Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani) profile picture

Practicing CA | Mumbai | Member of Exposure Draft committee of WIRC of ICAI

Ulhasnagar, India
Joined May 2013
Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)Photo by Sumit Anshani (@SumitAnshani)
Perfect or no perfect 😃
If you're looking for perfect investment; you'll never be able to invest. If you're looking for perfect spouse; you'll never get married. If you're looking for perfect job; you've to remain unemployed. If you're looking for perfect life; you'll never enjoy living.
9
The two things that PM Modi, after a good start, seems to have completely surrendered on in recent years 1) Corruption out of control 2) Digital India becoming Digital Red Tape India
The new FEMA rules have made me an exporter of services to America. Because I make videos that YouTube (an American company) pays me for, I’m considered an exporter in the eyes of the RBI. As a result, I must sign an Export Declaration Form (corroborate it with my Adsense account), sign it, stamp it, and email it to the bank. The bank then also wants a hard copy of each EDF. This is for payments as small as $100 to as large as $50,000. And I must do this every single time. If the state is going to wear down creators, freelancers, and internet service providers like this and add nightmarish friction to the process of getting paid, it makes sense to either scale up to become a corporation (unrealistic and impossible for many) or start dealing in petty cash and cease to trade with anyone outside of India or simply pack your digital enterprise up and participate in the lala and seth ji ball-bearing economy.
49
189
7
1,411
38,811
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Fairfax holdings, a Canadian financial services firm is buying IDBI Bank And indirectly, they are using LIC policyholders money to buy IDBI Bank Here is the sequence of events that explains what happened (TLDR): Scene 1: Bad Times and the rescue In 2018, IDBI had the worst bad loans of any government bank. Was close to collapse. The govt asked LIC to save it. LIC put in over ₹26,000 cr of policyholders' money. Scene 2: The sale and the bid Government set the minimum price for sale as 94.42 Rs. Fairfax made a lower bid around 75 Rs Officials dropped the minimum price and ordered a new valuation which came to exactly around Fairfax's bid (75.99 Rs). Magical :) Scene 3: Getting bought with policy holders' money After buying IDBI, Fairfax wants IDBI to buy Fairfax's other companies (Go Digit, IIFL Capital) for cash. Value: about ₹28,300 cr. That's half of what Fairfax is paying for the bank. So the bank LIC rescued using policyholders money may end up funding its own takeover 🥲 Scene 4: Appointment of the Babu Mahalingam was an independent director at LIC, on its investment committee. Dec 2025: joins the board of Thomas Cook, a Fairfax company Jan 2026: IDBI bids invited Jan 2026: LIC reappoints him anyway Jul 2026: Fairfax's final bid opened. He is still on both boards. So the seller (LIC) had a director sitting on the board of the buyer's company 🙃🙃 In Congress era, we called this corruption. These days, we call it coincidence :)
14
157
3
294
14,457
Sumit Anshani retweeted
GSTR-9 and 9C is full of portal glitches. Table 8A is not correctly populated - G-202610234713416 Invalid Summary Payload - G-202611034772043. @cbic_india @FinMinIndia With just 58 days to go the form is still not ready in @Infosys_GSTN portal.!
4
3
21
1,910
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Urging Hon’ble Union Finance Minister @nsitharaman ji to consider extending tax compliance deadlines during Diwali 2026. With TDS/TCS payments due on 7 November and several GST filings scheduled between 10 and 13 November, Chartered Accountants, tax practitioners, traders and small businesses face considerable pressure during the festive season. Mr. Nagesh Shivaji Salunkhe, State President of the @NCPspeaks Tax Practitioners Cell, Maharashtra, met me and submitted a memorandum highlighting these concerns. Diwali is an important time for families, and those fulfilling these statutory obligations deserve the opportunity to celebrate it with their loved ones. I request the Finance Ministry to provide suitable relief and consider a festival-sensitive compliance calendar to avoid such difficulties in the future. @FinMinIndia
36
210
6
703
68,279
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Supreme Court judge says 'Don't Travel by Air' on PIL of 700% rise in Airfare, But Can he say 'Don't Pay Income Tax' if Basic Services aren't provided by Govt!!!
47
1,498
15
7,572
83,337
Sumit Anshani retweeted
E invoice for RCM self Invoice is Pathetic in Design. Why should honest taxpayer sector do compliance for particular sectors which the govt finds difficult to control.? Eradicate RCM and bring everything under FCM !. @cbic_india @FinMinIndia
3
26
2
38
2,707
Sumit Anshani retweeted
RCM E- Invoicing is an ultimate thing that GST Department can delegate to tax payer. I humbly suggest Govt to now start paying salary to the tax payers for doing the delegated job of govt officers & @cbic_india. A thankless job done by taxpayers & also get threatened for interest & penalty for any miss-outs. #Democracy_Demands #मोदीजी_जनता_माफ़_नहीं_करेगी
4
27
1
69
3,330
Replying to @IncomeTaxIndia
@IncomeTaxIndia Hi Team, I’m not able to register DSC on Income Tax Website. Showing PAN in DSC is not matching with PAN as per website, however we checked, PAN is same. Is this a website issue? Tomorrow is due date for filing TP Audit report!!
2
187
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Tried from 3 different systems bt still of no use. what to do MCA tech team? @HelpdeskMCA21V3 @nsitharamanoffc @nsitharaman @narendramodi @narendramodi @icsi_cs @FinMinIndia @IndiaIcsi @theicai
8
13
1
27
1,361
Sumit Anshani retweeted
My iPhone Duo video went viral, so I'm giving away 100 iPhones on X 😛
91,497
92,087
6,530
139,437
6,208,894
Sumit Anshani retweeted
One form 4 different formats of the date. @HelpdeskMCA21V3 is it a system error just a portal issue? Form 8 does not shows any date in a same format, how are we supposed to rely on these data? #CSTwitter
6
20
45
4,760
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Replying to @HelpdeskMCA21V3
@HelpdeskMCA21V3 @MCA21India unable to download forms. how are we supposed to complete filings within due date if the site is performing like this??
