, rammed her into a building and shot her several times as she begged for her life. Police arrived while it was happening.
When detectives questioned him, he blamed the other drivers on the road. He called them “insensitive” for not letting him into traffic.
The sentencing was called off, and Williams was taken to a hospital to be checked. Four days later he was back in court and got 23 years to life. Asked if he had anything to say, he declined. The victim’s aunt apologized for her nephews, then told the court that Williams “shot her like an animal.”
The brothers got 30 days in jail for contempt, plus charges of assault and obstructing official business. They pleaded not guilty to the assault charge.
In the video below is the courtroom camera from that first hearing. One brother clears the table in a single jump. The other, dressed in orange, runs around it. Watch how many deputies it takes to pull them off.
He waited 45 minutes for her. They waited two years for him. Should the brothers have been charged at all?
Georgia’s Supreme Court has refused to hear Colt Gray’s appeal. He was 14 when he opened fire at Apalachee High School, and he wanted a new sentence. Now the one he got in July stands: life without parole. He’s 16, and he is expected to die in prison.
His lawyers had argued that sending a teenager away forever was too harsh. They pointed to his age, his mental health and an abusive childhood. The judge didn’t accept that. Neither did the state’s highest court.
On September 4, 2024, in Winder, Georgia, Gray killed two students, Mason Schermerhorn and Christian Angulo, both 14, and two teachers, Richard Aspinwall, 39, and Cristina Irimie, 53. Nine other people were injured. He pleaded guilty to 55 charges. At sentencing, Judge Nicholas Primm told him: “You weren’t being bullied at Apalachee.” Prosecutors said he had been planning a mass shooting since 2023.
With the appeal gone, his part of the case is essentially over. The harder question is what happened in 2023, because someone did warn the authorities that year.
In May 2023, the FBI received tips about an online account threatening a school shooting, and the trail led to the Grays’ house. In the video below, a deputy stands on their porch and asks the father whether the guns are accessible to his son. “I mean, there’s nothing loaded,” Colin Gray says, and the guns “won’t be accessible to him.” He says the boy is being picked on at school. Colt, 13, says, “No, I swear.” The deputy leaves with no arrest and no charges.
Seven months later, prosecutors say, the father gave his son a rifle as a Christmas present. In July, Colin Gray was sentenced to 15 years for second-degree murder, involuntary manslaughter and cruelty to children.
The son will die in prison, and the father got 15 years. Could it all have been stopped on that porch?
3
3
460
