Dundee
Joined September 2011
Who decides what Scottish children should know? This week in SUE: a neglected national inheritance, parents pushing back, and schools increasingly shaped by therapeutic culture. What is education actually for? bit.ly/sue171news @acadofideas @ScotPAG @enlighten_scot
7
8
1,184
This is a fantastic maiden speech from Amanda Lindsay. She’s absolutely correct that the ridiculous “trans guidance” needs removing from the CfE asap. Enough children have been indoctrinated in this nonsense. 🚨
Amanda Lindsay, (Reform MSP Shadow Minister for Women & Equalities) delivered a truly well-measured and factual speech in the Scottish Parliament today. She rightly acknowledged the common ground on supporting high-quality childcare and giving every child the best possible start, while courageously addressing the profound concerns so many parents and professionals have about the ideological capture of our education and childcare systems. Social transition is not a neutral or kind act when applied to very young children who still believe in the Tooth Fairy. It’s deeply concerning that guidance promoting this was rolled out across Scotland. This wasn’t rhetoric; it was a calm, evidence-led call to put child safeguarding, biological reality, and women’s rights first. Refreshing to hear such straight-talking common sense in Holyrood. Well done Amanda.
3
10
44
2,628
Local authority education committees need to be reformed so that parents and teachers can challenge the rampant complacency about education and knowledge. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
1
6
12
367
The SNP government has used the absence of curriculum content to politicise aspects of education. School values are no longer related to learning but are dictated by government. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
2
4
1
5
657
Our history is rarely visited as a source of inspiration or ideas but cast instead as a realm of abuse and violence. This contempt for our predecessors is a deeply destructive cultural phenomenon. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
1
1
1
4
241
Outlining what a student should know, and defining what is important, is an essential part of teaching missing from the new training regime. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
1
5
131
In To a Louse, Robert Burns wrote that it would be a great gift if we could ‘see ourselves as others see us’. He wasn’t just promoting humility; he was expressing an enthusiasm for objectivity. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
2
4
11
2,407
Scotland needs to take a long hard look at its education system and the flawed ideologies that underpin the Curriculum for Excellence (CfE). Scottish education has sidelined the authority of the teacher in the classroom. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
1
1
6
247
The CfE, introduced in 2010, has now been in place for an entire generation. We can say with certainty that it has been a failure. bit.ly/sue2026holyrood #holyrood #holyrood2026
1
10
21
1,053
Neurodiversity is a common term in education- and society. But it lacks precision both in definition and usage. And that really matters in the real world. For a start 'neurodiverse' is not a clinically recognised or used term, eg in the DSM-5. It was coined by the sociologist Judy Singer in 1998, as an advocacy term for people with ASD and very closely related conditions. 'Neurodivergent' describes an individual whose brain functions differently from the majority. Clinically recognized examples include autism spectrum disorder, ADHD, dyslexia, dyspraxia, Tourette syndrome, and others. These are formal neurodevelopmental diagnoses. Crucially this means people who have been born with a life-long condition. It does *not* include people with anxiety disorders, or dementia, or PTSD, or depression etc. It doesn't mean 'everything'. There is no diagnosis 'neurodiverse'. It is a purely vernacular term, with multiple meanings depending on who is using it and who you talk to. Clinicians diagnose specific conditions, like ASD. And of course even clinically diagnosable conditions like ASD, ADHD are subject to intense debates about how the category is defined, is it too broad or narrow etc. Diagnostic criteria can vary from country to country, LA to LA, school to school. And so can the response strategies. What a lot of people outside of either the education or clinical sectors don't realise is that this is an area that is crying out for high quality research, clarity, transparency, and honesty about what works, and when, and when it doesn't work. We are often talking about very different things when we use the same words carelessly. The common use of 'neurodiverse' matters; it is often heard in advocacy discourse, the media, etc. but frequently misunderstood. It doesn't mean 'a little bit different'. We are all different from one another. People who claim to be 'a little bit autistic' may very well simply misunderstand that some of the characteristics they identify in that category are also perfectly normal-spectrum qualities that many people have. Liking your house to be tidy doesn't mean that you are neurodivergent. Being a stickler for details doesn't mean you have OCD. If the term means 'everything' then it means 'nothing.' It has