Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY) header
Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY) profile picture

Ruminations on Torah, and Jewish Scholarship, History, and Education from a finance guy

Joined July 2022
Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)Photo by Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el (@TannadebeRY)
Tanna debè Ribbi Yishma'el retweeted
עושה מעשה זמרי ומבקש שכר כפנחס
🇳🇱 Dutch Prime Minister Rob Jetten has decided to place a mezuzah on the doorpost of his home in Amsterdam, in a powerful gesture of solidarity with the Jewish community. Speaking about the rise in antisemitism, Jetten described how some Jewish families are afraid to display mezuzahs on their doors for fear of hostility. His message was clear: Jewish people should never have to hide their identity or feel unsafe in their own country. At a time when antisemitism and hostility toward Israel are increasingly visible across Europe, this is a meaningful gesture that deserves recognition. Standing against antisemitism and defending the right of Israel to exist in peace and security should never be mutually exclusive. Source: Dutch Government , Reganews 📸 Robin van Lonkhuijsen , AFP via Getty Images
4
3
23
941
This is a good framing b/c honesty requires admitting that the "beneficiaries" of the "universal rights" will not get universal rights, but an authoritarian theocracy with a documented track record of prioritizing the mass murder of Israelis over any single other political aim.
"Palestine’s advocates speak not the language of special pleading — 'as a member of oppressed class X' — but that of universal rights. At stake is the principle that Washington can’t underwrite a permanent military occupation." Shadi Hamid in UnHerd. unherd.com/2026/11/the-power…
1
1
1
6
403
"Washington can’t underwrite a permanent military occupation." Okay, yes, that's why Israel unilaterally withdrew from Gaza and look what happened! It's just a lot of gaslighting to get you to forget what your lying eyes just saw.
1
1
3
66
Also from Twersky, on a topic that clearly preoccupied his mind, namely, on the tension inherent in Halacha between spirit and practice or "inward experience with routinized performance." The goal being "devotional routine."
3
10
604
This is a pretty great story from a beraita brought down in Bava Batra 10a. Many lessons, but here is one from I Twersky: "A providential view of history is no excuse for quietism."
1
1
10
515
Similarly: "The cherished version of bitachon is something with which to comfort yourself...but it is not a pain-killing drug to be callously prescribed for others...God's *inscrutable* benevolence is not a substitute for man's *tangible* benevolence."
3
1
2
132
In my view, this is quite consistent with avoidance of trying to explain why bad things happen to people while simultaneously using those events as motivation for teshuva.
1
1
3
95
Twersky argues that one of the main goals of MT was to rationalize (defined very broadly) the halacha. He suggests that perhaps that's what the Rambam means in general when he uses the root קרב.
3
1
2
5
863
This is like how in post-Expulsion Spain, some of the most vicious anti-Semites in the intellectual class were those of Jewish ancestry.
This is the wrong story. We are not facing an anti-Jewish pogrom in NYC. My Jewish friends mostly voted for the socialists. Darializa Chevalier is bad because she embraces socialist economics, is anti-prison, and anti-policing. She's a godsend to the Republican Party. I said most of my Jewish friends voted for them, but I also know Jews who are convinced they are raging antisemites. I simply don't see it. Mamdani has plenty of Jewish top staffers, including his deputy mayor for operations and his police commissioner. He was raised by parents ensconced in the worlds of academia and film. He went to Bronx Science. These are not bastions of antisemitism. Of course, he is anti-Israel. Lots of lefties, including lots of lefty Jews, are anti-Israel. Some of the anti-Israel sentiment in America (on both left and right) is fed by antisemitism, but most is not. When I talk to Jewish friends shocked by the bombing of Gaza, they aren't being antisemitic! You can point out that Israel is defending itself, but they'll respond that self-defense does not justify the extreme violence they've seen. You can point out that there are worse horrors in the world (Russia vs Ukraine, Ethiopia vs Tigray, Sudan, Yemen, Myanmar), but those aren't supported by US aid. I think the political class's obsession with Netanyahu's government is bad for America, but it's our current political reality. And being angry at Israel doesn't automatically make one an antisemite.
1
1
4
608
As a result, those with converso blood were even more rabidly anti-Semitic! History doesn't repeat it rhymes, etc
1
115
I think I'll make this an ongoing thread about the anti-Semitic Jew. Great reference here from @donbenitocereno from a 1908 Arthur Schnitzler novel (topic under discussion is present-day anti-Semitic Jew, Ben Moser) xitter.cf/donbenitocereno/status…
Replying to @MaxNordau
If only Moser had actually read the Schnitzler novel, he might have had the opportunity to read a perfect description of himself.
1
1
2
461
Just here to note that Daniel Boyarin literally wrote a book where the thesis was that this ideal should be the north star of the Jewish people.
Peter’s life project is for Jews to be stripped of full equality, bereft of self-determination
2
223
I submit that if an orthodox Jew won a senate seat and had been appealing to God in Hebrew throughout his campaign, the reaction would be different.
This quoted post is unavailable.
4
27
1,125
Perfect articulation
The ridiculous assumption that Jews’ “selfish interests” are to murder innocent children is the precise location of the antisemitism.
3
197
Guy representing Israel in The Economist thinks it's discrimination to exclude Hamas-supporting politicians in a governing coalition. It's ironic that he ends with "they deserve to lose to Netanyahu" when the reason they lost is b/c the voter bloc includes ppl like him.
It goes without saying that on a historic election night for the Arab voters, in which they’ve elected an unprecedented number of MKs, Netanyahu has just totally disregarded them as equal citizens. But that was to be expected. What’s more disappointing (though sadly not very surprising) is that the Jewish opposition leaders didn’t make any gesture in their speeches to the Arabs either, and spoke of a “Zionist” government. They deserve to lose to Netanyahu.
1
6
369
By far the most depressing thing about the Israeli elections is what it reveals about the ppl who post about it.
3
4
1,195
Unsurprising, but the academics I follow are the worst.
2
65
It's objectively very funny that this guy runs the closest thing to the Israeli seforimchatter podcast.
הזמן הכי טוב לבטל את החרם העלוב על הערבים אזרחי ישראל הוא בנאום הניצחון של אייזנקוט הלילה. זה מה שיהפוך את התבוסה של הימין האנטי-דמוקרטי לניצחון מהדהד
4
3
552
The thing about this is that it implies that society can be divided between the Talmidei Hachamim and everyone else, and that the entire society cannot be defined as Talmidei Hachamim.
3
8
720
I read Isadore Twersky's introductory essay on Mishneh Torah over the weekend and it's just so good. 1. On the deceptive simplicity and extraordinary depth subtly woven into the text:
2
3
1
28
3,221
4. On the unity of the Rambam's thought (pace both Strauss and the Haredi conception of the Rambam)
1
4
100
5. Diderot's phrasing here is beautiful - the combination of "two great qualities which are almost incompatible with one another - the spirit of discovery and that of method." /end
3
93