4
21
1
28
473
All of us thanked @IncomeTaxIndia when they extended the TAR due dates However, we knew right then that the extension was impractical due to Navaratri and Dasara festivities Had we raised our concerns then and there, we might have been enjoying the festive season by now #TaxAuditDueDateExtension #TAR #TaxAudit
9
120
106
17,781
18 Sunday 19 Durga Navami 20 Vijay Dashmi (Dussehra) Due date for GSTR-3B? Where is General Clauses Law, hat states that any due date falling on Holiday or Sunday is considered to be on next working day. I'm not asking for extension, but correct ✅ implementation of Law.
10
82
2
192
13,049
📢 GSTR-3B Due Date Extension? 📅 18 October (Sunday) 🙏 19 October – Ram Navami 🏹 20 October – Vijayadashami (Dussehra) With consecutive holidays around the due date, will the Government consider extending the monthly GSTR-3B due date? Businesses & Tax Professionals need practical compliance timelines @GST_Council @cbic_india #GST #GSTR3B #GSTDueDate
4
66
70
15,826
Sumit Anshani retweeted
You cannot pass a single highway toll without paying. Not one. That much accuracy and fool-proof 1.66 lakh vehicles, per hr, in various parts of country . FASTag hits. Money deducted. Boom opens. In 3 seconds. System never down. Power backup, 2 ISPs, scanner backup. Because if it's down for 10 mins, they lose lakhs. Now come to GST, MCA & Income Tax. On 20th - GSTN slow. On 31st July, 30th Sept, 31st Oct - Income Tax portal down. October and November- MCA portal down. "Portal under maintenance" "Don't panic, trying to file" Why can't we adopt the same SOP? Toll SOP is simple: • Uptime is money, so you ensure uptime. • If system fails, operator is penalised. • If tag fails, manager comes in 2 mins. In tax and MCA portals: • If system fails, TAXPAYER/stakeholder is penalised with late fee. • Vendor gets paid anyway. • Grievance goes auto-closed. NHAI proved India CAN build world-class, zero-downtime systems. If FASTag can handle 10 lakh extra cars on Diwali without crashing, why can't GSTN income tax and MCA handle last minute rush? Fix accountability. Link Infosys/GSTN/ LT payment to uptime. 1 hour down on due date = Rs 10 cr penalty + auto extension. Until then, toll booths will remain more efficient than tax portals. @IncomeTaxIndia @FinMinIndia @cbic_india @MCA21India #IncomeTax #GST #GSTN
12
101
5
279
15,710
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Hum keh rahe the RCM hi hata do Wo keh rahe hain RCM ka bhiE invoice banao Koi itna disconnected kaise ho sakta hain Logo se??
7
10
95
3,734
Sumit Anshani retweeted
After nearly 2 years of MCA V3, the solution is still “Use Incognito Mode and Mobile Hotspot”! Are we professionals responsible for corporate compliance or testing browsers and internet connections? MCA, we need a working portal, not workarounds!
3
24
1
48
1,748
Sumit Anshani retweeted
Replying to @HelpdeskMCA21V3
The only thing that has changed since 2023, is the error message and how it is being displayed. #CSTwitter
7
5
131
Sumit Anshani retweeted
The Great MSME Data Fraud - How RBI and Finance Ministry Killed Real Manufacturing. The damage done to the Indian economy by the RBI and Finance Ministry in the last few years is grave and irreparable. Small scale manufacturing, which was the backbone of this country, has almost vanished from the ground. What we see on paper is only data farming. Take one simple example. As per government records, MSMEs were just around 80 lakhs in 2022. Today the government claims 7.89 Crore MSMEs. How is it possible to create 7 Crore industries in 2-3 years? No country in history has done it. The answer is simple - forced Udyam certificate. Today if you want to open a current account, the bank manager forces you to get an MSME certificate. Whether you are a kirana shop, a tea stall, a commission agent, a trader you are registered as MSME. Whether you come under manufacturing or not is not important for them. They just need the number to show on the world stage. If we have 7.89 Crore MSMEs, we are double the number of MSMEs than China. China has around 3-4 crore SMEs. But our GDP is 1/5th of China. Their MSMEs contribute 60% to GDP and 70% to exports. Our 7.89 Crore MSMEs cannot even give 30% to GDP. This itself proves the numbers are fake. You cannot have double the factories and 1/5th the output unless the factories are only on paper. On the ground, real small manufacturing is dead: 1. Compliance cost has killed them - GST, e-invoice, e-way bill, TDS, TCS, 45-day payment rule. 2. RBI has made bank credit only for big corporate. Small industry gets loan at 11-12% with collateral, while big gets at 7% clean. 3. Finance Ministry has given all benefits to PLI for big players. Small tool room, foundry, fabrication units get nothing. The solution is only one and government must listen - Give a 10-year complete Tax Holiday for SME Manufacturing. No Income Tax, no MAT, no GST on job work for any manufacturing unit with turnover below Rs. 50 Crore. Unless you give them oxygen to survive, they will not survive. Make in India will remain only a slogan, and trading of Chinese goods will be shown as MSME growth. If this tax holiday is not given immediately, the economy will see only south. Data will keep growing, factories will keep closing.
1
15
1
32
1,583