become fashionable for people to self diagnose and self-refer as neurodivergent, even in the face of little evidence. Because it confers, for some, a sense of being special, different, or interesting. And of course in a sector where we rightly seek to support people/ students who need reasonable accommodations in order to promote inclusivity, the *incorrect* assignation of an unmet need leads to unfair advantages over those who do not receive those accommodations. A small but growing group of activists now campaign on the platform that almost any mental health difference indicates neurodivergence, but this is a huge definitional drift, without any clinical basis. You see a lot of this activism in education, often perfectly well-meant. Singer herself would have disagreed strongly with this. The reason this matters is that if we treat all mental health problems, all behavioural disorders, all learning problems, as having lifelong neurological foundations - which they absolutely do not- then we create a narrative that indicates all individuals face insurmountable obstacles in modifying the behaviours associated with the condition. Some children identified as dyslexic, for example, are simply deficient in high quality reading instruction. But if you treat every child that behaves unsuccessfully in the classroom as being neurodivergent, then you create a circumstance where we treat them as the victims of irresistible compulsions, rather than human beings with the ability to learn to take responsibility, to grow, to change their habits and attitudes. It is also a substantial abandonment of our commitment to only use evidence info strategies with children- especially the most vulnerable. In other words, not all forms of SEND are indications of neurodivergent conditions. And most certainly aren't. Sadly, as in so many fields, many of the strategies recommended for children with any form of SEND, including forms of neurodivergence, lack substantial or credible evidence bases. There is a lot of well-meant money being spent on approaches that simply have no basis in research, impact or other outcomes. This is an area that cries out for high quality evidence bases, and evidence informed approaches to support students with genuine need, not activism that leads to treating all children as incapable. But the energy of that activism, married to evidence, could produce something spectacular for those who need help the most, and I hope we see this happen in the future.
11
93
24
340
81,151
The absence of a knowledge-based curriculum is the number one problem facing Scottish schools. But the second problem is what has replaced the transmission of knowledge in the classroom. All too often, it seems that a progressive approach to teaching aligns with the promotion of progressive political views. bit.ly/sue139jw @jowilliams293
2
9
1
18
1,511
The authoritarianism of ‘critical social justice’ is now orthodoxy in education and beyond. No debate. Just compliance. Our young people are being programmed into ‘goodthink’ — with the eager help of partisan educators and politicians. Jane Fenton bit.ly/sue137jf
4
6
536
Stuart Waiton retweeted
1./ 🧵The BBC's Guilt. Defenders of the BBC keep insisting it never promoted trans ideology. Yet here's more snippets from the BBC's own schools materials. In this clip primary school kids are told they can be born with a gender identity different from their body. 👇
156
1,814
179
5,733
302,242
Oppression Olympics: a threat to academic freedom and democracy - Jane Fenton bit.ly/sue137jf @AFAF_freespeech @SpeechUnion @HPluckrose @ConceptualJames
4
6
495
Scottish Union for Education – Newsletter No137 Themes: facts versus creativity, discipline versus chaos, and how the Oppression Olympics is creating a new stifling conformity in education And our conference 'Why Scottish Education Matters', Saturday 15th November. bit.ly/news137news
3
5
1,094
Academic @jowilliams293 says Scotland’s brightest kids and hardest-working teachers are being failed by an education establishment hooked on progressive ideology — prioritising activity over learning and politics over knowledge. Schools need clarity and education, not indoctrination. bit.ly/sue2026event
8
2
14
7,078
Education is concerned with inculcating values and, for this reason, it is a moral project. Although we can be critical of the politicisation of education, its opposite is not value-free teaching. The transmission of knowledge and the call on children to learn is inherently connected to the promotion of certain values, most notably, a respect for knowledge. bit.ly/sue136jw #EducationReform #Curriculum #Knowledge
3
3
380
Scottish education matters - even if you're not in Scotland Ahead of the @ScotUnionEd conference in Glasgow, Stuart Waiton shows how everyone in the UK should learn about the disasters of Scotland's content-lite, ideology-enforcing education system (link 👇)
3
10
32
7,369
Could we rise to the challenge? @wyllie_cameron on @NickGibbUK and @RobertPeal's book Reforming Lessons. bit.ly/sue135cw
2
1
3
1,218
Scottish Union for Education – Newsletter No135 Themes: Cameron Wyllie, Nick Gibb, and the ‘crisis’ in Scottish schools – a new way forward @StuartWaiton bit.ly/sue135news @wyllie_cameron @pennyruthlewis @dianeukc #educationreform #schools #edchat
6
7
1,701